The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
That is not rock. That is just you being scientifically illiterate. As usual. It is a prerequisite of believing the unscientific crap that you believe.


What else did they find beside your imagined shed loads of ice at Tempel 1?

Did they find any clays?

Did they find any carbonates?

Did they sweep it under the carpet because IT does not fit with Whipple's outdated and incorrect dirtysnowball model?

You have nothing but OLD papers sport. We used to think comets as MOSTLY ICE now MOSTLY ROCK!!

That lying useless old codger and hes MOSTLY ROCK statement.

Every idiot knows comets are mostly vacuum with ice and some dust, correct jonesdave116?

Some people evolve some don't.

You've made your bed champ, lets discuss some more AFTER the new papers.

You don't like the papers that mess with your paradigm anyway.

Such as....Martin Pätzold's Paper

You conveniently ignored that paper.
 
What else did they find beside your imagined shed loads of ice at Tempel 1?

Did they find any clays?

Did they find any carbonates?

Did they sweep it under the carpet because IT does not fit with Whipple's outdated and incorrect dirtysnowball model?

You have nothing but OLD papers sport. We used to think comets as MOSTLY ICE now MOSTLY ROCK!!

That lying useless old codger and hes MOSTLY ROCK statement.

Every idiot knows comets are mostly vacuum with ice and some dust, correct jonesdave116?

Some people evolve some don't.

You've made your bed champ, lets discuss some more AFTER the new papers.

You don't like the papers that mess with your paradigm anyway.

Such as....Martin Pätzold's Paper

You conveniently ignored that paper.

Liar. There was nothing imagined about the thousands of tonnes of ice excavated at Tempel 1. Why do you lie so much? Because that one observation (by different instruments) kills your woo stone dead? 14 years ago. Is that why you lie? It is killing your religion?
And there are no papers, new or otherwise that outline the detection of rock. That is just you being economical with the truth. Again. Otherwise you'd link to them. Give up. You lost waaaaaay back. Why are you still here? Does your religion demand it?
 
Did. Martin patzolds. You ignore it just as ignore the comets are “ice” farietale you have a religious faith in.

Only one of us is correct. My money is on A’Hearns evolving understanding.
 
Did. Martin patzolds. You ignore it just as ignore the comets are “ice” farietale you have a religious faith in.

Only one of us is correct. My money is on A’Hearns evolving understanding.

A'Hearn isn't talking about rock. He is talking about dust. As you well know. And Patzold is wrong. There are too many measurements of various phenomena that rule out a drastic revision of the volatile production rates. The diamagnetic cavity for one. The solar wind cavity for another. No ice equals no way of creating the conditions that form those observed phenomena. No way around it. He has either underestimated the fallback material, or the total mass loss. Or both.
And I have no 'faith' in there being ice at comets. Thousands of tonnes of it observed to be ejected from Tempel 1. Want the links to the papers? For the umpteenth time? Shed loads of it detected and observed around Hartley 2. Want the papers. Again? Or the images? Again? Loads of detections of ice grains around comets. Want the papers? Again? Ice observed at 67P numerous times. Want the papers? Again?
I don't need faith. I have evidence. You have a quasi-religion, and nothing else. No science, no mechanisms and no evidence.
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88 usual insanity of lying about our posts.

We have listed the enormous physical evidence collected over at least 70 years that comets have no rock as in Sol88's demented dogma of comets being planetary rock. Comets have dust grains from the formation of the solar system and some interstellar dust grains held together with ices . Astronomers do not want to write that long phrase so they use the word "rock".
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

Sol88's usual insane lies about science and our posts. Sol88's usual insults of astronomers and posters.

Whipple's updated modern and correct model includes that cometary dust grains can include clays, carbonates, etc. because these are formed during solar system formation :jaw-dropp

We have never ignored Martin Pätzold's paper There are 37 occurrences of Pätzold in this part of the 10 year long thread alone :jaw-dropp.

We have never ignored Sol88's repeated insanity about Martin Pätzold's paper. For example on 16th January 2019:
 
Last edited:
Trollin' trollin' trollin'
Trollin' trollin' trollin'
Trollin' trollin' trollin'
Trollin' trollin' trollin'
Clueless

Keep trollin', trollin', trollin'
Though the facts are lackin
Keep them memes trollin', clueless
Through no theory, data or evidence
Hell bent for leather
Wishin' my reality was by my side
All the things I'm missin'
Good theory, facts and confirmation'
Are lacking at the end of my day
 
Trollin' trollin' trollin' ...
Nice poem, Dancing David.

Sol88 has been vomiting out his demented cult's insane dogma on comets, the Sun, etc. for probably over 12 years now and over 10 years here (6th July 2009) :eek:! Sol88 is more a religious nut who has only persistent ignorance, delusions, lies and insults. Thus the insanity in his posts is not only from what he writes but the old adage of "insanity is repeating the same actions and expecting a different outcome".

No one expects anything but ignorance, delusions, lies and insults from Sol88 and we get it confirmed almost daily!

My replies to his insane posts could just be:
The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
The insane insults of the deceased Michael Francis A'Hearn by Sol88 linking him with demented dogma, etc.

However I do try to expose just how insane what Sol88 writes for the benefit of lurkers.
 
Alternating currents cause Jupiter's aurora

Poor jonesy.

So so sad, love the comments though. Jonesy has a dummy spit because he’s been wrong all along.

The Electric Jupiter, Electric Comet, Electric Sun, Electric Universe...:D

Good to see mainstream catching up though, very pleasing.

Tissue mate?

Maybe time to revisit Shoemaker–Levy 9 again?

Tap tap nails in the Dirtysnowball coffin. :D
 
Last edited:
Ah, since you claim the EU thing again, have you finally worked out how positive and negative charges in the solar system can move at the same speed in the same direction in your putative solar wide electrical field?

Because as long as you can't figure that out the EU model and all it's derivatives are baseless fantasy.
 
Mainstream will work it out. ;)

I guess when they work out why the corona is hotter than the surface of Sun. :D

How’s that going?

Talking about fantasies, how can one make a singularity?
 
Last edited:
Alternating currents cause Jupiter's aurora

Poor jonesy.

So so sad, love the comments though. Jonesy has a dummy spit because he’s been wrong all along.

The Electric Jupiter, Electric Comet, Electric Sun, Electric Universe...:D

Good to see mainstream catching up though, very pleasing.

Tissue mate?

Maybe time to revisit Shoemaker–Levy 9 again?

Tap tap nails in the Dirtysnowball coffin. :D

I haven't been wrong about anything. Please point out where this happened. Do you mean about Birkeland/ FACs at Jupiter? Long since known. Next.
 
Mainstream will work it out. ;)

I guess when they work out why the corona is hotter than the surface of Sun. :D

How’s that going?

Talking about fantasies, how can one make a singularity?

Plenty of proposed methods for the coronal heating. However, you don't have one. If you want to start a thread on black holes, or the solar corona, go ahead. Just don't be spamming your ignorance in this one, which is about the 100% failed electric woo model of comets.
 
Ah, since you claim the EU thing again, have you finally worked out how positive and negative charges in the solar system can move at the same speed in the same direction in your putative solar wide electrical field?

Because as long as you can't figure that out the EU model and all it's derivatives are baseless fantasy.


Optimistic!!!! When the clowns who propose such idiocy, such as Scott and Thornhill, can't answer those questions, we can't expect Sol to have even the foggiest!
 
Mainstream will work it out. ;)

I guess when they work out why the corona is hotter than the surface of Sun. :D

How’s that going?

Talking about fantasies, how can one make a singularity?

You again dodge this question. Like every other time.

Once again, in every single electrical field ever measured positive and negative charges are accelerated in opposite directions.

In outer space we see positive and negative charges be accelerated in the same direction

Thus there are no space-wide electrical fields.

EU and all it's fantasy requires space-wide electrical fields.

Thus EU and everything it claims is wrong UNLESS they come up with a theory that explains this. And that is where you fail to deliver every single time challenged.

Which just proves you either do not actually believe your own theory enough to actually try to defend it, or you are trolling.
Based upon your posting history, I assume the latter.
 
You again dodge this question. Like every other time.

Once again, in every single electrical field ever measured positive and negative charges are accelerated in opposite directions.

In outer space we see positive and negative charges be accelerated in the same direction

Thus there are no space-wide electrical fields.

EU and all it's fantasy requires space-wide electrical fields.

Thus EU and everything it claims is wrong UNLESS they come up with a theory that explains this. And that is where you fail to deliver every single time challenged.

Which just proves you either do not actually believe your own theory enough to actually try to defend it, or you are trolling.
Based upon your posting history, I assume the latter.

The problem, in my opinion, is that none of the EU cranks have a clue about what the solar wind is! Their leading 'thinker' on such things is Don Scott. Who is a clown. To qualify that statement, here is his outrageously ridiculous method for accelerating the solar wind;

https://electric-cosmos.org/SolarWind.pdf

Have a read through that, starting at section 6. Bloody hilarious. Tells us how to accelerate ions. Word search through the document to see what he wants to do with electrons. Absolutely hopeless. We end up with a Sun that is expelling ions and retaining electrons, and presumably doing so until the negative charge on the Sun causes it to blow up!
With high priests like these, it is easy to see how lost souls like Sol could easily be led astray!
 
You again dodge this question. Like every other time.

Once again, in every single electrical field ever measured positive and negative charges are accelerated in opposite directions.

In outer space we see positive and negative charges be accelerated in the same direction

Thus there are no space-wide electrical fields.

EU and all it's fantasy requires space-wide electrical fields.

Thus EU and everything it claims is wrong UNLESS they come up with a theory that explains this. And that is where you fail to deliver every single time challenged.

Which just proves you either do not actually believe your own theory enough to actually try to defend it, or you are trolling.
Based upon your posting history, I assume the latter.


I don’t know. :D

I also don’t know why the solar wind proton doesn’t capture the solar wind electron and become plain ‘ol hydrogen. Can you tell me why LS?

I thought + &- attract?
 
Mainstream will work it out. ;)

I guess when they work out why the corona is hotter than the surface of Sun. :D

How’s that going?

Talking about fantasies, how can one make a singularity?

I don’t know. :D

I also don’t know why the solar wind proton doesn’t capture the solar wind electron and become plain ‘ol hydrogen. Can you tell me why LS?

I thought + &- attract?

ROTFLOL

Still asking the wrong question about the corona
Still in the dark about plasma physics

What a pointless thread
 
When’s the new papers out, they will fill me in, ay.

Two electron populations and a sheath, I’m excited. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom