So the best the brains here can come up with is blah blah blah whinge whinge whinge...ad nuseum
When actual pressed to present their NEW non dirtysnowball model the Whipple’s
[2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model of comets envisioned as mostly ice, we hear crickets.
And when A'Hearn said HIS understanding was EVOLVING toward mainly ROCK, we came up with some convoluted excuse he did not mean actual ROCK but a mixture of ICES and DUST, this is still just the first quantitative model of comets, the DIRTYSNOWBALL.
Now, everyone here has agreed A'Hearn is wrong and Whipple is also WRONG. So that leaves no model for the mainstream.
I understand science EVOLVES as new data becomes available and the new data is lending more weight to A'Hearn's understanding that Whipple’s
[2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice may not be the correct interpretation of said data.
There are quite a few papers out there that directly contradict each other or omit facts that leave them stumped on exactly what's going on.
It's been a real hoot to watch Jonesdave116 and Reality Check loudly and proudly proclaim ROCK is not actual ROCK...
Bugger sorry RC, my error it's not the DIRTYSNOWBALL any more it's the DIRTY Snowball!
Science evolving! love it.