Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fluid model = dirtysnowball
Kinetic model - electric comet.

Utter nonsense. No evidence nor observation in line with the stupid electric comet woo. It is therefore dead. No rock, no discharges, no EDM (lol). Dead as a dodo. Not a single piece of evidence in the data. Zilch, nix, nada, bugger all, nowt.
 
Another ~191 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 27 September 2018
Another ~215 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 2 October 2018
 
So we all agree the KENTIC MODEL is the more correct model!

Progress even if it is dragging you mob along kicking and screaming.
 
So we all agree the KENTIC MODEL is the more correct model!

Progress even if it is dragging you mob along kicking and screaming.

WTF is the KENTIC MODEL?

And please show us where Thornhill and Talbott modelled the cometary plasma using any sort of model. And where are the observations of their core predictions? You know - electric discharges, rock, EDM (lol)? Please refer to the data and point them out. Difficult, I know, given that they don't exist. Feel free to try though.
 
Last edited:
Now pay attention as this also answers the Mans question.


Birkeland currents

They are caused by the movement of a plasma perpendicular to a magnetic field.


Don't believe everything that is written there, Ian Tresman is a nice amateur, but he does get things very wrong (but at least he is willing to learn). This bold makes absolutely no sense.

COMETS


Now which model would you apply jean tate, the man, jd116, tusenfem and anyone else who would care to join in the answer.

The Kinetic plasma model?


Or

The Fluid (MHD) model?

As that page clearly cites Alfven's 1957 paper, ...
But then again it is NOT an either/or question, but I guess in these times everything has to be black or white for Sol.
 
Last edited:
So we all agree the KENTIC MODEL is the more correct model!

Progress even if it is dragging you mob along kicking and screaming.

Nope, again it depends on what your are doing. Wasting time effort and resources unnecessarily is certainly not "more correct". Heck, depending on the difficulty involved you may never get to the particular aspect you are looking for using a more complex approach.

Look at the link I gave you. The single particle approach is even more detailed than the kinetic approach. Also if you look at that link the kinetic approach looses aspects like plasma microdensity and collective thomson scattering. So if those are perhaps the aspect you are looking into then the kinetic model is the incorrect model to use.
 
Nope, again it depends on what your are doing. Wasting time effort and resources unnecessarily is certainly not "more correct". Heck, depending on the difficulty involved you may never get to the particular aspect you are looking for using a more complex approach.

Look at the link I gave you. The single particle approach is even more detailed than the kinetic approach. Also if you look at that link the kinetic approach looses aspects like plasma microdensity and collective thomson scattering. So if those are perhaps the aspect you are looking into then the kinetic model is the incorrect model to use.

Ahhhh, making the math easier!


Can I use the fluid (MHD) model for cometary Birkeland currents? Charge seperation?...etc????

So your answer is irrelevant :D

Why is so hard for you’se to accept? :rolleyes:
 
Now pay attention as this also answers the Mans question.


Birkeland currents



Any “discovered” at 67P, jean tate, the man?


COMETS



Now which model would you apply jean tate, the man, jd116, tusenfem and anyone else who would care to join in the answer.

The Kinetic plasma model?


Or

The Fluid (MHD) model?







Now don’t forget...

Fluid model = dirtysnowball
Kinetic model - electric comet.
Hmm ...

Anything on your work to show that "dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge" is consistent with data from FIRST, GLEAM, NVSS, ... ?

Apparently not.

OK, how about anything on your work to show that all relevant observations are consistent with:

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−31c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm
1d) the main minerals are silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron


In particular, that the estimated bulk density matches that in the ELECTRIC COMET model (or theory)?

Apparently not.

Why am I not surprised? :p
 
So we all agree the KENTIC MODEL is the more correct model!

Progress even if it is dragging you mob along kicking and screaming.
Um ... er ... no. :)

From reading what others have posted, and what I just posted, we seem to all agree that a) Sol88 seems to not understand what he's posting (in terms of science); and b) Sol88 seems to be avoiding hard questions on the ELECTRIC COMET model (or theory), which is - may I remind you - the topic of this thread. :p
 
They are caused by the movement of a plasma perpendicular to a magnetic field.


Don't believe everything that is written there, Ian Tresman is a nice amateur, but he does get things very wrong (but at least he is willing to learn). This bold makes absolutely no sense.



As that page clearly cites Alfven's 1957 paper, ...
But then again it is NOT an either/or question, but I guess in these times everything has to be black or white for Sol.

You ARE the expert here tusenfem, please fill all us ignorant numpties in on how cometary Birkeland currents are formed AND sustained?

Are you able to use MHD? Or would you use the Kinetic plasma approach? Maybe you could use the single particle approach?

Which one would a super duper space plasma physicist use?
 
<irrelevant stuff snipped>

Why is so hard for you’se to accept? :rolleyes:
Perhaps more pertinent: why is it so hard for you, Sol88, to focus on the ELECTRIC COMET model (or theory)?

Why do you continue to not show us the results of your analyses of the relevant FIRST, NVSS, GLEAM, etc data, re the detection (or not) of EDM in active comets? Or the results of your work on showing consistency (or not) between all relevant observations and comets having a bulk density of solid rock (per the ELECTRIC COMET model)?
 
You ARE the expert here tusenfem, please fill all us ignorant numpties in on how cometary Birkeland currents are formed AND sustained?

<stuff irrelevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model snipped>
You ARE the expert here Sol88, please fill all us ignorant numpties in on how the FIRST, NVSS, GLEAM, etc data are consistent (or not) with the ELECTRIC COMET model's EDM.

You ARE the expert here Sol88, please fill all us ignorant numpties in on how the relevant observational data are consistent (or not) with the ELECTRIC COMET model's "comets have bulk densities ~the same as solid rock".
 
Hmm ...

Anything on your work to show that "dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge" is consistent with data from FIRST, GLEAM, NVSS, ... ?

Apparently not.

OK, how about anything on your work to show that all relevant observations are consistent with:

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−31c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm
1d) the main minerals are silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron


In particular, that the estimated bulk density matches that in the ELECTRIC COMET model (or theory)?

Apparently not.

Why am I not surprised? :p


Surprised???

No it’s your last bastion of hope!

We KNOW comets are made from ICE with some dust and a WHOLE lot of nothing at all!

70-80% is nothing at all :confused:

It is noted that the mainstream are struggling to reconcile the unexpectedly high dust content.

The I a stronger electric field there than the 10% of the solar electric field of the sun.
 
You ARE the expert here Sol88, please fill all us ignorant numpties in on how the FIRST, NVSS, GLEAM, etc data are consistent (or not) with the ELECTRIC COMET model's EDM.

You ARE the expert here Sol88, please fill all us ignorant numpties in on how the relevant observational data are consistent (or not) with the ELECTRIC COMET model's "comets have bulk densities ~the same as solid rock".


Been there!

Waiting on the new paper to reinforce our assertion comets are more or less asteroids on eccentric orbits thru the solar electric field.
 
Hmm ...

Anything on your work to show that "dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge" is consistent with data from FIRST, GLEAM, NVSS, ... ?

Apparently not.


Why am I not surprised? :p

Yawns

GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity T.A. Nordheima,b,n, G.H. Jonesa,b, J.S. Halekasc, E. Roussosd, A.J. Coatesa,b

Get back to me when you can.

Cheers
 
Last edited:
Surprised???

<irrelevant nonsense snipped>
Still waiting Sol88.

For what?

Details, quantitative details, of your work showing that the bulk densities of comets (or even of one comet) are (is) consistent with them (it) being solid rock (which "is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids").

I am likely not all that much longer, here on Earth, but I'm increasingly reconciled to the (almost certain) fact that a) you have not done any such work, and b) have no intention of doing any.
 
Yawns

<irrelevant stuff snipped>
Hmm ...

Anything on your work to show that "dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge" is consistent with data from FIRST, GLEAM, NVSS, ... ? (bold added)

Apparently not.

Why am I not surprised?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom