Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Its fascinating to see how Sol88 keeps harping on on (totally misunderstood) forces that play an insignificant part in comets, yet keeps ignoring the fact that if those forces were as significant as the EU / EC fantasy world claims, not a single spacecraft would have made it to orbit around earth, let alone to any comet.

In pathological science, scientists manage to fool themselves
“Symptoms of Pathological Science:

1. The maximum effect that is observed is produced by a
causitive agent of barely detectable intensity

2. The effect is of a magnitude that remains close to the limit
of detectability
3. Claims of great accuracy
4. Fantastic theories contrary to experience
5. Criticisms are met by ad hoc excuses thought up on the
spur of the moment
6. Ratio of supporters to critics rises up to somewhere near
50% and then falls gradually to oblivion”

“THE SCIENCE OF THINGS THAT AREN’T SO”
(I. Langmuir, “Pathological Science,” Colloquium at The Oak Knolls Research
Laboratory, December 18, 1953; Physics Today 42, 36, October
1989, transcribed and edited by R.N. Hall)

Solar insolation springs to mind!

Just look at what's happening down the tail all from solar insolation!! the origin of your gas form your hidden ice :eye-poppi

So yeah, your statement "not a single spacecraft would have made it to orbit around earth, let alone to any comet" I hope was done in all seriousness. Seems like you've got a firm grasp on it!.

Spacecraft Charging, shall we talk about this phenomena in relation to your above assertion!
Description

In space, satellites and spacecraft materials are vulnerable. They can become charged to tens or even thousands of volts when plasmas in the space environment interact with a spacecraft.

Spacecraft Charging explains this phenomenon while exploring the effects that energetic plasma has on the space environment and the objects within it. High-voltage charging by energetic electrons and ions can negatively impact the scientific measurements onboard and threaten delicate instruments such as the telemetry and navigation systems.

This guide provides an overview of the what, when, where, how, and why spacecraft charging occurs. Gaining international momentum, spacecraft charging and mitigation is an emerging field within the aerospace industry—this book will meet the needs of this growing field and serve as the premiere volume covering many key aspects of spacecraft charging.

CONCEPTS DISCUSSED include properties of spacecraft charging and the underlying physical mechanisms; causes of energetic plasmas; how to protect spacecraft entering the harsh space environment; adverse effects of electrostatic discharges on spacecraft; spacecraft charging in auroral region; and deep dielectric charging by energetic electrons as causes of satellite anomalies and failures. . Spacecraft charging in auroral region
:eusa_whistle:

Hope your suitability fascinated! :)

Were you expecting a big bolt of lightning or something??
 
Last edited:
Spacecraft charging has many effects, the most
dangerous of which is perhaps electrostatic discharges which can have catastrophic
consequences such as structural damage, degradation of spacecraft components and
operational anomalies caused by damages to electronics
Spacecraft Charging and Hazards to Electronics in Space

Imagine the comet as the spacecraft and you'd be getting pretty bloody close to the electric comet!
 
Circuit diagrams "show" or paint pictures of electric circuits. Mathematics relay the relationships between quantitative values. The former is inherently less dynamic, showing generally fixed relations of predominantly stable components. Hence the lack of need for explicit and varying dynamic relations being laid out in the symbology. The later, mathematics, is more versatile and better suited to representing dynamic systems, even catastrophic and chaotic system.

Heck, given that just free space has electromagnetic properties, just to draw a circuit diagram of empty space you would have to draw little capacitors and inductors going every which way possible and it would just end up a big black splotch on the paper. So best to represent those characteristic as values with mathematical relationships.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_permittivity

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_permeability

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impedance_of_free_space


If it is just mainstream graphical representations of the dynamics of comets like 67p you are interested in, I'm sure they are easy to find.



https://www.google.com/search?q=gra...sAQIMA&biw=1280&bih=893#imgrc=8VUJL3QgOIm10M:


You can do the maths since you're The Man?
Would you consider helping me in finding out the charge on a comet?

I think we need to include the Poisson's equation, Boltzmann's constant, electron
temperature (in Kelvin), electron charge and ambient plasma density.

Like I said mathamagics, not my forte. Show me the data you need to complete the equations and we are underway!
 
Last edited:
current carrying double layers, nested concentric field aligned currents (Birkeland Currents) cannot exists along with "frozen in field lines", "Draped Magnetic Fields" and "Magnetic Reconnection".

H.Alfven says no, what do you say Tusenfem?

I doubt Hannes Alfvén said that, the combination of the words is at random, just some terms that you happen to know. And the combination does not even make any sense at all!

Yes, I know the talk by Alfvén, where he complains about two things.

First the idea about the "frozen in field" (and by the way we have been through this stuff already at least twice, I should keep a list of explanatory posts that I make).

As Alfvén introduced his Nobel prize winning theory on Magneto Hydro Dynamics (MHD), one of the consequences of his theory that, under the assumptions of MHD the magnetic field is "frozen in" in the plasma flow (actually the proof is very simple). Now you know how it is with new techniques, give a guy a hammer and he thinks everything is a nail. So too, with "frozen in". Everybody just took that tool not caring about the fact that it only holds under the assumptions of MHD (and I assume you know what those are, as you are the Alfvén expert.

Whether the field is "frozen in" is actually easily calculated from spacecraft data, by comparing the measured electric field in the magnetoplasma and calculated convective (motional) electric field E = vplasmaxB. Interestingly, it is not so easy, e.g. in the Earth's magnetosphere to find the breaking of the frozen in condition, as described by Tony Lui.

So, as long as we do not forget what the assumptions of MHD are, we can use the frozen in field.

Now, I have no idea why Alfvén would be against "draped magnetic fields" as one of his signature papers is On the theory of cometary tails in which he explains, using his own Nobel prize winning theory, how cometary tails are created, by mass loading of the field lines, which slow down in front of the comet, whereas the part of the field line far away from the pick-up region continues to travel as the solar wind speed. Thus creating a draping of the field around the active cometary nucleus.

What was not taken into account in Alfvén's paper was that the magnetic field of the solar wind is not stable, and thus, the nice picture he has in his paper, with "H" only in one direction does not hold, and therefore I changed the figure to a bit more realistic version here. This leads to the observed "nested draping", i.e. regions of differently (oppositely) directed magnetic field draped around the cometary nucleus. This is clearly observed by VEGA and Giotto at comet 1P/Halley and with Rosetta at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko.

Second: Magnetic Merging as it was called at the time, magnetic reconnection as it is called now. Indeed, Alfvén was a staunch opposition of MRx, and believed that "exploding double layers" was the solution. This was based on the "explosions" that occur in large rectifiers, when the current is disrupted when they are switched off. This leads to great discharges between the two poles.

The theory of MRx was in its childhood years, when Aflvén discussed this, without any real observations of the process. Now we have had Cluster and MMS, specifically designed to study this process in the Earth's magnetosphere on different scales. And lo-and-behold, we see in the data exactly what is supposed to be seen for MRx in the magnetic and electric fields and the plasma. There is no evidence of Alfvén's "exploding double layer". He was a great scientist, but in this case he has been proven to be wrong.

Now let's return to the "sentence" you wrote:

current carrying double layers, nested concentric field aligned currents (Birkeland Currents) cannot exists along with "frozen in field lines", "Draped Magnetic Fields" and "Magnetic Reconnection"

Now, I would love to see where Alfvén is claiming this. And I have no idea what "nested concentric field aligned currents" are supposed to be, but definitely not "Birkeland currents".

Current carrying double layers exist in a current carrying plasma, usually along the magnetic field. If the current happens to go through a region of lesser density, such that the thermal velocity of the particles and their density is not enough to maintain the current, then a double layer is created by the plasma. This happens above the auroral acceleration region.

But what exactly "CCDLs" and "FACs" have to do with nested draping and frozen in and MRx is something I don't understand.

I think I will stop here.
 
You can do the maths since you're The Man?
Would you consider helping me in finding out the charge on a comet?

I think we need to include the Poisson's equation, Boltzmann's constant, electron
temperature (in Kelvin), electron charge and ambient plasma density.

Like I said mathamagics, not my forte. Show me the data you need to complete the equations and we are underway!


What, there’s no one in the EC camp who can do math? What about Scott? He has a EE degree, can’t he do the math for you? Or are you just trying to roll up your score?

10 points for each statement along the lines of "I'm not good at math, but my theory is conceptually right, so all I need is for someone to express it in terms of equations"
 
Spacecraft Charging and Hazards to Electronics in Space

Imagine the comet as the spacecraft and you'd be getting pretty bloody close to the electric comet!

Errrr, no, you wouldn't. Spacecraft charging has been known about for yonks. Rosetta picked up a maximum negative charge of ~ -20V. Wow. What are you expecting that to do? It certainly isn't going to create EDM (lol), or electric discharges (which would have been seen) is it? I've told you before; this is dead. Forget it.
 
Its fascinating to see how Sol88 keeps harping on on (totally misunderstood) forces that play an insignificant part in comets, yet keeps ignoring the fact that if those forces were as significant as the EU / EC fantasy world claims, not a single spacecraft would have made it to orbit around earth, let alone to any comet.
But to understand why requires things like addition, division, differentiation, etc.

Which are skills/capabilities that almost, or no, EU/EC Fan has demonstrated. Ever.

Instead, all we ever get is word salad, which has no nutritional, or indeed scientific, value. :p
 
Just look at what's happening down the tail all from solar insolation!! the origin of your gas form your hidden ice

And off we go again. How many times do we have to point out that the ice is OBSERVED?
What is hidden is all the electric woo that we were promised. You know, EDM (lol) burning the surface black. Electric discharges causing the jets. Rock. Where was it? Sol seems to have missed the point that this is the 'electric comet' thread, and so far there hasn't been the teeniest bit of evidence for it, and a mountain against it. It has been a total failure.
 
You can do the maths since you're The Man?
Would you consider helping me in finding out the charge on a comet?

Shouldn't Thornhill have done this? And why bother? Philae landed on the damned thing, and nothing happened to it. It also measured zero magnetic field. Rosetta also 'landed' on it, and a number of instruments, including the RPC ones, were turned on all the way down. Not heard of anything indicating any sort of electric charge on the comet.
 
I doubt Hannes Alfvén said that, the combination of the words is at random, just some terms that you happen to know. And the combination does not even make any sense at all!

Yes, I know the talk by Alfvén, where he complains about two things.

First the idea about the "frozen in field" (and by the way we have been through this stuff already at least twice, I should keep a list of explanatory posts that I make).

As Alfvén introduced his Nobel prize winning theory on Magneto Hydro Dynamics (MHD), one of the consequences of his theory that, under the assumptions of MHD the magnetic field is "frozen in" in the plasma flow (actually the proof is very simple). Now you know how it is with new techniques, give a guy a hammer and he thinks everything is a nail. So too, with "frozen in". Everybody just took that tool not caring about the fact that it only holds under the assumptions of MHD (and I assume you know what those are, as you are the Alfvén expert.

Whether the field is "frozen in" is actually easily calculated from spacecraft data, by comparing the measured electric field in the magnetoplasma and calculated convective (motional) electric field E = vplasmaxB. Interestingly, it is not so easy, e.g. in the Earth's magnetosphere to find the breaking of the frozen in condition, as described by Tony Lui.

So, as long as we do not forget what the assumptions of MHD are, we can use the frozen in field.

Now, I have no idea why Alfvén would be against "draped magnetic fields" as one of his signature papers is On the theory of cometary tails in which he explains, using his own Nobel prize winning theory, how cometary tails are created, by mass loading of the field lines, which slow down in front of the comet, whereas the part of the field line far away from the pick-up region continues to travel as the solar wind speed. Thus creating a draping of the field around the active cometary nucleus.

What was not taken into account in Alfvén's paper was that the magnetic field of the solar wind is not stable, and thus, the nice picture he has in his paper, with "H" only in one direction does not hold, and therefore I changed the figure to a bit more realistic version here. This leads to the observed "nested draping", i.e. regions of differently (oppositely) directed magnetic field draped around the cometary nucleus. This is clearly observed by VEGA and Giotto at comet 1P/Halley and with Rosetta at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko.

Second: Magnetic Merging as it was called at the time, magnetic reconnection as it is called now. Indeed, Alfvén was a staunch opposition of MRx, and believed that "exploding double layers" was the solution. This was based on the "explosions" that occur in large rectifiers, when the current is disrupted when they are switched off. This leads to great discharges between the two poles.

The theory of MRx was in its childhood years, when Aflvén discussed this, without any real observations of the process. Now we have had Cluster and MMS, specifically designed to study this process in the Earth's magnetosphere on different scales. And lo-and-behold, we see in the data exactly what is supposed to be seen for MRx in the magnetic and electric fields and the plasma. There is no evidence of Alfvén's "exploding double layer". He was a great scientist, but in this case he has been proven to be wrong.

Now let's return to the "sentence" you wrote:



Now, I would love to see where Alfvén is claiming this. And I have no idea what "nested concentric field aligned currents" are supposed to be, but definitely not "Birkeland currents".

Current carrying double layers exist in a current carrying plasma, usually along the magnetic field. If the current happens to go through a region of lesser density, such that the thermal velocity of the particles and their density is not enough to maintain the current, then a double layer is created by the plasma. This happens above the auroral acceleration region.

But what exactly "CCDLs" and "FACs" have to do with nested draping and frozen in and MRx is something I don't understand.

I think I will stop here.

You are saying, you are unsure or truly do not understand?

The point is CCDLs and FACs have nothing do with nested draping, frozen in magnetic fields and Magnetic reconnection! :cool:

If CCDLs and NESTED FIELD ALIGEND CURENTS and all there UNIQUE properties are around in the tail region, as they MUST be if

H. Madanian1
, T. E. Cravens1
, J. Burch2
, R. Goldstein2
, M. Rubin3
C. Goetz5
, C. Koenders5
, and K. Altwegg3


And

Jan Deca,1,2,* Andrey Divin,3,4 Pierre Henri,5 Anders Eriksson,4 Stefano Markidis,6 Vyacheslav Olshevsky,7 and Mihály Horányi1,2

Along with

HARRI LAAKSO
To Have any leg to stand on, then the detection of these entities validates Alfvens little sook, no?

MRx in the magnetic and electric fields and the plasma....ahhhh! Makes more sense, electric fields and the charge carriers!

Sweet :)

Clears a fair bit up, cheers cob!
 
Last edited:
Another point that Sol seems to be having trouble with is this: we have now flown through the tail of a comet twice, and the things he wants to see haven't been seen. So what is the point of talking about stuff that isn't there? All seems a bit irrelevant to me.
 
Another point that Sol seems to be having trouble with is this: we have now flown through the tail of a comet twice, and the things he wants to see haven't been seen. So what is the point of talking about stuff that isn't there? All seems a bit irrelevant to me.

It is very reminiscent of fundamentalism
 
Sol88: Ignorant electrostatic, etc delusions

Sufficient electrostatic forces ...
30 November 2017 Sol88: Ignorant electrostatic, etc. delusions from a person ignorant of math, physics and English.

30 November 2017 Sol88: An irrelevant lie that magnetic reconnection is dead.

30 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that Hannes Alfven stated that the frozen in magnetic field approximation was wrong.
Alfvén's theorem is that "in a fluid with infinite electric conductivity, magnetic field lines are frozen into the fluid and have to move along with it."
In most astrophysical environments, as well as laboratory plasmas, the electric conductivity is not infinite, so the magnetic field lines are not ideally frozen into the fluid. However, with a high electric conductivity, or equivalently a small resistivity, the frozen in theorem can be approximately applied. This is called the frozen flux approximation which is widely used in dynamo theory.
Hannes Alfven stated in 1986 in a workshop about double layers that his opinion was that the frozen in magnetic field approximation was overused, i.e. where the approximation was not appropriate. Plasma physicists already knew that the approximation could be misused and were already working on treating fluids with finite electric conductivity. That was back in 1986. That is 31 years ago!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Ignorant statement and question to derail from his comet delusions

@Tusenfem Your the PLASMA expert here, is this a fair call?
30 November 2017 Sol88: Ignorant statement and question to derail from his comet delusions.
"nested concentric field aligned currents" are not Birkeland currents.
The stupidity of "Magnetic Reconnection" when magnetic reconnection is an standard plasma physics observed all of the time and done all of the time in labs.
Magnetic reconnection is a physical process in highly conducting plasmas in which the magnetic topology is rearranged and magnetic energy is converted to kinetic energy, thermal energy, and particle acceleration.
The Wikipedia article is about MR in plasma and skips the simpler examples of MR in vacuum and air. These are both real physical, trivial processes.

We have a magnetic reconnection thread containing another Thunderbolts cult member absolutely denying even physics textbooks. This is the 'Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)' thread where I quote Somov's textbook section on MR in vacuum. He could not even understand that there were 2 sections with the titles:
  • 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum
  • 4.4.3 Reconnection in plasma
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II has most of the text of 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum.

30 November 2017 Sol88: A "H.Alfven says no" lie since Hannes Alfven did not state that double layers "cannot exists" along with magnetic reconnection.
Hannes Alfven knew the basic fact that double layers and magnetic reconnection are 2 different physical processes. They can happen together. I recall one experiment measuring magnetic reconnection and detecting that double layers formed after the reconnection.

Double layers, Birkeland currents and magnetic reconnection are separate physical processes. The main thing that they share is that they can happen in plasma.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lie and ignorant delusion that comets are spacecraft

...Spacecraft Charging, shall we talk about this phenomena in relation to your above assertion!
30 November 2017 Sol88: A lie and ignorant delusion that comets are spacecraft!
It is a lie that the post he replies to was about what the mainstream knows about spacecraft. The post was what about his and the Thunderbolts comet delusions would predict about spacecraft.
If we deludingly treat spacecraft as the same as comets as Sol88 wants then Lukraak_Sisser was only wrong about "would have made it to orbit around earth".
If there is EDM eroding the surfaces of comets to depths of many meters then the same EDM should erode the surfaces of spacecraft in orbits similar to comets (maybe to the depths of many meters!). According to Sol88 and the Thunderbolts cult:
The 5 spacecraft in List of artificial objects leaving the Solar System no longer exist :eye-poppi!
The Cassini spacecraft never got to Saturn.
The Juno spacecraft never got to Jupiter.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A delusion that spacecraft act like comets (spacecraft are made of metal1)

Spacecraft Charging and Hazards to Electronics in Space
30 November 2017 Sol88: A delusion that spacecraft act like comets (spacecraft are made of metal, not ices and dust!).
Spacecraft are not made of ices and dust. Spacecraft do not have natural jets from sublimating ices. Spacecraft do not have cometary coma. Spacecraft do not have cometary tails.

Also his and the insane Thunderbolts delusions about comets do not include the mainstream electrostatic charging of comet nuclei.
His insane comets delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; etc. etc.
But maybe Sol88 can correct me by pointing to a relevant Thunderbolts cult page or confirm that this is his personal idea to be added to the above list?
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Confirms idiotic comet delusions are by asking an already answered question

Would you consider helping me in finding out the charge on a comet?
30 November 2017 Sol88: Confirms how idiotic his comet delusions are by asking a question he must already have an answer to.
In order to know what a charged comet does, the Thunderbolts cult have to first estimate the charge on a comet. They have has decades to do this (the idea first pops up in the 1970's) :jaw-dropp!

Thus Sol88 either knows the answer or knows that his cult is spinning totally deluded fantasies about comets.
 
Sol88: More whining and lying about irrelevant physics

You are saying, you are unsure or truly do not understand?
tusenfem is implying that your statement is so incoherent or stupid that he cannot understand it.

The point is this is
30 November 2017 Sol88: More whining and lying about irrelevant physics.
Your comet delusions are not about double layers.
Your comet delusions are not about field aligned currents.
Your comet delusions are not about nested draping, frozen in magnetic fields or magnetic reconnection.

An idiotic list of authors of uncited papers leads to a probable lie about "CCDLs and NESTED FIELD ALIGEND CURENTS and all there UNIQUE properties are around in the tail region".

What tusenfem wrote and you lie about was that the detection of magnetic reconnection without exploding double layers invalidates Alfven's "little sook".
 
Last edited:
I wonder if any of the EU loons can identify this extract of a paper. written in 2010?:

RECONNECTION
A special kind of violation of the frozen field condition is the process of reconnection. In the classic review article by Vasyliunas (1975) reconnection was defined as “the process whereby plasma flows across a surface separating regions containing topologically different magnetic field lines” (cf. also Priest and Forbes, 2000). But change of connectivity between plasma elements is possible without a separator. Independently of topology, two elements of plasma that are at one instant of time on a common magnetic field line can be on different magnetic field line at another instant, if the condition given above is satisfied somewhere between the plasma elements. This more general definition of reconnection was proposed by Schindler et al. (1988) and Hesse and Schindler (1988) and further elaborated by Birn et al. (1997).................

So, come on, EU loons, who wrote that? First one to get it right gets a lollipop!

P.S. Alfven was dead, so it wasn't him.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom