Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
9.1 Diamagnetic cavity Only the Giotto spacecraft [Reinhard, 1986], with its closest approach (CA) to the nucleus, observed the diamagnetic cavity around comet 1P/Halley. The observations by the Giotto magnetometer [Neubauer et al., 1986] clearly showed a field-free region around CA. The duration of this signature was . 124:5 s which corresponded to a physical width of . 8513 km. Fig. 5BB shows the transition of Giotto into the diamagnetic cavity, where over a very sharp boundary (C) the magnetic field strength decreases from . 20 nT to almost zero. From the behaviour of the magnetic field components it was deduced that there are not only currents perpendicular to the magnetic field (taking care of the shielding of the cavity) but there are also strong field-aligned currents in alternating directions.

There is no such thing as charge separation, no charge separation, no charge separation.

which is below the theoretical estimates for the sum of these two quantities, and a possible extra source of mass-loading through energetic electrons may have to be invoked [see e.g. recent Rosetta discoveries by, Feldman et al., 2015, for extra ionization through photodissociation electrons].

Nothing electrical, no charge separation, no charge separation.

During a short interval before CA, 0711 - 0724 UT, the magnetic field draping direction was opposite to that observed over the main part of the cometosheath. Verigin et al. [1987] show a model, see also Fig. 6AA, in which they show the topology of the magnetic field along the orbit of VEGA 1 and infer a reconnection site located before CA, which accelerates the ions to the observed energies. In a later paper, Kirsch et al. [1989] discussed observations from Giotto, where they state that the nested draping, i.e. the fast 180. rotations of the field direction, are gconsidered as an indication of the field line merging process in the front side of Halleyfs cometosheath.h A further study of the ions showed that during the magnetic field rotations there is a peak in the high-energy ions, coinciding with a drop in the low-energy ions. The pitch angle of the highenergy ions is shown to be near zero degrees, i.e. field aligned. However, Kirsch et al. [1989] estimated the energization of the ions through reconnection and found that the maximum energy would be Ei . 22 keV assuming acceleration of the ion over a length of 50000 km, well below the observed energies of 97 - 145 keV (see Fig. 6BB). These are indirect indications that magnetic reconnection could be taking place in the current sheets generated by nested draping. .

No charge separation no charge separation

In Fig. 9BB an example of such a structure is shown in minimum variance coordinates [Sonnerup and Scheible, 1998], which has the classical characteristics of a flux rope, which means that there is a strong current flowing along the centre of the tube.

This means that the induced magnetosphere around a comet consists of a complex geometry
of magnetic fields, as if a large amount of different kinds of curtains have been draped
around the nucleus. One of the consequences of these rotations of the magnetic field is that
there will be current sheets generated in the coma


All from the Super Duper Plasma Physicist paper Currents in Cometary Comae

If you say often enough is almost becomes reality! There is no charge separation...say's

tumblr_mu3amheHyz1suvtkio1_400.gif


there is no charge separation
 
Last edited:
The current system associated with the boundary of plasma bubbles

Abstract

The current system associated with the boundary of plasma bubbles in the Earth's magnetotail has been studied by employing Cluster multipoint observations. We have investigated the currents in both the dipolarization front (DF, leading edge of the plasma bubble) and the trailing edge of the plasma bubble. The distribution of currents at the edge indicates that there is a current circuit in the boundary of a plasma bubble. The field-aligned currents in the trailing edge of the plasma bubble are flowing toward the ionosphere (downward) on the dawnside and away from the ionosphere (upward) on the duskside, in the same sense as region-1 current. Together with previous studies of the current distributions in the DF and magnetic dip region, we have obtained a more complete picture of the current system surrounding the boundary of plasma bubble. This current system is very similar to the substorm current wedge predicted by MHD simulation models but with much smaller scale.

No charge separation No charge separation. No charge separation.

10.4 Solar wind impact The solar wind is variable, not only the magnetic field direction (responsible for nested draping), but magnetic explosions on the surface of the Sun regularly send coronal mass ejections (CMEs) into interplanetary space. These are fast, high-density, magnetic flux ropes [see e.g., M¨ostl et al., 2014] which can interact with the planets, creating e.g. strong disturbances in the Earth’s magnetosphere [see e.g., Zhang et al., 2007]. But they will also interact with comets and lead to interesting phenomena
Currents in Cometary Comae
 
Last edited:
nicecherry picking quote mining, sol

if you actually would read my papers you would see that i give a reason why there is no magnetic reconnection
the flux tube seen by edberg is from solar wind origin if i am not mistaken

now start answering questions please, explain your model above fully for us dumb ms peeps

i am off for the long weekend

Yeah, sorry, it was your paper.

Anywho safe travels cob.

Plasma will never be understood but it will be accepted. :blush:

For the maths purest, it’s dam hard when you get the maths absolutely bang on,....then the plasma does something leftfield, leaving the maths butt naked.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, sorry, it was your paper.

Anywho safe travels cob.

Plasma will never be understood but it will be accepted. :blush:

For the maths purest, it’s dam hard when you get the maths absolutely bang on,....then the plasma does something leftfield, leaving the maths butt naked.

All a total irrelevance. What it is not doing is causing EDM (lol) on the surface to a bunch of non-rock. Doesn't matter how you cut it - the electric comet is a total failure.

ETA:
The sheer hypocrisy of a believer in failed unscientific woo, quoting mainstream papers, should not escape anyone's attention. Particularly when the phenomena mentioned were, more often than not, predicted before they were discovered in-situ, based on (mathematical) modelling!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Idiotic and irrelevant post to derail from his comet delusions

Currents in Cometary Comae
8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiotic and irrelevant post to derail from his comet delusions.
Idiocy of just a paper title yet again.
Idiotic expectation that people who know his over 8 years od denial of basic physics and math will answer his irrelevant questions .
The stupidity that having the word magnetic in common means magnetic flux rope is "a bit like" magnetic reconnection.
The irrelevant stupidity of "but as long as it make your maths easer". Many assumptions make the math possible, not just easier.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Lies about tusenfem with "no such thing as charge separation" idiocy

There ....
8 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about tusenfem's paper with "no such thing as charge separation" idiocy.
The paper does not contain charge separation because charge separation is irrelevant to its subject. Charge separation is standard plasma physics, i.e. double layers!
8 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about tusenfem's paper with "Nothing electrical" idiocy.
8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy about what he quotes and highlights (field-aligned currents is not charge separation - :eek:!).
8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy about what he quotes and highlights (energetic electrons is not charge separation - :eek:!).
8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy about what he quotes and highlights (magnetic reconnection is not charge separation - :eek:!).
 
Last edited:
^^^^^ The thing is, RC, we will never get an answer to the obvious questions; as in - where was the electric woo? Where was the EDM (lol)? Where was the rock? All we will get is a Gish-gallop to cover over the fact that the electric comet woo has been shown to be (predictably) BS. Sol will never address the fact that his woo has been shown to be....well....woo!
The electric comet woo is dead. It was never alive. It is only believed in by idiots with a sub-human IQ. It is a waste of space. Only a loon would believe in such idiocy. I could go on - however, I think you get my point.
 
just a quick note
current (parallel or perpendicular) in space plasmas are induced by changes in the magnetic field (ampere's law)
currents have nothing to do with charge separation
 
just a quick note
current (parallel or perpendicular) in space plasmas are induced by changes in the magnetic field (ampere's law)
currents have nothing to do with charge separation


Ummmm....yeah righto!
 
Imagine How big are those currents when galactic size magnetic fields are involved.

But in this instance the magnetic field at a comet is induced and far as I can read the solar wind is being charge separated with all the ensuing complex plasma phenomena.

Just wait till you have to model in the charged dust component to get things real complex...for the maths.
 
just a quick note
current (parallel or perpendicular) in space plasmas are induced by changes in the magnetic field (ampere's law)
currents have nothing to do with charge separation

Am I misunderstanding you here tusenfem?

The current within this plasma is still quasi neutral?

My understanding of currents in space plasmas take on a nested concentric cylinders of opposite charge separated by sheath walls?

Makes more sense than
current (parallel or perpendicular) in space plasmas are induced by changes in the magnetic field (ampere's law)
currents have nothing to do with charge separation

How much current flowing between Io and Jupiter, tusenfem? Jd116?
 
It’s all related, jd116!

Somewhere back at the very start of this thread we were arguing over if said plasma physics actually operated like it now, Obviously is. Debye length, quasi neutrality and general dummy spitting were used to obstruct science on the bleed’n obvious electrical nature of well everything!

I think we will have a bit more to talk about once we can read tusenfem paper.

I also find it amusing from the various tweets on the Rosetta mission, when plasma is talked about most other disciplines roll there eyes and duck out for a hot cupa!
 
It’s all related, jd116!

Somewhere back at the very start of this thread we were arguing over if said plasma physics actually operated like it now, Obviously is. Debye length, quasi neutrality and general dummy spitting were used to obstruct science on the bleed’n obvious electrical nature of well everything!

I think we will have a bit more to talk about once we can read tusenfem paper.

I also find it amusing from the various tweets on the Rosetta mission, when plasma is talked about most other disciplines roll there eyes and duck out for a hot cupa!

Insofar as I understood the previous???? We had a spacecraft around a comet for 2+ years. None of this electric woo happened. Did it? Please explain why anybody needs to take this crap seriously? We don't. It is woo. It is dead. Stop polluting this site with idiotic, unscientific, debunked woo.
 
Insofar as I understood the previous???? We had a spacecraft around a comet for 2+ years. None of this electric woo happened. Did it? Please explain why anybody needs to take this crap seriously? We don't. It is woo. It is dead. Stop polluting this site with idiotic, unscientific, debunked woo.

I think you’ll find you are mistaken there, jd116.
 
just a quick note
current (parallel or perpendicular) in space plasmas are induced by changes in the magnetic field (ampere's law)
currents have nothing to do with charge separation

And that’s it nothing to see here, move along. :rolleyes: typical

Abstract:
As the rate of energy release in a double layer with voltage ΔV is P ≈ IΔV, a double layer must be treated as a part of a circuit which delivers the current I. As neither double layer nor circuit can be derived from magnetofluid models of a plasma, such models are useless for treating energy transfer by means of double layers. They must be replaced by particle models and circuit theory. A simple circuit is suggested which is applied to the energizing of auroral particles, to solar flares, and to intergalactic double radio sources. Application to the heliospheric current systems leads to the prediction of two double layers on the sun's axis which may give radiations detectable from Earth. Double layers in space should be classified as a new type of celestial object (one example is the double radio sources). It is tentatively suggested that X-ray and γ-ray bursts may be due to exploding double layers (although annihilation is an alternative energy source). A study of how a number of the most used textbooks in astrophysics treat important concepts such as double layers, critical velocity, pinch effects, and circuits is made. It is found that students using these textbooks remain essentially ignorant of even the existence of these concepts, despite the fact that some of them have been well known for half a century (e.g., double layers, Langmuir, 1929; pinch effect, Bennet, 1934).
Double Layers and Circuits in Astrophysics

I’m sure Alfven would be interested in the data obtained from all the latest missions e.g. Jupiter, Saturn, Venus, Mars, Pluto, Mercury, Ceres, various asretoids and comets.

But

In this case, comet 67P, its electrical environment is only JUST becoming clear! As said by a former student of Alfven’s.

:D
 
Last edited:
Imagine How big are those currents when galactic size magnetic fields are involved.

Those incredibly weak galactic magnetic fields, that do what exactly?

But in this instance the magnetic field at a comet is induced and far as I can read the solar wind is being charge separated with all the ensuing complex plasma phenomena.

No magnetic field is "induced" at all!
Around the comet there is an induced magnetosphere like around Venus and Mars. Get your facts straight.

Just wait till you have to model in the charged dust component to get things real complex...for the maths.

whatever you say, solly
 
Am I misunderstanding you here tusenfem?

The current within this plasma is still quasi neutral?

It is hard to know what exactly you misunderstand, it is so much.

Is there any reason why currents and quasi-neutrality cannot occur at the same time?

My understanding of currents in space plasmas take on a nested concentric cylinders of opposite charge separated by sheath walls?

Well, I guess your understanding is flawed to say the least.


Makes more sense than

current (parallel or perpendicular) in space plasmas are induced by changes in the magnetic field (ampere's law) currents have nothing to do with charge separation

How much current flowing between Io and Jupiter, tusenfem? Jd116?

Well I guess you are going to explain why that makes more sense.

You can google how much current is flowing, which has nothing to do with charge separation and all about inductive currents (in a simplified way like Alfvén's unipolar inductor)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom