The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

So: The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
Persistent insanity about real active asteroids has been explained to him many times in an electric comet insanity thread :jaw-dropp!
Persistent insane lies about the electric comet insanity which has no sublimation, centrifugal force or impacts producing dust - just the insanity of imaginary, invisible electric discharges ding whatever magic the massively deluded Thunderbolts cult wants.

ETA: Also the persistent insanity of mentioning active asteroids which debunk his electric comet insanity by not being in similar orbits to comets as that stupidity wants :jaw-dropp!
Electric comets still do not exist!: EC predicts that 100,000's of asteroids should be comets!
 
Last edited:
So sublimation and centrifugal force are the two main culprits for dust removal.

Ok just like on active asteroids!

Did we miss impacts?
 
As yet another example of Sol88 insane posts over the last 10 year, there is his citation of a paper on rotating comets when his electric comet insanity has no rotating comets :jaw-dropp!

On migration of dust and ice grains on the surface of the rotating comet nucleus

A rotating body has a maximum velocity at its equator. That is where it is most possible for dust grains to be ejected. Thus "We have shown that the grains traveling to the equator of the comet can be thrown out into space" is what mainstream physics allows.
The last sentence is the obvious fact that the amount of dust covering ices will influence comet activity. So the migration of dust from rotation should influence comet activity.


Like a rotating garden sprinkler? Looks like, from this angle and solar illumination anyway, a fractal assemblage of filamentary highly colimated jets.
 
So do you agree jonesdave116 that sublimation is not the driver of activity? As pointed out in a few papers now.

Or you are still happy for special sublimation of cometary rock?

That is not what those papers are saying. Learn to read.
 
So just to make sure the sublimation of water ice is the main driver of the activity on the Dirtysnowball?

Yes or no reality check, jonesdave116?

Yes. As stated. Learn to read;

The spatial correlation between dust and water, both coming from the sun-lit side of the comet, shows that water is the main driver of dust activity in this time period.

Which part of that is not penetrating what counts for your brain?
 
New *physics: *Dust *is *many *orders *of *magnitude *heavier *than *ions *and *can *carry *many *orders *of * *magnitude *larger *+ *or *-‐ * *me *dependent *charge. *


Dusty Plasmas in the Solar System

Now, which electric field is this dust responding to again reality check. Must of missed that bit.

Also

Is this the same electric field accelerating charged particles?

Gibberish. Which electric field? And what has that got to do with your failed woo? Where was the EDM (lol)? The discharges? The rock? You lost. Go away, and get over it.
 
Well there you go, Reality check was spot on.

Sorry for all my crank woo woo. :D

I mean so it has been shown in a peer reviewed paper, this paper On migration of dust and ice grains on the surface of the rotating comet nucleus

Got the MATHS that PROVES this is the case.

That, along with sublimation seems to be the main culprit!

Unlike my unscientific electric fields, charged dust, electric currents pseudo scientific malarky!

You haven't got a clue what you are talking about. As you have been told multiple times, by multiple posters. Go away. Lern to scienz.
 
You haven't got a clue what you are talking about. As you have been told multiple times, by multiple posters. Go away. Lern to scienz.

The dust is flung off a rotating nucleus.

Absolutely love it, this learning scienz stuff.

Maths is quite convoluted and in depth but yeah a viable option.

Anymore scienz available jonesdave116?
 
Water formation on the moon

"Overall, this study advances our understanding on the origin of water as detected on the moon and other airless bodies in our solar system such as Mercury and asteroids and provides, for the first time, a scientifically sound and proven mechanism of water formation," HIGP's Jeffrey Gillis-Davis concluded.

And comets, just saying...
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
Repeated delusion that any comet is the Moon :jaw-dropp!
Repeated delusion that a water producing mechanism explicitly stated to be for the "moon and other airless bodies in our solar system such as Mercury and asteroids" happens on comets.
Usual insane lie about the electric comet insanity which does not have this water producing mechanism (that insanity has electric discharges magically producing water from solid rock).
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Water is being made, brilliant.
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
Irrelevant nonsense about an experiment confirming water being made on the Moon. Water formation on the moon
Chemistry Professor Ralf I. Kaiser and HIGP's Jeffrey Gillis-Davis designed the experiments to test the synergy between hydrogen protons from solar wind, lunar minerals, and micrometeorite impacts. Zhu irradiated samples of olivine, a dry mineral that serves as a surrogate of lunar material, with deuterium ions as a proxy for solar wind protons.
 
Last edited:
Why not comets? Since our understanding has evolved away from thinking comets were mostly ice to mostly asteroidial type composition.
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.
Repeated delusion that any comet is the Moon :jaw-dropp!
Repeated delusion that a water producing mechanism explicitly stated to be for the "moon and other airless bodies in our solar system such as Mercury and asteroids" happens on comets.
Usual insane lie about the electric comet insanity which does not have this water producing mechanism (that insanity has electric discharges magically producing water from solid rock).

Happens on comets as well. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom