My point isn't that a turd-contaminated sandwich is not an apt analogy for how many Christians use the Bible, my point is that it is an apt analogy for just about everything in the world. (There's some oft-cited "somebody's law", I forget who the somebody is, that 80% or 90% of everything is crap.) But since it applies that generally, how apt an analogy is it really?
Not really. Sturgeon's law does say that "
ninety percent of everything is crap", but as in 90% of the individual works in a genre. I mean, let's hear it from Theodore Sturgeon himself:
I repeat Sturgeon’s Revelation, which was wrung out of me after twenty years of wearying defense of science fiction against attacks of people who used the worst examples of the field for ammunition, and whose conclusion was that ninety percent of SF is crud.
Using the same standards that categorize 90% of science fiction as trash, crud, or crap, it can be argued that 90% of film, literature, consumer goods, etc. are crap. In other words, the claim (or fact) that 90% of science fiction is crap is ultimately uninformative, because science fiction conforms to the same trends of quality as all other artforms.
So yeah, a case can be made that 90% of the books or films in a genre are crap -- even if by virtue that everyone just wants the 10% best -- but he never said that 90% of each individual book is crap.
If a movie or a book, say, the Bible, is 90% crap, then it is just a crap book. Nobody would say that oh, Plan 9 From Outer Space as an individual movie was on par with everything else because only 90% of it was crap. (If nothing else, the credits weren't all that bad

)
In fact, you'll find that most of the individual works included in that "90% of everything is crap" are far from being 90% made of vile, revolting crap. Most of them are "crap" just by not qualifying to be in the top 10%. They'll usually actually be mostly decent stuff, just marred by some boring sequences or predictable plot or such faults which ruin the rest. Something where actually 90% of it is revolting crap, wouldn't just be in the lower 90% of the scale, but probably in the lower 10%.
So I really don't see how its applying generally is making the case at hand less apt. It doesn't make it meaningless to say that an individual thing is crap. The fact that 90% of the works in a genre are crap, doesn't make it any less meaningful to say that book A is in those 90% which are crap and book B is in those 10% which aren't.
Maybe. But the Bible has to exist in the world. Bibles are words written down by humans in human languages, rendered in ink on paper and copied by humans or by printing presses. They're not written in secret holy runes scribed by starlight on sheets of crystallized angel song. So, I'm not surprised they have common characteristics with everything else that exists in the world. (And yeah, many Christians venerate the literal words, and often even the manufactured objects, to excess. I regard that as a form of idolatry -- as does the Roman Catholic church, so that in and of itself hardly makes me a radical Christian.)
Yes, and Plan 9 From Outer Space clearly was made by a human and shows the characteristics of that human. It doesn't make it on par with everything else, it still makes it a crap movie.
Let's drop this "common characteristic" pretense. Everything made by humans is not equal. You have good books, and you have bad books. You have good movies and bad movies. You have good morals and bad morals. All authors are not created equal. Variance is another common characteristic of human traits. Whatever measure or skill or trait you take, you find vast differences among humans. Some can paint a Mona Lisa, some can botch a stick figure, and that's that. Some can actually put some thought into how society or the universe works, and some are just writing stupid apologetics for their own sociopathy.
Point in case, you can't just put an equals sign between God prescribing wholesale genocide in the OT and, say, Buddhism which forbade it. You can't put an equals sign between the Bible's being A-OK with slavery even in the NT (read Paul) and Zoroastrianism who managed to forbid it centuries before. If Yahweh can't figure out how to do it, maybe he should ask Ahura Mazda for some lessons.
Yes, they all show human characteristics, but some show some positive characteristics, and some show very negative characteristics.