Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Biden Administration left behind Americans that wanted to leave and lied about it and your reaction is to complain about the right wing media blasting him?

Wait a minute. They didn't lie about leaving Americans behind. The problems were that they couldn't GET to some of them to get them out, some waited so long to make up their minds until it was too late and the date that the Taliban would allow us to stay per our agreement came. Still other US citizens have chosen to stay behind because they have family there. Our government is still working with the Taliban leaders to get Americans out. As it is, the Taliban have said the will allow all foreigners to leave the country safely. If Biden had broken our agreement to leave by Aug. 31 what kind of cooperation do you think he'd get?
 
True, but that is due to a myriad of reasons including the Taliban not letting people through to the airport. But half of Afghanistan wanted out, too.

It's a sad situation but I don't think we ever could have gotten everyone out who wanted to leave.

Why did Biden trust the Taliban to allow safe passage of Americans to the airport?

And why is Biden sticking to that deadline when he stated a few days ago that the US would not leave until we got all the Americans out?
 
That’s quite the takeaway.

Considering that the Trump administration purposely stalled visas for years for interpreters et al who worked for us, drastically reduced the amount of refugees allowed in by 80%, and stopped all SIV interviews in Kabul for a year, yeah....I don't think they were planning on getting many of them out.

Factor in that, a week after he lost the election, he wrote a memo to take all our military out before January 20 (when Biden would be inaugurated) and was only talked out of it because the Pentagon told him Kabul and the country could fall during his watch. Just how many of our Afghan allies do you think would have been gotten out then? Remember that Trump doesn't give a flying F(ig) what happens to anyone but himself.

A top Homeland Security adviser to former Vice President Mike Pence accused the Trump administration of distorting the truth about Afghan refugees, writing on Twitter that the former president and Stephen Miller, his top immigration adviser, sought to prevent the refugees from entering the United States.
In an interview, Olivia Troye recalled sitting in meetings where Miller demanded restrictions on refugees, including those from Afghanistan and Iraq. She said the reductions in the refugee program during Donald Trump’s presidency hollowed out the government’s ability to bring the interpreters and others to the United States.
“Now we are in this crisis and they are saying Trump would have evacuated them,” Troye said. “But he didn’t in four years. You don’t get to play revisionist history here. There are people who know what the situation is.”
https://www.seattletimes.com/nation...mp-and-miller-stymied-afghan-refugee-efforts/
The Biden administration was scrambling to clear a backlog of thousands of Special Immigrant Visa (SIV) applications to the U.S. that had piled up in Afghanistan for a year after in-person interviews with applicants were suspended.
The two officials, who spoke with Axios on condition of anonymity, said that in-person interviews — a crucial step in the visa application process — were suspended at the U.S. Embassy in Kabul in March of 2020 under the Trump administration due to COVID-19 protocols.

They said they were resumed in Biden's second week in office.
"Alarmed" was the emotion one of the officials used to describe the feeling when they found that "there was no plan from the Trump administration on how to move Afghan civilians out of the country, even though they had committed to leaving the country by May 1. So we began building one from scratch."
https://www.axios.com/afghan-allies...use-99e21c9a-c081-4a66-b5ae-74301bafdb25.html
 
Why did Biden trust the Taliban to allow safe passage of Americans to the airport?

Because 1) the Taliban controlled the city and 2) the Taliban wants us out. It was to their benefit that Americans left safely.

And why is Biden sticking to that deadline when he stated a few days ago that the US would not leave until we got all the Americans out?

For the reasons I just stated. Also, he qualified what he was saying about staying past the deadline:

"We're going to do everything in our power to get all Americans out and our allies out."

"It depends on where we are and whether we can ramp these numbers up to five to seven thousand a day coming out. If that's the case, they'll all be out."


Watch the larger clip of the interview with Stephanopoulos:

https://twitter.com/i/status/1428111847656497155
 
Why did Biden trust the Taliban to allow safe passage of Americans to the airport?

Would you have prefered that the US Marines forced their way through Taliban lines and turned Kabul into a shooting gallery?

And why is Biden sticking to that deadline when he stated a few days ago that the US would not leave until we got all the Americans out?

Because it's the best option. If the Taliban are saying that they're committed to cooperating if you do what you say and leave when you need to, and part of that cooperation is allowing anyone that wants to leave to leave, would you really want to jeopardize that cooperation by not upholding your end and potentially wind up with a slaughter?
 
Would you have prefered that the US Marines forced their way through Taliban lines and turned Kabul into a shooting gallery?



Because it's the best option. If the Taliban are saying that they're committed to cooperating if you do what you say and leave when you need to, and part of that cooperation is allowing anyone that wants to leave to leave, would you really want to jeopardize that cooperation by not upholding your end and potentially wind up with a slaughter?

This is why we need to have at least one course in high school on critical thinking. Although some may have to repeat it.
 
This is why we need to have at least one course in high school on critical thinking. Although some may have to repeat it.

Knowing how to think critically is one thing. Being willing to actually apply that knowledge fairly is another.

Lots of intelligent Republicans certainly understand the former. It's the latter that they fail horrendously at.
 
Last edited:
Knowing how to think critically is one thing. Being willing to actually apply that knowledge fairly is another.

Lots of intelligent Republicans certainly understand the former. It's the latter that they fail horrendously at.

True.

“Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity.”

Martin Luther King
 
Considering that the Trump administration purposely stalled visas for years for interpreters et al who worked for us, drastically reduced the amount of refugees allowed in by 80%, and stopped all SIV interviews in Kabul for a year, yeah....I don't think they were planning on getting many of them out.

Factor in that, a week after he lost the election, he wrote a memo to take all our military out before January 20 (when Biden would be inaugurated) and was only talked out of it because the Pentagon told him Kabul and the country could fall during his watch. Just how many of our Afghan allies do you think would have been gotten out then? Remember that Trump doesn't give a flying F(ig) what happens to anyone but himself.

The Biden Administration left Afghanistan without coordinating with our allies that joined in to support us for 20 years, repeatedly lied to the world about conditions on the ground, assured everyone he'd evacuate every American who wants to leave Afghanistan (but didn't), and left the Taliban as one of the best armed militaries in the world.

And when you look back and think on that, your takeaway is that Trump doesn't give a flying F(ig) what happens to anyone but himself?

Just about every other thread on this forum is about Trump, eventually. This thread is specifically titled The Biden Presidency, Joe Biden is the current President, Trump has been out of office for close to a year, and isn't even on Twitter any more.
 
This is why we need to have at least one course in high school on critical thinking. Although some may have to repeat it.

I think it would be almost impossible to get broad agreement on the contents of such a course. I doubt the right-wing and the evangelicals would support a course that teaches kids to question authority, examine evidence, demand proof, assess bias, etc.

Many school systems used to teach a course about how the government worked, not in a partisan way but about the basic facts of federal, state and local governance, elections, communicating with representatives and officials, etc., but even they have mostly been dropped.
 
This is why we need to have at least one course in high school on critical thinking. Although some may have to repeat it.

Yeah the Republicans are already literally, their words not mine, working on getting that outlawed in Texas so don't hold your breath.

Critical thinking is just a commie plot that moves America away from Jesus.
 
The Biden Administration left Afghanistan without coordinating with our allies that joined in to support us for 20 years, repeatedly lied to the world about conditions on the ground, assured everyone he'd evacuate every American who wants to leave Afghanistan (but didn't), and left the Taliban as one of the best armed militaries in the world.

And when you look back and think on that, your takeaway is that Trump doesn't give a flying F(ig) what happens to anyone but himself?

Just about every other thread on this forum is about Trump, eventually. This thread is specifically titled The Biden Presidency, Joe Biden is the current President, Trump has been out of office for close to a year, and isn't even on Twitter any more.

Oh please, you're ***** silly. Trump set up our withdrawal and under the agreement that he worked out with Taliban the withdrawal was supposed to be completed three months ago.

Also Biden hasn't been POTUS for anywhere near close to a year. More like seven months.
 
Last edited:
The Biden Administration left Afghanistan without coordinating with our allies that joined in to support us for 20 years, repeatedly lied to the world about conditions on the ground, assured everyone he'd evacuate every American who wants to leave Afghanistan (but didn't), and left the Taliban as one of the best armed militaries in the world.

And when you look back and think on that, your takeaway is that Trump doesn't give a flying F(ig) what happens to anyone but himself?

Just about every other thread on this forum is about Trump, eventually. This thread is specifically titled The Biden Presidency, Joe Biden is the current President, Trump has been out of office for close to a year, and isn't even on Twitter any more.

Did Trump 'coordinate with our allies' when he made the damn agreement with the Taliban without consulting the Afghan government in Feb. 2020? Hell, no. Exactly what 'lies' did he tell about conditions on the ground? I've already covered the he "assured everyone he'd evacuate every American who wants to leave Afghanistan (but didn't)" bit but you ignore it rather than give me reasons that's incorrect. Your assertion that he "left the Taliban as one of the best armed militaries in the world" is hyperbolic nonsense. As General McKenzie said, the planes and helicopters left behind at Kabul were made unusable.

And when you look back and think on that, your takeaway is that Trump doesn't give a flying F(ig) what happens to anyone but himself?

I suggest you look again at exactly what the topic of the posts I was responding to was:

Originally Posted by PhantomWolf
Considering that Trump and Miller's plan was to leave them all behind and the Rightwing Media was on board with that, then yes.
Originally Posted by sir drinks-a-lot
That’s quite the takeaway.

So, yeah...from those two posts, my 'takeaway' was right on target.

No matter how hard you and others try to lay all the blame on Biden while absolving Trump, it isn't going to work because it's just another lie.
 
Oh please, you're ***** silly. Trump set up our withdrawal and under the agreement that he worked out with Taliban the withdrawal was supposed to be completed three months ago.

OK, then why wasn't the withdrawal completed three months ago?

The answer is obvious. Trump is no longer President. For a hint on who is, check the thread title.

The current President cancelled/changed Trump's policy on many things, including the Afghanistan withdrawal date.
 
I think it would be almost impossible to get broad agreement on the contents of such a course. I doubt the right-wing and the evangelicals would support a course that teaches kids to question authority, examine evidence, demand proof, assess bias, etc.

In certain areas, yes. But remember that individual school districts would determine the content of the courses. I think in the deeply red areas, there would be more resistance for the reasons you state.

Many school systems used to teach a course about how the government worked, not in a partisan way but about the basic facts of federal, state and local governance, elections, communicating with representatives and officials, etc., but even they have mostly been dropped.

Yes, it was called Civics and I've never understood why so many districts dropped it as a required course. It's one of the major reasons so many Americans are woefully ignorant of how our government works. It's sad when an actual incoming US senator can't name the 3 branches of the federal government. It's unbelievable.
 
OK, then why wasn't the withdrawal completed three months ago?

The answer is obvious. Trump is no longer President. For a hint on who is, check the thread title.

The current President cancelled/changed Trump's policy on many things, including the Afghanistan withdrawal date.

What's your point? I'm damn glad we're out of Afghanistan. Could it have been done better? Sure. But that's easy to say in hindsight.

Unless Biden was going to escalate the 20 year war a month or two in office with Afghan locals, that had no reason to trust us, there was very little choice but to move forward.

Say what you want, but Trump made it very difficult on the incoming administration when they refused to cooperate with the transition.
 
OK, then why wasn't the withdrawal completed three months ago?

The answer is obvious. Trump is no longer President. For a hint on who is, check the thread title.

The current President cancelled/changed Trump's policy on many things, including the Afghanistan withdrawal date.

Oh, Jesus H. Christ. It wasn't done by May 1 because it wasn't possible and Biden had to renegotiate with the Taliban. As explained before but which you don't appear to grasp, if Biden just unilaterally changed the withdrawal date it would have broken the cease fire agreement with the Taliban and put our troops and American civilians into danger of Taliban attacks. Biden wanted to prevent that.

ETA: Biden needed the Taliban's cooperation to remove our people and troops safely. For example, we now know that the Taliban worked with us to get Americans safely to the airport in secret including literally escorting them undercover due to threats from ISIS K.
 
Last edited:
What's your point? I'm damn glad we're out of Afghanistan. Could it have been done better? Sure. But that's easy to say in hindsight.

Unless Biden was going to escalate the 20 year war a month or two in office with Afghan locals, that had no reason to trust us, there was very little choice but to move forward.

Say what you want, but Trump made it very difficult on the incoming administration when they refused to cooperate with the transition.

From the NPR:

Biden blamed the delay on the delay in the transition process after the election. "The failure to have an orderly transition from the Trump presidency to my presidency... has cost me time and consequences," he said.

Biden's national security adviser Jake Sullivan had warned in December that the lack of cooperation on transition issues with the Trump administration could lead to a delay in the withdrawal.
 
....
Yes, it was called Civics and I've never understood why so many districts dropped it as a required course. It's one of the major reasons so many Americans are woefully ignorant of how our government works. It's sad when an actual incoming US senator can't name the 3 branches of the federal government. It's unbelievable.

That was from a former Alabama college football coach. The deeper question is how did he even get elected to the Senate, his first elective office?
 
That was from a former Alabama college football coach. The deeper question is how did he even get elected to the Senate, his first elective office?

Because he was from a deep red state in Alabama and had an R by his name.

Dems were lucky they had gotten a Dem Senator from Alabama for two years prior to the 2020 election. That one was going to flip no matter what.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom