Stating Michael A'Hearn did not know that comets were made of ices and dust is an obvious lie about and insult of
Michael A'Hearn. He was an prominent astronomer studying comets and knew their composition from the physical evidence, e.g. we detect ices and dust at comets such as Deep Impact and the Rosetta mission to 67P

!
The lie/insult is even more obvious when the decades old fact that comets have gas and
dust tails is textbook astronomy that any astronomer knows. This is an accusation that Michael A'Hearn was ignorant about textbook astronomy. This is an accusation that Michael A'Hearn was ignorant about the
EPOXI mission for which he was the principal investigator!
If this was the first time that Sol88 cherry picked this paper, quote mined it and denied terminology that astronomers use about the dust in comets then it would be a mistake. But this has gone on for many months so it is an obvious lie/insult.
It takes a couple of minutes for anyone to confirm that A'Hearn knew that comets contained dust.
has 337 abstracts from SAO/NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) with 'Michael A'Hearn dust' 
!
For example:
Types of Outbursts From 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, as Seen by Alice: Gas, Dust, Ice, and Hybrid by Steffl, Andrew J.;
A'Hearn, Michael F.; Bertaux, Jean-Loup; Feaga, Lori; Feldman, Paul; Keeney, Brian A.; Noonan, John; Parker, Joel; Stern, Alan; Weaver, Harold
Contract this to the term that astronomers sometimes use for cometary ices and dust - rock:
8 abstracts!
Mate! Snap with it.
This is one of the last papers A’Hearn wrote before his death in 2017. He was trying, as best he could, to understand COMETS within the confines and boundaries of Whipple’s conglomeration and sublimation model by one of the more eminent scientists before him.
Though before his death and in his last paper he states,
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited.
My bolding.
Now I’m pretty sure ‘ol mate was cluey enough, from his previous papers, that he knew ice and dust within the context of the first quantitative model of comets proposed by Whipple.
Before his passing, A’Hearns understanding, and “ours” had been
evolving towards mostly ROCK.
Now any layperson (me) or indeed highly intelligent scientists or academics would assume A’Hearn referred to rock, as if in terrestrial type rock when he said rock.
But you and jd116 keep referring to rock as dust?
A’Hearn knew what dust was and the real lie or insult would be to ‘ol mates scientific career that he would not know the difference between dust and rock.
So either you or jd116 pony up answer to why you think A’Hearn meant dust instead of rock, or, you accept comets are rock.
AND
Before you spit the dummy and blather on about bulk density, read AND understand, as it states in the title, the
implications of the RSI data, bulk density and gas/dust ratio. A paper, that I’m sure A’Hearn would love to have read, calls all that that jazz into question.
The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications
The RSI data was bang on, there’s is minimal “ice” and the DUST is pulverised ROCK!
EDM on the molecular scale, ionising rock and releasing dust, along with water vapour from clays and carbon dioxide/monoxide from carbonates. We see these ROCKS on asteroids.
Now the real homework for you reality check, is where are all these organics coming from?
Especially the “
building blocks” of life.
That will keep you busy for awhiles.
Unless your keen on talking the real shintzel?
COMETARY DOUBLE LAYERS!!
