The Book of Dust

Foster Zygote

Dental Floss Tycoon
Joined
Jun 24, 2006
Messages
23,522
I was wondering if anyone else has read volumes one and two of Philip Pullman's 'The Book of Dust'?

Starting last summer I reread 'La Belle Sauvage', then I reread the 'His Dark Materials' trilogy in anticipation of 'The Secret Commonwealth', which I finished a couple of weeks ago.
 
I have! I have!

Sorry for not responding sooner. I wanted to start a new thread on the His Dark Materials HBO series, and this came up in my search to make sure there wasn't a prior one.

I read ALL of the books, including the supplementary ones. And, I saw the 2007 movie, and I am currently halfway through the HBO series.

So, we can talk about anything you want.

Good stuff, eh?
 
I have the original HDM novels autographed by Pullman when I saw him at a Humanist conference in Washington D.C., once. They're all very good: In fact I think I like them better than Harry Potter, overall! The first ("Golden Compass" or "Northern Lights") is definitely the best, The Amber Spyglass is second-best; and the middle book, The Subtle Knife, is probably the least good of the three.

Once Upon a Time in the North is a very entertaining read. And, Lyra's Oxford is good, but not quite to the same level as everything else.

Actually, I did NOT read The Collectors e-book, yet. Maybe I should do that. Almost forgot it existed until I started this post.

I thought that the 2007 movie, with Nichole Kidman and Daniel Craig, was actually quite good, for the most part, except for the ending, which was rushed and vital parts were cut off from it. I am a bit miffed about that.

La Belle Sauvage was waay better than I expected it to be, in fact. A good, solid, complete story; that serves as a worthy prequel. When re-reading the original trilogy, it does become a bit weird that the great flood is never mentioned in them. But, I suppose things could be worse. Pullman seems to be waaay better at writing prequels than both George Lucas and J.K. Rowling.

The Secret Commonwealth feels a bit forced, to me. It's still good, and has it's moments. And, we'll see how it ends in the next book. But, I can't help but feel that it's a bunch of misc. ideas tacked onto each other.

I will talk about the HBO series in its own thread, perhaps. But, that will have to come a bit later.
 
So, now I finished reading The Collectors. And, it's not really that big of a deal. Perhaps there is some hidden importance to it, that I will find out later. But, so far as I can tell, the story barely even needs to be part of the HDM universe, at all.


ETA: Ah Ha! The fan wiki explains it: "Pullman originally wanted to write a classic ghost story. It was Audible's idea to link it with His Dark Materials."
Source: https://hisdarkmaterials.fandom.com/wiki/The_Collectors
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom