The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Antarctic Fossil Questions

From a catastrophist point of view, there are many questions raised by the Antarctic forest. How accurate is the system by which the trees were dated? Was late Permian really 260 million years ago? Geologists consider this figure accurate, along with the "known" age of the Earth. And it's all backed by absolute radiometric dating techniques. Fifty years ago, they were equally confident of a different age, and another age fifty years before that. But this time they're sure they've got it right.




Like I said best guesstimate based on a general consensus.
 
Antarctic Fossil Questions

From a catastrophist point of view, there are many questions raised by the Antarctic forest. How accurate is the system by which the trees were dated? Was late Permian really 260 million years ago? Geologists consider this figure accurate, along with the "known" age of the Earth. And it's all backed by absolute radiometric dating techniques. Fifty years ago, they were equally confident of a different age, and another age fifty years before that. But this time they're sure they've got it right.




Like I said best guesstimate based on a general consensus.
 
Rosetta’s Ancient Comet



Some reality for Sol88 to go nuts about :p!

The surface itself is very dark, very hard, very dry (lacking much water ice), and rich in organic compounds.

The comet’s releases of gas and dust must originate at or near the nucleus’ surface. Yet despite all of the changes we witnessed, we had difficulty locating active areas or exposed ices on the surface of the nucleus. On rare occasions, the VIRTIS instrument detected patches of water and carbon dioxide frost on the dawn side of the nucleus.

However, unlike meteorites, 67P’s dust contained silicate (rocky) minerals without any water in their crystal structures. The lack of water in 67P’s mineral particles is evidence that the comet has never been part of a larger object containing liquid water.

Wonder were the “volatiles” come from...


Awesome cheers mate :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Like I said best guesstimate based on a general consensus.

What were the confidence bars then, and by how much were they exceeded by later measurements, and what are the confidence bars now?

What measurements have the "scientists" at Thunderdolts made, and with what confidence?
 
What were the confidence bars then, and by how much were they exceeded by later measurements, and what are the confidence bars now?

What measurements have the "scientists" at Thunderdolts made, and with what confidence?


Hey why were at it, should we ask reality check the same for his nebular lightning?

How big? How much current? So on and so forth... :D

You know, just to round it out.
 
Hey why were at it, should we ask reality check the same for his nebular lightning?



How big? How much current? So on and so forth... :D



You know, just to round it out.

Please do, but do not forget to find the figures for the late Permian. I'll bet they do not fit well with EU no matter what figures you find.
 
Hey why were at it, should we ask reality check the same for his nebular lightning?

How big? How much current? So on and so forth... :D

You know, just to round it out.

It was a consideration only. It seems to have fallen out of favour, due to its unlikelihood.

The importance of experiments: Constraints on chondrule formation models
Desch, S. J. et al. (2012)
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1945-5100.2012.01357.x

To conclude, all four models considered here more or less match the nonthermal constraints or at least are not in conflict with them, with a few exceptions. The lightning model appears to be too small in extent, and to invoke too small a pressure, and may be excluded on these grounds............................................................................................................................................ Although melting by large-scale nebular shocks matches the chondrule thermal histories quite well, melting in the X-wind and by nebular lightning do not. Chondrules in the X-wind environment start too hot, but do not achieve the needed peak temperatures to completely melt. Chondrules melted by nebular lightning cannot cool slowly enough to produce recognizable textures. The constraints on chondrule thermal histories allow us to reject the lightning and X-wind models for chondrule formation. The ability to make such definitive statements rests on the laboratory experiments that constrain the thermal histories of chondrules.

And that is in reference to a model initially proposed by the lead author of that paper!
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insanity of pathetic parroting from his demented cult.

This is Sol88's and the cult insane delusion that science does not progress. Sol88 has among many other delusions, the delusion that Whipple's 1950's model is the modern model of comets. His cult has among many other delusions, the delusion that radiometric methods are not improved or new data collected.
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's pathetic ignorance of the real world where this is "The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE " thread.

Sol88's usual insanity.
It is not my nebular lightning theory, it is a scientific theory written by scientists decades ago. There is a thing called the scientific literature which Sol88 and his cult are demented about :eye-poppi! The scientific model of nebular lightning is there.

Chondrule: Formation list mechanism to provides heat for chondrule formation.
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insanity of derailing form the electric comet insanity with irrelevant questions and insane lies.

Study of mesosiderite zircons suggests Vesta was struck by a very large rock has the dating technique in the study ("high-precision uranium–lead dating of mesosiderite zircons". Sol88's insanity is that the study is 1 click away in the phys.org article.
 
It was a consideration only. It seems to have fallen out of favour, due to its unlikelihood.

The importance of experiments: Constraints on chondrule formation models
Desch, S. J. et al. (2012)
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1945-5100.2012.01357.x



And that is in reference to a model initially proposed by the lead author of that paper!

The Generation of Lightning in the Solar Nebula

Lightning generation would seem to be more efficient closer to the Sun. If α = 10−4 , lightning easily could be generated out to 3 AU; if α = 10−2 , lightning could take place only within 1 AU. The asteroid belt, the site of the chondrules we observe today, may not be the favored environ- ment for chondrule formation. Chondrule formation closer in (e.g., at 1 AU) might be much more efficient, as lightning bolts would be more frequent and energetic, and could be generated for a greater fraction of the nebula lifetime, due to the increased density there.

Off topic but very interesting.
 
Sol88 shows once again how demented his thunderbolts cult is

Wrong. And that garbage was no doubt written by a scientifically illiterate Velikovskian fool.
It is worse than that, jonesdave116. The garbage was written by an unnamed scientifically illiterate "catastrophism" nutcase who thinks his delusions mean that "decay constants have changed". His other insanity is "thunderbolts of the gods actually flew between Earth and other planets" changed those rates. The article from 2005 is close to an ad for Ian Tresman's crackpot CD.

The nutter blatantly lies about the assumptions behind radiometric dating. The "assumptions" are the real world where
  • Earth is an body that interacts with other bodies.
    The Sun exists (solar wind, solar neutrinos)! Other planets exist!
  • There is no evidence that radioactive decay rates change enough to influence radiometric dating.
    Even the "Russian researchers S. E. Schnoll, et al" back in 2000 only found cyclic changes in rates correlated with astronomical cycles.
    This nutter does not know the meaning of "cyclic" and it means that the rates remain the same on longer time scales.
    This nutter thinks that any measured change of rate no matter how small means the rates changed enormously.
We must thank Sol88 for showing once again how demented his thunderbolts cult is when they allow a total nutter to write an article on their web site!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom