The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So comets are mostly charged DUST then? So cometary nuclei are charged bodies of MOSTLY DUST?

Stop being stupid. The vast majority of dust is WITHIN the comet. How would it get charged? Jesus H. Christ, this is like discussing QM with a baboon.
 
So, where are we now with the electric comet 'model'? What have we learned after over a decade of this woo being spammed around various fora on the internet? Let's break it down to its most fundamental claims, as per the Thornhill & Talbott poster from 2006;

Comets are rocks, blasted from planets by unknown electric woo.
Leaving aside the scientifically impossible mechanisms described to achieve this, we need only look at the composition of planets and moons, and at the composition of comets, and do a comparison. Earth, Mars, Mercury and Venus; all rock with high density. Comets; highly porous mixture of dust (fluffy and compact), ice and organics, with very low density.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Comets are merely asteroids on elliptical orbits.
Any cursory examination of the many asteroids on elliptical orbits shows this to be wrong.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.
Electric discharges would show up in the magnetometer data. There was nothing. The jets are observed to be gas, dust and, sometimes, ice.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

There is little to no ice, and the water observed is actually OH.
Water has been definitively detected at comets since 1986. So that was a lie.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The OH (H2O?) that is observed is due to solar wind H+ combining with O-.
Impossible. The H+ ions are far too energetic to combine with anything.
There is nowhere near enough H+ to explain even 1 litre of water per second.
There is little to no O-.
The solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus for about 8 months around perihelion.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Those are the fundamental building blocks underlying the electric comet model. Verdict? It fails. Horribly, and indisputably. The electric comet model was stillborn. It was never alive, and nobody has come close to zapping its stinking corpse with 50 000 volts to bring it to life. It is a miserable, neo-Velikovskian heap of trash, dreamed up by unqualified woo merchants. It is a joke. It isn't worthy of our attention
.

Still waiting.
 
Last edited:
Sol88, I think you would do better if you dropped the idea that EC must be right if the scientific understanding of comets is wrong (although as I can see it, at present it is more a question of the scientific understanding being not completely right, like all scientific understanding).

This is a thread about EC and SAFIRE. What about addressing this, and concentrate on the actual problems with EC. You could start by disassociate yourself from those elements of Thornhill's EC that are obviously wrong, if you think there are any. How about taking jonesdave116's list and tell us what is right and what is wrong in this list?
 
Stop being stupid. The vast majority of dust is WITHIN the comet. How would it get charged? Jesus H. Christ, this is like discussing QM with a baboon.


I thought you were of the opinion that at 75% porosity that the majority of the comet nucleus was vacuum? The rest being refractory dust with a minimal component of "ice".

Anywhoo there appears to be dust of varying sizes on the surface and this is charged, this is a dusty plasma!

Do you agree?
 
I thought you were of the opinion that at 75% porosity that the majority of the comet nucleus was vacuum? The rest being refractory dust with a minimal component of "ice".

Anywhoo there appears to be dust of varying sizes on the surface and this is charged, this is a dusty plasma!

Do you agree?

Irrelevant. Nothing to do with the EC idiocy. Show us where the idiot Thornhill discusses charged dust. There shouldn't be any according to that loon. Discuss why your woo has totally failed.
 
Sol88, I think you would do better if you dropped the idea that EC must be right if the scientific understanding of comets is wrong (although as I can see it, at present it is more a question of the scientific understanding being not completely right, like all scientific understanding).

This is a thread about EC and SAFIRE. What about addressing this, and concentrate on the actual problems with EC. You could start by disassociate yourself from those elements of Thornhill's EC that are obviously wrong, if you think there are any. How about taking jonesdave116's list and tell us what is right and what is wrong in this list?

G'day steenkh

Perhaps you like to read The effect of asymmetric surface topography on dust dynamics on airless bodies

Understand that the dust at a comet nucleus, at least the surface, is charged and that there is an ambipolar electric field in operation at a comet! On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2869

And that the comet is mostly dust, refractory dust with a minimal ice content!
The refractory-to-ice mass ratio in comets
This constraint
confirms that comets can be defined as “mineral organices” (Fulle et al. 2016b), i.e. a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them, and provides a disentangling test for all models describing the (probably common) origin of comets and KBOs.
 
G'day steenkh

Perhaps you like to read The effect of asymmetric surface topography on dust dynamics on airless bodies

Understand that the dust at a comet nucleus, at least the surface, is charged and that there is an ambipolar electric field in operation at a comet! On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2869

And that the comet is mostly dust, refractory dust with a minimal ice content!
The refractory-to-ice mass ratio in comets

And none of that has any relevance whatsoever to the electric comet idiocy.
 
Sol88, I think you would do better if you dropped the idea that EC must be right if the scientific understanding of comets is wrong (although as I can see it, at present it is more a question of the scientific understanding being not completely right, like all scientific understanding).

This is a thread about EC and SAFIRE. What about addressing this, and concentrate on the actual problems with EC. You could start by disassociate yourself from those elements of Thornhill's EC that are obviously wrong, if you think there are any. How about taking jonesdave116's list and tell us what is right and what is wrong in this list?

Already have, few pages back now.

I think there are a few bits and pieces that need revising, such as,ELECTROSTATIC CLEANING
The surface of Tempel 1 contrasts with the surface of the asteroid Itokawa (right). The asteroid appears to have attracted considerable surface debris electrostatically. We suggested an active comet will do the reverse.
http://thunderbolts.info/pdf/ElectricComet.pdf



Oh, no scrap that,Wal’s is on the money, especially if there is an ambipolar electric field in operation on at comets. Probably accelerates the dust of the nucleus but depending on charge could attract as well. Does sublimation do this?

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0019103516302573?via=ihub
 
Last edited:
Nope, never happened. You just crossed it out and ignored it. Because you have no explanation for the complete failure of this woo.

Is the dust charged? = yes

Is the an electric field centred on the nucleus = yes

:thumbsup:

I’m :D
 
I'm not watching lying EU crap on YT. He deliberately lied to you. Tempel 1 killed this rubbish. You cannot impact rock and produce water ice. Scientifically impossible.

So, I relented and watched this crap. As predicted it was more lying and impossible mechanisms. There was no electric discharge. Such a thing would have been seen by Chandra and SWIFT. It didn't happen. And the electrochemical stuff is pure woo. The solar wind is combining with nothing at that speed. How are you getting solid ice? Lol. And why did they wait 7-8 years after the detection of the ice to comment on it? Retrospective lying, after somebody likely pointed it out to him.
 
Thanks jt

Where would one get the best information on the mainstream model of comets?

You know like the one you are referencing?

NASA?
ESA?

Surely not wiki?

The latest model of course, not the Dirtysnowball model of comets as mostly ice sublimating under the warmth of the Sun.

Seems i’ve been under the wrong impression for 12 odd years now...:o

Feel like a bit of a goose and would like to study on the CURRENT mainstream model of comets.

Is that a reasonable request?
No. Not now, not ever.

We are, in this thread, discussing the Electric Comet Theory (or model, EC for short).

It is very hard to have such a discussion, partly because of your obsession with the logical fallacy False Dichotomy, but, these days, mostly because you keep contradicting yourself, sometimes more than once in the same day! :jaw-dropp

For example, one day it’s ROCK, with a bulk density of ~3-5; next day it’s mostly space with ROCK in between. One day it’s charging and discharging in a radial electric field centered on the Sun; next day it’s kinetic plasma effects local to the comet. And so on. And on. And on ...

But whatever it is, it resembles religion more than science.

Long since past time to close this thread, or more it to a more suitable board. Admins: please do so.
 
So the best the brains here can come up with is blah blah blah whinge whinge whinge...ad nuseum

When actual pressed to present their NEW non dirtysnowball model the Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model of comets envisioned as mostly ice, we hear crickets. :)

And when A'Hearn said HIS understanding was EVOLVING toward mainly ROCK, we came up with some convoluted excuse he did not mean actual ROCK but a mixture of ICES and DUST, this is still just the first quantitative model of comets, the DIRTYSNOWBALL.

Now, everyone here has agreed A'Hearn is wrong and Whipple is also WRONG. So that leaves no model for the mainstream.

I understand science EVOLVES as new data becomes available and the new data is lending more weight to A'Hearn's understanding that Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice may not be the correct interpretation of said data.

There are quite a few papers out there that directly contradict each other or omit facts that leave them stumped on exactly what's going on.

It's been a real hoot to watch Jonesdave116 and Reality Check loudly and proudly proclaim ROCK is not actual ROCK... :)

Bugger sorry RC, my error it's not the DIRTYSNOWBALL any more it's the DIRTY Snowball!

Science evolving! love it.


I would think the market for electric comet fan fiction is rather limited. Still, best of luck.
 
So, I relented and watched this crap. As predicted it was more lying and impossible mechanisms. There was no electric discharge. Such a thing would have been seen by Chandra and SWIFT. It didn't happen. And the electrochemical stuff is pure woo. The solar wind is combining with nothing at that speed. How are you getting solid ice? Lol. And why did they wait 7-8 years after the detection of the ice to comment on it? Retrospective lying, after somebody likely pointed it out to him.

Yawn, we don’t need no hidden pure ice invoked to be at depth inside a comet (which actually should raise some serious questions in self wrt density) the EC just needs water vapour.

5. Conclusion [17] Our results demonstrate that ice grains spontaneously form in a suitably cooled plasma containing water vapor. No external nucleation material is required, i.e., homogeneous ionic nucleation takes place. Furthermore, the ice grains are aspherical when the background pressure is lower than a certain pressure and presumably this aspherical shape develops soonafter nucleation rather thanlater when the grains arelarge. This result implies that it is plausible that aspherical ice grains are commoninnaturally occurring plasmas (Saturn’s rings, polar mesosphere clouds, and molecular clouds) in which case existing modelsassuming spherical grains wouldhave toberevised. This is important because ellipsoidal grains will have significantly different interactions with electromagnetic radiation in terms of effective cross section and in terms of how scattered light depends on the polarization of incident light [Holland and Gagne, 1970]. In particular, just as long chaff scatters radar most efficiently, highly elongated grains will provide much stronger scattering of electromagnetic radiation than the same mass arranged in a sphere.
Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment doi:10.1002/2013GL058268

1um pure ice grains....??


As far as I can tell, no one here as an issue with the findings from the deep impact experiment in which hydrated minerals were found. Also the impact would vaporised the hydrated minerals, total dissociating the constitute molecules.

You would also notice they would tend to line up with an electric field, such as the one in operation at comets. You would also note the latest papers suggest the dust at 67p is also elongate and responding to the ambipolar electric field.

One would also note Dr Anariba’s electrochemical water production needs a potential difference, a driving voltage for it to be even considered.

So looks like it’s a common process for the formation of water ice grains. Well done mainstream science. :thumbsup:

Now, jd116, jt, Fred, what say Ye to this evidence? Again.

Frost patch’s on 67p anyone?
 
Last edited:
Yawn, we don’t need no hidden pure ice invoked to be at depth inside a comet (which actually should raise some serious questions in self wrt density) the EC just needs water vapour.

And you have no mechanism to get water vapour, nor how to turn it into ice. Only an idiot would believe that. Do you believe it Sol? I expect you do.
 
As far as I can tell, no one here as an issue with the findings from the deep impact experiment in which hydrated minerals were found. Also the impact would vaporised the hydrated minerals, total dissociating the constitute molecules.

Errr, far too hot. You need ~ 600 C to bake water out of hydrated minerals. The ice and water at Tempel 1 was well below that. Idiotic argument. Try again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom