The evil on the political right and left is not equally egregious at the moment

Since it has been 9 minutes and no one has asked yet..... What is a Bill Sparkman and what does it/he have to do with anything?
 
RFK Jr's silly claim that Bush stole Ohio in 2004?

I don't know if "stolen" is the right word, but the Ohio presidential election was loaded with irregularities and well documented suppression techniques. The ballots were also illegally destroyed, making recounts impossible:

http://www.alternet.org/story/58328/?page=1

Issues about that election are not fraudulent lies. The worst you can say about RFK jr. (with respect to this issue) is that he exaggerated. Much different than, say, calling Van Jones a convicted felon that led the Rodney King riots:

http://www.alternet.org/environment/142310/glenn_beck's_crazy_lies_about_van_jones
 
Bill Sparkman

Show people lying about it. I remember Maddow discussing it and being very clear that they didn't have enough information to draw any conclusions.

Offer an example of someone using that story to smear anyone or otherwise pushing it.
 
The buck stops... Somewhere else

That was the Huffington Post headline from tonight.

President Obama said Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack erred in pushing out Shirley Sherrod over allegations of racism that later proved unsubstantiated, but the real culprit, he told ABC News, was the media.

No the real culprit was whoever decided that she needed to be fired even after she tried to explain.
 
Last edited:
This is an interesting tactic. Every right winger I know was flogging the "racist at USDA" just a couple of days ago. BAC was in a serious lather and challenged anyone to "defend" Sherrod. Then once it became obviously bad for Obama, every right winger I know is lamenting the fact that anyone believed the same "fair and balanced" smears they lap up every other day of the year and were here spitting out just one day before. And it's not just here, it's everywhere. Suddenly, Teabaggers are worried about a political scalp being had due to a Breitbart smear job? Seriously?

Rachel Maddow, speak of the devil, had a great piece on this.

http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2010/7/22/886671/-Late-afternoon-Early-evening-open-thread
 
I've had this same discussion before when the right leaners on the board tried to compare FAIR (a right wing propaganda site masquerading as a media watch dog) to Media Matters.
SG, for that all I generally agree with your political viewpoints, sometimes your scholarship is execrable.
 
Last edited:
Dan Rather's ridiculous Texas Air National Guard story on Bush? The NY Times attempt to smear John McCain with their absurd claim that he had an affair with some lobbyist?

What Skeptic Ginger really means is that she doesn't like it when it's her ox being gored.

I personally tend to agree with her but you do bring up valid examples and I note nobody on the left has addressed them.
 
Wait...

How can the evil on the political right possible be more egregious than that on the left at this present moment in time, when it's presently the left who have the power to stop state evil by virture of controlling the government?

Wow. Myopia is a strange thing.

Who gives a damn what Limbaugh says? Limbaugh is not in a position of any practical power. All he can do is say nasty things.
 
I don't know if "stolen" is the right word, but the Ohio presidential election was loaded with irregularities and well documented suppression techniques. The ballots were also illegally destroyed, making recounts impossible:

http://www.alternet.org/story/58328/?page=1

Well, let's see what your article says. It notes that the ballots legally had to be kept until September 2006. Then (on the second page) it says:

It is customary for public officials to preserve potential evidence when notified of pending litigation.

Customary? Is that a way of saying what they did was not illegal?

Blackwell negotiated with opposing attorneys and agree to send a directive to election boards saying the ballots should be retained.

Blackwell negotiated with opposing attorneys? How do you negotiate with opposing attorneys on a matter of federal law? And "should be retained"?

But of course I am sure that Obama's Justice Department is currently pursuing charges against the Ohio officials involved, right? Or is this a case where somebody on Alternet made the rash charges in the headline and then put the weasel words in the actual text?

Issues about that election are not fraudulent lies. The worst you can say about RFK jr. (with respect to this issue) is that he exaggerated. Much different than, say, calling Van Jones a convicted felon that led the Rodney King riots:

http://www.alternet.org/environment/142310/glenn_beck's_crazy_lies_about_van_jones

I hadn't heard this one before. But once again, we go to the article and find that the charge about Beck claiming that Jones was a convicted felon who led the King riots is vague and unsubstantiated with actual quotes:

For instance: several times on his show, Beck has said or implied that Van went to prison for taking part in the Rodney King riots.

I'm no defender of Beck--I think he's an idiot--but I never heard this charge against Van Jones, and it had nothing to do with his resignation. It doesn't seem too much to ask the writer to substantiate this claim, but there are no direct quotes from Beck saying that Van Jones was convicted for his part in the King riots.
 
Dan Rather's ridiculous Texas Air National Guard story on Bush? RFK Jr's silly claim that Bush stole Ohio in 2004?

Dan Rather's source was rapidly identified as a fraud who was having him on, and certainly he shouldn't have gone to air without doing his homework.

However my recollection was that the charge that George W. Bush didn't live up to his draft-dodging requirements was never proven or disproven because the relevant files were sealed, so in the end it just came down to allegations he had defaulted on his service which could not be proven one way or another.

The NY Times attempt to smear John McCain with their absurd claim that he had an affair with some lobbyist?

Careful now. They never actually said that. We wouldn't want to engage in egregious misstatements of the facts in a thread about whether right-wing partisans engage in egregious misstatements of the facts. :)

They said that former staffers claimed that they were worried about the possibility of an affair with Vicki Iseman, because she was constantly accompanying him or travelling with him. Iseman sued on the basis that people might think they said she had an affair, or something, and settled the court case for zero dollars and a clarifying note from the NY Times which in no way backed off on the actual story they printed.

Nothing here seems to be remotely as serious or as divorced from reality as creationism, AGW denial, lies about WMDs or the other major unethical acts or policies of the Republicans which have been cited in this thread already.
 
Of course the right is making up more :rule10 right now. The left is in power and they are much bigger targets.

The left is acting hypocritical on a large number of issues pertaining to the Iraq/Afghanistan war now.

In 2008, General Petraeus was General BetrayUs. Now he's lauded as the best replacement for McCrystal. His "surge" tactics were villified in 2008, now Obama, who voted against it and called it all sorts of mean things, heartily approves of it.

Obama has effectively ended things like water-boarding, but still continues to use rendition. He's not catching much flak over it compared to when Bush was doing it.

Gitmo.

The left also promoted and magnified some delusional things about Sarah Palin. Trig Palin Birtherism, "I can see Russia from my house"ism (which the majority of Democrats polled in the last election believed).

Then of course there's the insidious "everything is George Bush's fault". I've yet to see one bad thing happen in this country, on a non-political scandal level, that hasn't been blamed on George Bush yet.

The Deepwater Oil Spill? George Bush's fault. Please ignore the fact that Obama appointed people to "clean-up" the department that regulated drilling.

The national debt? Bush added $1 trillion in his last year, so it's Bush's fault that Obama is doing about 3 times that.

The economy? Okay, Bush deserves at least partial cred for that one :D
 
Errmmm....Seems to me that. about a year ago, every righty on this page were mocking me because I made it clear that I thought Breitbart to be lacking in such qualities as honesty, integrity, journalisitc talent, the ability to think clearly or a human soul.

I notice that that sorry bucket of slime seems nowhere near ready to apologize to Sherrod for sliming her over a story which, without the malicious editing of the tape, should have made her look like an excellant role model for young women thinking of entering public service.

Hell will be prime polar bear habitat before Faux News joins the human race on this issue.
 
Errmmm....Seems to me that. about a year ago, every righty on this page were mocking me because I made it clear that I thought Breitbart to be lacking in such qualities as honesty, integrity, journalisitc talent, the ability to think clearly or a human soul.

I notice that that sorry bucket of slime seems nowhere near ready to apologize to Sherrod for sliming her over a story which, without the malicious editing of the tape, should have made her look like an excellant role model for young women thinking of entering public service.

Hell will be prime polar bear habitat before Faux News joins the human race on this issue.

The earth is getting warmer; maybe hell is getting colder ;)
 
I personally tend to agree with her but you do bring up valid examples and I note nobody on the left has addressed them.

I'd also like to add NBC planting the igniter in their video of the pickup truck "exploding". You know, because "everybody knows it happens", so when they can't reproduce it, force it.

And before anybody says, "That ain't a right-left wing thing!" (which I'd likely agree, technically) I submit it is evidence of a fundamentalist belief in the evil and dangers of corporations which justified it.

Was it not the same attitude that generated the fake Bush document that lead to Rather's resignation? "Everybody knows it, therefore, what's the harm?"

ETA: Speaking of which, "the unconscionable profits of drug companies" ring a bell? Said of those in the nation that generates fully half the world's new drugs. This is a downright evil statement. And by that, I mean evil in the sense of leading to hundreds of millions of deaths if action is taken on that populist statement. Real evil. True, mass-murderous, demonic evil, as defined by many needless deaths and so much needless suffering. Anyone have a better definition?




Then there's Bill Moyers, as talked about by George Will, among other people.

On election night on public television -- your tax dollars at work -- Bill Moyers said: "I think if Kerry were to win this in a -- in a tight race, I think there'd be an effort to mount a coup, quite frankly. . . . I mean that the right wing is not going to accept it." Moyers, the emblematic face of public television, is an intellectual icon in the sort of deep blue precincts that think red America is paranoid.

The outrage, and apologists for Moyers, were legion.
 
Last edited:
I "the unconscionable profits of drug companies" ... nation that generates fully half the world's new drugs. This is a downright evil statement. And by that, I mean evil in the sense of leading to hundreds of millions of deaths if action is taken on that populist statement. Real evil. True, mass-murderous, demonic evil, as defined by many needless deaths and so much needless suffering. Anyone have a better definition?

lol

drug cos spend more on ads than R&D

they could take a dent in their margins and keep pumping out new vaccines etc.

so

in sum

no I don't think that forcing lower drug costs or allowing 3rd world countries to mfg generics or whatever you're talking about where someone brought up pharma profits will lead to millions of deaths


leading to hundreds of millions of deaths if action is taken on that populist statement

Generic drugs = worse than the holocaust. :P
 
In 2008, General Petraeus was General BetrayUs. Now he's lauded as the best replacement for McCrystal. His "surge" tactics were villified in 2008, now Obama, who voted against it and called it all sorts of mean things, heartily approves of it.

First of all, remember the standards here. We're talking about wholly made up BS, the Sherrod case, as well as those I listed before, serving as the example.

What was the lie about Petraeus? The BetrayUs thing was focused on the fact that Petraeus claimed success for the Surge even though it flatly failed to satisfy most of its benchmarks. Certainly we can argue about whether the Surge worked or whether MoveOn's add was in poor taste, but it isn't based on lies:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MoveOn.org_ad_controversy

Notice that most of their sources are military people and legitimate news agencies.

Obama has effectively ended things like water-boarding, but still continues to use rendition. He's not catching much flak over it compared to when Bush was doing it.

Well, Bush didn't catch all that much flak over it, either. Notice how thoroughly he's eluded any responsibility.

And yes, the very worst thing about Obama is his continuation of those policies. In fact, public opinion has moved towards approval of torture largely because Obama has adopted that rhetoric and failed to hold anyone accountable:

http://digbysblog.blogspot.com/2010/07/false-consensus-village-hypothesis.html

This is horrible, and troubling, but I don't know how you're generating false scandal out of this. What's the lie or distortion? I read about this issue every week, at least, I'm not sure why you think it isn't being covered.


What about it? What was the lie or distortion?

The left also promoted and magnified some delusional things about Sarah Palin. Trig Palin Birtherism, "I can see Russia from my house"ism (which the majority of Democrats polled in the last election believed).

The Palin-related birth crap is a totally fringe notion that is only being pressed by Andrew Sullivan, who can hardly be described as an important figure on the left.

And "Palin also said she had some "insight" into Russia because "they are our next-door neighbors, and you can actually see Russia from land here in Alaska." But she acknowledged that she had never met a foreign head of state.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26664074/

That's a fantastically stupid thing to say. I don't know when the "from my house" was added, but I'd imagine it was by a late night comedian. Notice that while it's slightly more amusing, it doesn't really change the content or stupidity of the initial statement all that much.

What's the lie? She really did claim foreign experience because Russia is visible from her state.

Then of course there's the insidious "everything is George Bush's fault". I've yet to see one bad thing happen in this country, on a non-political scandal level, that hasn't been blamed on George Bush yet.

The Deepwater Oil Spill? George Bush's fault. Please ignore the fact that Obama appointed people to "clean-up" the department that regulated drilling.

The deregulation, the drilling contract, the bribery of and abuse by the MMR, and most of the failed oversight occurred under Dubya. Notice that the criticism of Obama is that he didn't fix the mess Dubya made of regulating agencies fast enough. You're adding your own commentary about it being "all Bush's" fault, but it's not a lie or distortion to point out that 8 years of lax oversight is responsible for disasters (the mining catastrophes included) that originate from safety violations.

Again, where is the bold-faced lie? THe issue of proper regulation is an important one, it's not a false controversy.

The national debt? Bush added $1 trillion in his last year, so it's Bush's fault that Obama is doing about 3 times that.

This is just wrong. Observe the graph titled "figure 1." Please explain how that isn't Bush's fault:

http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index.cfm?fa=view&id=3036

Here is another visual representation:

http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/2009/06/what-caused-the-budget-deficit/

Notice that only 3% of the deficit comes from Obama programs.

In fact, I think the notion you expressed, that Obama is responsible for ballooning deficits, is a perfect example of one of the pernicious, vapid right wing lies. You'll notice this false premise was a strong motivating factor for the teabaggers.

You've managed to add only one example of a "false controversy," and it's an example of more right wing nonsense.
 
Well, let's see what your article says. It notes that the ballots legally had to be kept until September 2006. Then (on the second page) it says:
Customary? Is that a way of saying what they did was not illegal?

Blackwell negotiated with opposing attorneys? How do you negotiate with opposing attorneys on a matter of federal law? And "should be retained"?

But of course I am sure that Obama's Justice Department is currently pursuing charges against the Ohio officials involved, right? Or is this a case where somebody on Alternet made the rash charges in the headline and then put the weasel words in the actual text?

You're welcome to read the entire article. There were serious irregularities in the voting in Ohio. There were plenty of well documented voter suppression techniques, urban areas were given significantly fewer voting machines than they needed, and a large number of those malfunctioned. 54% of "spoiled" votes were cast by African Americans, who made up 11% of the population.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_United_States_election_voting_controversies
http://www.commondreams.org/views04/1118-30.htm

I'm agreeing with you that it's an exaggeration to call the vote "stolen," it may have been incompetence. But it isn't a lie made of whole cloth, like "stolen e-mails prove scientists colluded to make up global warming."

Some very serious problems existed in the 2004 Ohio vote, whether by malice or incompetence.

I hadn't heard this one before. But once again, we go to the article and find that the charge about Beck claiming that Jones was a convicted felon who led the King riots is vague and unsubstantiated with actual quotes:

I'm no defender of Beck--I think he's an idiot--but I never heard this charge against Van Jones, and it had nothing to do with his resignation. It doesn't seem too much to ask the writer to substantiate this claim, but there are no direct quotes from Beck saying that Van Jones was convicted for his part in the King riots.

Google is a powerful tool. It's almost like you could have looked this up in 12 seconds:

http://colorlines.com/archives/2009/08/post_97.html

There's the video. You can hear the claim made over melodramatic piano music.
 
Last edited:
Has MSNBC ever does anything remotely close to this nonsense?

http://tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsme...ing_afghan_soldiers_go_awol_in_us.php?ref=fpa

A loose network of Mexican-American women, some of whom may be illegal immigrants, have been responsible for helping numerous Afghan military deserters go AWOL from an Air Force Base in Texas, FoxNews.com has learned. Many of the Afghans, with the women's assistance, have made their way to Canada; the whereabouts of others remain unknown. Some of the men have been schooled by the women in how to move around the U.S. without any documentation.

The Afghan deserters refer to the women as "BMWs" -- Big Mexican Women -- and they often are the first step in the Afghans' journey from Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, Texas, to Canada, a diplomatic official told FoxNews.com.

Fear mongering, anti-Latina, unsourced crap? I suppose I should back up here because I assumed nobody believed this by default though I could be wrong...
 
I personally tend to agree with her but you do bring up valid examples and I note nobody on the left has addressed them.

Dan Rather messed up. He was fired. That was that.

As for McCain, please link the article in question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom