Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Again the next 3 years are going to be a concentrated effort from the Right (and a small fraction of the extreme Left) trying to turn "The President is boring" into a problem to be solved instead of the best thing that's happened in years.
 
And who would have thunk that Biden's first big foreign policy crisises would be so close to home in the Carribean?
 
Now Texas wants to arrest the Democrats who fled.
This is fascism,pure and simple.

This is what is known as a bill of attainder. It's a violation of the United States Constitution

Article I, Section 9, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution
“No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed.”
 
And who would have thunk that Biden's first big foreign policy crisises would be so close to home in the Carribean?

Cuba's been a powder keg for 60 years. But stable to a degree under Castro.
 
This is what is known as a bill of attainder. It's a violation of the United States Constitution

Article I, Section 9, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution
“No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed.”
Many legislative houses have attendance rules enshrined in statutes. The governor is blustering, he can't do anything about it thanks to separation of powers. The House itself has declared them absent without cause (which, technically, they are). The sergeant-at-arms is empowered to locate and return legislators to their duties.

Ethically, I actually don't have an issue with that. Pragmatically this is all late-stage, hard-nosed negotiating from a hopelessly weak hand. The idea of it is bigger than the reality of it. This has played out (at city/state level) a number of times that I can recall (way to go for making a list Ballotopedia).

Now, the really dumb move was taking private jets to D.C.

If one is taking the "standing up for the little guy/moral values" position (especially on the left), the proper play is hop over the state line, rent cheap hotel rooms, eat affordable meals together, invite media and constituents to visit, and control the dialogue.

The way they did it can easily be portrayed as skipping out on work in a pampered ride to go rub elbows with lobbyists in "the swamp."
 
Last edited:
Many legislative houses have attendance rules enshrined in statutes. The governor is blustering, he can't do anything about it thanks to separation of powers. The House itself has declared them absent without cause (which, technically, they are). The sergeant-at-arms is empowered to locate and return legislators to their duties.

Ethically, I actually don't have an issue with that. Pragmatically this is all late-stage, hard-nosed negotiating from a hopelessly weak hand. The idea of it is bigger than the reality of it. This has played out (at city/state level) a number of times that I can recall (way to go for making a list Ballotopedia).

Now, the really dumb move was taking private jets to D.C.

If one is taking the "standing up for the little guy/moral values" position (especially on the left), the proper play is hop over the state line, rent cheap hotel rooms, eat affordable meals together, invite media and constituents to visit, and control the dialogue.

Not if the intent is to persuade the US Congress to pass a voting rights act. Manchin is reportedly meeting with the Texas Democrats.
 
Many legislative houses have attendance rules enshrined in statutes. The governor is blustering, he can't do anything about it thanks to separation of powers. The House itself has declared them absent without cause (which, technically, they are). The sergeant-at-arms is empowered to locate and return legislators to their duties.

Ethically, I actually don't have an issue with that. Pragmatically this is all late-stage, hard-nosed negotiating from a hopelessly weak hand. The idea of it is bigger than the reality of it. This has played out (at city/state level) a number of times that I can recall (way to go for making a list Ballotopedia).

It should be noted that the tactic has been successful according to the Ballotpedia list half the time.
 
This is what is known as a bill of attainder. It's a violation of the United States Constitution

Article I, Section 9, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution
“No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed.”

I'm not sure that's right--this is a blocking tactic that has been used before. Sometimes the possibility of arrest comes up, usually under existing laws that empower capturing truant legislators and forcing them to return to the chamber. However, since any charged with enforcement can't do so across state lines, it is usually moot because the objecting representatives are smart enough to leave the state. So it's just another kind of stalemate that sounds really dramatic but isn't at all unprecedented.

Besides, most representatives wouldn't at all mind being arrested if they were confident their usual voters were on their side. It's a great photo op, though Delphic Oracle is right that they're flubbing it by taking private jets.

I'm being a little cynical, but I don't mind at all that this is a wrench in the works.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure that's right--this is a blocking tactic that has been used before. Sometimes the possibility of arrest comes up, usually under existing laws that empower capturing truant legislators and forcing them to return to the chamber. However, since any charged with enforcement can't do so across state lines, it is usually moot because the objecting representatives are smart enough to leave the state. So it's just another kind of stalemate that sounds really dramatic but isn't at all unprecedented.

Besides, most representatives wouldn't at all mind being arrested if they were confident their usual voters were on their side. It's a great photo op, though Delphic Oracle is right that they're flubbing it by taking private jets.

I'm being a little cynical, but I don't mind at all that this is a wrench in the works.

The point is you can't arrest anyone on Legislative or Executive say so. That is a bill of attainder.

It may only be reasonable if preexisting statutes are in place that include remedies, penalties etc. If not, it constitutes an ex post facto law.
 
Last edited:
The intellectual level of discourse has fallen so low that people can only accuse other people of doing what they have been actually doing. They can't even muster the neurons to think up actual lies.

This has been going on since Dump ran for office. He's the king of projection and his followers follow suit.
Here's a quote of Trump's from last weekend's CPAC (based on its phrasing, almost certainly written for him) that is chock full of projection.
The Effing Moron said:
Democrats are ruthless, but they are united. They don't have these Romney types. They don't have them. It must be wonderful to live like that, but they have bad policy and they have policy that's going to destroy our country. Like socialists and communists movements throughout history, today's leftists do not believe in freedom, they do not believe in fairness, and they do not believe in democracy. They believe in Marxist morality. Anything is justified as long as it hurts their political opponents and advances the radical agenda of their party. It's a radical agenda like nobody has seen before. Before our very eyes, the radical left Democrats are turning the law itself into a weapon for partisan persecution.
What a nice man.
 
Last edited:
The point is you can't arrest anyone on Legislative or Executive say so. That is a bill of attainder.

It may only be reasonable if preexisting statutes are in place that include remedies, penalties etc. If not, it constitutes an ex post facto law.

That's exactly what I'm saying though, that it's based on existing statutes.
 
Cuba's been a powder keg for 60 years. But stable to a degree under Castro.

Like Spain was stable under Franco.
Soviet Union was pretty stable too.
Stability can be overrated.
Frankly, Castro turned out be pretty much just another Latin American dictator who spouted Marxist ideology.
Yes, I find people on the left who defend his regime little better then those on the right who defend Trump.
 
This is what is known as a bill of attainder. It's a violation of the United States Constitution

Article I, Section 9, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution
“No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed.”

Hey, if you are going to go Bill of Attainder, go all the way and order the execution of the Texas congressmen. Don't be half assed about it.
 
The point is you can't arrest anyone on Legislative or Executive say so. That is a bill of attainder.

It may only be reasonable if preexisting statutes are in place that include remedies, penalties etc. If not, it constitutes an ex post facto law.

FOr those who do not know, a Bill of Attainder, was, in England a bill that basically allowed somebody to be bought to trial for an offense that might not even be against the law.
In face, a bill of attainder could order the execution of somebody without the formality of a trial, just on the stregth of the bill. Henry the Eight was very fond of using it. No wonder the Founding Fathers specifically outlawed them.
 
Like Spain was stable under Franco.
Soviet Union was pretty stable too.
Stability can be overrated.
Frankly, Castro turned out be pretty much just another Latin American dictator who spouted Marxist ideology.
Yes, I find people on the left who defend his regime little better then those on the right who defend Trump.

I agree. I'm not a fan of Che Guevara or Mao or Robespierre either.
 
FOr those who do not know, a Bill of Attainder, was, in England a bill that basically allowed somebody to be bought to trial for an offense that might not even be against the law.
In face, a bill of attainder could order the execution of somebody without the formality of a trial, just on the stregth of the bill. Henry the Eight was very fond of using it. No wonder the Founding Fathers specifically outlawed them.

In many cases they avoided the trial altogether.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom