The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Usual insanity emphasizes Sol88's electric comet insanity

So again we are all agreeing
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

No one here is agreeing with Sol88's electric comet insanity of actual rock blasted from Earth recently.

Rational people agree that comets Tempel 1 and 67P have low measured ratios of ices to dust. That "very little ices" for comet 67P is ~15% ices.
 
Usual insanity emphasizes Sol88's electric comet insanity

...just enough ice to account for Q?
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Sol88 insane stupidity of not knowing that a comet nucleus has a surface and an interior!
Sublimating ices outgassing with a gas production rate Q are on the surface of the comet. There are enough ices on the first few meters of the surface of a nucleus to produce Q.
 
More insanity added to Sol88's insane playbook since he asked for it

Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

46. Sol88's insanity of citing the Stardust return of only dust grains after a quote about ices/dust ratios.

47. Sol88's insane lie that a "surprise" from the Stardust mission supports his electric comet insanity.
As explained again and again and known since 2006, most of the dust grains had formed at low temperatures and a few dust grains had formed at high temperatures. All of the dust grains formed in space in the early solar system.
Stardust mission
Plucking comet dust from Stardust collectors (December 14, 2006)
In particular, the comet dust analysis identified a few grains that contain calcium/aluminum-rich inclusions (CAIs) similar to those found in meteorites known as chondrites. Thought to be the oldest objects in the solar system, chondrites have always been a puzzle because they contain minerals that formed at low temperatures as well as minerals, like CAIs, that must have formed at high temperatures.

This discovery supports a theory of chondrite formation proposed 10 years ago by UC Berkeley astronomers Frank Shu and Hsien "Sienny " Shang in collaboration with Typhoon Lee, an astrophysicist and geochemist at the Academia Sinica's Institute of Earth Sciences in Taiwan. This theory, referred to as the X-wind model of chondrites, says that stars like the sun recycle some of the dust falling into them during formation of the system, melting it and throwing it out from the center in a fiery spray that condenses into small "chondrules," or beads of melted rock. These beads are pushed by the strong solar wind, called an X-wind, out of the solar system disk and settle into the distant reaches of the solar system, where they eventually combine with colder material to form chondrites, asteroids and planets.

A repeat of his insane cult's dependence on press releases that gave rise to:
25. A deluded lie that we have detected clays and carbonates on comets [as found on planets].
 
Refractory minerals, go look it up champ and stop being so ignorant.

Remember what A'Hearn said?
(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

These beads are pushed by the strong solar wind, called an X-wind, out of the solar system disk and settle into the distant reaches of the solar system, where they eventually combine with colder material to form chondrites, asteroids and planets.
Pure fantasy!

Remember the DUST IS CHARGED. :)
 
Last edited:
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

46. Sol88's insanity of citing the Stardust return of only dust grains after a quote about ices/dust ratios.

47. Sol88's insane lie that a "surprise" from the Stardust mission supports his electric comet insanity.
As explained again and again and known since 2006, most of the dust grains had formed at low temperatures and a few dust grains had formed at high temperatures. All of the dust grains formed in space in the early solar system.
Stardust mission
Plucking comet dust from Stardust collectors (December 14, 2006)


A repeat of his insane cult's dependence on press releases that gave rise to:
25. A deluded lie that we have detected clays and carbonates on comets [as found on planets].

Interestingly
The Stardust results are consistent with this jet flow model, which may provide a potentially coherent and predictive framework for understanding the formation and transport of rocky material in the solar nebula.

Remember the dust is charged. :thumbsup:
 
Usual insanity, lies and insults from Sol88

Refractory minerals, go look it up champ and stop being so ignorant.
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

An insane lie and insult because we know that refractory minerals are created in the early solar system when comets formed.

Sol88 is doubly insane in this post because when we look up refractory we get Refractory (planetary science)
In planetary science, any material that has a relatively high equilibrium condensation temperature is called refractory.[1] The opposite of refractory is volatile.

The refractory group includes elements and compounds like metals and silicates (commonly termed rocks) which make up the bulk of the mass of the terrestrial planets and asteroids in the inner belt. A fraction of the mass of other asteroids, giant planets, their moons and trans-Neptunian objects is also made of refractory materials.[2]
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Last edited:
Usual insanity emphasizes Sol88's electric comet insanity

Remember the dust is charged. :thumbsup:
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Remember that Sol88 is deluded:
We do not have any measurement of the charges of dust grains from the early solar system ~4.6 billion years ago :jaw-dropp!
Sol88 is commenting on Stardust results that debunk his electric comet insanity.
Sol88's insanity that merely stating that dust is charged supports his electric comet insanity.
Sol88's usual insane lie - we detected that dust and ice grains around comet 67P were charged.
 
Correct, jonesdave116!

Now it’s claimed...


Or so little ice and so much DENSE dust they’ve also been called and

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

Martin Pätzold1, Thomas P. Andert2, Matthias Hahn1, Jean-Pierre Barriot3, Sami W. Asmar4, Bernd Häusler2, Michael K. Bird1, Silvia Tellmann1, Janusz Oschlisniok1, Kerstin Peter1





Absolute blasphemy for the Dirtysnowball camp and it’s adherents.



Define stony agglomerate, jonesdave116. ;)

So let's put another episode of cherry-picking and lying to bed, shall we?

Reasonable porosities are within 65% (for dust = 2000 kg/m3; Fnucleus = 3; dust = 20%; ice = 15%) to 80% (for Rho dust = 3500 kg/m3; Fnucleus = 7; dust = 13%; ice = 7%), corresponding to a highly porous dusty nucleus. Larger porosities (> 80%) require very high dust-to-ice ratios (Fnucleus >> 7), where the ice content decreases rapidly from a few percent to ultimately zero, representing a highly porous dusty nucleus with little to no ice. This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P, but not unreasonable because it is the ultimate fate of a comet nucleus at the end of its "active life".


The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications
Pätzold, M. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-abstract/483/2/2337/5210098
 
Last edited:
Cool, so your ready to have a go then champ!

Lets ask the expert shall we?


Reality Check, whats the porosity of the comet 67P?
 
I'd like to cherry pick this quote from the paper by Patzold.

The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice

Along with this ripper

and, not so unrealistically, the nucleus would be a highly porous stony agglomerate, essentially devoid of
volitiles
.
 
Last edited:
I'd like to cherry pick this quote from the paper by Patzold.

The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice

Along with this ripper

and, not so unrealistically, the nucleus would be a highly porous stony agglomerate, essentially devoid of
volitiles
.

Lying again. Learn to read. From the summary and conclusions;

Larger porosities (> 80%) require very high dust-to-ice ratios (Fnucleus >> 7), where the ice content decreases rapidly from afew percent to ultimately zero, representing a highly porous dusty nucleus with little to no ice. This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P, but not unreasonable because it is the ultimate fate of a comet nucleus at the end of its "active life".

The part you cherry-picked was from a list of possible porosities. They dismiss this in the summary. Comprehension gone walkabout again, hasn't it? They suggest that is the ultimate fate of comets, which may well be correct, especially for short period JFCs.
However, I suspect Patzold et al have got something wrong in their assumptions. Fulle's contemporaneous paper presents no such problems, and includes extended sources for the outgassing, which would explain the differences between ROSINA measurement at the spacecraft location, and those of VIRTIS and MIRO sampling the coma from much closer distances. All measurements of the outgassing rate are way too high for a dry body, regardless of who did the measurements, and how they did them.
The impact ejected ice at Tempel 1 killed your woo 13 years ago. Why are you still here?
 
Cool, so your ready to have a go then champ!

Lets ask the expert shall we?


Reality Check, whats the porosity of the comet 67P?

On RC's behalf;

The Rosetta CONSERT experiment, which studies the propagation of radio waves in the VHF-band (~100 MHz) between the Rosetta orbiter and the Philae lander through the nucleus, has concluded that at least the interior of the ‘head’ of the duck-shaped nucleus is homogeneous down to scales of 3 m and that the porosity is 75% to 85% (ref. 19). As stated above, we consider the lower-porosity value to be more likely because porosities larger than 75% unrealistically constrain the nucleus material to mostly dust with very little ice. The porosity of about 70% to 75% inferred from the mass and the bulk density must therefore be considered an inherent property of the nucleus material.

A homogeneous nucleus for comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko from its gravity field
Pätzold, M. et al. (2016)
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16535
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom