Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Whipple’s dirtysnowball model of comets composed of ice with some dust is one EVOLVING toward MAINLY ROCK.

Nope, because that was NOT Whipple's model, as I have told you dozens of times already. To quote Whipple himself from the abstract of his paper:
Whipple, 1950, A COMET MODEL. I. THE ACCELERATION OF COMET ENCKE, Astrophysical Journal 111, 375.

Whipple 1950 said:
The nucleus is visualized as a conglomerate of ices, such as H2O, NH3, CH34, C02 or CO, (C2N2?), and other possible materials volatile at room temperature, combined in a conglomerate with meteoric materials, all initially at extremely low temperatures ( <50° K). Vaporization of the ices by externally applied solar radiation leaves an outer matrix of nonvolatile insulating meteoric material.

Please explain how you read from this "ice with some dust"? You are not even familiar with the model which you want to "overthrow", for crying out loud!
 
Last edited:
But you have to give him that: Real physics is dealing with electric fields, and that is all he needs to claim victory. He is prepared to jettison anything of the original "model", if only the word "electric", or perhaps "ambipolar" is mentioned.

Thank you, I stand corrected! :-)
 
ELCTRIC FIELD from CHARGE SEPERATION where MHD is NOT VALID from a nucleus evolving toward MOSTLY ROCK!

The ELECTRIC COMET :thumbsup:


:thumbsup:
I'll use this post of yours, Sol88, but many others would do.

You've been banging on like this for what, several years now?

And almost every time you do, you get pushback, almost always questioning the veracity of your claims, sometimes even calling you out for mis-quoting. Many ISF members respond, many include science-based explanations of why you're off in a world of your own.

In all that time, and with all those posts, it seems you have convinced precisely no one else of the scientific validity of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or theory)! :jaw-dropp

Do you, at least sometimes, wonder why this is?

How come you are so spectacularly unsuccessful?

Are you concerned, even a little bit, about being perceived as a spamming troll?
 
Total woo. No discharges, no rock, no mechanism, no evidence. You are flogging a dead horse.

No mechanism?


You joker!

Complete muppet.

Evidence of Electrical Activity on Comet 67P: Towards an Electrochemical Framework for Cometary Phenomena Franklin Anariba, PhD

Very first paragraph

Episode 1 – Charge Separation in the Plasma Environment of Comet 67P

Ya muppet.

:
 
I see that Sol88 still has no evidence, just the same old recycled myths and fairy tales.

Evidence?

Or common sense?

If Whipple’s dirtysnowball model of comet nuclei has mostly ice with some dust and when one of the big players in the cometary community said OUR understanding is evolving toward MOSTLY ROCK... :thumbsup:


One wonders if there maybe be evidence?

Eyeball mkI was pretty accurate. :D
 
I'll use this post of yours, Sol88, but many others would do.

You've been banging on like this for what, several years now?

And almost every time you do, you get pushback, almost always questioning the veracity of your claims, sometimes even calling you out for mis-quoting. Many ISF members respond, many include science-based explanations of why you're off in a world of your own.

In all that time, and with all those posts, it seems you have convinced precisely no one else of the scientific validity of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or theory)! :jaw-dropp

Do you, at least sometimes, wonder why this is?

How come you are so spectacularly unsuccessful?

Are you concerned, even a little bit, about being perceived as a spamming troll?

Meh, not really. ;)

See post above. Now toddle off and THINK.

Whipple dirtysnowball model is wrong...so now what?
 
Nope, because that was NOT Whipple's model, as I have told you dozens of times already. To quote Whipple himself from the abstract of his paper:
Whipple, 1950, A COMET MODEL. I. THE ACCELERATION OF COMET ENCKE, Astrophysical Journal 111, 375.

Originally Posted by Whipple 1950
The nucleus is visualized as a conglomerate of ices, such as H2O, NH3, CH34, C02 or CO, (C2N2?), and other possible materials volatile at room temperature, combined in a conglomerate with meteoric materials, all initially at extremely low temperatures ( <50° K). Vaporization of the ices by externally applied solar radiation leaves an outer matrix of nonvolatile insulating meteoric material.


Please explain how you read from this "ice with some dust"? You are not even familiar with the model which you want to "overthrow", for crying out loud!

Ha ha, another spinner( ‘carn spinner)! That’s the ‘deep fried ice cream” version of Whipple’s model tusenfem, fair dinkum champ!

Astronomers tinkering with ice and organics in the lab may have discovered why comets are encased in a hard, outer crust.

Why Comets Are Like Deep Fried Ice Cream

But how can that be true if...

At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the rst quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited
Michael F A’Hearn

Is Whipple’s model in need of another revision, tusenfem?

So don’t you start confabulation as well sport! I understand whipple model plenty well, enough to agree it’s wrong!
 
Last edited:
Ooh ooh ooh, I predict DOUBLE LAYERS will be “discovered” by the ‘surprised” mainstream to be an important plasma procces in operation at comets.

See how we go ay?

October 2018
 
Nope, because that was NOT Whipple's model, as I have told you dozens of times already. To quote Whipple himself from the abstract of his paper:
Whipple, 1950, A COMET MODEL. I. THE ACCELERATION OF COMET ENCKE, Astrophysical Journal 111, 375.

Originally Posted by Whipple 1950

The nucleus is visualized as a conglomerate of ices, such as H2O, NH3, CH34, C02 or CO, (C2N2?), and other possible materials volatile at room temperature, combined in a conglomerate with meteoric materials, all initially at extremely low temperatures ( <50° K). Vaporization of the ices by externally applied solar radiation leaves an outer matrix of nonvolatile insulating meteoric material.

Please explain how you read from this "ice with some dust"? You are not even familiar with the model which you want to "overthrow", for crying out loud!
Measurement trumps "being able to visualize it"??
 
Measurement trumps "being able to visualize it"??

And measurement tells us he was pretty much spot on. Measurement also tells us that you are completely wrong. No discharges, no rock, no EDM (lol). Still batting zero, aren't you?
 
Last edited:
Ooh ooh ooh, I predict DOUBLE LAYERS will be “discovered” by the ‘surprised” mainstream to be an important plasma procces in operation at comets
.

Well, the data has been in for two years, and is publicly available. Get to it.
 
But how can that be true if...

At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the rst quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited

Michael F A’Hearn

It was a poor choice of wording by the late Michael A'Hearn. However, in the next sentence, which you failed to cherry-pick, he goes on to say;

Nevertheless, there is still considerable uncertainty about even this basic parameter, not least of which is that most measurements are subject to selection effects in removing refractories from the nucleus to the coma, where they are observed as dust.

So, there is no question of slabs of basalt or granite or sandstone lying around. This is dust. Refractory dust in some cases, as opposed to the fluffy primordial grains. This is what Whipple meant by 'meteoritic material'.
He was right, the loons Thornhill & Talbott were wrong. Despite having access to an extra 56 years worth of data that Whipple didn't have.
What does that tell you about the scientific credentials of the aforementioned woo merchants?
 
Evidence of Electrical Activity on Comet 67P: Towards an Electrochemical Framework for Cometary Phenomena Franklin Anariba, PhD

An unpublished, non-peer reviewed piece of junk by an unqualified (in any of the relevant sciences) wooist.

Instead, my intention is bring to everyone’s attention that there could be other mechanisms at work for the origin of water and other chemical species in the cometary coma. One mechanism is proton implantation, which has been recalled to explain water ice presence on craters in the moon....

Complete nonsense. The numbers don't add up, as any consideration of the basic parameters will show, assuming a reasonable competence in basic maths. Not to mention that the solar wind protons aren't reaching the surface for long periods.
Not worthy of any serious consideration.

Another mechanism, mostly unknown to the astronomical community, is based on electrochemical principles which I have named electron-stripping. This mechanism can be dominant at larger heliocentric distances, away from perihelion, when the voltage differential between the comet and the surrounding plasma sheath of the sun can be largest.

What voltage difference? There isn't one. Let's move on, shall we?
Interestingly, the authors add: “A simple scenario would be that the pick-up ions initially move along the undisturbed solar wind electric field, while the newly created electrons . . . drift, causing a charge separation [emphasis added]. The electric field of that charge separation would initially have a component opposite to the solar wind electric field and a component in the anti-sunward direction. This is consistent with both the flow of the water ions and the observed deflection of the solar wind.” The implications are three-fold:

a. Charge separation is due to an electric field, which is an indication of the presence of voltage differential.
b. If the accelerated water cations (H2O+) are traveling from the direction of the sun, electrons must be traveling in the direction towards the sun.
c. The high water cation flux production rate may be an indication that another process is at work besides the traditionally proposed photoionization due to ultraviolet radiation.

Re the bolded; whaaaat? Plasma physics isn't his forte, is it? The effect of the ambipolar field is to slow down the electrons, and speed up the ions, so that they both move in the same direction at the same velocity. Again, this bloke is just showing his ignorance of the relevant science.

That is all from Episode 1. More to come.

https://www.thunderbolts.info/wp/20...trochemical-framework-for-cometary-phenomena/
 
Episode 2

https://www.thunderbolts.info/wp/20...trochemical-framework-for-cometary-phenomena/

In this episode Dr, Anariba ventures into the world of plasma physics. He misunderstands the paper he is referencing, namely;

Suprathermal electron environment of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: Observations from the Rosetta Ion and Electron Sensor.
Clark, G. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2015/11/aa26351-15.pdf

His whole response to this paper? Zero calculations, nor equations. Just, "From an electrical perspective, electron acceleration is due to the point charged sitting on an electric field, which is an indication of the presence of a voltage differential."

Yep, very helpful.

In addition, this has been looked at further, in a later paper;

Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data
Madanian, H. et al.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/2016JA022610
 
Last edited:
Episode 3

In this episode, Anariba looks at the following paper;

Solar wind sputtering of dust on the surface of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Wurz, P. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/component/article/?access=doi&doi=10.1051/0004-6361/201525980

He gets off on completely the wrong foot, by saying;

Solar wind sputtering can explain dust jets and water ice formation in less illuminated areas of the comet,
but not those areas facing the sun as the solar wind does not penetrate through the plasma sheath of the comet. These findings suggest another mechanism must be at work along solar wind sputtering to generate all of the dust found in the coma. A corollary of this study is that proton ion implantation is more likely to occur in areas of less illumination.

That is not what the paper is about! The authors see a tiny amount of sputtering due to solar wind ion impacts. In no way is this related to the vast majority of dust in the coma, which is from outgassing. And nor can this mechanism explain the ice required for that outgassing. By many, many orders of magnitude.

He closes by repeating his impossible mechanism for the observed water vapour;

Taken together, it is reasonable to attribute the observed water ice formed in less illuminated areas to proton (H+) implantation into refractory silicates where they interact with oxygen atoms located in the refractory silicate lattice structures. This is not unusual as it has already been demonstrated to occur in laboratory experiments and thought to be the dominant mechanism for water ice found on crater rims on the moon.

We can add mathematics to the list of things that Anariba is apparently crap at.
 
Last edited:
Episode 4

Here, the intrepid Doctor turns his questionable abilities to this paper;

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Gombosi, T. I. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2015/11/aa26316-15.pdf

He states;

The authors explained the observation via the folding umbrella pattern of dust nanograins. In this reasoning, water nanograins are dragged out by gas outflow, which are then pushed back in the direction of the nucleus by radiation pressure.

But this attribution is problematic and to some degree contradictory for the following reasons:

His first item on the list is;

a. The folding umbrella pattern would indicate dust nanograins travel towards the nucleus, thus contradicting the observation that the negative-charged dust nanograins were moving from the direction of the nucleus when detected.

This, despite the authors clearly stating;

Particles with a < 10 nm, due their diminishing β, travel for a long time and reach distances d apex > 105 km, and due to charging (discussed below) and the orbital motion of the comet, are unlikely to return to the vicinity of the nucleus.

This is Anariba failing to read and/ or understand the paper properly. We can add comprehension skills to the list of things he isn't very good at.

He then gets back to more misunderstanding, and suggesting a voltage difference for the observations. Again, this is contra-indicated by the authors, as they say;

Ignoring cometary outgassing, the effects of surface electric fields can be quickly estimated to show that their contribution to the energization of negatively charged nano-dust grains is expected to remain negligible

Clearly, Dr, Anariba is well out of his depth in this subject area.
 
Last edited:
Episode 5

And in this episode, the dopey doctor applies his complete lack of cometary knowledge to the following paper;

Abundant molecular oxygen in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Bieler, A. et al.
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01346075/file/O2_letter_v4.pdf

Yet again he is back to his voltage differential nonsense to explain the observations. And adds;

O2 and H2O formation by electrochemical means – In this method, O2, O2-, OH, -OH, and other chemical species are released into the coma by various mechanisms, such as “electron-stripping,” solar wind sputtering, and solar heating. In this context, O2 can absorb a negative charged through charge exchange due to demonstrated high electron densities in the vicinity of the nucleus, followed up by protonation via the solar wind. Subsequently, water can then be formed via at least two pathways linking O2 and H2O formation:

This is obviously complete nonsense for numerous reasons. However, perhaps the main observation that shows it be nonsense, is the observations of H2O from 0 - 500m of the nucleus, as well as observations by Alice of O2 close to the nucleus.


WATER VAPOUR AND CARBON DIOXIDE IR EMISSIONS IN 67P/CG COMA: FIRST DETECTION BY ROSETTA/VIRTIS-M
Capaccioni, F. et al.
https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2015/pdf/2494.pdf

H2O and O2 absorption in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko measured by the Alice far-ultraviolet spectrograph on Rosetta
Keeney, B. A. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/469/Suppl_2/S158/3865158

Not to mention Philae detecting it at the surface.

Summary of Dr. Anariba's proposals;

He hasn't got a bloody clue.
 
Some further things to note regarding Dr. Anariba's thoughts;

He is not advocating the EC model as proposed by Thornhill & Talbott. As he says;

As can be ascertained by reading most of the reports published on scientific journals on comet 67P, the main paradigm is the one proposed by Whipple some time ago which can be called the Condensation-Sublimation model. I am not here to refute this model, which I recognize to be of importance near perihelion distances if comets were to contain large amounts of volatiles ices on their surface or in their subsurface

It should already have been known to him that the impact at Tempel 1 ejected ~ 8 - 18 000 tonnes of solid water ice. One wonders, had he known this, whether he would have written his ill informed nonsense on a crackpot website?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom