The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Experiments on cometary activity: ejection of dust aggregates from a sublimating water-ice surface
Bischoff, D. et al (Feb. 2019)
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-abstract/483/1/1202/5203640?redirectedFrom=fulltext

Accompanying videos;

CoPhyLab S-class experiment: Dust emission of sublimating water ice I

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1IM3DlACyA

CoPhyLab S-class experiment: Dust emission of sublimating water ice II

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TegTkPDlFI

Now all you need is ice!

How much ice does 67P contain?

Is it mostly ice or mostly refractory/dirt/rock/stone/dust?

We should ask an expert on comets this question...:p
 
Experiments on cometary activity: ejection of dust aggregates from a sublimating water-ice surface
Bischoff, D. et al (Feb. 2019)
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-abstract/483/1/1202/5203640?redirectedFrom=fulltext

Accompanying videos;

CoPhyLab S-class experiment: Dust emission of sublimating water ice I

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1IM3DlACyA

CoPhyLab S-class experiment: Dust emission of sublimating water ice II

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TegTkPDlFI

So many contradictions, so many.

But I guess if you hit hard enough you’ll eventually get that round peg into the square hole...

You’re going to need bigger hammer though :D
 
Nope. This is a (very) small subset of asteroids, some of which may well be almost de-volatilised comets.


Is a “de-volatilised” comet an asteroid?

If not, what’s the difference between a “de-volatilised” comet and an asteroid?

Good luck...
 
Last edited:
Is a “de-volatilised” comet an asteroid?

If not, what’s the difference between a “de-volatilised” comet and an asteroid?

Good luck...

Density. Far less dense than a stony or metallic asteroid. We have just never got up close and personal with one of these things. And it won't be totally de-volatilised - remaining ice will just be below the thermal heatwave depth for the majority of the time.
 
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88

So many contradictions, so many.
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

There are no contradictions except those inside the head of a deluded follower of the electric comet insanity.
Experiments on cometary activity: ejection of dust aggregates from a sublimating water-ice surface is about scientific progress. Rosetta and 67P have shown that the previous picture of dust being ejected as small particles by gas is incomplete. Rosetta detected dust aggregates which presumably were ejected from the surface. This experiment demonstrates this happening from the sublimation of solid water ice under a layer of dust, i.e. similar to the ices under dust layer we found on 67P.
 
Last edited:
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88

Is a “de-volatilised” comet an asteroid?
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

An "almost de-volatilised comets" is a comet that has sublimated most its ices, e.g. the origin of several meteor showers. However the paper is not on a asteroid–comet evolutionary continuum. Rather there is a range of "observational, physical and dynamical properties" between actual asteroids and actual comets.

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system Henry H. Hsieh
Abstract
In this review presented at the Royal Society meeting, ‘Cometary science after Rosetta’, I present an overview of studies of small solar system objects that exhibit properties of both asteroids and comets (with a focus on so-called active asteroids). Sometimes referred to as ‘transition objects’, these bodies are perhaps more appropriately described as ‘continuum objects’, to reflect the notion that rather than necessarily representing actual transitional evolutionary states between asteroids and comets, they simply belong to the general population of small solar system bodies that happen to exhibit a continuous range of observational, physical and dynamical properties. Continuum objects are intriguing because they possess many of the properties that make classical comets interesting to study (e.g. relatively primitive compositions, ejection of surface and subsurface material into space where it can be more easily studied, and orbital properties that allow us to sample material from distant parts of the solar system that would otherwise be inaccessible), while allowing us to study regions of the solar system that are not sampled by classical comets.
 
Last edited:
So A’Hearn was right, comets are mostly refractory/rock/dirt/dust

It has been known for some time that there is a high dust:ice ratio, and I have linked to papers showing that before. So, address that, rather than continuing with your deliberate ignorance and strawman tactics.
 
It has been known for some time that there is a high dust:ice ratio, and I have linked to papers showing that before. So, address that, rather than continuing with your deliberate ignorance and strawman tactics.

How hard was that champ?

We both agree with A’Hearn’s statement
(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].
Comets: looking ahead Michael F. A’Hearn

So one would have to concede comets are rocky bodies.

Which is in aagreement with this statement...
(ii) upper porosity bound: if ice = 0, then Fnucleus = ∞ and dust (1-poro)-bulk = 0 in (11) and, not so unrealistically, the nucleus would be a highly porous stony agglomerate, essentially devoid of volitiles.
The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications


Que squeals of a war cry as the wagons tighten into a circle.

“But we detected “ice” therefore any idiot would have to concede comets are mostly ice.

:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom