Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The usual lying question to derail from his many comet delusions

Sorry Rc did'nt know you where the expert in space plasma?
19 June 2018: The usual lying question to derail from his many comet delusions.

I am an expert in just how totally deluded your electric comet is. Anyone who reads this thread knows that you are lying abut "kinetic effects" having anything to do with your comet delusions and so derailing from the delusions. It is that repeated lie that I have posted about.
18 June 2018: A lie that a "Rosetta’s tail excursion" paper is to do with his many comet delusions.
18 June 2018: Another lying question about the "A tail like no other" paper to detail from his many comet delusions.
19 June 2018: Yet another stupid question to derail from his many comet delusions.
19 June 2018: A "It’s all about education" lie when he is spreading delusions and lies about comets.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
So...

I thought we’d ask the expert.

Save all that misinformation

No, Tusenfem's paper has nothing whatsoever to do with what JT and Indagator were asking. It is just another dodge to save you having to admit that the whole silly electric comet woo is a science-free zone. With zero evidence.
 
Great idea, Sol88! Let's ask the experts ....

tusenfem! Good Sir! You are under no obligation to "answer me these questions three ..."

However, if you choose to ...

1) Does the electric comet violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
2) Does the electric star violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
3) Can the "eu" defined electric comet be a real "physical" object? ... Yes/No
Hi Indagator. The answers are:
1) Yes.
2) Definitely Yes!
3) No.

A bit more:
1) We measure the masses of comets using multiple methods. Divide by their measured volume and we get densities. Comet densities are less than that of water. The average is ~6 g/cc. The ec delusions require that comet density is that of rock which is about 6 times higher.
For all of multiple methods to be wrong, laws of physics have to be wrong (Newtonian gravity, F=ma, etc.). Or we have fantasies about electric fields doing whatever magic ec followers want then to do. That was an idea touted 45 years ago in a crank journal and they have not produced any actual model since then.

2) The electric star has the delusion of stars being extremely powered but stars are stable because they have an internal source of heat.
This is Astronomy 101. A star's size is a balance between gravity and thermal pressure. Apply known, working physics. Set the radius to be constant. Calculate the temperature gradient needed and temperature has to increase with depth, i.e. a heat source at the core.
A couple of minutes and common knowledge tells us this. As depth increases there is more weight to be held up. Pressure has to increase. We thus expect temperature to increase (the details need a bit more working out).

3) See 1. Also the ec comet starts off as being blasted from the surface of unknown planets by other unknown planets wandering over to them and exchanging electric discharges. The delusion starts with Earth being magically exempt from whatever causes the other planets to wander. Things just get worse from there!
 
Last edited:
And yes, you certainly are no expert on the subject.
Oh, I know. However, I know more about it than you do. And I don't come on here telling experts in the field that they are wrong, just because their findings don't match up with some idiotic, Velikovsky inspired woo. I think you'll find the number of plasma physicists associated with your cult = zero. Correct? Guess why that is? Because they understand plasma physics!
 
And I don't come on here telling experts in the field that they are wrong, just because their findings don't match up with some idiotic, Velikovsky inspired woo. I think you'll find the number of plasma physicists associated with your cult = zero.
There seems to be 1 ex-plasma (chemistry) physicist associated with the Velikovsky inspired woo of the SAFIRE project. Lowell Morgan was stupid enough to appear at the EU2015 conference of cranks. On the other hand, his official page does not mention SAFIRE.
 
Last edited:
No, Tusenfem's paper has nothing whatsoever to do with what JT and Indagator were asking. It is just another dodge to save you having to admit that the whole silly electric comet woo is a science-free zone. With zero evidence.

So you don't know either, jd116?? :confused:

You're pretty keen on firing emails off, demanding answers. So I thought we'd ask the expert and the lead author on the paper "A Tail Like No other" on what kinetic effects in plasma in/on/around a weakly outgassing comet?

  1. What they are?
  2. What might the dirtysnowball model expect?

No math needed, we all understand plain English.
 
Sol88!

Luck has nothing to do with it! Tis all about intellect, knowledge, and "your" human nature, my friend!

Before I started posting here, I never expected you to engage in polite scientific discourse. Based on pages and pages of your historical commentary on the ISF alone, I knew that you do not engage in polite scientific discourse with anyone. Perhaps you don't care about the sacrifice that people make as they pursue scientific knowledge? Perhaps you have a religious agenda? Perhaps I misjudge you? If my questions and comments about your belief system cause discomfort, I would point out that this is nothing more than an extreme form of "peer" review! Get used to it! Get over it! It will never end!

If you make a "scientific" claim, you must be able to prove it using science!

No science? False claim! Failed model! NEXT!

Here's a short (and polite) list of what I have learned from you so far:

01) You display no knowledge of mathematics!
02) You display no knowledge of basic physics!
03) You display no knowledge of plasma physics!
04) You display no knowledge of electrodynamics!
05) You display no knowledge of geological processes!
06) You display no knowledge of the electric comet!
07) You display no knowledge of the electric star!
08) You display no interest in sharing or defending your views of the electric universe!
09) You display no interest in science or the scientific method! And finally, ...
10) You display no desire to learn! A trait I find common in the practitioners of fundamentalist religions!

Based on your previous posts (and the internet never forgets), I find it outrageously funny that you would want scientific or academic council from anyone, especially an expert. Honestly, why do you care what Tusenfem, or any other expert, has to say? Your modus operandi is to ignore everything that does not fit with your religious agenda! If Tusenfem, or any other expert, tells you your electric universe is humor praefandus, would you believe them?

Who are you trying to convert, Sol88?

Given your dismissive responses to my legitimate scientific questions, how seriously do you think others will embrace the electric universe? Is your behaviour typical of those in the electric universe community?

To conclude, there is one more thing I have learned from you! There is no electric comet!

Sol88! Is it time to engage in science? Or is it time to run and hide? Talk to me!
 
No math needed, we all understand plain English.

Sol88! You have just commited a ...

CRITICAL EXPERT ERROR!

Math is the one thing that is most needed in this thread! If Tusenfem wishes to respond to your off-topic query, then he should present the answers in purely mathematical form! No english language is required! Mathematics is truly a universal language! Besides, english sucks! Humble opinion!

And what is your obsession with the dirty snowball model? I want to know how eccentricity controls charging and discharging of the electric comet!

If you make a "scientific" claim, you must be able to prove it using science!

Prove the "ec" claim that eccentricity controls the charging and discharging of the electric comet using electrodynamics! And be sure to use lots of MATH!
 
Here's a general query (or two) for the ISF community reading this thread!

The "eu brain trust" is constantly claiming that there is growing momentum for the ideas promoted in, and by the electric universe!

If so, how come there is only one person from this "growing horde" willing to step up and (poorly) represent the bizarre magic that is the electric comet, electric star, and electric universe? Where are the rest?

I see no momentum! I see no peer-reviewed papers! And I see no science!

Without genuine proof (i.e., mathematical models that can be used to make predictions), I must conclude ...

There is no electric comet!

There is no electric star!

There is no electric universe!

Agree? Disagree?

"eu" Math is the one thing that is most needed in this thread!
 
Okay, first "kinetic effects" here means that on the scales that we are looking, the MHD approach cannot be used, and that therefore the particles (ions) will have to be recognized as individuals and not a fluid. This means that the motion of the individual particles needs to be taken into account (an example: the singing comet). It is chapter 2 of the Saas-Fee book on plasma astrophysics (by Don Melrose) that I mentioned a few pages ago.

1) Does the electric comet violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
2) Does the electric star violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... Yes/No
3) Can the "eu" defined electric comet be a real "physical" object? ...Yes/No
 
Last edited:
Okay, first "kinetic effects" here means that on the scales that we are looking, the MHD approach cannot be used, and that therefore the particles (ions) will have to be recognized as individuals and not a fluid. This means that the motion of the individual particles needs to be taken into account (an example: the singing comet). It is chapter 2 of the Saas-Fee book on plasma astrophysics (by Don Melrose) that I mentioned a few pages ago.

Thank you Tusenfem! :thumbsup:
 
So, now the electric comet thread has turned into a free online plasma physics course for the benefit of Sol88? I can see how this is useful as a way to avoid the questions raised by JT and Indigator, but it is rather transparent, and may give Indigator an idea of what to expect, and the reason why this thread still exists, despite its subject matter having been debunked multiple times by observation from numerous missions.
So, why not refer to the literature to try to figure out what is being said by Volwerk, et al? They state:

During the tail excursion the magnetic field strength aroundcomet 67P was B ≈ 10 nT; this means that when water ions are picked up by the magnetic field of the solar wind at v ≈ 350 km s−1, the gyro radius of these ions is ρi ≈ 6000 km. This radius is much larger than the radial distance covered by Rosetta from the nucleus, and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure.


So, type "kinetic plasma; comets" into Google Scholar, and see what comes up. One of the papers is this one:

THE PLASMA ENVIRONMENT OF COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO THROUGHOUT THE ROSETTA MAIN MISSION
Hansen, K. C. et al. (2006)
https://www.researchgate.net/profil...in_Mission/links/02bfe50db32d29295e000000.pdf

I'm certainly no expert on the subject, but I think their description of a hybrid model may give some clues.

A hybrid model describes the plasma environment in a semi-kinetic manner. In the model, electrons are assumed to be a massless charge-neutralizing fluid and are modeled using typical fluid methods (conservation equations). The ions, which have much larger gyroradii, are treated as particles and the code solves individual equations of motion. This method resolves physical structures down to a time scale below the inverse lower hybrid frequency.
The hybrid model that we employ considers two ion species: the solar wind protons and the ion of cometary origin. These cometary ion are significantly heavier than the solar wind protons. In order to correctly model the ions, the dynamic equations include collisions with neutral gas in addition to the Lorentz force. This driver may become significant in dense atmospheres such as near the cometary nucleus.





Might be worth a read, as well as the references therein.

And, it seems that I was right, after doing just a very quick search and read. And having taken a few hints from many, many posts by Tusenfem and Tim Thompson going back years on here and BAUT/ Cosmoquest.
So, yes, it is about education. However, education depends on the ability to understand what is being said, and learning from it.
 
Okay, first "kinetic effects" here means that on the scales that we are looking, the MHD approach cannot be used, and that therefore the particles (ions) will have to be recognized as individuals and not a fluid. This means that the motion of the individual particles needs to be taken into account (an example: the singing comet). It is chapter 2 of the Saas-Fee book on plasma astrophysics (by Don Melrose) that I mentioned a few pages ago.

Thank you, Tusenfem! Excellent work, good Sir!

Okay, Sol88! Back to you! Tusenfem (a genuine expert in plasma physics) has politely answered our questions! What will you do with that information? Ignore it? Throw it back in his face?

Now, using a technique pioneered by Jean Tate (thank you, Jean), I have updated, and will continue to update this list as the answers roll in ....

Great idea, Sol88! Let's ask the experts ....

Tusenfem! Good Sir! You are under no obligation to "answer me these questions three ..."

However, if you choose to ...

1) Does the electric comet violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... YES
2) Does the electric star violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... YES
3) Can the "eu" defined electric comet be a real "physical" object? ... NO

Now your turn, Sol88! As the resident expert in the electric comet, please ...

Sol88, In your opinion / To your knowledge ...

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... Yes/No
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... Yes/No
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
05) Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
06) Does gravity play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
07) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
08) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
09) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring in the core? ... Yes/No
10) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring on the surface? ... Yes/No
11) Are asteroids made of rock? ... Yes/No
12) Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
13) Are comets made of rock? ... Yes/No
14) Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
15) Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process? ... Yes/No
16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? ... Yes/No
17) Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)? ... Yes/No
18) Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of an electric current? ... Yes/No
19) Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle? ... Yes/No
20) Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is? ... Yes/No

I am so looking forward to your expert answers, and your expert predictive mathematical model! Share with us your wisdom, Sol88! Show us the value of your electric comet!

Remember! Just 20 simple questions, "ec" expert!

To summarize, there is no electric comet!

You can't ignore the inevitable, Sol88!

PS - I would also like to extend thank yous to Jonesdave116 and Reality Check for their input in this as well!

Have a great day, everyone! And that includes you too, Sol88!
 
Last edited:
PS - I would also like to extend thank yous to Jonesdave116 and Reality Check for their input in this as well!

Have a great day, everyone! And that includes you too, Sol88!


You are welcome, from my point of view, Indagator. However, do not expect any answers of a scientific nature from the one remaining person on the planet who still believes in this EC woo. This is just a place to promote said woo, and ISF let him do it. Personally, I'd have closed this thread way back. The day that Tempel 1 was impacted, and threw out thousands of tonnes of ice, killed it dead. That was 2005. Reported in 2006/7. And here we all are! Sad.
Come on Sol. Get the idiots who came up with this woo to come here and back up their lies. Not good at science, are they, love? Ashamed of them, perhaps? Who knows? However, Sol still seems to see the need to go into bat for these con artists.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your kind words, Indagator.
<snip>

And what is your obsession with the dirty snowball model? <snip>
I think you'll find that Sol88 explained this, many a post ago.

My summary of his explanation is "the dirty snowball model is WRONG, therefore the Electric Comet model must be RIGHT!" In somewhat more detail, there are only two potentially viable explanations (models) for comets, dirty snowball (a.k.a. Whipple) and EC/ES/EU, and so many contemporary results from comet missions have shown the former to be wrong, wrong, wrong.

From my POV, what's particularly odd about this (aside from the reliance on the logical fallacy, False Dichotomy) is that Sol88 did not seem concerned in the least to subject the EC to any tests ... the mere mention of "plasma" or "electric field" in a paper on comets was (apparently) all that's needed to claim the viability of the EC.
 
Field aligned currents, Birkeland currents, flux ropes, double layers, electrostatic shocks... etc MHD does not apply.

Correct or incorrect, tusenfem?


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12229499&postcount=1946

From just a few pages back!!! So do the thread a favour and go read those few pages where I argued MHD does not apply and the SUPER DUPER SPACE PLASMA PHYSICIST played coy, dam well knowing what was what!

YOU, the mainstream, including plasma EXPERTS posting on this forum, were still arguing black and blue with me on the above point :mad::mad::mad:

But now ohhh... it happens but so what????? :confused::confused::confused:

Well chumps, that's the electric comet, bang on right there!!!

KINETIC EFFECTS: Charge separation, Applied electric fields, Particle acceleration, Plasma heating, Plasma instabilities, Birkeland currents, Force free currents, electric circuits AND DOUBLE LAYERS etc etc....!!!

All from MHD being total CRAP at modelling REAL plasma/s!

like a super duper plasma guru states
The plasma physics around a weakly outgassing is only slowly beginning to be understood by the analysis of data from Rosetta RPC and new numerical modelling. This mission has
opened a new window in space plasma physics.
A tail like no other The RPC-MAG view of Rosetta’s tail excursion at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Martin Volwerk

Games on you mob! :cool:
 
Last edited:
When the surrounding plasma refills the wake, the lighter and faster electrons move inwards ahead of the ions, producing an ambipolar electric field (because of charge separation) that accelerates ions and decelerates electrons into the wake.
Plasma – Surface Interactions with Airless Bodies in Space and the Laboratory J.Deca(PI),X.Wang

Any ambipolar electric fields around 67/P, I wonder?

When those surface electric fields become strong enough to turn rock to dust and accelerate it away in collimated jets, what would we observe?

Is there a need any more for J. Agarwal's fictitious requirement for some sub surface energy storage? Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03 doi:10.1093/mnras/stx2386

Now that MHD arguments is done and dusted, we can talk about REAL PLASMA PHENOMENA that CAN happen around comets!
 
An insult and his persistent lies about his electric comet delusions

Well chumps, that's the electric comet, bang on right there!!!
20 June 2018: An insult and his persistent lies about his electric comet delusions.

Kinetic effects are the results of the treatment of plasma as particles.
Okay, first "kinetic effects" here means that on the scales that we are looking, the MHD approach cannot be used, and that therefore the particles (ions) will have to be recognized as individuals and not a fluid. This means that the motion of the individual particles needs to be taken into account (an example: the singing comet). It is chapter 2 of the Saas-Fee book on plasma astrophysics (by Don Melrose) that I mentioned a few pages ago.

Nothing to do with his ignorant delusions about comets and electric field magic.
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom