The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
ASSIGNMENT #003

Sol88, you make me laugh! Watching you argue "science" is like watching a four year old natter on about their favourite little fantasies! Why don't you come out from the dark corner you find yourself cowering in and join the mainstream! It'll be fun! We can fight for limited research funding together!

ALRIGHT! LET'S DISCUSS DECA et al (2017)! Or at least scratch the surface ...!

ASSIGNMENT #003 of ....

Referring to Deca et al (2017) Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet!

The referenced document is a brilliant mainstream paper, written by mainstream scientists, in support of the mainstream comet model!

Sadly, this paper provides NO MATERIAL SUPPORT for your 'electric comet' religion!

Sol88, I expect this exercise will be a true test of YOUR reading comprehension skills!

And I would like to apologize in advance for what is to follow, but you did say you wanted to DISCUSS Deca et al (2017)!

Part I: (10 points)

To be successful, every scientist must develop skills and techniques in reading comprehension! The "Title" and "Abstract" of a paper provides a brief introduction to the contents that awaits within ...!

Deca et al (2017) said:
ABSTRACT

Using a 3D fully kinetic approach, we disentangle and explain the ion and electron dynamics of the solar wind interaction with a weakly outgassing comet. We show that, to first order, the dynamical interaction is representative of a four-fluid coupled system. We self-consistently simulate and identify the origin of the warm and suprathermal electron distributions observed by ESA’s Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko and conclude that a detailed kinetic treatment of the electron dynamics is critical to fully capture the complex physics of mass-loading plasmas.


I have highlighted several fragments of text from the Abstract ...
  1. What do you notice about the first fragment of text?
  2. What mainstream issues might be associated with an "electrically neutral" solar wind interacting with a weakly outgassing comet?
  3. Why is a "weakly outgassing comet" important to the paper's results?
  4. Why did the authors limit their model to a "weakly outgassing comet?"
  5. Why did the authors change the order of some text between the title and abstract? Is this important?
  6. What is the difference between a "dynamic" interaction and a "static" interaction?
  7. What is meant by "representative of a four-fluid coupled system?"
  8. Can a "four-fluid coupled system" accurately simulate cometary behaviour?
  9. How is a "four-fluid coupled system" consistent with your expectations of "kinetic" simulations?
  10. How is a "four-fluid coupled system" consistent with your expectations of "hybrid" simulations?
  11. How is a "four-fluid coupled system" consistent with your expectations of an "MHD" simulation?
  12. Can you define the term "simulate" within the context of your 'electric comet' model?
  13. Can you "simulate" the "ion and electron dynamics of the solar wind" without mathematics?
  14. Can you "simulate" the "ion and electron dynamics of the solar wind" without plasma physics?
  15. Why is the temperature of an electron distribution important?
  16. Do the terms "warm" and "suprathermal" have any meaning with respect to human sensations?
  17. What did we know about "warm and suprathermal electron distributions" before Rosetta?
  18. Why is it important to "capture the complex physics of mass-loading plasmas?"
  19. How does your 'electric comet' model deal with "mass-loading plasmas?"
  20. Why did the authors take the time to research and write the paper we are now discussing?
Bonus question : What is a "fluid" in the context of a "kinetic" plasma simulation? Do you have any thoughts on kinetic fluids, Sol88?

Now, what do you do, Sol88? DO YOU IGNORE the "short" list of questions related to the Abstract? Do you continue to hide in a dark corner hoping the scary Indagator goes away? Or do you double down on your 'electric comet' religion?

Did you think "science" was easy, Sol88?
Did you think "peer-review" was easy, Sol88?
Do you think you can model plasma physics without mathematics?
Do you think "religion" is a better description of your world view, Sol88?
Do you think at all, Sol88?

Don't cower in a dark corner anymore, Sol88! Science is hard! Religion is easy! Learn to be skeptical! Learn to question your model! Learn to question your assumptions! Learn some "real" science! Any questions? :D

It is clear (to me at least) that the premise of the paper is to "self-consistently simulate" observed mainstream comet behaviour! I wonder how that's going to turn out!

Now we can finally move on to the meat of the paper! With respect to the topic at hand, what is a model? A model is a physical (e.g., KOSI experiments) and/or numerical representation of some real world phenomena. Models may be qualitative or quantitative, but to have any utility to science and engineering, they must be consistent with observations (i.e., data) and they must ultimately predict future behaviour!

Your 'electric comet' model, Sol88, has neither a qualitative or quantitative description, and it obviously has NO predictive capabilities! Regardless of your opinion, your model needs mathematics, as we shall see!

Part II: (40 points)

The Deca et al (2017) paper is delightfully short and packed with all kinds of mainstream cometary science! In my reading of said paper, I can identify dozens and dozens of statements and concepts that support the mainstream comet model! I can also identify dozens and dozens of "mathematical" statements and concepts that are critical to the modeling effort undertaken!

For example, the very first sentence reads ...
Deca et al (2017) said:
Cometary nuclei are small, irregularly shaped "icy dirt balls" left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules [1-4].

Let's break that sentence down, shall we? Quoting directly ...

Cometary nuclei are
  • small, irregularly shaped "icy dirt balls"
  • left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and
  • are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules
  • [1-4].
Does that sound like a mainstream comet to you, Sol88? Just for fun, let's restate ...
  • Bullet 1) "Icy dirt balls" are consistent with Whipple's original comet description from 1950!
  • Bullet 2) Comets formed in the PSN 4.6 billion years ago as noted by A'Hearn (2017) and others!
  • Bullet 3) Comets are composed of volatile ices and dust! True fact based on observation!
  • Bullet 3) Comets are NOT composed of "rock" or "stone" ... (how long will we have to wait, Sol88?)
  • Bullet 4) Reference #1: F. L. Whipple, Astrophys. J. 111, 375 (1950) = Mainstream cometary science
  • Bullet 4) Reference #4: J. M. Sunshine et al., Science 311, 1453 (2006) = Mainstream cometary science
  • Overall assessment? ALL MAINSTREAM! No mention of "rock" or "stone" or your 'electric comet!'
Oh POOP! How does your 'electric comet' reconcile this "in-your-face" mainstream cometary science?

Sentence two reads ...
Deca et al (2017) said:
When a comet is sufficiently close to the Sun, the sublimation of ice leads to an outgassing atmosphere and the formation of a coma, and a dust and plasma tail.

Let's break that sentence down, shall we? Quoting directly ...

When a comet is sufficiently close to the Sun,
  • the sublimation of ice
  • leads to an outgassing atmosphere and
  • the formation of a coma, and
  • a dust and plasma tail.
Well what do you know? ALL MAINSTREAM! And necessary to the simulation that Deca et al perform! Now, how do you dismiss the first two sentences of this brilliant paper, Sol88? Given that the Deca et al simulation is based on the mainstream comet model, how can you then claim it supports your religion?

And two tails, Sol88? Is that not a violation of your 'electric comet' science religion? A positive ion tail? A negative dust tail? Pointing in different directions? In your science religion, Sol88, which tail is driven by the solar wind? And which is shaking it's fist at your 'electric universe?' FYI - We'll get back to this EPIC 'ec' FAILURE in a future post! OK? (This thing is going to be long enough as it is!)

So, the cometary simulation performed by Deca et al (2017) is BUILT DIRECTLY FROM MAINSTREAM SCIENCE'S UNDERSTANDING OF OBSERVED COMETARY BEHAVIOUR!

And it only gets harder from here, Sol88!

Deca et al, also employ dozens of concepts consistent with mainstream plasma physics! For example, ...
Deca et al (2017) said:
The interplanetary magnetic field is directed along Y at BIMF = (0,6,0) nT, resulting in a solar wind proton and electron Larmor radius of rp;sw = 142 km and re;sw = 12 km, respectively.
  1. What is an "interplanetary magnetic field?"
  2. Is there an "interplanetary magnetic field" observed at 3.0 AU?
  3. What does a "frozen-in" magnetic field look like at 3.0 AU?
  4. Is an "interplanetary magnetic field" the same as a "frozen-in" magnetic field?
  5. Why did the authors feel a need to introduce an "interplanetary magnetic field" into the model?
  6. Is an "interplanetary magnetic field" critical to the results obtained by the authors?
  7. Is an "interplanetary magnetic field" critical to your "electric comet" model?
  8. Describe in your own words what the Larmor radius is!
  9. Why are the proton and electron Larmor radii different?
  10. Why is the Larmor radius important to Deca et al's simulation efforts?
I want you to notice, Sol88, that everything discussed in the Deca paper, including boundary conditions, textbook plasma physics, and simulation results, is contingent on the mainstream comet model (i.e., comets accreted in a PSN 4.6 billion years ago, and are composed of primordial volatile ices and dusts, where the volatile ices are sufficiently close to the surface to sublimate when insolated)!

For you to claim that Deca et al (2017) supports your 'electric comet' model, you must also accept ...
  • Whipple (1950) - Comets are "Icy dirt balls" or "dirty snowballs" or simply "COMETS" (not asteroids),
  • Lisse et al (2006) - Comets formed by accretion in the protosolar nebula 4.6 billion years ago,
  • A'Hearn (2017) - Comets formed by accretion in the protosolar nebula 4.6 billion years ago,
  • A'Hearn (2017) - Comets are composed of primordial volatile ices and dust,
  • A'Hearn et al (Date TBD - your outstanding ASSIGNMENT #002) - Comets are NOT composed of "rock"
  • An "interplanetary magnetic field" is REQUIRED to produce the results obtained,
  • The solar wind plasma is slowed and "mass-loaded" by cometary ions, and
  • This list of scary monsters will continue to grow as we discuss Deca et al (2017) ...! :D
As stated earlier, I can identify dozens and dozens of mainstream comet model statements and concepts required by Deca et al (2017) to produce the "peer-reviewed" published results! Results that you claim support your religion! Results that depend on concepts that violate your religion!

Just a few more questions then, Sol88, ...
  1. List ten (10) additional statements or concepts that are consistent with the mainstream comet model!
  2. List just two (2/0) statements or concepts that are consistent with your "electric comet" model!
  3. List just three (3/6) CHEATS that Deca et al (2017) used to generate the results obtained! OUCH!
  4. Describe in your own words what the Vlasov equation is!
  5. Describe in your own words what the Vlasov-Maxwell equations are!
  6. Describe in your own words how an implicit particle-in-cell code works!
  7. In a paragraph, describe the known instabilities inherent in implicit PIC codes!
  8. In a paragraph, describe the connection between Deca et al (2017) and MAGNETIC RECONNECTION!
  9. How many computational nodes are employed in the simulation (to four sig. figs. please)?
  10. How many SW proton/electron pairs are used to populate the computational domain (to four sig. figs.)?
  11. How long does it take for an unperturbed SW particle to cover the length of the computational domain?
  12. What cometary gas species is used in the simulation, and WHY?
  13. What is the initial temperature of the cometary gas species, and WHY is that important to the results?
  14. How does Deca et al introduce the cometary gas species into the computational domain?
Referring to Figure 1. in Deca et al (2017)
  1. Identify the four (4) panels that contain the "interplanetary magnetic field."
  2. Identify the four (4) panels that illustrate magnetic field draping as proposed by Alfven (1957).
  3. In which panel(s) do we find evidence of an ambipolar electric field? Explain in detail!
  4. What is the areal extent of the ambipolar electric field in three-dimensions?
  5. What is the electric field strength in this ambipolar region?
  6. Does the ambipolar electric field strength vary with time?
  7. What might cause the ambipolar electric field strength to change?
  8. Under what circumstances do ambipolar electric fields form?
  9. Under what circumstances do ambipolar electric fields dissipate?
In the past, Sol88, you've made the unsubstantiated claim that double layers will be found at comets! PROVE IT!
  1. Where do you "see" double layers mentioned in the text of Deca et al (2017)?
  2. In which panel(s) of Figure 1. do you find evidence for double layers? Explain in detail!
  3. Are hallucinogenic drugs required to "see" your double layers?
  4. Where are these double layers going to be found? The nucleus? Coma? Tail? BE SPECIFIC!
  5. How far from the nucleus will these double layers be found? Distance measurements are required!
  6. What is the areal extent of these double layers? Surface area measurements are required!
  7. How thick are these double layers? You know the drill! Give me a number!
  8. How transient are these double layers? How do you know? BE SPECIFIC!
  9. Under what circumstances do double layers form at comets?
  10. Under what circumstances do double layers dissipate at comets?
  11. What is the potential difference across these double layers? How do you know? BE SPECIFIC!
I can't wait to see what answers you come up with for all these questions! And guess what? There are hundreds more waiting in the wings! Show us what you've got 'ec' expert!

So, Sol88! Would you really like to discuss Deca et al (2017)? Would you really like to discuss Lisse et al (2006)? Would you really like to discuss A'Hearn et al (date TBD by your fine self (ref. ASSIGNMENT #002))? Or are you going to continue cowering in some dark corner hoping the scary Indagator goes away? And just to let you know, I can bring this kind of scientific and academic rigour to you and your religious fantasies all day long! There are NO mainstream papers that support your "electric" religion! NONE! Now, if you'd like, we can turn the discussion of the Vlasov-Maxwell equations into a full-year course! That would be fun, wouldn't it? Do you think you could pass one of my exams, Sol88?

I wonder, Sol88? Do you really want to discuss your 'electric comet' model? Are you open to the possibility that your 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE? Or are you just trolling? Based on your posting history, I don't think you want to engage in any kind of real intellectual conversation. Am I wrong about you, Sol88? Perhaps you're nothing more than a missionary hoping to recruit for Thunderbutts! How's that going?

Remember, Sol88, ...
  • The internet never forgets
  • The internet is watch and waiting to see what you will do
  • The internet is hoping you'll try to answer the questions posted here
  • The internet is wondering if you can find the A'Hearn paper from ASSIGNMENT #002
  • There are NO mainstream papers that support your 'electric comet' religion
  • There is NO mainstream science that supports your 'electric comet' religion (trust me)
  • There is no 'electric comet' (the object is physically IMPOSSIBLE)
  • There is no 'electric comet' model (a model requires mathematics and/or lab work*** we'll address this FAILURE later)
  • There is no 'electric comet' science ('eu/es/ec' violations of fundamental physics requires, ... no demands, a whole new set of physical laws)
  • There is no 'electric comet' evidence (comets are not "rocks discharging in the solar plasma")
  • There is no 'electric star' (the object is physically IMPOSSIBLE)
  • There is no 'electric universe' regardless of what your religion asks you to "believe"
End of ROUND #001 for ASSIGNMENT #003 ... How's your stamina, Sol88? Want to go a few more rounds?

Post Script - Sol88! Have I opened your eyes at all? Are you able to see how Deca et al (2017) supports the mainstream comet model? Do you see how untenable your "electric comet" religion is? You've been duped by a bunch of scam artists! It's OK to admit you've been wrong and change directions! Sadly, though, I doubt you will "see" the light and you'll "patiently" continue down your ragged path, tilting at windmills! A real waste!

Oh! And what is it you said got all over your monitor? It wasn't coffee! It was ... what? Grow up! You're better than that!

Now, would you like to continue our discussion of Lisse et al (2006)? It is a mainstream paper that craps all over your 'electric comet' religion.
 
Last edited:
Great post, Indagator and not to take the wind out of your sails, but...

Interesting to see what mainstream science comes up with. Not some crakhead who believes comets are rocks discharging in the solar plasma.

Might have to wait some more as, and from Deca's paper, the mainstream are still working out the bugs in the sublimation theory.
Although globally the dynamics of the solar wind – weak comet system is that of a four-fluid coupled system, we conclude that a multi-species electron-kinetic description is a must to fully capture the complex global solar wind – comet interaction process.

Now, there was another recent paper that was dealing with the circuits that are a part of the kinetic modeling of the plasma environment of comets and 67P in particular.

Ah, here it is Energy conversion in cometary atmospheres Hybrid modeling of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko J. Lindkvist

Abstract

Aims. We wish to investigate the energy conversion between particles and electromagnetic fields and determine the location where it occurs in the plasma environment of comets.

Methods. We used a hybrid plasma model that included photoionization, and we considered two cases of the solar extreme ultraviolet flux. Other parameters corresponded to the conditions of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko at a heliocentric distance of 1.5 AU.

Results. We find that a shock-like structure is formed upstream of the comet and acts as an electromagnetic generator, similar to the bow shock at Earth that slows down the solar wind. The Poynting flux transports electromagnetic energy toward the inner coma, where newly born cometary ions are accelerated. Upstream of the shock-like structure, we find local energy transfer from solar wind ions to cometary ions. We show that mass loading can be a local process with a direct transfer of energy, but also part of a dynamo system with electromagnetic generators and loads.

Conclusions. The energization of cometary ions is governed by a dynamo system for weak ionization, but changes into a large conversion region with local transfer of energy directly from solar wind protons for high ionization.

and as for my double layers, i believe mainstream still call them shocks and they were seen as far back as Halley...

The structure and dynamics of the plasma environment on the sunward side of comet Halley are investigated using measurements during the Vega inbound encounters from a double probe antenna and two Langmuir probes (the APV‐V experiment), within a cometocentric distance of ∼850,000 km. Based upon the behavior of the electric fields and the cold electrons, three regions can be identified in the cometosheath (in particular during the Vega 1 approach): transition layers are passed through at ∼780,000 km (R1) and ∼360,000 km (R2). The outer cometosheath (near and beyond R1) is characterized by large‐scale variations in the cold electron density and the electric field, peaking at ∼1 mHz. The R2 crossing is detected in the plasma wave data as enhanced fluctuations at ∼15 mHz. About 25,000 km downstream of R2, the spacecraft traverses a current layer (thickness ∼10,000 km) indicated by a sharp gradient in the dc electric field and the cold electron density. The continuous, relatively rapid increase in the intensity of plasma waves begins at a cometocentric distance of ∼200,000 km. Simultaneously, the cold electron density starts growing in accordance with the r−2 law. The cometopause crossing at ∼160,000 km produces only moderate effects in the APV‐V measurements. In the cometary plasma region, some interesting features are examined, such as a current layer passed by Vega 1 at 54,000 km and sudden ion density enhancements observed by Vega 2 at ∼35,000 km. On several occasions, the APV‐V measurements are heavily influenced by dust particles striking the spacecraft structure. From these events we can conclude that the dust particles are strongly charged and partially coupled to cometary plasmas (or vice versa).
Electric fields and cold electrons in the vicinity of comet Halley

So don't let me preempt proper real mainstream scientist.


Just happy to see charge separation acknowledged.

PS as a side note I hope you are aware of the overestimation of the "outgassing" rate?
 
Last edited:
Cometary nuclei are

small, irregularly shaped "icy dirt balls"
left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and
are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules

Speculation only and the new papers cast doubt on Whipple's original assumptions.

Have you read

For very high Fnucleus values, the nucleus is highly porous and dusty with very little ice (e.g. for Fnucleus = 7, the ice content is about 7% for porosities between 68% and 80%, respectively). A variation in porosity by 1% beyond the 70% implies a steep increase in Fnucleus, leaving only a tiny fractional ice content. As a reminder, the upper bound on the porosity is 73% to 85% for a highly porous stony body without ice for the selected dust material density range.

My bolding
 
Last edited:
Great post, Indagator and not to take the wind out of your sails, but...

Interesting to see what mainstream science comes up with. Not some crakhead who believes comets are rocks discharging in the solar plasma.

Might have to wait some more as, and from Deca's paper, the mainstream are still working out the bugs in the sublimation theory.

Now, there was another recent paper that was dealing with the circuits that are a part of the kinetic modeling of the plasma environment of comets and 67P in particular.

Ah, here it is Energy conversion in cometary atmospheres Hybrid modeling of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko J. Lindkvist



and as for my double layers, i believe mainstream still call them shocks and they were seen as far back as Halley...

Electric fields and cold electrons in the vicinity of comet Halley

So don't let me preempt proper real mainstream scientist.


Just happy to see charge separation acknowledged.

PS as a side note I hope you are aware of the overestimation of the "outgassing" rate?

Irrelevant. Nothing to do with the failed EC woo.
 
ALRIGHT! LET'S DISCUSS DECA et al (2017)! Or at least scratch the surface ...!

It would appear that Sol no longer wishes to discuss Deca! Perhaps he's realised that Deca's paper is about a four-fluid model. And he has now realised where two of those fluids are coming from!
He wants to talk about a trifling ambipolar field at the comet, which is of no relevance. However, he doesn't want to discuss the fact that stronger fields will form at asteroids, and also comets when they are at low outgassing levels. He cannot explain why asteroids aren't outgassing, and why the comet outgasses more as the field weakens.
We should not be surprised by this behaviour - the whole of the electric comet woo is based on deceit.
56 years after Whipple had published his essentially correct model of a comet, and 20 years after the Halley encounters, and the definitive detection of water at that comet, two unqualified nobodies wrote a pile of scientifically illiterate nonsense. None of this nonsense has come to pass, unsurprisingly. However, what irks me is the seemingly deliberate deceit employed by these wooists to entrap their intellectually challenged followers. As mentioned, 20 years after KAO and the VEGA spacecraft had detected H2O at Halley, these clowns were telling their gullible followers that it was OH. This might be excused as an oversight on their part, were it the only such detection prior to 2006, when they penned this misinformation. However, there had been another ~ 20 definitive detections at different comets. Many of those were made by the Odin satellite, which detects in the microwave range, essentially the same as the MIRO instrument on Rosetta. At the time of the publication of this orchestrated litany of lies and obfuscation by the esteemed T & T, we were told that one of the T's had been studying comets for ~ 30 years. That would put it into the mid-70s. Yet he seemingly missed the first definitive detection of H2O at a comet in '86, and many subsequent detections!
And that, among other things, is why I say that the electric comet is not only unscientific claptrap, but is built on a deceit.

Detection of Water Vapor in Halley's Comet (KAO)
Mumma, M. J. et al.
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/232/4757/1523

The 2.5-12 um Spectrum of Comet Halley from the IKS-VEGA Experiment
Combes, M. et al.
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.537.7727&rep=rep1&type=pdf

Recent astronomy highlights from the Odin satellite (2005)
Hjalmarson, Å, et al.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0273117705007969 (among others)
 
Last edited:
It would appear that Sol no longer wishes to discuss Deca! Perhaps he's realised that Deca's paper is about a four-fluid model. And he has now realised where two of those fluids are coming from!
He wants to talk about a trifling ambipolar field at the comet, which is of no relevance. However, he doesn't want to discuss the fact that stronger fields will form at asteroids, and also comets when they are at low outgassing levels. He cannot explain why asteroids aren't outgassing, and why the comet outgasses more as the field weakens.
We should not be surprised by this behaviour - the whole of the electric comet woo is based on deceit.
56 years after Whipple had published his essentially correct model of a comet, and 20 years after the Halley encounters, and the definitive detection of water at that comet, two unqualified nobodies wrote a pile of scientifically illiterate nonsense. None of this nonsense has come to pass, unsurprisingly. However, what irks me is the seemingly deliberate deceit employed by these wooists to entrap their intellectually challenged followers. As mentioned, 20 years after KAO and the VEGA spacecraft had detected H2O at Halley, these clowns were telling their gullible followers that it was OH. This might be excused as an oversight on their part, were it the only such detection prior to 2006, when they penned this misinformation. However, there had been another ~ 20 definitive detections at different comets. Many of those were made by the Odin satellite, which detects in the microwave range, essentially the same as the MIRO instrument on Rosetta. At the time of the publication of this orchestrated litany of lies and obfuscation by the esteemed T & T, we were told that one of the T's had been studying comets for ~ 30 years. That would put it into the mid-70s. Yet he seemingly missed the first definitive detection of H2O at a comet in '86, and many subsequent detections!
And that, among other things, is why I say that the electric comet is not only unscientific claptrap, but is built on a deceit.

Detection of Water Vapor in Halley's Comet (KAO)
Mumma, M. J. et al.
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/232/4757/1523

The 2.5-12 um Spectrum of Comet Halley from the IKS-VEGA Experiment
Combes, M. et al.
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.537.7727&rep=rep1&type=pdf

Recent astronomy highlights from the Odin satellite (2005)
Hjalmarson, Å, et al.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0273117705007969 (among others)

Why bother, you are not prepared to discuss new findings. You've become irrelevant.

At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

So would you concede that the only error A'Hearn made was he should of used mostly STONE not mostly ROCK in his wording?

Martin Pätzold new paper has one particular word in it that should cause you to raise an eyebrow

The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications

This paper reinforces A'Hearn's statement.

The dust particles are compact, i.e. denser than the nucleus of 67P, and similar to the non-fragmenting particles, composed of multiple minerals that produced carrot-shaped tracks in the aerogel of the Stardust collector (Brownlee et al. 2006; Della Corte et al. 2015).

The RSI (Pätzold et al. 2016) and the CONSERT (Kofman et al. 2015) experiments exclude macro-porosity at scales above 100 m. CONSERT experiment provides a micro-porosity between 75 per cent and 85 per cent (Kofman et al. 2015). Hapke models provide a surface porosity of 87 per cent (Fornasier et al. 2015).

https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S2/2633355

Is the above true, jonesdave116?
 
ASSIGNMENT #000

No wind out of my sails, Sol88! I, too, can be patient! After all, you and I are engaged in the eternal struggle for the hearts and minds of souls seeking truth! And I intend to win! Though it's really not much of a contest, as I've got "gaslight era" physics and everything that came before and after that on my side! What have you got, Sol88? Ducks and Bunnies? High school mathematics? Less than that?

Based simply on observation, Sol88, ...

I come here to TEACH! You come here to PREACH!

I come here to educate! You come here to misinterpret, misunderstand, confound, confuse, obfuscate, deceive, and troll (when you're not attempting to demean, belittle, and insult mainstream science and scientists)! Sol88? How do you expect mainstream science will help when all you do is crap all over those that offer their assistance? In the last several years a number of people have shown you, and your 'electric comet' to be wrong. These individuals know what they are talking about. You do not! Why then, would you think that mainstream science will suddenly provide the evidence you seek? Mainstream physics does not work on an 'electric comet!' The world is still waiting for a description of what an 'electric comet' is! No model! No science! No evidence!

As a mainstream scientist, I know that an 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE! As an educator, I just need to find a way to open your eyes to the truth! FACT - turns out, Sol88, neither you (a layman), or I (a mainstream scientist) can build a useful model of an 'electric comet!' Why? An 'electric comet' MUST violate basic laws of physics to exist! Ergo! It can't exist!

Now what do we do? You and I? How about we keep discussing things you REFUSE to discuss when presented with overwhelming evidence that contradicts your 'electric rock' religion!

To date, I have gently scratched the surface of two papers that you claim contains some content that supports your 'electric comet' nonsense! Whilst you feign a noble desire to discuss, when presented with contradictory evidence, you immediately tuck tail and run! In case it was not obvious to you, Sol88, discussion requires some back and forth! This is how it works - I ask you a few simple questions (the hard ones come later), and you, as the resident 'ec' expert MUST answer them! Remember, Sol88, this is your 'electric comet' thread! Stop cowering in the dark, Sol88, and enlighten us! Stop preaching and start teaching! Otherwise, I will start making a case to have all references to the 'eu/es/ec' dumped in the Religion section of the ISF where it belongs!

So, we have two options regarding Lisse et al (2006) and Deca et al (2017), 1) you can openly admit on the internet that you misunderstood the results presented and forever drop these papers from your 'ec' toolbox, or 2) we can dig deeper and deeper and deeper into the subtleties of these papers until you realize just how wrong you are about ... everything science!

ASSIGNMENT #000 of ....

<SNIPPY>

ELECTRIC COMET MODEL = A Rock on an eliptical orbit, discharging in the solar plasma flow.

<SNIPPY>


It occurred to me shortly after posting ASSIGNMENT #001, that I had already given you, Sol88, our resident 'ec' expert, an unnumbered assignment. I would like to rectify that oversight and properly fold this into the sequence. Remember the internet never forgets! :D

YOUR ASSIGNMENT

Part I: (50 points) Your PROOF re. eccentricity will require physics and mathematics to complete!

Presented for your consideration, Sol88, is the penultimate table of eccentricities! The next step is to dump the entire contents of the ever expanding JPL Small Body Database! In my humble opinion, I don't think that's necessary or helpful, as you seem incapable of addressing the STAGGERING FAILURE of your 'electric comet' model to account for the 35 celestial objects listed here! Regardless, let's continue our lopsided discussion of eccentricity and why it is IRRELEVANT to your 'electric comet' religion!

Please explain, in 'electric comet' terms, Sol88, why comet and asteroid eccentricities are so intimately mixed! What fundamental physics is missing from your model? The mainstream has no problem accounting for the variability! Do you, 'ec' expert, need to apply 'electric epicycles' to account for the discrepancies? You keep claiming (without science or evidence) that your 'electric comets' charge and discharge because of their eccentricity! Where's the evidence? Where's the lab work? When are you going to PROVE IT? When is anyone in your camp going to do some real science?

TABLE: Small Solar System Bodies that will NEVER be 'electric comets'
Object ID | a (AU) | e | i | q (AU) | Q (AU) | TJ
| ====== | ====== | ====== | ====== | ====== | ======
KBO: 2014 MU69 | 44.630 | 0.0505 | 2.50 | 42.38 | 46.88 | 5.96 Comet: 372P/McNaught | 4.496 | 0.1539 | 9.52 | 3.80 | 5.19 | 2.97 X Asteroid: 1999 CK103 | 3.337 | 0.2053 | 25.43 | 2.65 | 4.02 | 2.98 X Comet: 367P/Catalina | 3.511 | 0.2800 | 8.46 | 2.53 | 4.49 | 3.04 Asteroid: 2014 QP241 | 3.493 | 0.3225 | 1.51 | 2.37 | 4.62 | 3.04 Comet: 116P/Wild 4 | 3.478 | 0.3725 | 3.61 | 2.19 | 4.78 | 3.01 Comet: 9P/Tempel 1 | 3.146 | 0.5096 | 10.47 | 1.54 | 4.75 | 2.97 X Asteroid: 6489 Golevka | 2.502 | 0.6053 | 2.27 | 0.99 | 4.02 | 3.18 Asteroid: 2001 KD55 | 3.344 | 0.6235 | 9.98 | 1.26 | 5.43 | 2.79 X Asteroid: 4179 Toutatis | 2.531 | 0.6287 | 0.45 | 0.94 | 4.12 | 3.14 Asteroid: 2014 LS26 | 3.364 | 0.6289 | 10.86 | 1.25 | 5.48 | 2.77 X Asteroid: 2000 DQ110 | 3.361 | 0.6297 | 58.28 | 1.25 | 5.48 | 2.20 X Asteroid: 2016 RP33 | 3.334 | 0.6343 | 23.04 | 1.22 | 5.45 | 2.70 X Asteroid: 2014 XN40 | 3.381 | 0.6349 | 14.20 | 1.24 | 5.53 | 2.75 X Asteroid: 1986 RA | 3.327 | 0.6358 | 19.13 | 1.21 | 5.44 | 2.73 X Comet: 67P/C-G | 3.463 | 0.6414 | 7.05 | 1.24 | 5.69 | 2.75 X Asteroid: 2014 HW177 | 3.302 | 0.6437 | 13.00 | 1.18 | 5.43 | 2.76 X Asteroid: 1995 QN3 | 3.300 | 0.6450 | 14.79 | 1.17 | 5.43 | 2.75 X Asteroid: 2014 HY196 | 3.526 | 0.6561 | 42.29 | 1.21 | 5.84 | 2.40 X Asteroid: 2016 WX8 | 3.529 | 0.6572 | 13.29 | 1.21 | 5.85 | 2.68 X Asteroid: 944 Hidalgo | 5.741 | 0.6608 | 42.52 | 1.95 | 9.53 | 2.07 X Asteroid: 2016 LA2 | 3.565 | 0.6748 | 17.43 | 1.16 | 5.97 | 2.63 X Asteroid: 2011 YY28 | 3.388 | 0.6765 | 7.35 | 1.10 | 5.68 | 2.71 X Comet: 2P/Encke | 2.218 | 0.8471 | 11.76 | 0.33 | 4.11 | 3.03 Asteroid: 2005 MW9 | 3.580 | 0.8876 | 55.24 | 0.40 | 6.76 | 1.89 Comet: 1P/Halley | 17.834 | 0.9671 | 162.26 | 0.59 | 35.10 |-0.61 Comet: C/2004 P1 | 8057. | 0.9993 | 28.82 | 6.01 | 16107 | 2.58 X Comet: C/2004 U1 | 3613. | 0.9993 | 130.63 | 2.66 | 7224 |-1.28 Comet: C/2007 M2 | 5360. | 0.9993 | 80.95 | 3.54 | 10717 | 0.38 Comet: C/2011 F1 | 2776. | 0.9993 | 56.62 | 1.82 | 5550 | 0.95 Comet: C/2013 F2 | 8409. | 0.9993 | 61.75 | 6.22 | 16812 | 1.42 Comet: C/2013 J5 | 7151. | 0.9993 | 136.01 | 4.91 | 14297 |-1.99 Comet: C/2017 U7 | -4109. | 1.0016 | 142.64 | 6.42 | N/A |-2.53 Comet: C/2018 C2 | -1082. | 1.0018 | 34.45 | 1.96 | N/A | 1.42 Interstellar: 1I/2017 U1 | -1.272 | 1.2011 | 122.74 | 0.26 | N/A |-4.45

Columns: a = Semi-major axis, e = Eccentricity, i = Inclination, q = Perihelion, Q = Aphelion, TJ = Tisserand parameter.

All data extracted from the JPL SBDB. Please note, the tabulated data, above, is a trivial subset of a greater whole. Literally thousands of data records! Literally thousands of small bodies! And not one 'electric comet' in the whole damned database! POOP!

You'll note, I've added a few more records and a new column of data to further invalidate your claim that orbital mechanics can be used to predict when an object will become an 'electric comet!' So, what is WRONG with your 'electric comet' model, Sol88? Eccentricity is obviously a meaningless physical parameter in your model, yet you continue to shriek on about it! When are you going to admit that you are WRONG? When are you going to open your eyes and realize that you've been deceived? When are you going to start thinking?

Given the evidence presented, your quote should now read ... "ELECTRIC COMET MODEL = A Rock discharging in the solar plasma flow." Yes? Eight words? Is that enough effort, Sol88?

Sol88! Your 'electric comet model' is beginning to fall apart before your very eyes!

Part II: (50 points) Comets are NOT Rock

Please make an effort to answer the following "focused" questions ...

  1. How does 'electric rock' explain the wild variability in the eccentricities tabled above?
  2. How does 'electric rock' explain observed density discrepancies (noted previously and ignored)?
  3. How might different rock types explain these mounting 'ec' discrepancies?
  4. Is your 'electric rock' of IGNEOUS origin? What is your evidence?
  5. Is your 'electric rock' of METAMORPHIC origin? You know the routine!
  6. Is your 'electric rock' of SEDIMENTARY origin? How do you know? Fossils?
  7. Is your 'electric rock' better modeled like THIS?
  8. How much of your 'electric comet' is consolidated rock? Specific numbers, please!
  9. How much of your 'electric comet' is machined dust? More numbers, please!
  10. How much of your 'electric comet' is primordial dust (i.e., unprocessed from the ISM)?
  11. What is the size distribution of 'electric rock' particles? Power law? Numbers, please!
  12. What is the technical difference between "rock" and "stone?"
  13. Why have you moved the goal posts again regarding 'electric comet' composition?
  14. At what temperature does EDM remove material from a planet? NUMBERS based on thermodynamics, please!
  15. At what temperature does EDM remove material from a comet? NUMBERS based on thermodynamics, please!
  16. At what temperature does a "Coulomb explosion" operate? NUMBERS based on thermodynamics, please!
  17. How is a "Coulomb explosion" even remotely similar to the Wang et al (2016) "patched charge model?"
  18. What is the EM frequency of the "pulsed solar laser" emitted by your 'electric star?'
  19. What is the duty cycle for the "pulsed solar laser" emitted by your 'electric star?'
  20. What is the power output and areal coverage of this "pulsed solar laser?"
  21. How does an 'electric star' produce and direct a "pulsed solar laser?"
  22. Why don't we observe the effects of this "pulsed solar laser" on the moon?
  23. How does eccentricity influence "pulsed solar laser" machining behaviour?
  24. How did the micro-machining concept of a "Coulomb explosion" become an 'ec' machining mechanism?
  25. What was the maximum temperature measured at 67P?
  26. Where are the thermodynamic signatures of EDM or "Coulomb explosions" at 67P?
  27. What temperatures did Lisse et al (2006) use to determine the IR-based composition of DI impact ejecta?
  28. How much cold water was observed in the DI impact ejecta?
  29. How does your 'electric comet' model account for amorphous dust in the DI impact ejecta?
  30. How much amorphous dust comes from the interstellar medium?
  31. According to 'eu/ec' science religious myth, how old is comet 9P?
  32. According to 'eu/ec' science religious myth, how old is comet 67P?
  33. According to 'eu/ec' science religious myth, how old is KBO 2014 MU69?
  34. According to your 'eu/ec' religion, what "physics" forced KBO 2014 MU69 from its "point of origin" to its current orbit (a = 44.63 AU, e = 0.0505, i = 2.50, q = 42.38 AU, Q = 46.88)? Magic?
  35. According to your 'eu/ec' religion, what "physics" forced the orbit of KBO 2014 MU69 to be almost circular (e = 0.0505) in a span of how many years? More magic?
  36. According to your 'eu/ec' religion, where did comet C/2004 U1 come from (a = 3613 AU, e = 0.9993, i = 130.63, q = 2.66 AU, Q = 7224 AU)? An inclination of 130 degrees?

I could go on for hours, but why bother! Right, Sol88? Observational data means nothing to the religious! Science means nothing to the religious! Physics means nothing to the religious! All that matters is your FAITH. Sol88! Twenty years from now, a thousand years from now, there will still be no electric comet or electric universe! Comets, like 9P and 67P accreted in a PSN 4.6 billion years ago, and are composed of primordial volatile ices and dusts, where the volatile ices are sufficiently close to the surface to sublimate when insolated! But you go ahead and believe that "magic space rocks" outgas because they're special, after having been electrically rejected by a planet that didn't want them! Childish MYTH based RELIGION!

[size=+1]Bonus Question: Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet![/size]

An impossible task! Eccentricity has absolutely nothing to do with 'electric comets' charging and discharging! Just another childish FANTASY!

FYI (and just a reminder) - Electrostatics and electrodynamics are "gaslight era" physics! And orbital mechanics predate the "gaslight era" by decades! :D Are you having fun, Sol88? I am!

Remember, Sol88, you've still not completed ASSIGNMENT #002! Please, locate the A'Hearn et al (TBD) paper that discusses rock at comets! Get cracking! Your model is coming apart at the seams! I don't want you, or anyone else, to have to choke on this crap any longer! Let's kill this 'ec' abomination!

And make note of this post, Sol88! We are going to keep coming back to it until you either, 1) PROVE that eccentricity is applicable to your comet charging and discharging mechanism, or 2) you openly declare on the internet that eccentricity plays absolutely NO role in comet charging and discharging behaviour! Let's see just how patient you really are, 'ec' expert!

Oh! And have a nice day! :D
 
Last edited:
Indagator, another great post. :thumbsup:

Are you able to elaborate on the following statement?

I know that an 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE! As an educator, I just need to find a way to open your eyes to the truth!

What makes it physically IMPOSSIBLE? At this stage forget about orbits and the composition of the nucleus.

I think we need to start here before we delve into the really really fun stuff.
 
Last edited:
I feel so stupid for not realizing how scientifically/physically impossible the ELECTRIC COMET is and really need help on knowing why this is.

Are you able to set me straight,?

Reality Check likes to keep reminding me how much of an idiot I am.

Please try and keep it simple for me, I seem to struggle, so it seems.

PS

I also of the opinion that comets are a small part, the visible focus, of a larger electric circuit.

May help with your understanding of my understanding.
 
Last edited:
Indagator, another great post. :thumbsup:

Are you able to elaborate on the following statement?



What makes it physically IMPOSSIBLE? At this stage forget about orbits and the composition of the nucleus.

I think we need to start here before we delve into the really really fun stuff.

No rock, no discharges, no mechanism for discharges, no mechanism for EDM, no mechanism for producing ice or vapour.................... need I go on?
 
I also of the opinion that comets are a small part, the visible focus, of a larger electric circuit.

Then you haven't got a clue what you're talking about. What circuit? Where does it begin, where is it closed? What is the evidence for it? Why are asteroids not in this circuit? Stop talking nonsense.
 
Why bother, you are not prepared to discuss new findings. You've become irrelevant.



So would you concede that the only error A'Hearn made was he should of used mostly STONE not mostly ROCK in his wording?

Martin Pätzold new paper has one particular word in it that should cause you to raise an eyebrow

The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications

This paper reinforces A'Hearn's statement.





https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S2/2633355

Is the above true, jonesdave116?

It is irrelevant. Patzold is likely wrong, as Fulle's paper indicates. The water production rate is measured by various instruments in various ways, including ground based measurements. It is not going to be far off. And nothing is changing the fact that thousands of tonnes of ice was excavated at Tempel 1, therefore invalidating your stupid model. Nor is the fact that Thornhill lied to you going to change. Your hero is a proven liar. Deal with it.
 
It is irrelevant. Patzold is likely wrong, as Fulle's paper indicates. The water production rate is measured by various instruments in various ways, including ground based measurements. It is not going to be far off. And nothing is changing the fact that thousands of tonnes of ice was excavated at Tempel 1, therefore invalidating your stupid model. Nor is the fact that Thornhill lied to you going to change. Your hero is a proven liar. Deal with it.

Old mates probably wrong...:thumbsup:

No, it contradicts your, Whipple’s, sublimation model. :D

The more porous it is the less ice it has for your “gas” (water) and the more dense it is the more ice there is...except we see, touch and feel the dust.

From Wild 2, Tempel 1 and more recently 67P, so we are getting up there in the terms of comets visited and, as stated by A’Hearn, our understanding of comets is evolving toward mostly rock. :boggled:

True, I can quote him again if you like.

He did corroborate the assumed density and porosity in said paper. I can quote again if you like?
 
It is irrelevant. Patzold is likely wrong, as Fulle's paper indicates. The water production rate is measured by various instruments in various ways, including ground based measurements. It is not going to be far off. And nothing is changing the fact that thousands of tonnes of ice was excavated at Tempel 1, therefore invalidating your stupid model. Nor is the fact that Thornhill lied to you going to change. Your hero is a proven liar. Deal with it.


Nothing wrong with the measuring, just the assumption in the modeling. As A’Hearn said. It would be assumed if comets were mostly ice but would be hard to reconcile if comets were mostly rock.

Our understanding is evolving toward mostly rock stoney agglomerations...with little to no ice.

Ouch


So, yup, best bet is to say old mates Patzold is likely wrong, to is completely wrong...classic jonesdave116 defence, circle the wagons type stuff. ;)
 
Last edited:
Nothing wrong with the measuring, just the assumption in the modeling. As A’Hearn said. It would be assumed if comets were mostly ice but would be hard to reconcile if comets were mostly rock.

Our understanding is evolving toward mostly rock stoney agglomerations...with little to no ice.

Ouch


So, yup, best bet is to say old mates Patzold is likely wrong, to is completely wrong...classic jonesdave116 defence, circle the wagons type stuff. ;)

Fulle's paper is contemporaneous with Patzold's, and Patzold offers no reason why the production rates would be off by a large margin. He has likely underestimated the fall black. And none of this has anything to do with the EC woo. Tempel 1 killed that. You still have no model, no mechanisms, no science and no evidence. What is it - 13 years now? Not a single thing. Bit pathetic that, wouldn't you say?
 
Then you haven't got a clue what you're talking about. What circuit? Where does it begin, where is it closed? What is the evidence for it? Why are asteroids not in this circuit? Stop talking nonsense.

I think that may also be Indagator problem.

There are no currents in space...:rolleyes:

So ergo, there can be no electric comet, physical impossibility!

True, no currents, no electric field so no electric comet.


Is there an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

No, maybe, could be, little one that does nothing or yes?

You have NEVER given a definitive answer. If you had, and I’ve been itching looking out for it, I would have jumped on it faster than flies on ***** and updated my signature.

But alas....
 
Fulle's paper is contemporaneous with Patzold's, and Patzold offers no reason why the production rates would be off by a large margin. He has likely underestimated the fall black. And none of this has anything to do with the EC woo. Tempel 1 killed that. You still have no model, no mechanisms, no science and no evidence. What is it - 13 years now? Not a single thing. Bit pathetic that, wouldn't you say?


The error is the RSI and the assumption that comets are mostly ice.

The dust we have empericaly tested beats that nonsense, hands down.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom