The Death of Religion – not with a bang but a whimper

A new article in the NY Times, Scandinavian Nonbelievers, Which Is Not to Say Atheists, also shows that if people have reason to feel secure and safe because the conditions of life are, if not top notch then at least more than tolerable as far as ”life expectancy, child welfare, literacy, schooling, economic equality, standard of living” are concerned, they seem to lose the need to believe.

No heroic rebellion against religion seems to be necessary. Religion just dies away because the opium of the people isn’t necessary any more. Instead of militant atheist rejection of religion, you find “benign indifference” and even “utter obliviousness.”
And what is even more surprising: When the threats to your everyday life disappears, the fear of death also seems to dwindle:
“It is possible for a society to exist in which most people don’t really fear death all that much,” he concluded, “and simultaneously don’t give a great deal of thought to the meaning of life.”
I.e. when life seems to make (some kind of) sense, people don’t need to seek the meaning of life beyond reality.

Religion has not disappeared in Scandinavia – poverty has not disappeared either, but it is not usually the kind of abject, hopeless poverty that does not make you see a way out of your problems in this world.
The USA is the wealthier and more powerful nation, but it lacks the social safety net of Scandinavia, making your existence more insecure.
Does this mean that the Icelanders are going to turn into Bible-thumpers now that their economy has tanked?
 
It’s hard to tell, but it is not impossible. They appear to have been fairly secularised Lutherans, but they might also consider reviving Norse paganism. :vk:
In the upcoming elections the right-wing Independence Party seems to be the major loser, so at least the Icelanders appear to have lost their faith in the local version of ‘Reaganomics’. (And I’m pretty sure that the local Libertarian Society has a hard time convincing people that ”promoting the values of a free-market economy” is the way to go right now.)

There have been protests against the financial policies of the Icelandic government, which were blamed for the present financial crisis in Iceland. Now that fish and Björk seem to be the only solid Icelandic export articles, they might also consider applying for the position as Danish colony that they gave up in 1944 … Unfortunately I don’t think that the recent lesson on the character, performance and power of finance capital has made the Icelanders consider giving up the market economy and realize the necessity of communism.
 
God isn't quite dead yet, but he isn't doing well

Indre Mission (Wikipedia) was the last, fairly big group of Lutheran fundamentalists within the Danish National Church (Wikipedia). "Its traditional dogmas condemned drinking, dancing, card playing, swearing and working on a Sunday." The founders of LEGO (Wikipedia) belonged to Indre Mission.

In the last ten years, more than one third of Inner Mission’s mission houses in Denmark have disappeared, and the magazine Inner Mission Gazette has lost 1,700 subscribers in the recent seven years.
At the same time more local branches report that they they don't have any back up, among other places at Jegindø.
This development makes Ernst Møller sad.
- I feel bad about this. A lot of mission houses have been closed because nobody shows up. People nowadays no longer need God, he says.
(…)
”LOOK FOR THE LORD WHILE HE IS STILL HERE,” a sign in the mission house at Jegindø says.
Inner Mission is bleeding: 'The only thing we can do is to pray' (DR.dk, Nov. 17, 2019)
 
Personal god versions are alive and well.

I scrap stuff for good metals, hate messing with all the tin by product. This morning I packed out about 80 lbs of it to get it gone. About 1/3 of the way I bumped into an older guy that scraps everything as his retirement income.

I unloaded all into his cart and he thanked God for this after he thanked me. I thanked him for saving me from lugging it across town.

He didn't forget his God in sending him this unexpected windfall he needed. Even though my belief is far different, I had no idea who I might see on the way but any scrapper would have gotten lucky.
 
Personal god versions are alive and well.
(...)
About 1/3 of the way I bumped into an older guy that scraps everything as his retirement income.


You make it very obvious why the older guy you met needs religion, why he can't do without the opium of the people.

A new article in the NY Times, Scandinavian Nonbelievers, Which Is Not to Say Atheists, also shows that if people have reason to feel secure and safe because the conditions of life are, if not top notch then at least more than tolerable as far as ”life expectancy, child welfare, literacy, schooling, economic equality, standard of living” are concerned, they seem to lose the need to believe.

No heroic rebellion against religion seems to be necessary. Religion just dies away because the opium of the people isn’t necessary any more. Instead of militant atheist rejection of religion, you find “benign indifference” and even “utter obliviousness.”
And what is even more surprising: When the threats to your everyday life disappears, the fear of death also seems to dwindle:
“It is possible for a society to exist in which most people don’t really fear death all that much,” he concluded, “and simultaneously don’t give a great deal of thought to the meaning of life.”
I.e. when life seems to make (some kind of) sense, people don’t need to seek the meaning of life beyond reality.

Religion has not disappeared in Scandinavia – poverty has not disappeared either, but it is not usually the kind of abject, hopeless poverty that does not make you see a way out of your problems in this world.
The USA is the wealthier and more powerful nation, but it lacks the social safety net of Scandinavia, making your existence more insecure.
 
I started this thread 17 years ago after the article Scandinavian Nonbelievers, Which Is Not to Say Atheists had appeared in the New York Times on Feb 27, 2009. It was based on Phil Zuckerman's book Society Without God: What the Least Religious Nations Can Tell Us About Contentment from 2008:
Before he began his recent travels, it seemed to Phil Zuckerman as if humans all over the globe were "getting religion"—praising deities, performing holy rites, and soberly defending the world from sin. But most residents of Denmark and Sweden, he found, don't worship any god at all, don't pray, and don't give much credence to religious dogma of any kind.
Since then, the USA seems have been going in the same direction, albeit very slowly, with a drop of 17 percent:
Drop in U.S. Religiosity Among Largest in World (Gallup News, Nov 13, 2025)
About half of Americans now say religion is not an important part of their daily life.
A couple of other countries, mostly in Europe, have seen similar or even greater declines in religion.

However, Trump was recently heard saying this:
Visibly Declining Trump Says He’s DESPERATE To Get Into Heaven (Farron Balanced on YouTube, May 21, 2026 – 7:40 min.)
3:24--> I think religion is very important for a country. This country was built largely on religion. When you have strong religion, you have less crime. It's just a fact. Whatever it may be, it's like, 'Gee, I want to go to heaven, so I'm not going to do this or that. Who knows? Religion is a good thing. Christianity is the great thing for our country. The successes that we've had have been based on Christianity and religion. I'm very proud of that. Religion is taking off like our country is taking off. Our country is hotter now than it's ever been. And I'll tell you, religion is making a tremendous comeback. You look at churches today, they're full. You go back two or three years, nobody was going.

Now, we all know that Trump's alleged facts are always very alternative. It's not true that strong religion makes crime go down, for instance. Farron Cousins points it out in the video. And Trump's other claims are contradicted by the Gallup poll mentioned above, unless much has changed since November '25.
But what about church attendance? Is it true that "churches today, they're full"? Is that 'fact' as made up as the rest of them? Or has something happened in the last six months to give credence to Trump's claim?

Google AI claims that,
While overall membership trends continue to decline, congregational median attendance ticked up for the first time in 25 years as established churches stabilize. About 25% to 26% of Americans attend weekly, with a growing divide between active participants and those who have left entirely.
However, surveys like this one aren't exact science, and Pew mentions this peculiar factoid:
8. Religious attendance and congregational involvement (Pew Research, Feb 26, 2025)
Research shows that telephone surveys tend to produce higher estimates of religious attendance than web/paper surveys do.
In other words, people don't want to be judged, and if they somehow feel bad about not going to church, they may lie and say that they do.
Are there any other sources that can confirm or disprove Trump's claim? "And I'll tell you, religion is making a tremendous comeback. You look at churches today, they're full. You go back two or three years, nobody was going." I.e. a rise in church attendance. Let's not get into Trump's hyperbole: "full" vs. "nobody."
 
TBH, I'm not even convinced that religion is fading out. It seems to be more like fracturing and mutating. Children of devout evangelical parents just go Wica or Netjer (the later being an idiocy that a term the Ancient Egyptians never used except in the plural "all gods",) means just one monotheistic god (then why the ◊◊◊◊◊ plural?), and depicted differently by god in each painting (why the different shape if it's the same god?), and never referred to as such in any prayer or tomb "spellbook", and isn't reflected in any Pharoh name, etc... just to piss off their parents.

So yeeah... goth kids just find some other religion to piss their parents off with, rather than go atheistic.

And hey, not blaming anyone, Just... it's not really religion fading, is it?
 
HansMustermann is baaack!!!

In New Zealand it's definitely fading. In the 2023 census it was 52% no religion, 32% Christian, 3% Hindu, 1.5% Muslim and 1.3% indigenous Maori.

Anecdotally most people here don't discuss religion except to poke fun at it. before I retired I worked with a guy who I'm pretty sure was deeply religious, but he never mentioned it and I didn't ask. That's a big contrast from 30 years ago when Christian workmates would be quite open about it and even try to push their religion onto me.

Most Christians in New Zealand are old, and as they die their numbers dwindle. Around here there a lot of Indians and Pacific Islanders who mostly do seasonal work. They tend to be strongly religious, but their total numbers are low. Their offspring who reside here will probably become less religious.

We get a few Mormon missionaries from the US here too. They probably come here thinking they will get easy pickings, then quickly find out nobody's got any time for them. The last two I talked to were quite coy about who they represented. Mormonism was popular with Maori where I live, but that seems to be fading too.
 
Maybe fading in more developed parts of the world, but it never seems to go away completely and I can't foresee that it will, given human nature.
 
Where Religion serves the population it will never go away.
Where it just serves the the people in charge it will be swiped away
 
@Roger Ramjets
I have no idea what the percentages were in the past, though, to estimate if it's really on the decline. Today is probably the safest time in history to say you don't believe. And I don't just mean the inquisition, but even just being ostracised by your community if you didn't go through the motions.

True story, my great grandma kinda got the same idea long before, when she first heard a different priest in a different church reading the bible translated, not in Latin. Quoth her, "dear god, such stupidity..." But she still went through the motions.

So, anyway, I wouldn't be surprised if many people in the past were also sceptical of it, but just less likely to say so publicly.
 
Last edited:
In the UK the far right is trying to camouflage themselves in Christianity - which is ironic given that it is immigrants that are much more likely to be regular church goers than British born folk!
 
THAT too. A god that always agrees with you can be used to justify anything. As indeed it was at least since the ancient Sumerians.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom