Sol88
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2009
- Messages
- 8,437
Edited by zooterkin:
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
Last edited by a moderator:
What's going on here Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist?
Are you able to clarify since you've also done some work on Earths magnetoshpere
What's going on is what is written down there.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/abs/2018/08/aa32353-17/aa32353-17.htmlResults. We find that a shock-like structure is formed upstream of the comet and acts as an electromagnetic generator, similar to the bow shock at Earth that slows down the solar wind. The Poynting flux transports electromagnetic energy toward the inner coma, where newly born cometary ions are accelerated. Upstream of the shock-like structure, we find local energy transfer from solar wind ions to cometary ions. We show that mass loading can be a local process with a direct transfer of energy, but also part of a dynamo system with electromagnetic generators and loads.
What are these structure called, tusenfem?
I did ask rc but nothing, do you know, tusenfem?
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/abs/2018/08/aa32353-17/aa32353-17.html
Nah, yeah you’ve confabulated it stinky!
What I said is comets are rock but not really knowing the Rosetta mob didn’t have a name for a mixture of ices and dust. So reality check said we, the Royal we, call it rock for WANT of a better term.
So we call comets rock but not actual fair dinkum bona fide true blue rock but a highly porous mixture of ices and dust with a soft fluffy outer layer, a hard crunchy shell and the reminder of said ice and dust mix.
Some said this mix contained MOSTLY ice but data appears to say MOSTLY dust.
So just for ease of conversation we’ll all call it rock as but not actual rock. It’s seems it was just an unfortunate use of the the term that our understanding of cometary nuclei is evolving mostly toward ROCK along with this CONSOLIDATED MATERIAL or BEDROCK and FRACTURED LAYERED TERRAIN. So you see rock is just easier to write 4 letters.
But we don’t mean actual rock, bedrock, consolidated material with fractured and layered terrain.
Now steenkth, are you aware of the electric field centred on the rocky nucleus?
So now we have comets are rock but not actual real rock and double layers that maybe plasma structures very similar to electric double layers.
They are called "shock-like structures" just as Jesper writes.
Oh just for the lurkers
Double layers and electrostatic shocks in space
I can hear you grinding your teeth from here jd116!
Nope, no rock, no double layers. And not a jot of evidence for either. No scientist on the planet is claiming that there is. No discharges, no EDM (lol). I'm sorry, but this woo is as dead now as it always was. An evidence-free zone of scientifically illiterate woo from people who couldn't find their own arses with an extra pair of hands.
Nope, just amazed that somebody can be so thick as to misunderstand yet another paper, and pretend that it has anything to do with the unscientific electric comet insanity, which has been thoroughly debunked.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/RG017i003p00418Abstract
In recent years, much evidence has been accumulated which supports the existence of spatially limited regions of strong electric fields (>100 mV/m) parallel to the magnetic field. Evidence which will be reviewed comes from rocket measurements, satellite observations, and plasma cloud releases above the polar ionosphere. The most plausible explanation of such structures is provided by the concept of double layers or electrostatic shocks, which are double layers moving in relation to the plasma. We also review some recent laboratory investigations of double layers which show that double layers can exist for long periods of time. The production of these structures requires large currents.
Nope, just amazed that somebody can be so thick as to misunderstand yet another paper, and pretend that it has anything to do with the unscientific electric comet insanity, which has been thoroughly debunked.
Read the paper yet jonesey me 'ol m8?
Double layers and electrostatic shocks in space
Oh and not real rock
Edited by zooterkin:<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
Please provide the papers where these structures Wrt comets has been discussed before in peer reviewed mainstream papers.
Why would I? Nobody is claiming that there are DLs, or EDM (lol). The electric comet is a busted flush. And the author of the paper, J. Lindkvist, has his email on the paper. Shouldn't be beyond the wit of man to contact him and clarify whatever it is that you are misunderstanding. What are you waiting for?
Not relevant to comets, and predates all cometary missions.
Your a clever enough cookie jd116, you'll work it out.
so now we have electromagnetic structure connected by electric currents in circuits that can as a load on this circuit or as particle accelerators. astronomers don't have a name for these structures so we call them plasma double layers as this it what these structure look like on paper.
Sorry mate, i'm confused. these "shock-like structures" can act as loads and generators?
Do you think there is an electrostatic potential in this shock, like the one you found in Earths magnetosphere, tusenfem?
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/RG017i003p00418
Do you also go la la la when someone tells you stuff you are just to fundamentally indoctrinated to rationally see whats right before your very eyes in hard scientific data??
Edited by zooterkin:<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
More irrelevant insults and questions to derail rom his electric comet insanity.More than ok to say your completely clueless rc!
....
!Abstract
Aims. We wish to investigate the energy conversion between particles and electromagnetic fields and determine the location where it occurs in the plasma environment of comets.
Methods. We used a hybrid plasma model that included photoionization, and we considered two cases of the solar extreme ultraviolet flux. Other parameters corresponded to the conditions of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko at a heliocentric distance of 1.5 AU.
Results. We find that a shock-like structure is formed upstream of the comet and acts as an electromagnetic generator, similar to the bow shock at Earth that slows down the solar wind. The Poynting flux transports electromagnetic energy toward the inner coma, where newly born cometary ions are accelerated. Upstream of the shock-like structure, we find local energy transfer from solar wind ions to cometary ions. We show that mass loading can be a local process with a direct transfer of energy, but also part of a dynamo system with electromagnetic generators and loads.
Conclusions. The energization of cometary ions is governed by a dynamo system for weak ionization, but changes into a large conversion region with local transfer of energy directly from solar wind protons for high ionization.