Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Serving in government should be a duty, not a career.

The more I think about it the more I think the Athenian model made sense: no elections; MPs chosen by random lot (in their case, by tribe; in the modern world, by district), kinda like jury duty.

But, given the history of Athens, that did not work out so well either..Not thrilled with giving blind chance total control.
It easy to become disillusioned with Democracy, it is a messy system but the Churchllian saying holds true:Democracy is the worst form of government...except for all the others
Some very smart people became fed up with democracy and tried to suggest some substitutes without much success. HG Wella and Robert Heinlein come to mind.
You do need career professionals in Government, but they need to the Civil Servants, not the elected officials.
 
Do you actually believe this deranged garbage? For starters, why don't you tell us by what mechanism you think Trump could enjoy "an early return to the WH."


Don't hold your breath. Monica drops by, unloads her standard QAnon/Trump cultist nonsense, then disappears.
She never explains or gives evidence of anything.
She's a drive-by CT shooter.
 
Serving in government should be a duty, not a career.

The more I think about it the more I think the Athenian model made sense: no elections; MPs chosen by random lot (in their case, by tribe; in the modern world, by district), kinda like jury duty.

Are you talking a random lot from a pool of citizens?



HAVE YOU SPOKEN TO THE AVERAGE CITIZEN LATELY? My god, man! Do you really wish that upon us?
:jaw:
 
Looking in from God's favourite country I must say that the momentum continues to be with Trump .
His comments this weekend to huge audiences referenced an early return to the WH which could become distinctly more likely if the AZ recount highlights huge Election fraud, and then the Military supervise an election re-run , locking up a number of traitors en passant .

Toupee Fiasco himself is a major problem for the GOP - he's an easy reminder of complete incompetence, he's obsessed with his own delusional grievances, and even as president he did a fantastic job of dragging his preferred candidate down in special elections. The fact that he's undermining faith in voting among his own fans really helps.

The GOP, itself, is obsessed with returning to Jim Crow, and it's also obvious that Manchin at least is perfectly fine with that - classic Letter from Birmingham Jail white moderate nonsense. Obvious problems for them - first, none of these have been through the courts, and despite the atrocious Shelby decision, I'm not sure if anyone aside from Thomas and Alito would favor scrapping the VRA entirely.

Second, lawmakers aren't very good at this, yet. They're busily knocking out good chunks of their own voters because they're writing laws based strictly on 202, which was mid-pandemic. They may get better in the future, but maybe not.

Third, the folks screeching about "CRT" and "Replacement" aren't many, and are far from the monopoly on violence that they needed to quickly mplement any serious Jim Crow discrimination.

In short, I think the dems will be fine, *if* they get out the vote - and telling people "the Trump GOP is trying to stop you from voting" is actually a great movitator. You want positives as well, of course, executive actions, ending COVID, Child tax credits, and the like. I'd say something about international relations, but c'mon, Americans won't vote for that.
 
>snip<

In short, I think the dems will be fine, *if* they get out the vote - and telling people "the Trump GOP is trying to stop you from voting" is actually a great movitator. You want positives as well, of course, executive actions, ending COVID, Child tax credits, and the like. I'd say something about international relations, but c'mon, Americans won't vote for that.

This is the key. The Dems must get out and vote. They have too much of a history of not coming our in large numbers whereas Republicans do. Stacey Abrams did an excellent job in Georgia of getting the Black/people of color out to vote. Of course, Georgia has now done everything they can think of short of establishing a literacy test to keep them from repeating that kind of turn out.
 
This is the key. The Dems must get out and vote. They have too much of a history of not coming our in large numbers whereas Republicans do. Stacey Abrams did an excellent job in Georgia of getting the Black/people of color out to vote. Of course, Georgia has now done everything they can think of short of establishing a literacy test to keep them from repeating that kind of turn out.
This is what I keep thinking. I think the Dems should get up off their collective butts right now, not tomorrow, today, and get people out right now on the streets and churches and whatnot, acknowledging that voting is going to become more difficult, not that it might if only this or that. They need to figure out exactly what measures must be taken to get past the obstacles, and then take those measures, fund them, advertise them, put up billboards, set things up. Assume the worst now. There's plenty of time to fight it later.
 
This is the key. The Dems must get out and vote. They have too much of a history of not coming our in large numbers whereas Republicans do. Stacey Abrams did an excellent job in Georgia of getting the Black/people of color out to vote. Of course, Georgia has now done everything they can think of short of establishing a literacy test to keep them from repeating that kind of turn out.


SSSHHH> Don't give them any ideas....
 
Yes, but…

Isn’t it apparent Republican lawmakers are today working three-hour shifts plus overtime to put into place methods/procedures/criteria with which they can, wait for it, nullify election results if any are not to their liking?

Get out the vote all you like, but if that vote is merely used to light a cartoon-sized cigar, clutched in the fist of a Republican who, between puffs, is bleating on and on about “ballot integrity”…
 
I would like the Democratic Party in a partnership with the ACLU to challenge these voting restrictions in every state that has implemented them. If Manchin wants to be a ass about blocking action on the federal level, we should attack the laws on the state level.
 
Last edited:
I would like the Democratic Party in a partnership with the ACLU challenge these voting restrictions in every state that has implemented them. If Manchin wants to be a ass about blocking action on the federal level, we should attack the laws on the state level.

The conservative SCOTUS is pretty clear that they are ok with states radically restricting access to the ballot box. The same SCOTUS gutted the Voting Rights Act in the Shelby County decision, and since then it's picked up an additional seat to make it a 6-3 bench.
 
Last edited:
I would like the Democratic Party in a partnership with the ACLU challenge these voting restrictions in every state that has implemented them. If Manchin wants to be a ass about blocking action on the federal level, we should attack the laws on the state level.

As of late April, three states (Montana, Iowa, Georgia) are being sued for their voter restriction laws at the state level. You can expect every state that passes these laws to be sued.

 
Yes, but…

Isn’t it apparent Republican lawmakers are today working three-hour shifts plus overtime to put into place methods/procedures/criteria with which they can, wait for it, nullify election results if any are not to their liking?

Get out the vote all you like, but if that vote is merely used to light a cartoon-sized cigar, clutched in the fist of a Republican who, between puffs, is bleating on and on about “ballot integrity”…

Even Trumpist judges just give this a flat no for now. Give them more time to confirm judges, and we'll see. They need a massive level of actual evidence, not just "I heard they was a'cheatin'."
 
Are you talking a random lot from a pool of citizens?



HAVE YOU SPOKEN TO THE AVERAGE CITIZEN LATELY? My god, man! Do you really wish that upon us?

Compared to what? The dredge who run for office? You think they know better than the average moron?

It works for jury duty, and we expect them to make impartial, reasoned decisions with people's lives.
 
Yes, but…

Isn’t it apparent Republican lawmakers are today working three-hour shifts plus overtime to put into place methods/procedures/criteria with which they can, wait for it, nullify election results if any are not to their liking?

Get out the vote all you like, but if that vote is merely used to light a cartoon-sized cigar, clutched in the fist of a Republican who, between puffs, is bleating on and on about “ballot integrity”…



The GOP might fantasize about doing such a thing, but if they ever actually did it, I suspect that would be the trigger for that civil war everyone seems to expect to be coming any time now. Were they to arbitrarily overturn a legitimate vote, that would be the signal of the end of US democracy.
 
Compared to what? The dredge who run for office? You think they know better than the average moron?

It works for jury duty, and we expect them to make impartial, reasoned decisions with people's lives.

Lighten up, Belz....I was having a bit of fun.

But, since you asked: I don't have a lot of faith in our juries, especially in some parts of the country. After being involved in the Knox case for years and seeing how some people think about evidence, the idea of ever having a jury decide my fate scares the crap out of me. I've seen them reject actual scientific evidence in favor of 'body language', a past sex life, and buying underwear when she had one pair to her name.

But speaking of jury duty, I have to report next week.
 
Yes, but…

Isn’t it apparent Republican lawmakers are today working three-hour shifts plus overtime to put into place methods/procedures/criteria with which they can, wait for it, nullify election results if any are not to their liking?

Get out the vote all you like, but if that vote is merely used to light a cartoon-sized cigar, clutched in the fist of a Republican who, between puffs, is bleating on and on about “ballot integrity”…
They certainly are trying to do this, but there is (I think) a limit to the extent that they can do it without being so far off that they cannot sustain it. That is why, I think, the Democrats should be doubling their efforts, while still fighting away, to make sure they know exactly what is needed to comply, and to make visible, conspicuous efforts not only to comply but to make that compliance public. Ask outright what is and is not going to be permitted, demand clarity and demand that those entitled to vote will have an opportunity of some sort, demand to know what is or is not going to be challenged, get it stated up front, and then win, publicly and conspicuously, by the opposition's rules.

They can fight the rules and overturn them too, but in the mean time they need to get the Republicans to explain them explicitly, and to understand how to use them.
 
The conservative SCOTUS is pretty clear that they are ok with states radically restricting access to the ballot box. The same SCOTUS gutted the Voting Rights Act in the Shelby County decision, and since then it's picked up an additional seat to make it a 6-3 bench.

I don't think you can assume every one of these laws is OK.
 
Lighten up, Belz....I was having a bit of fun.

Well it certainly sounded like something a rational person would say. I just happen to disagree with it.

Of course, I also believe that more focus on education is crucial, so it would certainly help in this process.

But speaking of jury duty, I have to report next week.

Presumably you will take this important function very seriously. Does that mean you'll be incommunicado, or just prevented from talking about the case?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom