The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sol88 plays his "irrelevant and stupid question" card

What sign is the field jonesdave116?
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "irrelevant and stupid question" card
It is Sol88's electric comet insanity so it is Soll88 who must answer questions about it. For example: What sign do you think it is, if it is accelerating ions outward, and retarding electrons?
 
Last edited:
Sol88 plays his "lie about science" card

Well, they do “run” together don’t they. :boggled:
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "lie about science" card.
Lukraak_Sisser wrote:
So, the very core of the model you claim to represent, a massive solar electric field, is something you have no clue about as to how it would work.
Nor apparently have given any thought as to how the physics would apply differently in space except where our spacecraft are.
Remember if positive and negative charges were to run in the same direction in an electric field ALL of our electronics would instantly fail.

And your answer is 'gee, plasma must by really funky, rather than, maybe there is no massive magical electric field'

The science is that positive and negative charges cannot run in the same direction in an electric field for the simple reason that F = qE where F is the force, q is the charge and E is the electric field. An electric field gives opposite forces for opposite charges :eye-poppi.
 
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "obviously idiotic and slightly insane question" card
Sol88 is so abysmal ignorant about plasma that he does not know its basic properties. That makes the question slightly insane because proceeding will just get his electric comet insanity, not any actual plasma physics.
  • Plasma conducts so no electric discharges through it.
  • Plasma is quasi neutral and the Debye length gives a limit to the scale of effects.
  • Plasma has ions and electrons with different mobility thus the ambipolar electric field inside plasma.


Dude, we going right back to the start again?

Give me your run down on the field aligned currents (Birkeland currents) in operation at 67P and how that to the above statements.
 
Were you able to add to your list?

If not be champ if you could.

Charge separation, electric fields, Field aligned currents :thumbsup:

If you’d like to round it.

:D

No, you need planetary rock, and you need discharges. You have neither, therefore your model has failed. You need OH instead of H2O, therefore your model fails. You don't need thousands of tonnes of ice to be excavated by an impact. Therefore your model fails. Et cetera. You failed. Get over it.
 
Good, I’m happy with the knowledge you know the DC is caused via ion/electron-neutral collisions and there may only possibly be an ambipolar electric field at at 67P but none at Halley.

Could I hazard a guess and say this would be true, no ambipolar electric field at Tempel 1, Wild 2, Borelly, Hartley 2 and Giacobini–Zinner?

Irrelevant. Plenty of volatiles seen at those comets, and thousands of tonnes of ice excavated at one of them, and shed loads floating around another. Fail. And which of those comets has the most elliptical orbit? Halley. Therefore you fail again. That is a long list of fail, isn't it? Care to address it?
 
And are present in stronger form at asteroids and inactive comets. What does that tell you?

Tells me you are completely ignorant.

THE ROLE OF ELECTRIC FIELDS IN THE COMETARY ENVIRONMENT

Polarization electric fields in the cometary environment are shown to influence both the cometary plasma and the fine cometary dust. In the first part of this paper we will consider the role of the ambipolar electric field on the dynamics and thermodynamics of the cometary ionosphere. In particular, it will be shown that this field would both decelerate and cool the plasma in the outer cometary ionosphere. It is shown that a shock possibly develops in the plasma flow due to this deceleration. In the second part of the paper .'c will consider the consequences of electrostatic charging of the cometary dust. It will be shown that while the consequences are minimal within the cometary ionosphere, they are substantial outside. It will be shown that the convec- tional electric field in the inflowing solar wind (both outside and inside the outer shock), as well as the Coulomb drag of this plasma on the charged dust, will significantly affect the dynamics of the lower end of the dust mass spectrum.

We see it at comets, why don’t we see it at active asteroids?

Oh, wait, never mind we do.

In this review presented at the Royal Society meeting, ‘Cometary science after Rosetta’, I present an overview of studies of small solar system objects that exhibit properties of both asteroids and comets (with a focus on so-called active asteroids). Sometimes referred to as ‘transition objects’, these bodies are perhaps more appropriately described as ‘continuum objects’, to reflect the notion that rather than necessarily representing actual transitional evolutionary states between asteroids and comets, they simply belong to the general population of small solar system bodies that happen to exhibit a continuous range of observational, physical and dynamical properties. Continuum objects are intriguing because they possess many of the properties that make classical comets interesting to study (e.g. relatively primitive compositions, ejection of surface and subsurface material into space where it can be more easily studied, and orbital properties that allow us to sample material from distant parts of the solar system that would otherwise be inaccessible), while allowing us to study regions of the solar system that are not sampled by classical comets.
Asteroid–comet continuum objects inthe solar system

So, what is the difference?

Comets were once thought of as mostly ice, you know, but mainstreams understanding has been evolving toward mostly rock since visiting a few comets over the last couple years.

Moot point anyway as asteroids have more h2o than comets. This was one of the first findings from Rosetta. Rosetta Spacecraft's Comet Water Discovery: What It Means for Earth
 
Last edited:
So, what is the difference?

The difference is that the vast majority of asteroids are not surrounded by a coma. And they have stronger fields. Just as 67P would have had when it was LEAST active. Try to understand that, and stop talking rubbish.
 
evolving toward mostly rock since visiting a few comets over the last couple years.

Nope, no rock ever detected at a comet. Density = ~ 530 kg/m3. What is the density of asteroids?
 
Sol88 plays his "god of the gap/false dichotomy insanity/abysmal ignorance" card

Well at comet 67P we have both ions and negatively charged dust coming from the nucleus.
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "god of the gap/false dichotomy insanity/abysmal ignorance" card.
It is not a surprise to people who can think that the complex, turbulent interaction of the solar wind and comet coma will move charges outward from the nucleus. One "twist" in the magnetic fields pushes positive coma ions outward to be detected by Rosetta. A different "twist" in the magnetic fields pushes negative coma dust particles outward to be detected by Rosetta.
 
Last edited:
Sol88 plays his "lies about science" card and makes it insane as usual

Do we see ions coming from the nucleus, yes.

Do see negatively charged dust coming off the nucleus in jets, yes.
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "lies about science" card and makes it insane as usual.
We see ions in the coma moving outward from the nucleus as expected for ions in a turbulent plasma.
An insane "negatively charged dust coming off the nucleus in jets" lie. We detected beams of negatively charged nanograins in the coma going both inward and outward.
 
Last edited:
Sol88 plays his "insane lies about science and comets" card

Think you’ll find that’s impossible. :D
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "insane lies about science and comets" card
The first insanity is the "dust" lie. What was detected was nano-grains of ice or dust.

The next insanity is that Sol88 has cited a paper stating the processes producing these nano-grains of ice or dust many times :jaw-dropp!
Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
In this paper we review the processes that can explain the energization and the directionality of the observed nano-dust populations.

To prevent an insane rant abut gas-drag- this is the gas in the coma dragging the dust.
 
Sol88 plays his "insane lies about science and comets" card

Sublimation is untenable.
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "insane lies about science and comets" card
Only insanely stupid or ignorant people would deny the massively well tested properties of ices which includes that they sublimate under the appropriate conditions. It is utterly insane to write that it is untenable that ice (H2O), dry ice (CO2), or methane ice (CH4) will not sublimate on comets.
 
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "lies about science" card and makes it insane as usual.
We see ions in the coma moving outward from the nucleus as expected for ions in a turbulent plasma.
An insane "negatively charged dust coming off the nucleus in jets" lie. We detected beams of negatively charged nanograins in the coma going both inward and outward.

Oh, beams :D

Keep going rc, your doing a fantastic job. I think you and jonesdave116 should have a little talk.

Seems to be hung up on some old high school electrostatic explanations of ions only being able to go one way electrons the other.

You know simplistic stuff.

Sounds like you have more of a grasp of the complexities.
 
Last edited:
Sol88 plays his "insane belief in obvious insanity about stars" card

I’d most probably look at the ES model of the Sun...
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "insane belief in obvious insanity about stars" card
Insane if only because Sol88 has been told the Astronomy 101 physics that stars need an internal power source to be stable many times.
SAFIRE insanity in addition to his electric comet insanity.
Insane because Sol88 links to a web site listing obvious delusions from Ralph Juergens from 1972 in a crank newsletter :eye-poppi.
Immanuel Velikovsky was not deluded enough to fall for Juergens' insanity: "He adhered to internal thermo-nuclear fusion as the secret of the Sun’s radiation"
The page ends with a list of criticisms which omits that Juergens turns the Sun into a white dwarf! The other obvious insanity of the electric sun "we would expect the positively charged sun to repel positively charged protons, and attract negatively charged electrons" but both charges travel away from the Sun :eye-poppi!
Tim Thompson (an actual astronomer), “On the ‘Electric Sun’ Hypothesis“ about Donald Scott's Electric Sun insnaity.
The vastly ignorant and deluded about the physics of stars Donald Scott had a "rebuttal" at his web site page (link broken). That was the stupidity of citing an unsupported comment from the insane and documented liar Wal Thornhill.
 
Last edited:
Sol88 plays his "insane lying questions about comets" card

Well how far does the comet tail extend? Does it remain coherent over these distances? if so why?
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "insane lying questions about comets to derail from his electric comet insanity" card
Sol88 has been utterly deluded about comets for at least 12 years now but must know the basic facts about comets such as tail lengths.
Sol88's usual insanity of asking about mainstream cometary science.
 
Sol88 plays his "insane questions about posters knowledge" card

Do you know much about double layers and Birkeland currents? or indeed what there is an ambipolar electric field at 67P?
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults, lies.

Sol88 plays his "insane questions about posters knowledge to derail from his electric comet insanity" card
This is that insanity that we have to know mainstream physics when Sol88's electric comet insanity has not physics in it :jaw-dropp! Insane and ignorant delusions from the Thunderbolts cult and Sol88 are not physics.

This is the insanity of implying other posters are not able to read and understand the many citations of double layers, Birkeland currents and the ambipolar electric field in this thread.
We know that Sol88 has completely fallen for the obvious insanity in his electric comets. Sol88 is totally unable to read or understand the many citations of double layers, Birkeland currents and the ambipolar electric field in this thread. That does not apply to other posters in this thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom