The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.


Cheers Reality Check. Prediction confirmed by the main man himself, again cheers mate, as you state below.

We know that there is charged dust and ice grains in comet coma - they were detected at comet 67P:jaw-dropp!

We also know

"Any electric fields/currents in play at comets reality check?" -
Answered many times - yes and nothing to do with his insane delusion about comets.




Why would the charged particles NOT respond to the, confirmed by you, electric fields?
 
Cheers Reality Check. Prediction confirmed by the main man himself, again cheers mate, as you state below.



We also know

"Any electric fields/currents in play at comets reality check?" -




Why would the charged particles NOT respond to the, confirmed by you, electric fields?

What has any of this got to do with the 100% failed EC 'model'? No rock, no discharges, plenty of ice, plenty of H2O. Why are you still here?
 
What has any of this got to do with the 100% failed EC 'model'? No rock, no discharges, plenty of ice, plenty of H2O. Why are you still here?

Is that all you have left jd116? Couple old papers from A’Hearn, when even he use to think comets were mostly. Even A’Hearn accepted our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock.

Electric fields and charged dusty plasma, trumps “sublimation”.

:D

Sorry if it challenges your belief system, jd116. Not everyone is able to understand complex systems and many people feel “safer” just accepting “facts” at face value.
 
Last edited:
Is that all you have left jd116? Couple old papers from A’Hearn, when even he use to think comets were mostly. Even A’Hearn accepted our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock.

Electric fields and charged dusty plasma, trumps “sublimation”.

:D

Sorry if it challenges your belief system, jd116. Not everyone is able to understand complex systems and many people feel “safer” just accepting “facts” at face value.

Gibberish. Read my lips - there has never been any rock detected at a comet. There are no electric discharges. There is a shed load of H2O. There is plenty of ice. And sublimation is an observed fact.
Your silly 'model' has failed. 100%. As shown. Why are you still here?
 
Last edited:
Sorry if it challenges your belief system, jd116
.

Hypocrite. What I 'believe' is backed up by evidence. What you believe is mythology-based woo, spewed forth by idiots like Thornhill. Not a single scientist backs that idiocy. It is puerile pseudoscience. And that is possibly being unkind to pseudoscientists.
 
Surprise! 'Active Asteroid' Bennu Is a Rare Particle-Ejecting Space Rock

"Basically, it looks like Bennu has a continuous population of particles raining down on it from discrete ejection events across its surface," Lauretta said. "This is incredibly exciting."

The team doesn't know what's spurring the ejection events. The ejections have been observed around the time of Bennu's closest passage to the sun during the asteroid's elliptical orbit, which occurred this year on Jan. 10. So, solar heating of the asteroid's surface and near-subsurface may be the main driver. But that's just speculation at the moment, Lauretta stressed.

Just say’n, just say’n....


Sublimation? Impacts? Spin up?....these are the only tools you have jd116!
 
What the hell has Bennu got to do with your failed 'model' (lol)?

I also note you maybe coming senile as well jd116?


If you’d like to back way up to when tusenfem still fluttered around this thread.


Let’s test your memory.

Is there charge separation occurring a comet 67P?


Don’t worry, this has a point and ties in very nicely with the “active” asteroid Bennu we are currently orbiting up close and personal.

It was a little whiles back mind you , so you may struggle with your deteriorating memory to recall the whole charge separation failure of MHD part of this thread.

Or if you can’t face all that embarrassment, again, you could offer up a reasonable explination, in your obvious “expert” opinion.

What is causing Bennu
The 1,650-foot-wide (500 meters) space rock ejected particles of dust and gravel into space multiple times over the past few months, newly announced observations from NASA's OSIRIS-REx spacecraft reveal. So, Bennu is one of just a dozen or so known "active asteroids" — and the only one to be observed up close.

ACTIVE ASTEROIDS

First Signs of Trouble

Scienitsts have known for years that no perfect definition distinguishing asteroids and comets has been found. Some consider chemical properties as the guideline while others feel orbital distances are key. Even how they interact with Jupiter can be the guiding principle for some. But fuzzy areas exist on the boundaries of the generally accepted parameters. No one fully agrees on the ice/rock content to differentiate the two, for example. And other physics can change orbital positions like radiation and mass loss, so some objects will be in places they otherwise normally wouldn’t be (Jewitt).

A’Hearn did..
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].
.


But the mainstream can’t get their &@$# together to decide what’s a comet or what’s an asteroid. :blush:

Further,

A2 and 596 Scheila were the first examples of the so called disrupted asteroids, and models indicated that a 98 foot wide object impacting the 71 mile long Scheila could have resulted in the observations seen. For P/2010 A2, a 3.3 to 6.6 foot long object impacting the 62 mile long object would also result in the observations seen for it. So to incorporate all of this data a new term was coined: active asteroids. This covers main-belt comets and disrupted asteroids, since the distinction between them is murky at best (Hsieh, Redd 30-1).

So sublimation, from main belt comets and impacts are covered so far {see my post above) what else do you have in your toolkit jd116?

Let’s see,

How Are They Losing Mass?

Several theories are in play for what may be causing these objects to be active. One is sublimation, which is what drives comets. Why would that be a candidate here, then? Turns out, a thin layer of regolith as shallow as 1 meter in depth can cause ice to be trapped for almost a billion years, only becoming exposed when a collision occurs. Perhaps small pockets of ice formed in shadowed regions of asteroids and were not melted away by the radiation from the closeness of the sun. Maybe instead we are witnessing some projectiles coming from a recent collision with another space object, or maybe an object spinning apart because of a large torque. The problem is, the asteroid belt is not like how it looks in the movies. It is mainly empty space with the average distance between objects clocking in at 600,000 miles. With 800,000 asteroids in the belt, that translates to a lot of real estate available. Therefore, collisions should be quite rare (Jewitt, Redd 31).

Electrostatic forces may also be at play. Turns out, solar radiation involves a bombardment of not only photons but also electrons and protons. As an object spins in space, surfaces are hit with the radiation and electrons, being of a smaller mass, travel away faster than protons. This causes a net charge to develop as the objects spins and the surface falls into the dark side. But as it spins towards the light again, protons come into play again and electrostatic forces can cause particles to rise. If enough of a charge is developed, then the dust can achieve escape velocity and away they go. But the math shows it may only work for smaller asteroids, plus the moon models this is based off of may be incomplete (Jewitt).

Thermal properties can also be at hand. Fracturing caused by extreme temperature changes as an object approaches the sun can cause particles to escape. Another possibility is liquid water escaping the surface (as opposed to sublimation, where it goes directly from a solid to a gas), taking particles with it, whether that water loss be driven by heat differences or by shock compressions from collisions (Ibid).

So we have sublimation, that’s makes it a comet. Impact, could happen but has never been observed. Thermal fracturing, plausible though relied on a little to heavily considering the insulating properties of the dust
Turns out, a thin layer of regolith as shallow as 1 meter in depth can cause ice to be trapped for almost a billion years, only becoming exposed when a collision occurs.

But

Mainstream now, only very recently “discovered” another force at play ELECTROMAGNETISM! It has a caveat though,
But the math shows it may only work for smaller asteroids, plus the moon models this is based off of may be incomplete (Jewitt).

Ahhhh...the “math”. :rolleyes:

Which math is this MHD? Black hole. Dark matter?

Similar to this math?
 
Last edited:
^^^^^ None of which has any relevance to the failed electric comet woo. No rock, no discharges, plenty of ice and plenty of gas. Next.
 
Electrostatic forces may also be at play. Turns out, solar radiation involves a bombardment of not only photons but also electrons and protons.

How many times do you need to be told? Not happening at comets when they are most active.
 
How many times do you need to be told? Not happening at comets when they are most active.

Whata numpty.

What forms the diamagnetic cavity, again jd116?

Links and papers please, not your simpleton version.
 
Last edited:
Any charge separation happening at 67P?

Numptys can not accept this fact, obviously.
 
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88

Why would the charged particles NOT respond to the, confirmed by you, electric fields?
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

I did not say that charged dust and ice grains in the coma of comets would not respond to the electric fields inside the coma of comets.

I confirmed Sol88's persistent insane ignorance of textbook plasma physics yet again.
Plasmas have electric fields because they contain ions and electrons :jaw-dropp!
Neutrals, ions and electrons move differently and so plasmas have ambipolar electric fields :jaw-dropp!
 
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88

Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Asteroid Bennu is an asteroid :jaw-dropp!

Asteroid Bennu is one of the rare active asteroids that are ejecting dust by spinning or possibly sublimation of ice pockets. That is the surprise.

Irrelevant to Sol88's insanity about comets.
 
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88

Sublimation? Impacts? Spin up?....these are the only tools you have jd116!
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Sol88's total insanity that active asteroids are relevant to his electric comet insanity. Insane fabatsies about active asteroids.

The physically sane mechanisms to explain active asteroids are:
  • Sublimation of ice ejecting dust.
  • Impacts ejecting dust.
  • Spin up ejecting dust.
Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom