The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
As shown by Don Scott in his paper on Birkeland currents.

Is a current force free when perpendicular to the magnetic field?

Sol88, we've covered this so called paper by Scott before; it's garbage.

Why is it that you seem completely unable to discuss science here, or even post something new?
 
Right! if that is the only thing you can take home from my post, so be it.
This should be moved to the AAH section, as clearly you do not want to learn anything from me.
Every time you come with a post "explain it to the "lurkers"" and when I explain it to you the only thing you can do is complain and misinterprete.
You clearly are not interested in plasma physics, neither in the MHD, kinetic or circuit form, and do not want to learn what is applied when and what the results tell you.
And that is all good and fine, but you have wasted my time long enough.

Administrators, please move this thread to "Abandon All Hope".

Did not ask you this and you’ve been conspicuous by your absence.

Simple question do you agree or disagree that A’Hearn statement that comet nuclei, with 67P in particular, are now MOSTLY ROCK and not MOSTLY ICE?
 
Sol88, we've covered this so called paper by Scott before; it's garbage.

Why is it that you seem completely unable to discuss science here, or even post something new?


Birkeland currents are not real?

They are in operation at comets. :cool:
 
Did not ask you this and you’ve been conspicuous by your absence.

Simple question do you agree or disagree that A’Hearn statement that comet nuclei, with 67P in particular, are now MOSTLY ROCK and not MOSTLY ICE?

Where do you live Sol? Strawman City, W.A.? We didn't visit a comet until '86. Since then, the idea that comets have a shed load of dust (which Whipple also proposed, but how could he know how much?), has evolved with every mission.
And there is not, nor ever has been, any rock detected at a comet.
 
Birkeland currents are not real?

They are in operation at comets. :cool:

No, they are not. You just made that up. Why not deal with the electric comet woo? Where is the rock, where are the discharges? How is the solar wind creating water (hahahaha) when it is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods? Why did the idiot Thornhill lie about it being OH 20 years after it was definitively shown to be H2O?
Care to deal with this, or are you just going to post more irrelevant crap that has nothing to do with your failed 'model' (lol)?
 
Where do you live Sol? Strawman City, W.A.? We didn't visit a comet until '86. Since then, the idea that comets have a shed load of dust (which Whipple also proposed, but how could he know how much?), has evolved with every mission.
And there is not, nor ever has been, any rock detected at a comet.


I see you can’t handle the truth, jd116.

Comets are mostly rock with a minor mass fraction from ice.

That’s what peer reviewed mainstream science says, now.

Can’t really see why it’s so hard for you to swallow.

This is the first tenet of the Electric Comet.

This test has now been confirmed by mainstream big bangers.

Now we are talking electric fields and curcuit theory, Birkeland currents...:cool:
 
No, they are not. You just made that up. Why not deal with the electric comet woo? Where is the rock, where are the discharges? How is the solar wind creating water (hahahaha) when it is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods? Why did the idiot Thornhill lie about it being OH 20 years after it was definitively shown to be H2O?
Care to deal with this, or are you just going to post more irrelevant crap that has nothing to do with your failed 'model' (lol)?

Yes they are, you call the field aligned ELECTRIC CURRENTS.

Confirmed. :thumbsup:

Or would like to have a “discussion” on if they are real or not and if they are in operation at a comet?
 
Last edited:
Where’s all the exposed water ice?

Not a couple m2 or some nightly frost but the MOSTLY ICE nucleus?

This is dark ice inferred from Whipple’s postulate back in the 50’s.

Now things have changed after every comet we see is not the ditysnowball we’ve been told.

There are other procees, that involve plasma, electric fields...

There are more tools in box to use, so why not use them?

Too scary or a physical impossibility for the mainstream?
 
Maybe, jd116, you’d care to discuss the diamagnetic cavity again and your misunderstanding that cometary outgassing is the cause.

Now it seems charge separation does the trick.
 
STOP LYING.

I have linked numerous times to the papers where they estimate the strength from the sound waves. Is it beyond your understanding? Is that why you need to keep LYING?

Knock it off, you have a serious problem. You lost. Get over it.


Oh deary me. :rolleyes:

They never tested rock, why not?


Because Whipple KNEW they were MOSTLY ICE with some dust, the “Dirtysnowball”.

A’Hearn disagrees comets are MOSTLY ROCK.

THE MAINSTREAM NEED TO GET THEIR STUFF TOGETHER and redo fine what a comets is.

They’ve had crack and the best they’ve come up with is comets and asteroids are a continuum!

I’m happy with that. :D

Suits my world view.
 
Yes they are, you call the field aligned ELECTRIC CURRENTS.

Confirmed. :thumbsup:

Or would like to have a “discussion” on if they are real or not and if they are in operation at a comet?

Have you got eyesight problems? Here is the question again;

Where is the rock, where are the discharges? How is the solar wind creating water (hahahaha) when it is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods? Why did the idiot Thornhill lie about it being OH 20 years after it was definitively shown to be H2O?
Care to deal with this, or are you just going to post more irrelevant crap that has nothing to do with your failed 'model' (lol)?

Ignored it, didn't you? Because Thornhill is a liar. Fair enough.
 
They never tested rock, why not?

Serious question; what is your IQ, Sol? Lower than that of a badger? They measured the sound wave velocity from the hammering. It is nothing like rock. Stop lying.
 
Birkeland currents are not real?

They are in operation at comets. :cool:
Again?

This thread is about the electric comet model, and you are the only proponent of that here. You have kept repeating pretty much the same few words, and apparently making no effort to back your assertions with things like quantitative analysis, or even reference to the model itself.

How does this differ from trolling?
 
Correct me if I'm wrong Sol88, but you've introduced this/these before, in this thread, more than once in fact.

And in most instances, the core content of your posts is ~the same; you rarely introduce something new, either content or analysis.

Lately, those who respond to these posts of yours have become repetitious too (the first few times around you'd get something original almost every time).

So, how is what you're doing different from trolling?

Papers from November 2018 on circuit theory in relation to comets and that comets are predominantly refractory dust and organics not new enough for you?

That are just confirming, for me at least, my model is correct.


Comets are rocks discharging in the solar plasma!

Have not changed my stance since day one over at the universe today forum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom