Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
916 items of ignorance, idiocy, delusions and lies, 29 August 2016 - 1 May 2018

881 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 23 April 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

  1. 23 April 2018: A stupid demand for a yes/no answer to support his delusions about comets and DLs.
  2. 23 April 2018: A "Every double layer is an electric field" lie.
  3. 24 April 2018: Yet another lying question to derail from his many comet delusions.
  4. 24 April 2018: Usual insanity of irrelevant papers to detail from his many comet delusions.
  5. 24 April 2018: Lies about the electric comet delusion yet again by missing out the blasted from planets insanity.
  6. 24 April 2018: A "postulated" and "quantitative" electric comet lie.
  7. 24 April 2018: A Whipple postulated lie.
  8. 26 April 2018: Multiple "electron beam or "jets"" lies about a tusenfem post.
  9. 26 April 2018: Insanity of a ices and dust "Current sheets" paper to derail from his many comet delusions.
  10. 26 April 2018: Repeated lie about the "Current sheets" paper which has no double layers.
  11. 26 April 2018: A lie that observations are problems solved by insanely ignorant delusions.
  12. 26 April 2018: Repeats his lies about a tusenfem post supporting his comet delusions.
  13. 26 April 2018: A idiotic lie that these coma observations affect "sublimating snowballs".
  14. 26 April 2018: Likes how totally deluded the electric comet is, his heroes lying about comets and his lie!
  15. 26 April 2018: A "That’s most probably an order or two of magnitude" is an Aussie colloquialism lie.
  16. 26 April 2018: A "electrostatically disrupting the nucleus" electric comet delusion.
  17. 26 April 2018: A lie that a paper is on his "electrostaticly disrupting the nucleus" delusion.
  18. 26 April 2018: An "the effect is scalable" lie (no scalable in the abstract).
  19. 27 April 2018: Repeats the many electric comet delusions and his "consolidated dust" lie in red.
  20. 27 April 2018: Totally lies that ambipolar electric field = double layer again !
  21. 30 April 2018: A lie that a clearly labeled image is sublimating ice.
  22. 30 April 2018: Usual ices in quotes lie.
  23. 30 April 2018: Usual lies by citing ices and dust comet papers.
  24. 30 April 2018: Persists with his double layers in papers lie.
  25. 30 April 2018: A jets in quotes lie and lying question.
  26. 30 April 2018: He lies about a hint about jets
  27. 30 April 2018: A "these where acknowledged" lie as his post was an uncited image.
  28. 30 April 2018: A deluded "what we see when we zoom out a little" lie.
  29. 1 May 2018: A "Link corrected in original post" lie when the post has no links at all
  30. 1 May 2018: Repeats a lie that the 2 images are for the same dates (they are years apart).
  31. 1 May 2018: Lies that a PDF is about "the ELECTRIC COMET model" as in the question.
  32. 1 May 2018: The usual lie of jets in quotes.
  33. 1 May 2018: A "Your question is beyond the scope of this thread" lie when the question is about the ELECTRIC COMET model.
  34. 1 May 2018: Emphasizes the lie of only citing "snowballs sublimating from the warmth of the Sun" papers.
  35. 1 May 2018: More idiocy of an delusional gap of the gaps" argument (Whipple's model in its modern form is ices and dust comets).
 
So anywhoo, back to the “jets”.

Are you comfortable with the mainstream explanation for how the “jets” work, jean Tate?

It was a primary goal of Rosetta.
As you yourself so aptly noted, this thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory).

Seeing as how you’re now interested in jets, perhaps you’d like to say more?

I have a question on this topic: using the ELECTRIC COMET model, how do you derive estimates of the composition of jets? Do jets differ in their composition, between jets from the same nucleus? Between comets? If so, why; if not, why not?
 
Why do YOU, jean tate, think that this has any bearing at all on the ELECTRIC COMET model?


I've never read anything, wrt the EC, on determining if the same objects returning to be viewed from Earth is made of ice, rock, cheese or lego!

So what bearing does your question have on the premise of a comet being dominantly electrical in nature, jean tate?

The electric universe has no problem with Newton....Einstein is a different kettle
 
Why do YOU, jean tate, think that this has any bearing at all on the ELECTRIC COMET model?


I've never read anything, wrt the EC, on determining if the same objects returning to be viewed from Earth is made of ice, rock, cheese or lego!

So what bearing does your question have on the premise of a comet being dominantly electrical in nature, jean tate?
I'm a bit surprised that you can't answer this question yourself, but perhaps in time you'll come to realize what importance it has. :)

The electric universe has no problem with Newton....Einstein is a different kettle
Both men are long dead, so neither will be posting in this thread.

Why do YOU, Sol88 think either (dead) man has any bearing at all on the ELECTRIC COMET model? :confused:
 
The breakthrough work that allowed a proper modeling of the nongravitational effects on comets came with Whip- ple’s introduction of his icy conglomerate model for the cometary nucleus (Whipple, 1950, 1951). Part of his moti- vation for this model was to explain the so-called nongravi- tational accelerations that were evident in the motion of Comet Encke and many other active periodic comets. That is, even after all the gravitational perturbations of the plan- ets were taken into account, the observations of many ac- tive comets could not be well represented without the intro- duction of additional so-called nongravitational effects into the dynamical model. These effects are brought about by cometary activity when the sublimating ices transfer mo- mentum to the nucleus. The nongravitational effects become most evident as deviations in a comet’s perihelion passage when compared with a purely gravitational orbit, and these deviations are typically a fraction of a day per apparition, although for Comet 1P/Halley it is as large as four days.
Cometary Orbit Determination and Nongravitational Forces

And Whipple model was wrong as that’s not what is observed at 67P

So where does that leave
Newton's Principia formulated the laws of motion and universal gravitation that dominated scientists' view of the physical universe for the next three centuries. By deriving Kepler's laws of planetary motion from his mathematical description of gravity, and using the same principles to account for the trajectories of comets, the tides, the precession of the equinoxes, and other phenomena, Newton removed the last doubts about the validity of the heliocentric model of the Solar System and demonstrated that the motion of objects on Earth and of celestial bodies could be accounted for by the same principles. Newton's theoretical prediction that the Earth is shaped as an oblate spheroid was later vindicated by the geodetic measurements of Maupertuis, La Condamine, and others, thus convincing most Continental European scientists of the superiority of Newtonian mechanics over the earlier system of Descartes.
me old mate Sir Isaac Newton?

Einstein was a Mathamajical genius!
 
Correct or not jean tate? Would you answer a newbie to this thread?
You know I cannot answer such questions, Sol88! :p

I have no idea how you, Sol88, calculate orbits using the ELECTRIC COMET model (which is, after all, what this thread is about), nor even positions. Whether of traditional objects or comets.

Would you be so kind as to help us all? How do you, Sol88, calculate orbits and positions using the ELECTRIC COMET model?
 
Correct or not jean tate? Would you answer a newbie to this thread?

She or he did, at least to my satisfaction.

I am slightly surprised that you did not yourself presented an explanation like mine. Is that because there is something I still haven't grasped about the electric comet theory, that Jean Tate is pushing you to admit, but you would rather not?
 
Great news for ELECTRIC COMET model fans! :)

Hot off the press: "The Sublimative Torques of Jupiter Family Comets and Mass Wasting Events on Their Nuclei" (Steckloff&Samarasinha 2018)

Steckloff&Samarasinha said:
Sublimative outgassing of comets produces torques that alter the rotation state of their nuclei. Recently, parameterized sublimative torque models have been developed to study rotation state changes of individual comet nuclei and populations of cometary bodies. However, these models simplify the interactions between the escaping gas and cometary surface into only a few parameters that hide the details of these complex interactions. Here we directly compare the X-parameter model (Samarasinha & Mueller, 2013) with the SYORP model (Steckloff & Jacobson, 2016) to tease out insights into the details of the gas-surface interactions driving sublimative torques. We find that, for both of these models to accurately model sublimative torques, the number of sublimating molecules that contribute to the net torque is largely independent of the detailed shape and activity of the nucleus, but rather depends primarily on the size of the nucleus and the effective heliocentric distance of the comet. We suggest that cometary activity must be largely restricted to regions of steep gravitational surface slopes (above the angle of repose), where mass wasting can refresh activity by shedding mantles of refractory materials and exposing fresh volatiles. We propose a new classification scheme for comets based on the frequency of this mass-wasting process (relative to the timescale of activity fading): quasi-equilibrium, episodic, quasi-dormant, and extinct.

Hmm; on second thoughts, maybe not such good news for such fans ... Sol88?
 
Thanks.

Here's my revised summary, incorporating your comments etc. Feedback appreciated.

The ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)
1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103kgm−3
1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm

2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is usually negatively charged, but can also be positive (positively charged dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe

7) neutrals go along for the ride (not everything is ionised at the same time/energy)


There's an addition which RC wrote and to which Sol88 gave a thumbs' up, but I'm not sure if it's part of the ELECTRIC COMET model (Theory) or not:

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.
.

An update, taking this to a sufficiently stable state that I feel comfortable about beginning to critique/question/challenge/etc it seriously. As always, further revisions are welcome, from any ISF member who feels they know and understand it.

The ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103kgm−3
1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm

2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3aa) specifically, 1v to to 000’s Kv inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons
3ab) a lower range 1v to 000’s v out to aphelion and the comet is receiving electrons
3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is usually negatively charged, but can also be positive (positively charged dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe

7) neutrals go along for the ride (not everything is ionised at the same time/energy)
 
My first question about the ELECTRIC COMET model to you, Sol88, is one that we touched on before (but didn't really run to ground).

It concerns the very first word, "comet".

Observationally (or, if you prefer, empirically), comets are fuzzy/tailed things in the sky which move (relative to the stars). Interestingly, the term is used for an object which may exhibit a coma ("fuzz") or tail(s) only some of the time, e.g. Main Belt Comets (or at least some of them).

As written, the ELECTRIC COMET model is at least somewhat ambiguous: does "comet" refer to what we have, historically, observed (and may observe in future)?
Is it a "theoretical" concept, as such not directly related to what we may (or may not) observe?
Something else?

Clarification please, Sol88! :)
 
I don't want to overwhelm you Sol88, but I'd like to have two serious questions about the ELECTRIC COMET model in the pipeline; hope you don't mind.

My second question about the ELECTRIC COMET model to you, Sol88, concerns this:
1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids

What are the main minerals or mineraloids which comprise the rock?
 
Usual lies about the working comet model

Cometary Orbit Determination and Nongravitational Forces

And Whipple model was wrong as that’s not what is observed at 67P

So where does that leave
2 May 2018: Usual lies about the working comet model

Whipple's model is still correct because comets are still made of ices and dust as observed at several comets including 67P. What has changed in Whipple's model is that we have known for some time that activity such as jets is tends to happen in small areas and that a typical comet has more dust than ices.

2 May 2018: An insane delusion that Newtonian gravitation is wrong :jaw-dropp!
Where observations over the last more than 300 years leaves Newtonian gravitation is that it is correct except in strong gravity and relativistic speeds where GR is better.
 
Last edited:
Great news for ELECTRIC COMET model fans! :)

Hot off the press: "The Sublimative Torques of Jupiter Family Comets and Mass Wasting Events on Their Nuclei" (Steckloff&Samarasinha 2018)



Hmm; on second thoughts, maybe not such good news for such fans ... Sol88?


Do we observe this on 67P? :rolleyes:

This would require pressurised subsurface chambers expelling gas thru a nozzle. Unfortunately we are yet to see this, the 67P movie doing the rounds atm comes to mind.

The sublimation model of comets (Whipples) is not viable, so you maybe able to use the paper when you go to snap one off on the morning.
 
She or he did, at least to my satisfaction.

I am slightly surprised that you did not yourself presented an explanation like mine. Is that because there is something I still haven't grasped about the electric comet theory, that Jean Tate is pushing you to admit, but you would rather not?

Well just come out and say it. :D

Lay the cards on the table as such.
 
You know I cannot answer such questions, Sol88! :p

I have no idea how you, Sol88, calculate orbits using the ELECTRIC COMET model (which is, after all, what this thread is about), nor even positions. Whether of traditional objects or comets.

Would you be so kind as to help us all? How do you, Sol88, calculate orbits and positions using the ELECTRIC COMET model?


No different than you do jean tate.

Like I said, your question is beyond the scope of this thread.

If you’d like to talk gravity, orbits etc etc perhaps you’d like to start a new thread and we can talk about the GRAND TACK AND NICE MODELS alone with GALAXY ROTATIONS! :thumbsup:

This thread is specifically about the failure of Whipple model and the success of the ELECTRIC COMET!
 
I don't want to overwhelm you Sol88, but I'd like to have two serious questions about the ELECTRIC COMET model in the pipeline; hope you don't mind.

My second question about the ELECTRIC COMET model to you, Sol88, concerns this:
1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids

What are the main minerals or mineraloids which comprise the rock?

Overwhelmingly silicate, along with carbonates, clays, high temperature minerals like olivine, aluminium, magnesium, iron...etc you know rock!

Whilst not an exhaustive list, you get the gist.
 
No different than you do jean tate.
huh?

Sol88, I have no idea how to calculate orbits and positions per the ELECTRIC COMET model.

Like I said, your question is beyond the scope of this thread.
Huh?

This thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model, so it is entirely pertinent to ask about how, using the ELECTRIC COMET model, one calculates (or estimates) the orbits and positions of comets.

And, as far as I know, you are the only ISF member who might know how to do that.

It’s perfectly OK to say that you, Sol88, do not know how such a thing is done. Even in principle.

If you’d like to talk gravity, orbits etc etc perhaps you’d like to start a new thread and we can talk about the GRAND TACK AND NICE MODELS alone with GALAXY ROTATIONS! :thumbsup:

This thread is specifically about the failure of Whipple model and the success of the ELECTRIC COMET!
Again, to repeat, my interest in this set of questions is how you, Sol88, calculate/estimate positions and orbits of comets, using the ELECTRIC COMET model.

Oh, and FTFY (see this thread’s title :p)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom