The Doc vs Pdoherty - Debate Underway

The Doc said:
I noticed p'doh has replied to my last post. Is anyone else finding these one-liner responses dull?
Click to expand...

Strawman

Myself and Pdoherty have posted:
Click to expand...

Irrelevant

1x Opening Statement
3x Replies
Click to expand...

Wrong.

We are down to closing statements ladies and gentlemen.
Click to expand...

_41606720_silverstein203ap.jpg

Jew!
 
The debate is over. Closing statements have been made by both sides.
 
jaydeehess said:
BINGO, and he does say 'eh'.

BTW, I am east of Winnipeg but west of (way west of) Toronto
Click to expand...

That likely puts you either in London or Windsor, or somewhere near those two (if in Ontario).

MG1962:

"Iron Knob" is hillarious. Seems the Aussies have the same flavor for "off the wall" names as do Canadian East Coasters.

TAM:)
 
The Doc said:
The debate is over. Closing statements have been made by both sides.
Click to expand...
Doc, Why did you even bother to say anything? PDoh beat himself on his first post. He doesn't know the meaning of the word "debate". You do know he will claim he owned you?
 
DGM said:
Doc, Why did you even bother to say anything? PDoh beat himself on his first post. He doesn't know the meaning of the word "debate". You do know he will claim he owned you?
Click to expand...

Yeah, I saw the thread on SLC.
 
This Pdoh gem is something:

The Doc also fails to explain the complete logical inconsistency of his belief that the firefighters were certain of collapse, yet the official body investigating the collapse does not know why it collapsed. If the collapse was a foregone conclusion to the firefighters on the scene then the report should be very easy to write.
Click to expand...

So firefighters are structural engineers now? Because they knew the building was in jeopardy they could write the report?

:rolleyes:
 
Terrific top-gun performance, Maverick/Doc. The skies are now clear.

"We got a Mig/Pdoh circling around our left side, Mav! He's gonna get behind us! Do some of that pilot stuff, Mav!"

"Just stay with me, Merlin, I'm gonna bring him in closer."

"Closer?!? Pdoh's right on our six he's going for missile lock! Maverick!"

"Okay I've had about enough of this s##t, Merlin. I'm gonna hit the brakes, he'll fly right by..."

"That's it, Mav, you're on his tail!"

"Roger that, c'mon baby, lock up, lock up. I got him! I got tone Merlin, fire it!"

Well, at least Pdoh punched out of his stricken Mig before it went down. Hope somebody rescues him... Ah hah! There's a Loose Copter! He'll be okay...
 
Does Pdoh even know what a formal debate is??? Cripes, that was a mess. Good work Doc, at least we know that one of the people in that debate was (mostly) sane. :)

Cheers,
TGHO
 
Jeez, that was really pathetic on pDohs post, he just made one claim then treated the rest like a regular forum, it was supposed to be a formal debate, and he lost, big time.
 
The Great Hairy One said:
Does Pdoh even know what a formal debate is??? Cripes, that was a mess. Good work Doc, at least we know that one of the people in that debate was (mostly) sane. :)

Cheers,
TGHO
Click to expand...

It seems apparent that pdoh does not know the first thing about a formal debate.

Good work by The Doc in maintaining decorum and sticking to the debate format even in the face of pdoh's inability to comprehend the basics.

NeoRicen said:
Jeez, that was really pathetic on pDohs post, he just made one claim then treated the rest like a regular forum, it was supposed to be a formal debate, and he lost, big time.
Click to expand...

Agreed on all points.
 
Good job, Doc. You presented your arguments in a clear manner. It is interesting to watch PDoh try to debate without actually providing evidence to support his conclusions.
 
The Doc said:
The debate is over. Closing statements have been made by both sides.
Click to expand...

Well to be honest, while you did a good job of showing him up, I really don't think it achieved anything. We'll alkl agree that you proved your case and he failed to, and over on Loose Change I bet they are saying that he proved his and you just resorted to logical facacies and doddged the relevant points he made, so really, we're nowhere further then we were before.
 
PhantomWolf said:
Well to be honest, while you did a good job of showing him up, I really don't think it achieved anything. We'll alkl agree that you proved your case and he failed to, and over on Loose Change I bet they are saying that he proved his and you just resorted to logical facacies and doddged the relevant points he made, so really, we're nowhere further then we were before.
Click to expand...

No, I completely agree.

At least now, though, he can't say that no debunkers will debate him. We also have provided a bit of publicity for the site so we can get some major debates going.

I never expected anyone at LC or pdoh himself to change their minds as a result of this debate. That wasn't my intention at all.
 
Here was the Loose Change Forum reaction to the debate.

Does anybody care?
Click to expand...

Not really.
Click to expand...

Nope.
Click to expand...

The premise of the debate sound like bull[rule 8], so no, don't care.
Click to expand...

The Doc set up a debate site........... oh wow :rolleyes:
Click to expand...


And so, their apathy begins to take over their ignorance as their defining characteristic.

I'm not sure if that's a good sign or a bad sign?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom