The Final Theory: Mark McCutcheon

There was definitely another thread on this a while back, but I'm too lazy to find it.

Basically, the theory he's pushing is expansionism, where all matter is expanding at an accelerating rate and this is why things accelerate towards each other (gravity, ya see?!).

Of course, you have to hypothesise that things expand at 4.9m/s^2 on the surface of the Earth. That bit works.

The inverse square rule causes the whole thing to completely break down, although he's damned if he'll admit it. In order for different gravitational accelerations to be observed, things would need to be expanding at different rates, and thus we would observe things getting either exponentially larger or smaller as time passed.

It's 100% Grade A bullsh!t.
 
Just joined the forum recently after browsing the web in an idle moment and finding here a reference to my review of McCutcheon's book at Amazon. I have to admit to being that TruthSayer who gave it a five-star review, but I'm Simplicious at Barnes and Noble; a bit of a schizophrenic you might say.

I don't wish to reopen the debate on the book itself. I was just wondering if anybody here has actually/read bought the book. Nobody I speak to has even heard of it, despite it being a "best seller". Most of the five-star reviews read like anti-ageing cream commercials and cannot be taken as real customer comments. I'd be very interested to find out what a geniune advocate of this book is like. I imagine that they are the sort of people who think the X Files is a serious critique of FBI policy, but I may well be wrong. Has anybody met one, even if only in cyberspace?
 
Just joined the forum recently after browsing the web in an idle moment and finding here a reference to my review of McCutcheon's book at Amazon. I have to admit to being that TruthSayer who gave it a five-star review, but I'm Simplicious at Barnes and Noble; a bit of a schizophrenic you might say.

I don't wish to reopen the debate on the book itself. I was just wondering if anybody here has actually/read bought the book. Nobody I speak to has even heard of it, despite it being a "best seller". Most of the five-star reviews read like anti-ageing cream commercials and cannot be taken as real customer comments. I'd be very interested to find out what a geniune advocate of this book is like. I imagine that they are the sort of people who think the X Files is a serious critique of FBI policy, but I may well be wrong. Has anybody met one, even if only in cyberspace?
Welcome! I hope you stick around. Judging by your review of McCutcheon's book, I think you'll get along fine here. I wonder if Mark even got the joke.
 
I don't wish to reopen the debate on the book itself. I was just wondering if anybody here has actually/read bought the book. Nobody I speak to has even heard of it, despite it being a "best seller". Most of the five-star reviews read like anti-ageing cream commercials and cannot be taken as real customer comments. I'd be very interested to find out what a geniune advocate of this book is like. I imagine that they are the sort of people who think the X Files is a serious critique of FBI policy, but I may well be wrong. Has anybody met one, even if only in cyberspace?

There were some chapters available for free on the Internet. I started reading them, so I could comment, but couldn't go on after a couple of minutes. The author knows less about physics than a high school drop out and his arguments were so childish that no one in his right mind, no matter his background, would buy it. Most (if not all) the positive reviews are surely sock puppets. They are made by people with no other reviews on Amazon, are long and reasonably well written (grammatically, I mean) and isomorphic in their content.

Welcome to the forum!
 
Well would you believe it! After several months, my one-star review of McCutcheon's great work has disappeared from the Barnes and Nonle website, just a few daysafter joining this forum and admitting I hadn't read it (well who would?). Do you think someone is watching us? I had assumed Barnes and Noble were above thses Amazon type antics.

Anyway, my five-star review as Truthsayer at Amazon is still there. Maybe he liked the joke after all! Perhaps he assumes that his readers are so stupid they won't see the irony. After all, they critcize us for not having read it while they criticize physicists for misusing a "work function" that they couldn't even quote. I wonder if McCutcheon is reading this?
 
Having bought the book and been utterly gobsmacked at its ludicrous content, I came across this site by doing a websearch and have now become a member. I too have been very suspicious about the lack of negative reviews on Amazon and yesterday sent in this following review ...
_________________

If you are interested in fairies, the paranormal, homeopathy or astrology then this just might be the book for you. If, on the other hand, you have an serious interest in science or a scientific education like myself then avoid it like the plague!

I have never in my life read such an amalgamation of pseudoscientific claptrap. The author seems to have no grasp of basic science, scientific technique or mathematics, and demonstrates a fundamental lack of understanding of basic physical principles. There is so much in the book which is so laughingly, absurdly and farcically wrong that I wouldn't know where to start quoting them.

If it were possible to give a negative star rating I would rate this as a minus five.

I shall be much more selective in future about any recommendation I receive from Amazon.

_________________

It remains to be seen if Amazon publishes it!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom