The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.


Sweet.

Just to reiterate, there are NO ELECTRIC FIELDS in space.

Galactic Charge
We are aware of several workers who have published discussions of the role of electromagnetism and plasma in the universe under the generic title
, “Electric Universe” (EU). We emphasise that we are not involved with this group of researchers and we neither support nor oppose the EU ideas
.

Seems there are but of course you already know!

Good one sport :thumbsup:

So tell us about the electric fields at comet 67P and Halley

Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley H.Laakso

The root of a comet tail – Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar

So what's your game?
 
Last edited:
So poor jd116, rc and yourself seem to be struggling.

Every new paper points toward the electric comet!
 
Last edited:
WTF!

Sol88 ...

Twelve years you've been peddling your tired, irrelevent, inconsequential, "anti-science" religion without anything to show for it! Twelve years with no science! Twelve years with no predictive model! Twelve years with no supporting evidence! Twelve years with no mainstream converts! Pathetic really! Sol88, if you can't convince a mainstream scientist like me that your electric comet has utility and research potential, your model will never grow beyond these forum walls? Seriously! When can we expect a properly peer-reviewed 'electric comet' paper in A&A or MNRAS or ...? What? No cojones? Not a surprize! Best not to expose your electric comet to peer-review! Obviously there is nothing there that is worthy of mainstream's time and attention! Question for you 'ec' expert -- How many people think your 'electric comet' is part of a scam?

And it only gets harder from here!

As I've stated previously, mainstream science cannot be used to describe your electric comet! Why? Your electric comet violates fundamental laws of physics, and ignores decades of observational evidence! Your electric comet is PHYSICALLY IMPOSSIBLE! Unless you and your 'eu/es/ec' buddies develope new physics, your electric comet will only be modelled using myth and magic! That is not science! Again, there is ABSOLUTELY NO MAINSTREAM SCIENCE that can help you model your electric rock! If YOUR electric comet did not violate fundamental laws of physics, then MY mainstream physics would be applicable ... and progress would have been made already!

For decades, there's been no scientific progress on your electric comet because your electric comet is not science! Now, why is that so hard to comprehend?

Sol88! Your electric comet is an abject FAILURE! Where's the scientific evidence mainstream science needs to move this idea forward? Chop! Chop! Let's go!

Do you ever take the time to think about the bigger picture and your lasting legacy? Do you ever take the time to ask yourself the fundamental 'philosophical' questions,

Could everything I believe about the electric comet be wrong?
Could everything I believe about the electric star be wrong?
Could everything I believe about the electric universe be wrong?

The reason I use the word 'believe' is that YOU have shown no sign of 'knowing or understanding' your own electric comet model, or the mainstream physics, chemistry, and observational data that consistently and continuously refutes every aspect of your fantasy!

Would you like to try again? After all, Part IV of your useless, delusional ISF thread should be the charm, right?

AS THE 'electric comet' EXPERT, YOU HAVE PUT ON A PATHETIC SHOW, Sol88! Where's your evidence?

How about we refresh everyone's memory regarding your ongoing failures to address fundamental flaws with YOUR electric comet model ...! Because YOU claim to understand the electric comet, I'll ask all the questions! As the resident 'ec' expert, you must answer all my questions! Fair? This is, after all your 'electric comet' thread! I still don't know why we have to keep reminding you of this fact!

First, my original 20 informational 'Yes/No' questions ...

In your opinion / To your knowledge ...

01) Could any principles or physics of the electric comet be WRONG?
02) Could any principles or physics of the electric star be WRONG?
03) Could any principles or physics of the electric universe be WRONG?
04) Could every principle of the electric universe be WRONG?
05) Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? *1*
06) Does gravity play any part in star formation processes?
07) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics?
08) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes?
09) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occuring in the core?
10) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occuring on the surface?
11) Are asteroids made of rock?
12) Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts?
13) Are comets made of rock?
14) Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts?
15) Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process?
16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? *2*
17) Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)?
18) Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of a current?
19) Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle?
20) Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is?

*1* I believe you have inadvertantly answered this question in the affirmative. Gravity does play a role in orbital mechanics! I wonder if gravity might also be more important than electrostatics/electrodynamics by several orders of magnitude?
*2* Absolutely NOT! NO VIABLE PHYSICAL MECHANISM OR PREDICTIVE MODEL HAS EVER BEEN PROPOSED BY THE 'ec' COMMUNITY TO PROVE THIS CLAIM! The concept is truly laughable! The concept is part of an ongoing series of epic FAILURES!

Do you remember ignoring this fundamental 'ec' modelling requirement?

[size=+2]Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet![/size]

In case it was not obvious, eccentricity has nothing to do with your electric comet!

Restated: The idea that eccentricity is, in any way, responsible for the charging and discharging of electric rocks is obviously WRONG! Thus, Sol88 is WRONG! Wally is WRONG! Donny is WRONG! Shall I go on?

Do you recall the table of 'randomly selected' orbital data required to PREDICT electric comet charging and discharging behaviour? This is but one of a thousand glaring FAILURES on your part! All your spouting about plasma physics is meaningless until you have resolved all the outstanding foundational issues associated with your electric comet! By the way, what are your plasma physics credentials anyway? You have a PhD from where? Sol88, your displayed knowledge and understanding of plasma physics is laughable and 'always' WRONG! Everyone that reads this thread will come to the conclusion that Sol88 is WRONG!

For your 'ec' expert consideration! Please note, this table has been expanded by five records to further illustrate that ECCENTRICITY PLAYS ABSOLUTELY NO ROLE IN THE BEHAVIOUR OF YOUR electric rock!

Object ID | a | e | i | q | Q
Comet 372P/McNaught | 4.496 | 0.1539 | 9.52 | 3.80 | 5.19
Comet 367P/Catalina | 3.511 | 0.2800 | 8.46 | 2.53 | 4.49
Comet 116P/Wild 4 | 3.478 | 0.3725 | 3.61 | 2.19 | 4.78
Asteroid 2001 KD55 | 3.344 | 0.6235 | 9.98 | 1.26 | 5.43
Asteroid 2014 LS26 | 3.364 | 0.6289 | 10.86 | 1.25 | 5.48
Asteroid 2000 DQ110 | 3.361 | 0.6297 | 58.28 | 1.25 | 5.48
Asteroid 2016 RP33 | 3.334 | 0.6343 | 23.04 | 1.22 | 5.45
Asteroid 2014 XN40 | 3.381 | 0.6349 | 14.20 | 1.24 | 5.53
Asteroid 1986 RA | 3.327 | 0.6358 | 19.13 | 1.21 | 5.44
Comet 67P/C-G | 3.463 | 0.6414 | 7.05 | 1.24 | 5.69
Asteroid 2014 HW177 | 3.302 | 0.6437 | 13.00 | 1.18 | 5.43
Asteroid 1995 QN3 | 3.300 | 0.6450 | 14.79 | 1.17 | 5.43
Asteroid 2014 HY196 | 3.526 | 0.6561 | 42.29 | 1.21 | 5.84
Asteroid 2016 WX8 | 3.529 | 0.6572 | 13.29 | 1.21 | 5.85
Asteroid 2016 LA2 | 3.565 | 0.6748 | 17.43 | 1.16 | 5.97
Asteroid 2011 YY28 | 3.388 | 0.6765 | 7.35 | 1.10 | 5.68
Comet 2P/Encke | 2.218 | 0.8471 | 11.76 | 0.33 | 4.11
Comet 1P/Halley | 17.83 | 0.9671 | 162.3 | 0.59 | 35.1

Columns: a = Semi-major axis (AU), e = Eccentricity, i = Inclination, q = Perihelion (AU), Q = Apihelion (AU). All data extracted from the JPL SBDB. Please note, the tabulated data, above, is a trivial subset of a greater whole. Furthermore, two of six cometary bodies are classified as JFC's, three of six are ETC's, and one is an HTC. Can you identify which of the three families the six listed comets belong to, and why? What does your 'ec' model say about comet families? Has the 'ec' community ever discussed comet families?

So, Sol88, what's WRONG with your electric comet? Everyone that reads this will KNOW that eccentricity plays no role in your 'ec' model! That means that you, Sol88, are obviously WRONG! Again!

You know, ... it's OK to admit that you are clueless, Sol88! Unfortunately, religions are NEVER WRONG! Sol88, your 'eu/es/ec' religion appears to have ALL the answers, yet cannot show me, in mathematical terms, how eccentricity is important in electric rock behaviour! SCIENCE FAILURE! And religious success!

Comets are made of volatile ices and dust! The volatile ices sublimate when insolated! FACT!

The data in the above table is sufficient proof that eccentricity is not involved in the charging and discharging of electric rocks! A list of 18 objects --- with eccentricities ranging from 0.1539 to 0.9671! Only six are deemed to be comets! Why? Because comets are made of volatile ices and dust with the ices being sufficiently close to the surface to allow sublimation when insolated! That's a fact!

It's your model, Sol88! You fix it! And forget about plasmas! You have a thousand much more fundamental problems to resolve before we can start talking about your pathetic lack of knowledge and skills when dealing with plasmas! Remember, you still have an unresolved density problem! And I've so many more unanswerable questions just for you!

Remember, Sol88, the internet never forgets ... ANYTHING! In twelve years now, you have FAILED to provide any tangible evidence to support your religious delusion that you try to pass off as science! Truly LAUGHABLE! Sadly PATHETIC! By the way, how are your two kids? As a parent, I do hope you've allowed them to pursue their own religious fantasies and adventures without drawing them into your steaming, 'electric excrement' soaked mess!

Oh! And FYI! MHD is still a valid modelling tool when dealing with specific plasma structures around comets! If you understance vector calculus, we can discuss several ways in which kinetic models can fail around comets!

Sol88! You cannot ignore me! And you cannot win!
 
Sol88! You're really not very good at this 'science' game are you? I fear too much 'eu/es/ec' religion?

Remember, this forum is called the ISF! The key word being Skeptic! Have you ever wondered why you FAIL so miserably to convince others of the validity of your electric BS? And why would this mainstream scientist call it BS? Have you ever wondered? Have you ever thought about how ill-conceived and backwards your model looks to others who actually have scientific credentials? No? Not a thinker? Not a skeptic? A religious zealot, perhaps? Clueless, perhaps?

Do you remember my three 'comet density' posts? Let's remind the internet of your ongoing FAILURES to comprehend and address this issue, shall we?

Comet Density: Part 1/3 Here, I asked you, Sol88, to review the 21/Lutetia data gathered by the RSI team to confirm the physics and methods used for determining mass are sound! Do you have anything to contribute? No? Your silence = FAILURE!

REALITY! There is nothing wrong with the physics, methods, and measured mass for 21/Lutetia!

Comet Density: Part 2/3 In this post, I asked you, Sol88, the resident 'ec' expert, to show how the RSI data has been "fooled" to produce a mass that is 5x smaller than that required of your model! Do you have any evidence of errors to contribute? No? Your silence = FAILURE! On top of FAILURE!

REALITY! There is nothing wrong with the physics, methods, and measured mass for 67P! Radio science experiments (conducted by dozens of spacecraft) are the most reliable, in situ way of determining mass!

And it only gets harder from here!

Comet Density: Part 3/3 Guess what! Laboratory data! Here, I asked you, Sol88, to review the KOSI density results and explain how the experimental evidence could be wrong! Measured density values range from 400 to 600 kg/m3 which is consistent with that measured for the handful of comets encountered to date! Perhaps there is something wrong with YOUR electric dirt clod model? Any thoughts? Counter arguments? No? Have you got the SAFIRE folks working on an "electric comet simulation" as I had proposed earlier? No? Your silence = FAILURE! On top of compounding FAILURE!

As just noted, radio science experiments or investigations are the most reliable way of determining mass! You are the only one making the wild, unsubstantiated claim that something MUST be WRONG! What makes you so damned smart? And what happens to your electric comet, if you're WRONG? Remember, the mainstream science community has decades of evidence to show that comets are made of volatile ices and dust! There is no evidence to support your claim that comets are actually made of rock and that some magical process is responsible for the perceived error in mass ... but then, only at comets!

Your assignment, Sol88 (resident 'ec' expert), is to find and explain the errors in ALL the radio science data collected by literally dozens of spacecraft, and write the paper! Are you up to the challenge? We are talking about millions and millions of data points here! Now, I am perplexed! Why is Sol88 so much smarter than the thousands of mainstream scientists and engineers that build and use these instruments everyday, and yet he cannot provide the specific and appropriate evidence that there is something wrong with 'electromagnetic' radio science experiments!

Remember! It's your model, Sol88! You fix it!

Aside#1! The Radio Science Subsystem (RSS) on Cassini was used to determine and/or refine the following masses and densities ...

Object | Mass (kg) | Density (kg/m3) | e* | i*
Saturn | 5.6851E+26 | 687. | 0.0565 | 2.485
Mimas | 3.7493E+19 | 1148. | 0.0196 | 1.574
Enceladus | 1.08022E+20 | 1609. | 0.0047 | 0.019
Tethys | 6.17449E+20 | 984. | 0.0001 | 1.12
Dione | 1.095452E+21 | 1478. | 0.0022 | 0.019
Rhea | 2.306518E+21 | 1236. | 0.0013 | 0.345
Titan | 1.3452E+23 | 1880. | 0.0288 | 0.349
Iapetus | 1.805635E+21 | 1088. | 0.0286 | 15.47

* Included for completeness! Note, for the seven moons, the eccentricity and inclination are given with respect to Saturn's equator.

Any clue on what this table represents? Any clue on why you can't answer my questions? Any clue why all the densities are consistently less than rock?

Aside #2! The bulk density of 67P was recently revised following the release of a meter-scale shape model! The updated bulk density follows from ...

Mass = 9.982 ± 3 E12 kg
Volume = 18.56 ± 0.02 km3Bulk Density = 537.8 ± 0.7 kg/m3
Now! Will you look at that! Four sig figs! Damn! That's mighty fine! Comets are composed of volatile ices and dust! What we don't know, and can't predict, is the exact proportions of all the ices and dusts! I wonder if the KOSI experiments might point us in the right direction?

Sol88! My plan is to kill the electric comet! Your plan should be to prove its worthy of scientific study! Let's dance! Or you can continue to run and hide and misdirect! Your thread! Your choice! I'm not going away!
 
Last edited:
Can you answer the question?


You are not very intelligent, are you?

How about we refresh everyone's memory regarding your ongoing failures to address fundamental flaws with YOUR electric comet model ...! Because YOU claim to understand the electric comet, I'll ask all the questions! As the resident 'ec' expert, you must answer all my questions! Fair? This is, after all your 'electric comet' thread! I still don't know why we have to keep reminding you of this fact!


This is how you and I are going to play this game! It's your model! You explain it! You want to claim any kind of mainstream support? Convince this mainstream scientist! No problem! Right? NO! Big problem!

Do you remember ignoring this fundamental 'ec' modelling requirement?

[size=+2]Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet![/size]

In case it was not obvious, eccentricity has nothing to do with your electric comet!


If eccentricity plays no role in your electric comet, what other problems might we find?

Sol88! When are you going to get your head out of Thornhill's ass and answer my questions about YOUR 'electric comet' model! It is time for the electric comet to die! It is time for this lie to die!

PROVE to me that your electric comet is not IMPOSSIBLE! Build one in a laboratory! With nothing more than water, dry ice, and some dust swept from under the bed, I can make a simple comet simulant! Thousands of 'students' do that very thing every year! How about you, Sol88! How do YOU build a real, working electric comet simulant? I'll wager real money that no one on this planet could ever recreate an 'electric comet' in the lab! Why? The concept is unscientific! The physical processes required are IMPOSSIBLE!

If you want recognition for this ... electric comet crap, PROVE IT HAS MERIT! PROVE IT to this mainstream scientist!

Stop wasting your time! Twelve years! NOTHING!
 
Every new paper points toward the electric comet!

Quit with the lying, woo boy. Not a single paper has discovered rock or electric discharges. Not a single one. Why do you have to lie so much? Afraid of losing your religion? The electric comet is dead. It was never alive. It is unscientific, puerile woo.
 

Why not just link the paper, so that people can see the answer for themselves? Because of more obfuscation and lying?;

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system
Hsieh, H. H.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5454227/

In addition to sublimation, two of the more common activity generation mechanisms that have been inferred are impact disruption and rotational destabilization. Active asteroids for which comet-like activity is not at least partially attributed to sublimation, and instead appears to be due to impacts, rotation or other disruptive effects, are often referred to as disrupted asteroids [47]. For detailed discussions of these objects, interested readers are referred to recent reviews of MBCs [45,48] and of active asteroids in general [43], though I will highlight key aspects of these objects here.

The work of how many decent, respected, and in some cases, late scientists are you prepared to crap all over with your ignorance, lies, obfuscation and cherry-picking, to try to prop up your idiotic belief system? You ought to be ashamed, but I doubt very much that an evangelical like you has such a care. Go tell it to the idiots at Thunderdolts, you are finished here. Yes?
 
And, following on from above;

Hsieh's paper does nothing to harm mainstream science. On the other hand, it causes enormous problems for the electric idiots. I cannot believe Sol would want us to see this damning paper! Maybe he didn't read it properly. That would be par for the course.
Let's take section (ii) Main-belt comets;

First recognized as a new class of cometary objects in 2006 [44], MBCs have attracted interest because the unexpected present-day ice (given their location in the warm inner solar system) implied by their apparently sublimation-driven activity means that they could potentially be used as compositional probes of inner solar system ice and also as a means of testing hypotheses that icy objects from the main-belt region of the solar system could have played a significant role in the primordial delivery of water to the terrestrial planets.

The first of these MBCs to be discovered was 133P/ Elst-Pizzaro, by Dave Jewitt and Hsieh. Are the electric idiots claiming this activity to be due to electrical woo? In which case we need to look at the orbital parameters of 133P;

Aphelion: 3.67 AU
Perihelion: 2.65 AU
Eccentricity: 0.16

So, can we take that as a minimum e for electric woo to occur? In which case, what about the many thousands of other objects with e = or > 0.16 that do not show any activity?
Talk about shooting oneself in the foot.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7968_Elst–Pizarro
 
Last edited:
So what's your game?

Getting very tired of this stupid game you are playing.
Unless you can provide a real, qualitative and quantitative model of the EC, there is absolutely nothing to discuss.
You will just claim any paper that mentions electric field (no matter what kind) as a confirmation of your double layer obsession and of the necessary enormous electric fields that the EC needs to discharge machine the surface of the comet (without actually being visible in the magnetometer data, now THAT is magic).
 
Usual ROCK insult of Mike A'Hearn who knew that comets are made of ices and dust

Yup, he's the man!...
Usual ROCK insult of Mike A'Hearn who knew that comets are made of ices and dust, not actual rock, as in the cited papers by him. Deep Impact produced ices and dust, not molten rock!
 
Last edited:
A "Rosetta has said ..." supports his electric comet insanity delusion

Do you know what Rosetta said jd116?
A delusion that "Rosetta has said comets are much different than expected" supports his electric comet insanity

Rosetta said that 67P was a comet made of ices and dust formed in the early Solar System.

No insanity of actual rock was found. No insanity of jets being electrical discharges was found. No insanity of EDM was found. No stupidity of double layers. No detection of Birkeland currents.

The video is real world science: Rosetta: the story continues
This short movie shares an impression of some of the scientific highlights from Rosetta's mission at Comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as told through the voices of scientists working with Rosetta's vast dataset, two years after the mission ended.

Sol88's electric comet insanity:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
Insanity of dust removal from the surface changing measured comet density
Electrical discharge machining insanity.
A repeated insane insult of Michael A’Hearn.
 
A deluded lie of "Hydrated ROCK" releasing H20 and inability to comprehend English

Been here 'ol mate ...
A deluded lie of "Hydrated ROCK" releasing H20 and inability to comprehend English in a paper.

A lie of "ROCK" as in actual rock. A "hydrated" rock delusion. A magical release of H2O delusion. Usual stupidity of citing an irrelevant, mainstream paper.

Spontaneous formation of non-spherical water ice grains in a plasma environment is that in some conditions in laboratory experiments, water ice grains in plasma are elongated, not spherical as generally assumed. The only mention of comets is comet tails.
 
A stupid reply to jonesdave116's post to derail rom his electric comet insanity

Are you saying can not happen?
A stupid reply to jonesdave116's post to derail rom his electric comet insanity.

jonesdave116 labels a Sol88 post Complete crap because Sol88 has no rational, physical mechanism to release H20 from a delusion of "hydrated rock". It is up to Sol88 to supply a rational, physical mechanism. His electric comet insanity has irrational things that do whatever he imagines , e.g. invisible electrical discharges.

Sol88 repeats the insane citation of Spontaneous formation of non-spherical water ice grains in a plasma environment which has 1 mention of comet tails.

Sol88's electric comet insanity:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
Insanity of dust removal from the surface changing measured comet density
Electrical discharge machining insanity.
A repeated insane insult of Michael A’Hearn.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom