The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is there or is there not an ambipolar electric field at work at comet 67P, jd226?
 
Is there or is there not an ambipolar electric field at work at comet 67P, jd226?

Who cares? It has nothing to do with the list of failures of your model.Tell me how the ambipolar field is altering the density? Why is it causing thousands of tonnes of ice to be excavated from Tempel 1? Like I said, it is an irrelevance, and is just a very transparent attempt by you to avoid addressing those failures. I've asked you repeatedly to assume an ambipolar field, and address how it has any relevance to those failures. Your refusal to do so tells everyone that you have accepted those failures. You failed.
 
Last edited:
As you say jd116, irrelevant.

It’s a straw man.
:D

No it isn't. You lied about MUPUS hitting rock, when you have been repeatedly directed to the measurements made, and the strengths recorded, and shown how they relate to various materials. There is no strawman here - you lied.
 
So, let's assume there is an ambipolar field. How then does that address the following?


Comets are rocks, blasted from planets by unknown electric woo.
Leaving aside the scientifically impossible mechanisms described to achieve this, we need only look at the composition of planets and moons, and at the composition of comets, and do a comparison. Earth, Mars, Mercury and Venus; all rock with high density. Comets; highly porous mixture of dust (fluffy and compact), ice and organics, with very low density.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


Comets are merely asteroids on elliptical orbits.
Any cursory examination of the many asteroids on elliptical orbits shows this to be wrong.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.
Electric discharges would show up in the magnetometer data. There was nothing. The jets are observed to be gas, dust and, sometimes, ice.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?

There is little to no ice, and the water observed is actually OH.
Water has been definitively detected at comets since 1986. So that was a lie.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


The OH (H2O?) that is observed is due to solar wind H+ combining with O-.
Impossible. The H+ ions are far too energetic to combine with anything.
There is nowhere near enough H+ to explain even 1 litre of water per second.
There is little to no O-.
The solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus for about 8 months around perihelion.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?

snowstorm_strip.jpg


Ambipolar field explains this how?


8 000 - 18 000 tonnes of ice grains excavated at Tempel 1.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


Crater far too big to have been formed in rock at Tempel 1.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


Density = ~ 530 kg/m3.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


CO sublimates at ~ 30 K. Comets contain CO.

Ambipolar fields explain this how?


Debris from collapsed cliffs on 67P show ice.

Ambipolar fields explain this how?


CONSERT sent radio waves through the comet, and show that it isn't rock.

Ambipolar fields explain this how?


The Philae lander tested the electrical permittivity of the nucleus. Nothing like rock.

Ambipolar fields explain this how?


Both MUPUS and MIRO measured the thermal inertia of the surface and near surface. Nothing like rock.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


Thornhill's lie about a pre-impact electric discharge at Tempel 1 is a failure, due to the Chandra and SWIFT data. He said it would be seen in x-ray. It wasn't.

Ambipolar fields explain this how?

To summarise; the electric comet woo failed.
 
Last edited:
You seem incapable of processing the fact comets have an ambipolar electric field.

Or are you still in your canoe up the river de Nile?

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?
 
You seem incapable of processing the fact comets have an ambipolar electric field.

Or are you still in your canoe up the river de Nile?

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Explain why it has any relevance to your failed model, and I might consider answering. In the meantime, you may want to study those failures, and then ask why Deca et al are using a four fluid model, that requires an ambipolar field. It may save you some embarrassment.

EDIT:
Oh, and you might want to consider whether an asteroid has an ambipolar field.
 
Last edited:
Explain why it has any relevance to your failed model, and I might consider answering. In the meantime, you may want to study those failures, and then ask why Deca et al are using a four fluid model, that requires an ambipolar field. It may save you some embarrassment.

EDIT:
Oh, and you might want to consider whether an asteroid has an ambipolar field.

OK, I'll make it a little easier; two of the fluids are cometary ions and cometary electrons. Where do they come from? Why, cometary neutrals, of course! Which neutrals? Many, but mainly H2O. And the ions that are most prevalent are H3O+ and H2O+. Now, what did Thornhill say? Scientists were mistaking, or inferring, H2O from detections of OH. Which was a blatant lie, but anyhow.........so those ions shouldn't be there. The neutrals shouldn't be there. The ambipolar field, assuming it exists at all comets (and that is not a certainty, especially at high activity levels), is another strike against the EC woo. See what you've done? You need to think these things through.

Oh, and yes, there will be an ambipolar field at an asteroid. What are the vast majority of asteroids not doing? Even those on elliptical orbits?

Grid-free 2D plasma simulations of the complex interaction between the solar wind and small, near-Earth asteroids
Zimmerman, M. I. et al.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20150011018.pdf
 
Last edited:
So you are saying YES to an ambipolar electric field at all asteroids but are still unsure for comets?
 
Piddley little amounts of water does not make the assumption that comets are mostly ice even remotely true.

As has been shown.
 
OK, I'll make it a little easier; two of the fluids are cometary ions and cometary electrons. Where do they come from? Why, cometary neutrals, of course! Which neutrals? Many, but mainly H2O. And the ions that are most prevalent are H3O+ and H2O+. Now, what did Thornhill say? Scientists were mistaking, or inferring, H2O from detections of OH. Which was a blatant lie, but anyhow.........so those ions shouldn't be there. The neutrals shouldn't be there. The ambipolar field, assuming it exists at all comets (and that is not a certainty, especially at high activity levels), is another strike against the EC woo. See what you've done? You need to think these things through.

Oh, and yes, there will be an ambipolar field at an asteroid. What are the vast majority of asteroids not doing? Even those on elliptical orbits?

Grid-free 2D plasma simulations of the complex interaction between the solar wind and small, near-Earth asteroids
Zimmerman, M. I. et al.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20150011018.pdf


It’s a great paper, hey jd116,

:D
 
Piddley little amounts of water does not make the assumption that comets are mostly ice even remotely true.

As has been shown.

250 000 l/s at Hale-Bopp. ~1000 l/s at 67P. Do you know what a 1000 litres looks like? That is a container of water that is a cube of 1m on a side. Every second. And according to the idiot Thornhill, it shouldn't be there. You lose. Again.
 
So you are saying YES to an ambipolar electric field at all asteroids but are still unsure for comets?

Like I've said, it is irrelevant to the failures of your model. It's doing squat at asteroids, so why would it at comets? I'm sure Deca, or one of the other authors, stressed that this was at low activity levels. They were using ~ 3 l/s at 3 AU. And said things may be different at higher activity levels around perihelion. However, it is all irrelevant.
 
..................does not make the assumption that comets are mostly ice even remotely true.

Who is saying that? Nobody. For decades. The idiot Thornhill used it as a strawman. Given that his scientific illiteracy, lies, obfuscation and misrepresentation are all the clown has to convince his acolytes, then we should not be surprised about that.
 
It’s a great paper, hey jd116,

Tom Bridgman's blog first brought it to my attention. However, I think you fail to understand the significance of it, regarding your claims. What is generally not happening at asteroids, but is happening at comets? What is the density of asteroids? What is the density of comets? What is not happening to asteroids on elliptical orbits? I could carry on, but it's like.................

 
250 000 l/s at Hale-Bopp. ~1000 l/s at 67P. Do you know what a 1000 litres looks like? That is a container of water that is a cube of 1m on a side. Every second. And according to the idiot Thornhill, it shouldn't be there. You lose. Again.

Too daft too see your own cock up! Truly a sign of a real fair dinkum zealot.

What model did they use for Hale bops “water” production?
 
Too daft too see your own cock up! Truly a sign of a real fair dinkum zealot.

What model did they use for Hale bops “water” production?

Doesn't matter. It's in the ballpark. Probably an underestimate. Halley was ~ 30 000 l/s. Of H2O. Which shouldn't be there, according to the idiot Thornhill. Everywhere we look, your woo fails. And no need to put water in inverted commas - it was water vapour. As it was at Halley. 20 years before the clown Thornhill told us it was OH. Why does that guy lie so much, Sol? Bit clueless, isn't he? (rhetorical question).
 
Last edited:
250 000 l/s at Hale-Bopp. ~1000 l/s at 67P. Do you know what a 1000 litres looks like? That is a container of water that is a cube of 1m on a side. Every second. And according to the idiot Thornhill, it shouldn't be there. You lose. Again.

Out dated and incorrect Haser model has led you to believe comets are mostly ice.

But our understanding is evolving toward mainly rock. :cool:


We’ve now got data from in situ observations from 67P...

Surface localization of gas sources on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko based on DFMS/COPS data

Which trumps a 1950’s model based on observations from Earth.

Comets have a dribble of water that can be more than accounted for via hydrated minerals and CO2 from carbonates. :D

Electric fields anyone?

e found to be especially complex, with nearby sunlit regions of positive potential electrically connected to unlit negative potentials and forming adjacent natural electric dipoles. For objects near the surface, we find electrical dissipation times (through collection of local environmental solar wind currents) that vary over at least 5 orders of mag- nitude: from 39 ls inside the near-surface photoelectron cloud under direct sunlight to ��1 s inside the particle-depleted nightside wake and shadowed pocket regions.
Grid-free 2D plasma simulations of the complex interaction between the solar wind and small, near-Earth asteroids

Now one wonders how charged dust is emitted from the nucleus...:rolleyes:


Poor jd116, useing out dated and incorrect models.
 
Last edited:
Doesn't matter. It's in the ballpark. Probably an underestimate. Halley was ~ 30 000 l/s. Of H2O. Which shouldn't be there, according to the idiot Thornhill. Everywhere we look, your woo fails. And no need to put water in inverted commas - it was water vapour. As it was at Halley. 20 years before the clown Thornhill told us it was OH. Why does that guy lie so much, Sol? Bit clueless, isn't he? (rhetorical question).


Electric fields champ!

You know the one you refuse to acknowledge. :D

Because all of a sudden we are talking the electric comet model by default and not the outdated Dirtysnowball.

If we are not comparing the ELECTRIC COMET to The Dirtysnowball then we are comparing the ELECTRIC COMET to the evolving mostly rock model with electric fields.:blush:
 
Last edited:
Doesn't matter. It's in the ballpark. Probably an underestimate. Halley was ~ 30 000 l/s. Of H2O. Which shouldn't be there, according to the idiot Thornhill. Everywhere we look, your woo fails. And no need to put water in inverted commas - it was water vapour. As it was at Halley. 20 years before the clown Thornhill told us it was OH. Why does that guy lie so much, Sol? Bit clueless, isn't he? (rhetorical question).

Which has more water comets or asteroids?

Both have have ambipolar electric fields and strong surface electric fields and in in at least Tempel 1’s case the same composition.


Failed model much jd116. :jaw-dropp

You may even ask what the difference between an asteroid and a comets is.

Seems it all a bit blurry except their orbits and state of charge.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom