The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
What evidence are you looking for to lend more weight to the electric comet?

We have rock, electric fields, charge seperation, electric currents....

I’m a happy man.
 
What evidence are you looking for to lend more weight to the electric comet?

We have rock, electric fields, charge seperation, electric currents....

Dude, we've been over this a bazillion times before.

Let me state the title of this thread, with some added emphasis ...

The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Where is it, this wonderful Theory?

It certainly seems to be lacking, spectacularly so, in all the thousands of posts by you, in this thread.

I’m a happy man.

Enjoy your happiness, knowing that you have failed - spectacularly - to present any Theory at all, much less any Electric Comet Theory. :p
 
Dude, we've been over this a bazillion times before.

Let me state the title of this thread, with some added emphasis ...

The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Where is it, this wonderful Theory?

It certainly seems to be lacking, spectacularly so, in all the thousands of posts by you, in this thread.



Enjoy your happiness, knowing that you have failed - spectacularly - to present any Theory at all, much less any Electric Comet Theory. :p

Go look it up and get back to us when you can, cheers.

You seem to struggle with the basics bit like rc.

Simpleton version just for you, comets are rocks discharging within the solar plasma.

At least our understanding has been evolving toward mostly rock. Singing comet was a good’n too for the EC.

Good start in my book.
 
Last edited:
You didn't. What do you mean by "active"?



Anything would be a start.



Having EM fields is not an indication that gravity doesn't exist.

Who ever said gravity doesn’t exist?

You getting lessons from reality check in confabulation?
 
Thanks.

Go look it up and get back to us when you can, cheers.

You seem to struggle with the basics bit like rc.

Simpleton version just for you, comets are rocks discharging within the solar plasma.

At least our understanding has been evolving toward mostly rock. Singing comet was a good’n too for the EC.

Good start in my book.

Some time in the past, I would have been rather surprised to see you so freely and openly admitting that no Electric Comet Theory exists, let alone one that you have written about here. But as you’ve been doing this for what, several years now, I am no longer.

It is good, however, to read - once again - your open admission of your spectacular failure. :p
 
Go look it up and get back to us when you can, cheers.

You seem to struggle with the basics bit like rc.

Simpleton version just for you, comets are rocks discharging within the solar plasma.

At least our understanding has been evolving toward mostly rock. Singing comet was a good’n too for the EC.

Good start in my book.

If a call rock consolidated refractory material does that make it better for you?

The scarcity of ice suggests that the thermo-physical properties of the nucleus are dominated by those of the refractory component.
LINK

Is this exactly what A’Hearn stated?

Comets are mostly rock, no. Comets are mostly consolidated refractory material.

Oh, ok.

:rolleyes:

Sorry jean tate. :)
 
If a call rock consolidated refractory material does that make it better for you?

LINK

Is this exactly what A’Hearn stated?

Comets are mostly rock, no. Comets are mostly consolidated refractory material.

Oh, ok.

:rolleyes:

Sorry jean tate. :)
No worries mate.

I acknowledge that, over the many year life of this thread, you have been given dozens and dozens of opportunities to present, and defend, an Electric Comet Theory (or Model). And that at least once you made an attempt to do some very simple modeling and calculations.

I’m sure it’s very frustrating to keep failing, year after year. But maybe you could make another attempt? Try to at least start to tackle one of Indagator’s assignments?
 
Who ever said gravity doesn’t exist?

You getting lessons from reality check in confabulation?

The whole point of the Electric Universe nonsense is to deny the existence of gravity as a force and instead explain all of that with EM fields. Don't pretend otherwise.
 
EM is the dominant force not gravity. EU never said gravity does not exist.

Don’t know where you got that howler. Not nearly as bad as a singularity though, now that’s a HOWLER.

Divide by zero = singularity
 
EM is the dominant force not gravity. EU never said gravity does not exist.

If gravity exists then how strong is it? Why would you need EM to explain what gravity normally explains if gravity's there to begin with? The EU claims make no sense unless they're meant to replace gravity.

Not nearly as bad as a singularity though, now that’s a HOWLER.

Divide by zero = singularity

The real howler is that you don't know what a singularity is, and what it means to science. No wonder you're looking for an alternative.
 
Not just any astronomer, the preeminent COMETARY astronomer. :D

Reckon he’d be all over it, after all our understanding has been evolving.

Do you know what evolving means?

:thumbsup:


You seem to not give the man credit for he’s life’s work. Poor form I’d say as I’m just quoting him from his last paper.

Seems to get up every ones nose for some reason and I can’t fathom why. Is it because Thornhill said comets are rocky?

Anyhoo, he said it at it is what it is!

:p

Suck it up princess.

Link to the detection of rock at a comet or quit with the pathetic lying.
 
Go look it up and get back to us when you can, cheers.

You seem to struggle with the basics bit like rc.

Simpleton version just for you, comets are rocks discharging within the solar plasma.

At least our understanding has been evolving toward mostly rock. Singing comet was a good’n too for the EC.

Good start in my book.

No rock, no discharges (lol). Ergo you failed. Come up with another model that involves ice, gas and dust. I think we already have one of them. And I see no evidence to make it worth considering changing that model for one that is scientifically impossible, has no mechanisms and no evidence.
 
What evidence are you looking for to lend more weight to the electric comet?

We have rock, electric fields, charge seperation, electric currents....

I’m a happy man.

No rock. Any charge separation is limited. The electric field is pointing in the wrong direction. Currents are doing nothing. You need EDM (lol), and you need discharges. You haven't got them. Therefore, you have failed.
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Is it because Thornhill said comets are rocky?
The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Usual insane lies abut the electric comet insanity. The impossibility of comets being rocks (not "rocky") is just 1 bit of the insanity.

The thunderbolts cult prophet Thornhill is a deluded liar, e.g. 14 years of blatant lies of confirmed prediction for the Deep Impact mission that shoed that Tempel 1 was made of ices and dust by blasting ices and dust from the comet :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom