Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
is this supposed to be an answer? and if yes, to what?

i asked if recombination csn ocur, as you, sol, write it seems to happen (apparently in the tail from your quote :
Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
4. this oxygen combines with the solar wind protons to generate water, which is then released as the EC tail that is observed. )

Seems it does recombine!

See post above.
 
@ Tusenfem

Since H.laakso is not a crank, as so kindly pointed out by you, would you be prepared to discuss his paper on Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley?

Standard mainstream non scary stuff
 
@fred

Are you aware of proton implantation into to silica wafers is semiconductor manufacture?

Local vibrational modes of weakly bound O-H complexes in Si. B. Bech Nielsen, K. Tanderup, M. Budde, K. Bonde Nielsen, J. L. Lindström, R. Jones, S. Öberg, B. Hourahine, and P. R. Briddon, in "Defects in Semiconductors 19", edited by G. Davies and M. H. Nazaré, Materials Science Forum Vol. (Trans Tech, Aedermannsdorf, 1998), p. 391.

Same thing happening at a comet

OH is formed in this way to be released as a highly reactive radical, later forming water which also becomes ionised becoming all the water group ions we observe.

And if the energy is high enough nuclear transmutation can occur.

Which just need something to accelerate ions to high energies.....mmmmmmm

And just like that, we are back to double layers and electric fields!
I think, Sol88, that you have missed something here.

And indeed in perhaps all of your posts.

What, I hear you ask?

Numbers, quantities, values, and so on.

Seems to me you and numbers have a rather uneasy relationship, no?

Yeah, you’ve said often enough that you don’t really understand mathematics; but it seems to me you don’t really understand numbers either.

All this stuff about H, OH, water etc ... I don’t seem to recall you ever writing down any numbers, like quantities, rates, etc.
 
I think, Sol88, that you have missed something here.

And indeed in perhaps all of your posts.

What, I hear you ask?

Numbers, quantities, values, and so on.

Seems to me you and numbers have a rather uneasy relationship, no?

Yeah, you’ve said often enough that you don’t really understand mathematics; but it seems to me you don’t really understand numbers either.

All this stuff about H, OH, water etc ... I don’t seem to recall you ever writing down any numbers, like quantities, rates, etc.

Which numbers would you like me to use?

The numbers where you assume radial outgassing from the sublimation of a global surface ice layer to give you Q for your mathmagical formula?

Hasn’t really gone all that well for the mainstream has it?

We could then move onto the frozen in magnetic field ideal MHD maths if you’d like? I’m sure you’ve been following the joust tusenfem and I have been having?

How about we do the “maths” when we agree on comets are not “dirtysnowballs”?

The Rosetta mission was a great success for science as it has proved a 60vodd years of dirtysnowball wrong.

Still very amusing to watch the mainstream pound round pegs into square holes!
 
Last edited:
@jean Tate


I may not understand complex math but a do understand comets are not ‘dirtySnowballs” left over from the formation of the solar system.


From the very first hi res pic of 67P the nucleus looks like rock, solid layered bedrock with no surface ice and in fact no subsurface ice.

SOHO's Unique View of a Comet that Fell to Pieces

Just like EVERY other comet we’ve been able to image!
 
Last edited:
@fred

Are you aware of proton implantation into to silica wafers is semiconductor manufacture?

Local vibrational modes of weakly bound O-H complexes in Si. B. Bech Nielsen, K. Tanderup, M. Budde, K. Bonde Nielsen, J. L. Lindström, R. Jones, S. Öberg, B. Hourahine, and P. R. Briddon, in "Defects in Semiconductors 19", edited by G. Davies and M. H. Nazaré, Materials Science Forum Vol. (Trans Tech, Aedermannsdorf, 1998), p. 391.

Same thing happening at a comet

OH is formed in this way to be released as a highly reactive radical, later forming water which also becomes ionised becoming all the water group ions we observe.

And if the energy is high enough nuclear transmutation can occur.

Which just need something to accelerate ions to high energies.....mmmmmmm

And just like that, we are back to double layers and electric fields!


Sol, my post concerned electrochemistry, specifically the misuse of that term by Anariba. Instead you Gish Galloped, repeating something long ago debunked by people here who actually understand physics and math. Hint: the solar proton flux is insufficient by orders of magnitude to account for the water you admit is observed.

Oh, I’m sorry, do you actually think ion implantation is electrochemistry? Did you drink the Anariba Kool-Aid?
 
@jean Tate


I may not understand complex math but a do understand comets are not ‘dirtySnowballs” left over from the formation of the solar system.


From the very first hi res pic of 67P the nucleus looks like rock, solid layered bedrock with no surface ice and in fact no subsurface ice.

SOHO's Unique View of a Comet that Fell to Pieces

Just like EVERY other comet we’ve been able to image!


Aaaaaand we’ve come full circle, all the way back to looks-like-a-bunny astrophysics. Yippee!!
 
@jean Tate


I may not understand complex math but a do understand comets are not ‘dirtySnowballs” left over from the formation of the solar system.


From the very first hi res pic of 67P the nucleus looks like rock, solid layered bedrock with no surface ice and in fact no subsurface ice.

SOHO's Unique View of a Comet that Fell to Pieces

Just like EVERY other comet we’ve been able to image!

How do you explain the density if it's rock?
 
@ Tusenfem

Since H.laakso is not a crank, as so kindly pointed out by you, would you be prepared to discuss his paper on Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley?

Standard mainstream non scary stuff

that paper has passed by several times, so search for it

and don't forget that laakso talks about ac electric fields
 
Which numbers would you like me to use?

The numbers where you assume radial outgassing from the sublimation of a global surface ice layer to give you Q for your mathmagical formula?

Hasn’t really gone all that well for the mainstream has it?

We could then move onto the frozen in magnetic field ideal MHD maths if you’d like? I’m sure you’ve been following the joust tusenfem and I have been having?

How about we do the “maths” when we agree on comets are not “dirtysnowballs”?

The Rosetta mission was a great success for science as it has proved a 60vodd years of dirtysnowball wrong.

Still very amusing to watch the mainstream pound round pegs into square holes!
Thanks for your prompt response, Sol88.

Which numbers?

How about the rates, of water going away from the comet; of H going in; of OH production wherever?

MHD maths? This thread is replete with posts by you, posts which seem fully consistent with your oft repeated “can’t understand mathemagics”. Unless and until you take that off the table, what’s the point of even considering MHD maths?

Dirty snowballs? Why should we talk about them? Isn’t the central topic of this thread the Electric Comet idea?

Or perhaps we could add logic to mathematics, as something which can be challenging for you? You know, false dichotomy ...
 
@jean Tate


I may not understand complex math but a do understand comets are not ‘dirtySnowballs” left over from the formation of the solar system.
Really?

How do you know what a dirty snowball looks like (whether left over from the formation of the solar system or not)?

And why is that even relevant?

I mean, isn’t this thread about the Electric Comet idea?

From the very first hi res pic of 67P the nucleus looks like rock, solid layered bedrock with no surface ice and in fact no subsurface ice.

SOHO's Unique View of a Comet that Fell to Pieces

Just like EVERY other comet we’ve been able to image!
I seem to recall that we’ve discussed this before ...

Aren’t there a lot of posts on the general topic of how can you tell rock from ice, if all you have is a hi res pic?

Here in Sandy territory there’s been a few snowfalls lately, with some of the snow sublimating and some melting. The snowplows have been through a couple of times, and the nights have all been below zero (as have a couple of days). There’s some cool-looking grunge on the kerb, a mixture of frozen water, stones, dust, and the odd leaf. What snow there is is certainly dirty. The mess is, at night, certainly solid. There is certainly ice. While there aren’t that many - the winter is still young - there certainly are some layers. Apart from the leaves, how could you tell this grunge isn’t a comet’s surface, if I were to take a hi res pic of it?
 
1. How exactly does the EC nucleus get charged? just like EVERYTHING ELSE immersed in flowing plasma.

So it is now the EC claim that their charging of the nucleolus is just the expected reaching of local equilibrium and not that the comet carries some overall charge with respect to the sun?


You are a plasma physicist are you not, Tusenfem? That's a pretty basic even for this mug!

Do the plasma parameters change of the course of it's orbit?

Overall charge neutrality doesn't change.


2. What makes that on the charged surface EDM can take place?


Nothing.

(aparently it is not in balance with its surroundings, the one fact that seems to be charging the nucleus).

Quite the contrary reaching a state of equilibrium "with its surroundings" is by definition "in balance with its surroundings".


Very strong local surface 'lectric fields. As observed the surface of a comet. the rock is charged along with the dust, which funnily enough happens from the same electric fields breaking the rock at the molecular level.

Nope, you will note photo-ionization in just your own citation above. That is not charging as a result of ''lectric fields'". One of the reasons I didn't consider ion and electron gas attraction in my previous post is that can even help keep materials bond together. Metals are often modeled as a positive ion lattice infused with an electron gas. The attraction between the ion lattices and the gas is thought to give metals part of their structural stability.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_electron_model

So the mere presence of free electrons doesn't infer "breaking" anything "at the molecular level".

3. this EDM works out the oxygen from the minerals which build the EC. your onto it, long with all the other "stuff" seen in the coma. There is stuff going on in there that no mathmagical formula is going to 'splian.

What EDM? Again two rocks on the ground can have a potential difference, even one as a result of photo-ionization or some local free electrons without any "EDM".

4. this oxygen combines with the solar wind protons to generate water, which is then released as the EC tail that is observed. https://www.thunderbolts.info/wp/2016/01/06/evidence-of-electrical-activity-on-comet-67p-towards-an-electrochemical-framework-for-cometary-phenomena/

So ELECTRIC FIELDS are very important for the ELECTRIC COMET. No electric fields no electric comet!

However, the mere presence of electric fields still can't imbue EC with any importance nor relevance. Given your own stated importance of electric fields for EC that too makes the projected values of such fields just as important to EC


Simple stupid, is it.! :p

Indeed without any expected values for EC to apply, it remains simply and apparently deliberately stupid.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your prompt response, Sol88.

Which numbers?

How about the rates, of water going away from the comet; of H going in; of OH production wherever?

MHD maths? This thread is replete with posts by you, posts which seem fully consistent with your oft repeated “can’t understand mathemagics”. Unless and until you take that off the table, what’s the point of even considering MHD maths?

Dirty snowballs? Why should we talk about them? Isn’t the central topic of this thread the Electric Comet idea?

Or perhaps we could add logic to mathematics, as something which can be challenging for you? You know, false dichotomy ...

I’ll try and make it simple for you, I hope you understand.

There is change separation, double layers and electric fields!

Do you understand?
 
Jeantate said:
Thanks for your prompt response, Sol88.

Which numbers?

How about the rates, of water going away from the comet; of H going in; of OH production wherever?

MHD maths? This thread is replete with posts by you, posts which seem fully consistent with your oft repeated “can’t understand mathemagics”. Unless and until you take that off the table, what’s the point of even considering MHD maths?

Dirty snowballs? Why should we talk about them? Isn’t the central topic of this thread the Electric Comet idea?

Or perhaps we could add logic to mathematics, as something which can be challenging for you? You know, false dichotomy ...
I’ll try and make it simple for you, I hope you understand.

There is change separation, double layers and electric fields!

Do you understand?
Sorry, no, I do not understand.

How is "There is change separation, double layers and electric fields!" an answer to my question "How about the rates, of water going away from the comet; of H going in; of OH production wherever?"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom