Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
SCOTUS rules 7-2 (Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch dissented) to keep Obamacare/The Affordable Care Act in place.
Barret and I-Like-Beer voted for?
Gee, it's almost as if they're not slaves of the party that nominated them.
True, Drunky McRapeface and the Stepford Wife voted in a way that was contrary to what Moscow Mitch and his kin would have wanted.

But lets wait and see how they rule on things like voting reform, LGBTQ rights and abortion before we start assuming they will truly function as independent thinkers.
 
True, Drunky McRapeface and the Stepford Wife voted in a way that was contrary to what Moscow Mitch and his kin would have wanted.

But lets wait and see how they rule on things like voting reform, LGBTQ rights and abortion before we start assuming they will truly function as independent thinkers.

We shouldn't care about the specific vote....only the quality of the argument.
 
True, Drunky McRapeface and the Stepford Wife voted in a way that was contrary to what Moscow Mitch and his kin would have wanted.

But lets wait and see how they rule on things like voting reform, LGBTQ rights and abortion before we start assuming they will truly function as independent thinkers.

True. At least they're not in lockstep. That's somewhat encouraging.
 
Goursch and Alito seem to have the same reason for their descent dissent, that the penalty for not carrying insurance amounts to a tax.

ETA: "Descent" good one Joe you big stupid head.
 
Last edited:
If senators didn't like what McConnell was doing, they could change it.

If he nominated a federalist society judge, he would have got that vote.
This sounds an awful lot like regression. One might have thought that the hearing is where the character and suitability of a candidate is hashed out. You're saying that the holding of a hearing be conditional on what the hearing is about. It's like saying you have a contract if you have reason to expect a contract.
 
This sounds an awful lot like regression. One might have thought that the hearing is where the character and suitability of a candidate is hashed out. You're saying that the holding of a hearing be conditional on what the hearing is about. It's like saying you have a contract if you have reason to expect a contract.

The hearing is irrelevant. Business does not get done at the hearing.
 
Barret and I-Like-Beer voted for?

Gee, it's almost as if they're not slaves of the party that nominated them.

Actually, I think a lot of comes from the fact that the SC has put itself in a corner in regards to standing issues.

For so many uncomfortable cases in the past, in order to avoid making a ruling that they know would be correct but unpopular, they've run to the "lacks standing" approach. For example, they've made it basically impossible to sue the government for using public funds to support religion. Not because they can justify allowing public money to be used to support religion, so all they have said is that "you don't have standing." That way they don't have to say, "you can't use public money to support religious schools."

Now lawyers know that's the answer to pretty much everything. Argue that they don't have standing, and the SC will side-step having to make a decision.

This was dismiss on standing.
 
Actually, I think a lot of comes from the fact that the SC has put itself in a corner in regards to standing issues.

For so many uncomfortable cases in the past, in order to avoid making a ruling that they know would be correct but unpopular, they've run to the "lacks standing" approach. For example, they've made it basically impossible to sue the government for using public funds to support religion. Not because they can justify allowing public money to be used to support religion, so all they have said is that "you don't have standing." That way they don't have to say, "you can't use public money to support religious schools."

Now lawyers know that's the answer to pretty much everything. Argue that they don't have standing, and the SC will side-step having to make a decision.

This was dismiss on standing.

But in those uncomfortable cases, are you arguing they did have standing?
 
Actually, I think a lot of comes from the fact that the SC has put itself in a corner in regards to standing issues.

For so many uncomfortable cases in the past, in order to avoid making a ruling that they know would be correct but unpopular, they've run to the "lacks standing" approach. For example, they've made it basically impossible to sue the government for using public funds to support religion. Not because they can justify allowing public money to be used to support religion, so all they have said is that "you don't have standing." That way they don't have to say, "you can't use public money to support religious schools."

Now lawyers know that's the answer to pretty much everything. Argue that they don't have standing, and the SC will side-step having to make a decision.

This was dismiss on standing.

Especially considering the lawsuit was basically just a re-hash of the same old arguments from the original challenges to the ACA, but packaged up in an absurd way to make them seem like new.

Precedence doesn't count for much these days with the conservatives taking over SCOTUS and looking to slash and burn decades of liberal jurisprudence, but reversing the ACA decision that was only made a few years ago is too overt of a power play, even for this court. I wouldn't be surprised if there were challenges to the ACA that further neuter the law in the near future, but outright reversal is probably something that will have to wait.
 
Last edited:
Especially considering the lawsuit was basically just a re-hash of the same old arguments from the original challenges to the ACA, but packaged up in an absurd way to make them seem like new.

Precedence doesn't count for much these days with the conservatives taking over SCOTUS and looking to slash and burn decades of liberal jurisprudence, but reversing the ACA decision that was only made a few years ago too overt of a power play, even for this court. I wouldn't be surprised if there were challenges to the ACA that further neuter the law in the near future, but outright reversal is probably something that will have to wait.

So this is a case where the plaintiffs who DID have standing failed to win their cases (in the previous cases) so someone else repackaged it and then tried to bring basically the same suit?

That's what happened in the election challenges, of course. It started with actual plaintiffs failing in court on the merits, and so then a bunch of suits were brought by everyone else who had no standing and therefore were blown off.
 
You called it dereliction of duty. That generally applies to things you are required to do.

Duty can go beyond legal requirement. I think the Senate Majority Leader of an opposition party than the president has a duty to pursue a compromise candidate (which Garland arguably was) rather than to refuse any but names that a president of their own party would nominate.

Nothing forces him to be that way except the disapproval of voters. I am expressing my disapproval.
 
"On Sunday, June 20th, Joe Biden will have been President for exactly five months. And in those five months we've seen crisis after crisis after crisis." - Sen Ted Cruz.

*Gets up... walks over to the window. Opens it. Crickets*

What the **** is he on about?
 
"On Sunday, June 20th, Joe Biden will have been President for exactly five months. And in those five months we've seen crisis after crisis after crisis." - Sen Ted Cruz.

*Gets up... walks over to the window. Opens it. Crickets*

What the **** is he on about?

He means "and in those five months we've complained and complained and complained."
 
Duty can go beyond legal requirement. I think the Senate Majority Leader of an opposition party than the president has a duty to pursue a compromise candidate (which Garland arguably was) rather than to refuse any but names that a president of their own party would nominate.

Nothing forces him to be that way except the disapproval of voters. I am expressing my disapproval.

Duty would go beyond a legal requirement....if you hadn't invoked a crime under a legal code. If you meant it figuratively, I don't think it was clear.

Maybe it means something figurative in civilian circles?
 
"On Sunday, June 20th, Joe Biden will have been President for exactly five months. And in those five months we've seen crisis after crisis after crisis." - Sen Ted Cruz.

*Gets up... walks over to the window. Opens it. Crickets*

What the **** is he on about?
Caravans of foreigners at the border? Till it got too hot. And Israel. Send money to fight insurrection. All insurrections are bad except Jan 6.
 
Given that this came right after some aimless verbal rambling & meandering including replacing a name with another name a few times, the context is a bit too sad for a joke.

Are you still on the "Biden has dementia" wagon? Biden started to say Trump but corrected himself before he'd even gotten the entire name out.

"I caught part of President Tru-, Putin's press conference, and he talked about the need for us to be able to have some kind of modus operandi where the Arctic was in fact a free zone," Biden said.
https://www.businessinsider.com/vid...ident-trump-at-summit-press-conference-2021-6

What other names were replaced "a few times" by Biden incorrectly? I've heard of none.
 
Barret and I-Like-Beer voted for?

Gee, it's almost as if they're not slaves of the party that nominated them.
No but they are supporters of church beliefs even when said beliefs are applied to members of the public that do not hold them: working in a Catholic hospital, no employee or patient rights even when there are no alternative hospitals; a same-sex couple wanting to adopt a child even when there are no alternative adoption agencies; etc.

Thomas is another Evangelical extremist.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom