The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Insane "sublimation is not needed or OBSERVED" lies

As I've stated sublimation is not needed or OBSERVED. It's been implied and invoked.
Insane "sublimation is not needed or OBSERVED" lies as part of Sol88's electric comet insanity.

We measure in labs that ices in vacuum at cometary temperatures sublimate. We measure that comets are made of ices and dust. We observe the gases given off by sublimating ices :jaw-dropp.
 
Repeated Sol88 "HYDRATED minerals/ROCK" electric comet insanity

the water ions you attribute to solid ice comes from the HYDRATED minerals and I'd hazard a guess CO2, CO come from the CARBONATES! The refractory minerals are also be emitted from the in situ dissociation of ROCK!
Repeated Sol88 "HYDRATED minerals/ROCK" electric comet insanity and lies.

We have never observed solid ice. We observe water and other ices mixed with dust. We observe water molecules. We observe disassociated water ions from those water molecules.

Sol88's insanity of electrical discharges and electrical discharges machining has never been detected. Sol88's ignorant delusions do not make CO and CO2 into carbonates. Deluded lies do not make the carbonate minerals created in the early solar system into carbonate minerals created on Earth or other rocky planets and blasted off recently as in Sol88 electric comet insanity.
 
Last edited:
Mainstream paper insanity as part of Sol88's electric comet insanity

Mainstream paper insanity as part of Sol88's electric comet insanity and usual ignorant delusions about electric fields.

Sol88's ignorant delusions about electric fields does not invalidate actual physics.

Tom Bridgman did a valid calculation of the electrostatic forces between Rosetta and 67P that with Harvey's calculation showed how physically insane Sol88's cult is (voltage of 35 GeV on 67P!).
 
Simply pathetic!

Since my last visit, there have been 245 posts in a little over 100 hours!

We should be rolling into Part V of this dead-end thread sometime in January!

And with all this 'talk' there is still no 'electric comet' model! No 'electric comet' science!

The arguments put forward by our resident 'ec' expert are the same as those posted two years ago! Four years ago! Nine years ago! ...!

No progress!

And yet ....
 
Simply pathetic!

Since my last visit, there have been 245 posts in a little over 100 hours!

We should be rolling into Part V of this dead-end thread sometime in January!

And with all this 'talk' there is still no 'electric comet' model! No 'electric comet' science!

The arguments put forward by our resident 'ec' expert are the same as those posted two years ago! Four years ago! Nine years ago! ...!

No progress!

And yet ....

a new MAINSTREAM paper is released!

tap tap tap another nail..


Sol889 other the other hand a totally scientifically illiterate woo boy, predicted the charged dust is accelerated of the nucleus via the ambipolar electric field double layers!

On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Have a read and get back to me when you can. ;)
 
Last edited:
I start by assuming you have read the papers jd116, indigator, rc?

Let’s go in chronological order.

Spitzer

Spitzer Space Telescope imaging spectrometer observations of comet 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact encounter returned detailed, highly structured, 5- to 35-micrometer spectra of the ejecta. Emission signatures due to amorphous and crystalline silicates, amorphous carbon, carbonates, phyllosilicates, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, water gas and ice, and sulfides were found. Good agreement is seen between the ejecta spectra and the material emitted from comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) and the circumstellar material around the young stellar object HD100546. The atomic abundance of the observed material is consistent with solar and C1 chondritic abundances, and the dust-to-gas ratio was determined to be greater than or equal to 1.3. The presence of the observed mix of materials requires efficient methods of annealing amorphous silicates and mixing of high- and low-temperature phases over large distances in the early protosolar nebula.


How do the assembled “experts” here on the thread, reconcile the bolded texts?

A see A’Hearn had a few mentions. He also knew comets to be mostly ice.

Before he’s death he’s understanding had evolved toward mostly rock. Why?


Sol88!

With respect to your invitation, I would love to discuss the first paper with you!

However, before we do, I would like to deal with a couple minor issues.

At the outset, the name is Indagator! Only one "I" and it is capitalized! Please and thank you! Civility dictates that we at least get each others names spelled correctly! And there should be no attempts at corrupting another posters handle in the hopes of insulting them (as you have done in the past)! Dig?

Next? Let's talk about what is involved in acquiring scientific knowledge. In order for a "student" to succeed, be it academically or in a personal "scientific" pursuit, they MUST learn three things ....

First, they must learn the subject matter! That should be obvious, of course! For example, before one can pursue higher education in subjects such as astrophysics, geophysics, biophysics, or engineering physics, one must learn basic, fundamental physics! That includes statics, mechanics, thermodynamics, electricity, and magnetism! As a co-requisite, one must also simultaneously learn the tools of the trade - calculus, statistics, and computer programming! Please note, this is not a complete list of course material, by any means! And before one can even think about plasma physics, one needs three to four solid years of A+ fundamentals!

Second, and this is one you, Sol88, personally need to work on ... reading for comprehension! Based on your posting history, it is obvious that you have a strong religious bias, or agenda! This impairs your perception of the real world! Reading for comprehension does not come naturally to us. Problem is, we are story tellers! And some of us start our 'academic' adventures with preconceived ideas of what is true! Regardless of where we start, we can learn to read for comprehension! And with the overwhelming amount of misinformation prevalent throughout the internet, we MUST learn to read for comprehension!

As relates to my last point, reading for comprehension requires one to be skeptical of all they read! And to question everything!

Third! Observational skills! Remember this question from ASSIGNMENT #001?

1) Describe in detail, what YOU see in this OSIRIS NAC "telescope" image!

Do you see rock? Do you see an electric discharge? Do you see ice? Or do you see nothing more than a pretty "picture" of 67P? Is the lesson attached to this image starting to sink in?

WHY IS CONTEXT IMPORTANT?

Three "professionals" walk into a pub; an aeronautical engineer, a police officer, and a sheep herder! Of the three, which has the most acute observational skills? Trick question! We've not been given a situation! We've not been given any context! Are we investigating a traffic accident or a plane crash? Or perhaps are we concerned with a predatory threat that could adversely impact the health of a herd! Unless an individual is knowledgeable or familiar with the 'contextual' subject matter, they are going to make a terrible "witness" to an event! Now, do you notice anything 'odd' about the scenario just presented?

CONTEXT! CONTEXT! CONTEXT!

To summarize, anyone pursuing 'scientific' knowledge must,
1) Learn the subject matter, including the most boring of fundamentals!
2) Learn comprehensive reading skills!
3) Learn appropriate observational skills!

FYI - I don't just teach these ideas, I apply them to my own intellectual pursuits!

Now, regarding the first paper, I don't recall reading it in the past, so I'll need to find some time to pull me thoughts together! You've been at this for more than twelve years! I ask for a little patience, please! I'll present something within hours.
 
Simply pathetic!

Since my last visit, there have been 245 posts in a little over 100 hours!

We should be rolling into Part V of this dead-end thread sometime in January!

And with all this 'talk' there is still no 'electric comet' model! No 'electric comet' science!

The arguments put forward by our resident 'ec' expert are the same as those posted two years ago! Four years ago! Nine years ago! ...!

No progress!

And yet ....

I hope you notice that most of the post go something like this...

LIAR, deluded, insanity, insults, idiocy, abysmal, ignorance, blah blah blah, no evidence, no true, blah blah, whinge whinge...

Yet here AGAIN is the evidence there is a ELECTRIC FIELD centered on a cometary nucleus...and the mainstream seem stumped by some strange and unexpected acceleration mechanism?

Now, one would have to wonder if the dust is charged (Dusty plasma) ions and electrons (charged particles) along with a electric field centered on the nucleus...now :eusa_think:
 
Last edited:
Sol88!

With respect to your invitation, I would love to discuss the first paper with you!

However, before we do, I would like to deal with a couple minor issues.

At the outset, the name is Indagator! Only one "I" and it is capitalized! Please and thank you! Civility dictates that we at least get each others names spelled correctly! And there should be no attempts at corrupting another posters handle in the hopes of insulting them (as you have done in the past)! Dig?

Next? Let's talk about what is involved in acquiring scientific knowledge. In order for a "student" to succeed, be it academically or in a personal "scientific" pursuit, they MUST learn three things ....

First, they must learn the subject matter! That should be obvious, of course! For example, before one can pursue higher education in subjects such as astrophysics, geophysics, biophysics, or engineering physics, one must learn basic, fundamental physics! That includes statics, mechanics, thermodynamics, electricity, and magnetism! As a co-requisite, one must also simultaneously learn the tools of the trade - calculus, statistics, and computer programming! Please note, this is not a complete list of course material, by any means! And before one can even think about plasma physics, one needs three to four solid years of A+ fundamentals!

Second, and this is one you, Sol88, personally need to work on ... reading for comprehension! Based on your posting history, it is obvious that you have a strong religious bias, or agenda! This impairs your perception of the real world! Reading for comprehension does not come naturally to us. Problem is, we are story tellers! And some of us start our 'academic' adventures with preconceived ideas of what is true! Regardless of where we start, we can learn to read for comprehension! And with the overwhelming amount of misinformation prevalent throughout the internet, we MUST learn to read for comprehension!

As relates to my last point, reading for comprehension requires one to be skeptical of all they read! And to question everything!

Third! Observational skills! Remember this question from ASSIGNMENT #001?

1) Describe in detail, what YOU see in this OSIRIS NAC "telescope" image!

Do you see rock? Do you see an electric discharge? Do you see ice? Or do you see nothing more than a pretty "picture" of 67P? Is the lesson attached to this image starting to sink in?

WHY IS CONTEXT IMPORTANT?

Three "professionals" walk into a pub; an aeronautical engineer, a police officer, and a sheep herder! Of the three, which has the most acute observational skills? Trick question! We've not been given a situation! We've not been given any context! Are we investigating a traffic accident or a plane crash? Or perhaps are we concerned with a predatory threat that could adversely impact the health of a herd! Unless an individual is knowledgeable or familiar with the 'contextual' subject matter, they are going to make a terrible "witness" to an event! Now, do you notice anything 'odd' about the scenario just presented?

CONTEXT! CONTEXT! CONTEXT!

To summarize, anyone pursuing 'scientific' knowledge must,
1) Learn the subject matter, including the most boring of fundamentals!
2) Learn comprehensive reading skills!
3) Learn appropriate observational skills!

FYI - I don't just teach these ideas, I apply them to my own intellectual pursuits!

Now, regarding the first paper, I don't recall reading it in the past, so I'll need to find some time to pull me thoughts together! You've been at this for more than twelve years! I ask for a little patience, please! I'll present something within hours.

Awesome! I appreciate your post and understand you.

Then with out taking a break, read this one first Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet This was the paper that really got jizz on the monitor!

These reinforce the my views. On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae, The root of a comet tail – Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view., Size of a plasma cloud matters The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere

and once youv'e read them you MAY or MAY not think the electric fields play a DOMINATE role in cometary dynamics!

Because this mob seem to totaly ignorant of this fact, Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Near-surface accelerations inconsistent with the free sublimation
of water ice have been found in earlier studies (Agarwal et al. 2016;
Kramer & Noack 2016), suggesting that the underlying process may
be quite common and significantly contribute to the mass-loss in comet 67P.

Sorry about your name, my apologies.
 
Last edited:
This paper brings nothing but the heat...

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical
parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Near-surface accelerations inconsistent with the free sublimation of water ice have been found in earlier studies (Agarwal et al. 2016; Kramer & Noack 2016), suggesting that the underlying process may
be quite common and significantly contribute to the mass-loss in comet 67P.
Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03


I'm sure you can connect the dots.

As long as you keep the options open and accept sublimation is indeed not needed and electric fields are in operation around comets!

More than happy to discuss with someone with out the thread being spammed with
LIAR, deluded, insanity, insults, idiocy, abysmal, ignorance, blah blah blah, no evidence, no true, blah blah, whinge whinge...

From just a couple posters!
 
Last edited:
As relates to my last point, reading for comprehension requires one to be skeptical of all they read! And to question everything!

Third! Observational skills! Remember this question from ASSIGNMENT #001?

1) Describe in detail, what YOU see in this OSIRIS NAC "telescope" image!

Do you see rock? Do you see an electric discharge? Do you see ice? Or do you see nothing more than a pretty "picture" of 67P? Is the lesson attached to this image starting to sink in?

WHY IS CONTEXT IMPORTANT?

Three "professionals" walk into a pub; an aeronautical engineer, a police officer, and a sheep herder! Of the three, which has the most acute observational skills? Trick question! We've not been given a situation! We've not been given any context! Are we investigating a traffic accident or a plane crash? Or perhaps are we concerned with a predatory threat that could adversely impact the health of a herd! Unless an individual is knowledgeable or familiar with the 'contextual' subject matter, they are going to make a terrible "witness" to an event! Now, do you notice anything 'odd' about the scenario just presented?

CONTEXT! CONTEXT! CONTEXT!

To summarize, anyone pursuing 'scientific' knowledge must,
1) Learn the subject matter, including the most boring of fundamentals!
2) Learn comprehensive reading skills!
3) Learn appropriate observational skills!

FYI - I don't just teach these ideas, I apply them to my own intellectual pursuits!

Now, regarding the first paper, I don't recall reading it in the past, so I'll need to find some time to pull me thoughts together! You've been at this for more than twelve years! I ask for a little patience, please! I'll present something within hours.

Yup, gave up looking at "bunnies" along time ago but as for your image and within context of the ELECTRIC COMET. That's a short circuit.

Follow the circuit!

Energy conversion in cometary atmospheres: Hybrid modeling of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Aims. We wish to investigate the energy conversion between particles and electromagnetic fields and determine the location where it occurs in the plasma environment of comets.

Methods. We used a hybrid plasma model that included photoionization, and we considered two cases of the solar extreme ultraviolet flux. Other parameters corresponded to the conditions of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko at a heliocentric distance of 1.5 AU.

Results. We find that a shock-like structure is formed upstream of the comet and acts as an electromagnetic generator, similar to the bow shock at Earth that slows down the solar wind. The Poynting flux transports electromagnetic energy toward the inner coma, where newly born cometary ions are accelerated. Upstream of the shock-like structure, we find local energy transfer from solar wind ions to cometary ions. We show that mass loading can be a local process with a direct transfer of energy, but also part of a dynamo system with electromagnetic generators and loads.

Conclusions. The energization of cometary ions is governed by a dynamo system for weak ionization, but changes into a large conversion region with local transfer of energy directly from solar wind protons for high ionization.
 
I'm sure you can connect the dots.

As long as you keep the options open and accept sublimation is indeed not needed and electric fields are in operation around comets!

More irrelevant crap. YOU connect the dots. No rock, no discharges. You lost. Give up.
 
Aims. We wish to investigate the energy conversion between particles and electromagnetic fields and determine the location where it occurs in the plasma environment of comets.

Methods. We used a hybrid plasma model that included photoionization, and we considered two cases of the solar extreme ultraviolet flux. Other parameters corresponded to the conditions of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko at a heliocentric distance of 1.5 AU.

Results. We find that a shock-like structure is formed upstream of the comet and acts as an electromagnetic generator, similar to the bow shock at Earth that slows down the solar wind. The Poynting flux transports electromagnetic energy toward the inner coma, where newly born cometary ions are accelerated. Upstream of the shock-like structure, we find local energy transfer from solar wind ions to cometary ions. We show that mass loading can be a local process with a direct transfer of energy, but also part of a dynamo system with electromagnetic generators and loads.

Conclusions. The energization of cometary ions is governed by a dynamo system for weak ionization, but changes into a large conversion region with local transfer of energy directly from solar wind protons for high ionization.

And what the hell has tht got to do with the idiotic electric comet woo? Nothing. Give up.
 
Near-surface accelerations inconsistent with the free sublimation of water ice have been found in earlier studies (Agarwal et al. 2016; Kramer & Noack 2016), suggesting that the underlying process may
be quite common and significantly contribute to the mass-loss in comet 67P.

What the hell has that got to do with the failed electric comet woo? You lost. Get over it. Give up. Where is the ice in that outburst coming from in your Velikovskian woo?
 
Because this mob seem to totaly ignorant of this fact, Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03

Stop lying. That paper has NOTHING to do with your failed woo. Nothing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom