Brown
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2001
- Messages
- 12,984
The United States Supreme Court has decided that, in some circumstances, it is permissible to discriminate against an individual in government hiring solely on the basis of race.
In the case of Collier vs. Hayden, Collier was a trained intelligence agent. He applied for a lucrative overseas assignment, but the assignment was awarded to a less skilled operative (known in court records as "W.A."). Because Collier has degrees in Mathematics, Engineering and Linguistics, and since W.A. is a former weightlifter with no advanced college degrees, Collier had expected to get the assignment.
When Collier asked why he had been passed over for the post in favor of a less qualified individual, Collier was told that is was because of his race. Collier is black, and W.A. is white. (Collier was offered a position tracking down computer-based confidence artists in Nigeria, but at less than half of the pay.) Collier sued the head of the Central Intelligence Agency for damages due to racial discrimination.
The Supreme Court, by a vote of 7 to 2, ruled in favor of the CIA.
Chief Justice Roberts wrote the opinion for the majority, saying that though it was undisputed that racial discrimination had occurred, the discrimination was legal:
Justice Ginsburg, joined by Justice Thomas, dissented:
Justice Thomas, although he concurred in the dissent by Justice Ginsburg, wrote a brief opinion of his own:
In the case of Collier vs. Hayden, Collier was a trained intelligence agent. He applied for a lucrative overseas assignment, but the assignment was awarded to a less skilled operative (known in court records as "W.A."). Because Collier has degrees in Mathematics, Engineering and Linguistics, and since W.A. is a former weightlifter with no advanced college degrees, Collier had expected to get the assignment.
When Collier asked why he had been passed over for the post in favor of a less qualified individual, Collier was told that is was because of his race. Collier is black, and W.A. is white. (Collier was offered a position tracking down computer-based confidence artists in Nigeria, but at less than half of the pay.) Collier sued the head of the Central Intelligence Agency for damages due to racial discrimination.
The Supreme Court, by a vote of 7 to 2, ruled in favor of the CIA.
Chief Justice Roberts wrote the opinion for the majority, saying that though it was undisputed that racial discrimination had occurred, the discrimination was legal:
The position for which Collier was applying was as an undercover operative in a well-to-do suburb of Moscow in which Collier would be the only black man in the entire community. The majority of the Court concluded that Collier's race would compromise his ability to remain inconspicuous:We apply strict scrutiny to racial classifications, and although this is a very high standard of scrutiny, it is not an insurmountable one. In this case, the government has shown compelling reasons for its decision to award the position to W.A.
The Court also noted that although W.A. lacked the college technical degrees, he had exactly as many years of in-the-field experience as Collier did.The CIA asserts, and Collier agrees, that the position would require the operative to engage in activities by stealth, and that the operative would be required to blend in with the population. Collier's qualifications are no doubt stellar, but because of the color of his skin, he simply cannot blend in.
Justice Ginsburg, joined by Justice Thomas, dissented:
Justice Ginsburg further remarked that a normal-sized black man walking at night in a winter coat and hat would be less noteworthy than a six-foot-five-inch muscleman who, apart from his white skin, did not look remotely Russian.The majority remarks that Collier's qualifications are "stellar," but does not describe how stellar they are. Collier had served undercover in Russia many times in the past. All of his missions were successful, even though some experts had thought success would be impossible. Although Collier spent most of his time in Moscow in the back of a panel truck or crawling through an air duct, he used these experiences to become an unobtrusive operative. Further, Collier can ably speak with a Russian accent, something that W.A. is unable to do.
Justice Thomas, although he concurred in the dissent by Justice Ginsburg, wrote a brief opinion of his own:
(Link to the story from CNN and AP.)We must accept the record of the trial court, and not engage in suppositions and speculations. We must remember that allegations are not proof. There were allegations, but not an iota of proof, that Collier would have stood out in a crowd like Tom Cruise, and therefore would have been completely unbelievable as an undercover agent. The evidence introduced before the trial court showed that Collier was able to operate undercover successfully for more than a decade in many environments. In all of his work in the intelligence community, he was not caught or killed, and the Secretary never had to disavow knowledge of his actions.
