Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Meh,



Size of a plasma cloud matters The polarisation electric eld of a small-scale comet ionosphere

Let’s see, ay jt?

It doesn't matter how they model it - no model is going to make undetected discharges suddenly show up. It isn't going to make non-existent rock suddenly appear in the data. Nor EDM (lol). Observation, not to mention basic science, has already debunked this ridiculous 'model'.
Not that it needed debunking, as it appears nowhere in the scientific literature.
 
I predict that comets are based on the laws of atoms, and you will find atoms on them everywhere. Even the plasma would not exist without atoms. The ATOMIC COMET theory will be victorious!

Any mainstream papers that mentions atoms or plasma will be seen as supportive of the ATOMIC COMET theory.

Additionally atoms have charges that are separate, as protons and electrons, which can form both neutral and ionic atoms. So any mention of charge separation, ions or nurtarls is also supportive of the ATOMIC COMET theory.
 
Ah, charge separation of space plasma :D :thumbsup:

Looked and looked but can find no reference whatsoever from Whipple dirtysnowball model at all, wrt electric fields, charge separation or field aligned currents????

Is this not part of standard mainstream physics on comets?

:D
Weird.

Just weird.

Am I in the wrong thread? Are you, Sol88?

The ELECTRIC COMET MODEL (or THEORY)? Isn’t that what we’re supposed to be discussing?
 
Additionally atoms have charges that are separate, as protons and electrons, which can form both neutral and ionic atoms. So any mention of charge separation, ions or nurtarls is also supportive of the ATOMIC COMET theory.

Could you also squeeze in Birkeland currents (FAC’S), charge accumulation and charged particle acceleration and double layers(electric fields)?

You just to round it out.

Now how far again from the nucleus does this process finish?

Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet Jan Deca

Not even the great plasma physicist can not answer this question. :D

Perhaps you could give it a go?
 
Last edited:
Weird.

Just weird.

Am I in the wrong thread? Are you, Sol88?

The ELECTRIC COMET MODEL (or THEORY)? Isn’t that what we’re supposed to be discussing?

We are unless you know what the NEW model is?

Like I said a few post back, we are waiting for the mainstream to catch up...slowly

This paper, when released, will smash ANOTHER nail in the coffin of the dirtysnowball model. :cool:

important physics will be missed unless electrons and charge accumulation are taken properly into account.
Size of a plasma cloud matters The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere :D

Care to discuss, in this ELECTRIC COMET thread, what the IMPORTANT physics may be?

You will no longer have a standard mainstream Whipple model and will concede the dominate role Plasma processes play at comets!

Are you able?

Sublimating “ices” :blush:
 
Additionally atoms have charges that are separate, as protons and electrons, which can form both neutral and ionic atoms. So any mention of charge separation, ions or nurtarls is also supportive of the ATOMIC COMET theory.

The model does not consider instabilities at the boundary and it is assumed that field-aligned electric fields are negligible. The processes we are interested in concern the separation of ions and electrons as they move across the magnetic field.
Size of a plasma cloud matters The polarisation electric eld of a small-scale comet ionosphere

How spatially separate are your electron and ions in your ATOMIC MODEL?
 
It doesn't matter how they model it - no model is going to make undetected discharges suddenly show up. It isn't going to make non-existent rock suddenly appear in the data. Nor EDM (lol). Observation, not to mention basic science, has already debunked this ridiculous 'model'.
Not that it needed debunking, as it appears nowhere in the scientific literature.


Ya joker!

How’s the diamagnetic cavity formed and sustained again jonesdumb?

Collision with neutrals?
Close to the cometary nucleus, the plasma becomes collisionally coupled to the radially expanding neutral atmosphere. This prevents the magnetized solar wind from penetrating into the inner cometary regions, which results in the formation of a region void of any signicant magnetic eld:a diamagnetic cavity(Cravens 1987; Ip & Axford 1987).
Diamagnetic region(s): structure of the unmagnetized plasma around Comet 67P/CG

:dl:


Or

The latter implies that the inner part of the comet ionosphere is largely shielded from the main solar wind electric eld because the ion motion is determined by an ambipolar electric eld and another electric eld giving rise to an anti-sunward motion.
Size of a plasma cloud matters The polarisation electric eld of a small-scale comet ionosphere

And

The electron pressure gradient create s a strong ambipolar electric field that will be even-tually responsible for the development of a short-lived magnetic dropout.
A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Now twaddle off and be Einstein’s bitch.
 
Could you also squeeze in Birkeland currents (FAC’S), charge accumulation and charged particle acceleration and double layers(electric fields)?

You just to round it out.

Want to really round it out? Include rock and/or ice then, as they too are made of atoms.


Now how far again from the nucleus does this process finish?

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet Jan Deca


"how far again"? "finish"? I'm not exactly sure what you're asking. Though I expect it would depend greatly as to how one defines that "finish". Naturally the interaction region would taper off as there are less and less of a given amount of cometary ions to neutralize. However one would need a clear set of limiting parameters to establish what might be considered the finish of that interaction. Heck, given an over abundance of cometary ions as compared to the local solar wind particles neutralization of those ions by the solar may never finish. More importantly particularly for the case of a weakly outgassing comet as addressed in that paper might be how from the nucleus that such interaction starts.


Not even the great plasma physicist can not answer this question. :D

Sure they can, figures 1 and 2 give density profiles for solar wind electrons and protons as well as cometary electrons and ions based on the model used. Again it simply depends on what one might consider the "finish" and along what axis. Also as noted above the level of neutral outgassing plays a significant role.


Perhaps you could give it a go?

Give what a go? Charting for you what the very paper you reference charts for you? From the carts of the cited paper it looks like 1000 to 1500 km is about when interaction really tapers off. The ion exobase is given as 3 km from the nucleus for this particular model and from the charts looks like about -500 km is the start of the interaction region.
 
Size of a plasma cloud matters The polarisation electric eld of a small-scale comet ionosphere

How spatially separate are your electron and ions in your ATOMIC MODEL?


In the ATOMIC MODEL electrons can be in bound states with the nucleus of the atom or unbound and free to perhaps the dominance of other electromagnetic fields. Theoretically the charge separation distance for an unbound electron can be infinite. How spatially separate does the electric comet model need them to be? Is it less than infinite?
 
Close to the cometary nucleus, the plasma becomes collisionally coupled to the radially expanding neutral atmosphere. This prevents the magnetized solar wind from penetrating into the inner cometary regions, which results in the formation of a region void of any signicant magnetic eld:a diamagnetic cavity(Cravens 1987; Ip & Axford 1987).

That is about the MAGNETIC field. And has nothing to do with;

The latter implies that the inner part of the comet ionosphere is largely shielded from the main solar wind electric eld because the ion motion is determined by an ambipolar electric eld and another electric eld giving rise to an anti-sunward motion.

Which is about the ELECTRIC field. Try to learn the difference. Plasma physics not really your thing, is it? Beats me why you keep flogging this dead horse.
 
You will no longer have a standard mainstream Whipple model and will concede the dominate role Plasma processes play at comets!

You do know, i hope, that the "whipple model" absolutely talks neither about comet-solar wind interaction , nor about plasma physics
yes he mentions ions, created by sublimation and solar radiation ionization
the solar wind was not known in 1950 (although birkeland proposed a corpuscular radiation from the sun in the 1920s but had no real evidence)
only in 1951 biermann proposed again corpuscular radiation from the sun to explain the gas tail of the comet. now there was some supporting, though not direct, evidence
first in 1959 the russian satellite luna 1 measured directly the solar wind
 
That is about the MAGNETIC field. And has nothing to do with;



Which is about the ELECTRIC field. Try to learn the difference. Plasma physics not really your thing, is it? Beats me why you keep flogging this dead horse.

no YOU said it stops the solar wind from reaching the surface all together(Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity???) remember mate???, I told you that was crap and low and behold... it was!! :D

So could electric fields be removing dust from the surface, jd116? :rolleyes:

AND

effecting your density estimates?

from the paper above
the predicted surface potential becomes increasingly more
negative towards the center of the wake, reaching more than
2 kV in the case of κ¼ 3.0 and 600 V in the case of κ¼4.5.
Model predictions for the nucleus during the time of the Philae
landing at 3 AU are shown in Fig. 4, but as the results are relatively
similar to those of the rendezvous case, they will not be
discussed further.

now where's that paper on the solar wind electric field and it's application to 67P...goes looking...
 
Last edited:
You do know, i hope, that the "whipple model" absolutely talks neither about comet-solar wind interaction , nor about plasma physics
yes he mentions ions, created by sublimation and solar radiation ionization
the solar wind was not known in 1950 (although birkeland proposed a corpuscular radiation from the sun in the 1920s but had no real evidence)
only in 1951 biermann proposed again corpuscular radiation from the sun to explain the gas tail of the comet. now there was some supporting, though not direct, evidence
first in 1959 the russian satellite luna 1 measured directly the solar wind

Exactly!

They also made up black holes and such more or less at the same time, funny that!
 
no YOU said it stops the solar wind from reaching the surface all together(Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity???) remember mate???, I told you that was crap and low and behold... it was!!

Sheesh! You REALLY don't understand the papers that you are quote mining, do you?
This is too silly to even try to explain it to you again.
 
Exactly!

They also made up black holes and such more or less at the same time, funny that!

So now you are claiming that the solar wind is "made up"?
Or what exactly are you claiming here?
Another staggering example of how you do not understand (space) phyisics.
You also do not seem to grasp that claiming that plasma interactions "prove the Whipple model wrong" is a ridiculous claim, as the Whipple model has absolutely nothing to do with plasma interactions.
But I might as well say this to a brick wall, which might even understand more than you do.
 
Last edited:
no YOU said it stops the solar wind from reaching the surface all together(Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity???) remember mate???, I told you that was crap and low and behold... it was!! :D

So could electric fields be removing dust from the surface, jd116? :rolleyes:

AND

effecting your density estimates?

from the paper above

now where's that paper on the solar wind electric field and it's application to 67P...goes looking...

The solar wind is prevented from accessing the surface ALTOGETHER. Once activity reaches a certain level. That includes the magnetic field and the electric field. Why would the EF persist, when its existence depends on a moving magnetic field which is no longer present? There are only cometary species in that cavity.
And how on Earth would any such nonsense affect density measurements? Now, that really is dumb.
 
The solar wind is prevented from accessing the surface ALTOGETHER. Once activity reaches a certain level. That includes the magnetic field and the electric field. Why would the EF persist, when its existence depends on a moving magnetic field which is no longer present? There are only cometary species in that cavity.
And how on Earth would any such nonsense affect density measurements? Now, that really is dumb.


And as I said jonesdumb116 it’s (the solar wind) does not need to access the surface but the ELECTRIC COMET REQUIRES an ELECTRIC FIELD!

Guess what sport...:D

Another argument from you that just fades into the rest of your bovine digestive waste products!

Far as I concerned that is why you are a complete plasma :boggled::blush:
 
So now you are claiming that the solar wind is "made up"?
Or what exactly are you claiming here?
Another staggering example of how you do not understand (space) phyisics.
You also do not seem to grasp that claiming that plasma interactions "prove the Whipple model wrong" is a ridiculous claim, as the Whipple model has absolutely nothing to do with plasma interactions.
But I might as well say this to a brick wall, which might even understand more than you do.

No dear, no.

What I’m claiming is ALL of modern cosmology being theoretical mathematical constructs that DO NOT include kinetic plasma processes.

i.e.

Einstein and plasma :mad:
 
And as I said jonesdumb116 it’s (the solar wind) does not need to access the surface but the ELECTRIC COMET REQUIRES an ELECTRIC FIELD!

Guess what sport...:D

Another argument from you that just fades into the rest of your bovine digestive waste products!

Far as I concerned that is why you are a complete plasma :boggled::blush:

What the hell are you on about? We know the solar wind carries an electric field. It kind of has to. So what? It isn't reaching the surface at times of high activity, is it? What is your point, assuming you have one? You don't understand plasma physics worth a damn, so what, in your befuddled mind, has this to do with the thoroughly debunked electric comet woo?
 
Might I remind the hard of thinking, that the same solar wind electric field is in constant contact with asteroid surfaces. What sort of idiotic woo are we suggesting for those bodies? Why does it appear to do the square root of sod all at asteroids, but somehow produces various fantasised woo at comets? What is the difference, in what passes for the cognitive processes of EU loons, between asteroids in this EF, and comets?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom