The Biggest Elephant in the Parlor

pomeroo

Banned
Joined
Oct 30, 2006
Messages
7,081
Well-informed rationalists have done splendid work in dissecting and demolishing the myths, canards, and outright falsehoods peddled by the 9/11 fantasy movement. While the conspiracy liars have been shown to be wrong about all of their specific claims, it seems to me that they have been let off easy. The biggest elephant in the room is the massive, multi-agency investigation that identified the hijackers. Here was the ultimate forensic test for crime fighting agencies, and it required the participation of 7,000 agents from the FBI alone.

I learned on the far-left talk show CLOUT that fantasists will simply dismiss the findings of this enormously comprehensive effort with a wave of their hand. The rabid America-hater Elias Davidsson was reduced to sputtering incoherence when I pointed out that he was lying about the flight mainfests. But, here's the point: if the flight manifests really do show the seating positions of the hijackers, then the whole fantasy movement evaporates. The liars must deny that the case has been solved, but we never press them on the details.

Tell us, fantasists, how you know that the FBI is fabricating evidence. More importantly, explain how the Impossibly Vast Conspiracy gained control of America's most prominent law enforcement agency and subverted it to complicity, if not active participation, in a monstrous crime.

Again, DNA testing revealed that the remains of the passengers and crews of the hijacked planes were found at the crash sites. You must deny this or your evil fantasy is dead. How do you deny it? The twoofer "Sizzler" ineptly tried pretending that he knows more about the science of forensic detection than the FBI lab technicians. He was unconvincing. Can you do better?
 
Last edited:
Good point. I have not heard the CFs comment on this one other than crap like "The hijackers are still alive" nonsense. Its not likely that you are going to get much out of them in this thread though.
 
Good point. I have not heard the CFs comment on this one other than crap like "The hijackers are still alive" nonsense. Its not likely that you are going to get much out of them in this thread though.


You nailed it! I expect very little from the bad guys. This is, as we used to say, the nitty-gritty: WHY ISN'T THE CASE SOLVED?
 
pomeroo,

Is this another of your mythical creatures, like the rabid attack dog Democrats on the 9/11 Commission? Are you suggesting that the whole FBI needs to be turned in order to permit a conspiracy?
 
pomeroo,

Is this another of your mythical creatures, like the rabid attack dog Democrats on the 9/11 Commission? Are you suggesting that the whole FBI needs to be turned in order to permit a conspiracy?



By contrast with your mythical creatures, my creatures are not myths at all. Seven thousand FBI agents participated in the massive investigation that identified the hijackers. Evidence, according to you liars, was fabricated AT EVERY LEVEL! The passenger manifests were faked--implicating the airlines in the crime; the chain of custody for the remains to be tested was compromised--by whom?

The Bush-loathing Democrats on the 9/11 Commission, in your hopelessly absurd fantasy, cooperated in covering up the crimes of a man they despise. To us rationalists, this makes no sense. It is your task to explain why your imaginary conspiracy perpetrated a mass murder in order to elect more Democrats to Congress. Above all, it is your task to show the evidence for the FBI's involvement in this monstrous crime.
 
Well-informed rationalists have done splendid work in dissecting and demolishing the myths, canards, and outright falsehoods peddled by the 9/11 fantasy movement. While the conspiracy liars have been shown to be wrong about all of their specific claims, it seems to me that they have been let off easy. The biggest elephant in the room is the massive, multi-agency investigation that identified the hijackers. Here was the ultimate forensic test for crime fighting agencies, and it required the participation of 7,000 agents from the FBI alone.

I learned on the far-left talk show CLOUT that fantasists will simply dismiss the findings of this enormously comprehensive effort with a wave of their hand. The rabid America-hater Elias Davidsson was reduced to sputtering incoherence when I pointed out that he was lying about the flight mainfests. But, here's the point: if the flight manifests really do show the seating positions of the hijackers, then the whole fantasy movement evaporates. The liars must deny that the case has been solved, but we never press them on the details.

Tell us, fantasists, how you know that the FBI is fabricating evidence. More importantly, explain how the Impossibly Vast Conspiracy gained control of America's most prominent law enforcement agency and subverted it to complicity, if not active participation, in a monstrous crime.

Again, DNA testing revealed that the remains of the passengers and crews of the hijacked planes were found at the crash sites. You must deny this or your evil fantasy is dead. How do you deny it? The twoofer "Sizzler" ineptly tried pretending that he knows more about the science of forensic detection than the FBI lab technicians. He was unconvincing. Can you do better?

You are quite correct. It seems to be a never ending chase.

Truther: There were no hijackers, as they were not on the flight manifests.

Debunker: Here is a record of one of the manifests, listing the alleged hijackers.

Truther: Well how do we know that manifest is real. And if it is, how do we know that the persons presenting themselves as "Hijacker X" was in fact that person, and not someone else who had stolen their identity?

Debunker: Here is DNA evidence matching 2 of the 9/11 hijackers that attacked the WTCs.

Truther: Well how do we know the DNA evidence is real? The FBI provided it, so it might be faked.

and on it goes...

TAM:)
 
You are quite correct. It seems to be a never ending chase.

Truther: There were no hijackers, as they were not on the flight manifests.

Debunker: Here is a record of one of the manifests, listing the alleged hijackers.

Truther: Well how do we know that manifest is real. And if it is, how do we know that the persons presenting themselves as "Hijacker X" was in fact that person, and not someone else who had stolen their identity?

Debunker: Here is DNA evidence matching 2 of the 9/11 hijackers that attacked the WTCs.

Truther: Well how do we know the DNA evidence is real? The FBI provided it, so it might be faked.

and on it goes...

TAM:)


Do you see, TAM, how this is the crux of the whole matter? Either the FBI solved the case or it didn't. Tell us why it didn't. How do you know?
 
Specifically, the no-planers are accusing this person, and those she worked with, of perjury. From page 267 of Firefight.

Special Agent Tara Bloesch was assigned to set up the morgue. She had all the right experience- before joining the FBI, she'd worked as a forensic investigator near Philadelphia and as a parole officer in the city itself. With the FBI, Bloesch had helped run morgue operations in Kosovo and Serbia, documenting war crimes and mass graves, after NATO troops intervened in the war there in 1999. Her colleagues knew her as an articulate, tough Philly girl who didn't blanch at difficult jobs. She would keep the morgue under tight control.

O'Connor needed other people to work with her. He gathered several dozen agents on the lawn, near the helipad, to sort out who would deal with remains, evidence, and other aspects of the huge job. "Obviously we'll be doing a lot of human remains and body recovery," he announced to the crowd. "If you're comfortable doing that step over here. If you're not, that's okay, because I need people doing other things too." More than half the group moved to the spot he had indicated. Then he added, "This is not a normal event. If anybody needs to talk to someone, nobody's going to think any less of you."
 
This is an excellent point, Ron. I think this point, more than any other, demonstrates the utter inability of the conspiracists to think critically and objectively.

The conspiracists maintain that because the evidence came from the government (eg. an FBI investigation), it must be false and cannot be trusted. Instead of saying "It's from the government, who I believe to be responsible for this event, I must look at it very closely", they essentially say "It's from the government, I need not even examine this counter evidence because it is wrong". It's all circular logic. They can't trust government evidence because the government did 9/11, but they dismiss all counter-evidence because it comes from the government who apparently did 9/11.

Instead of objectively looking at each piece of government evidence objectively, they dismiss it straight away. This is a fundamental flaw in logic, and should speak volumes about the conspiracists to someone who's sitting on the fence with this issue.
 
derail moved - please stay on topic.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
You are quite correct. It seems to be a never ending chase.

Truther: There were no hijackers, as they were not on the flight manifests.

Debunker: Here is a record of one of the manifests, listing the alleged hijackers.

Truther: Well how do we know that manifest is real. And if it is, how do we know that the persons presenting themselves as "Hijacker X" was in fact that person, and not someone else who had stolen their identity?

Debunker: Here is DNA evidence matching 2 of the 9/11 hijackers that attacked the WTCs.

Truther: Well how do we know the DNA evidence is real? The FBI provided it, so it might be faked.

and on it goes...

TAM:)

Its funny though with the flight manifest thing that the troofers have never produced a copy of what claims to be the original manifest document that doesn't contain the hijackers names. Surely such a thing must exist and they must have seen it in order to be making the claim in the first place? ;)
 
Well, that sucks; I thought this thread was going to be about elephants. I love elephants.
 
Does anyone have a rough idea what percentage of CTers deny that there were hijackers on the planes? And do you know the positions of the prominent CTers on this? Thanks
 
Does anyone have a rough idea what percentage of CTers deny that there were hijackers on the planes? And do you know the positions of the prominent CTers on this? Thanks

Alex Jones, Steven Jones, David Ray Griffin, Chris Bollyn, Carol Valentine, Eric Hufschmid, Killtown, Dylan Avery, Jason Bermas, Korey Rowe, Richard Gage
 
Alex Jones, Steven Jones, David Ray Griffin, Chris Bollyn, Carol Valentine, Eric Hufschmid, Killtown, Dylan Avery, Jason Bermas, Korey Rowe, Richard Gage

And the positions of the prominent CT'ers on this is that they refuse to take a position on it, if Griffin's anything to go by.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom