Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Overt Race Discrimination

Brown

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Aug 3, 2001
Messages
12,984
The United States Supreme Court has decided that, in some circumstances, it is permissible to discriminate against an individual in government hiring solely on the basis of race.

In the case of Collier vs. Hayden, Collier was a trained intelligence agent. He applied for a lucrative overseas assignment, but the assignment was awarded to a less skilled operative (known in court records as "W.A."). Because Collier has degrees in Mathematics, Engineering and Linguistics, and since W.A. is a former weightlifter with no advanced college degrees, Collier had expected to get the assignment.

When Collier asked why he had been passed over for the post in favor of a less qualified individual, Collier was told that is was because of his race. Collier is black, and W.A. is white. (Collier was offered a position tracking down computer-based confidence artists in Nigeria, but at less than half of the pay.) Collier sued the head of the Central Intelligence Agency for damages due to racial discrimination.

The Supreme Court, by a vote of 7 to 2, ruled in favor of the CIA.

Chief Justice Roberts wrote the opinion for the majority, saying that though it was undisputed that racial discrimination had occurred, the discrimination was legal:
We apply strict scrutiny to racial classifications, and although this is a very high standard of scrutiny, it is not an insurmountable one. In this case, the government has shown compelling reasons for its decision to award the position to W.A.
The position for which Collier was applying was as an undercover operative in a well-to-do suburb of Moscow in which Collier would be the only black man in the entire community. The majority of the Court concluded that Collier's race would compromise his ability to remain inconspicuous:
The CIA asserts, and Collier agrees, that the position would require the operative to engage in activities by stealth, and that the operative would be required to blend in with the population. Collier's qualifications are no doubt stellar, but because of the color of his skin, he simply cannot blend in.
The Court also noted that although W.A. lacked the college technical degrees, he had exactly as many years of in-the-field experience as Collier did.

Justice Ginsburg, joined by Justice Thomas, dissented:
The majority remarks that Collier's qualifications are "stellar," but does not describe how stellar they are. Collier had served undercover in Russia many times in the past. All of his missions were successful, even though some experts had thought success would be impossible. Although Collier spent most of his time in Moscow in the back of a panel truck or crawling through an air duct, he used these experiences to become an unobtrusive operative. Further, Collier can ably speak with a Russian accent, something that W.A. is unable to do.
Justice Ginsburg further remarked that a normal-sized black man walking at night in a winter coat and hat would be less noteworthy than a six-foot-five-inch muscleman who, apart from his white skin, did not look remotely Russian.

Justice Thomas, although he concurred in the dissent by Justice Ginsburg, wrote a brief opinion of his own:
We must accept the record of the trial court, and not engage in suppositions and speculations. We must remember that allegations are not proof. There were allegations, but not an iota of proof, that Collier would have stood out in a crowd like Tom Cruise, and therefore would have been completely unbelievable as an undercover agent. The evidence introduced before the trial court showed that Collier was able to operate undercover successfully for more than a decade in many environments. In all of his work in the intelligence community, he was not caught or killed, and the Secretary never had to disavow knowledge of his actions.
(Link to the story from CNN and AP.)
 
Wait wait wait... Thomas actually had a different opinion than Scalia? :jaw-dropp
 
But I can certainly see why race could be an important factor in this situation, and discrimination should be allowed.

Likewise, I'd have no sympathy for a white actor who sued a movie producer for not casting him in the lead role of The Martin Luther King Story solely because he's white.
 
Although some recent castings have been done on equivalent basis. Not a problem for me given I am either primarily concerned with plot OR plot is unimportant to the specific film and therefor characters are somewhat interchangeable. I would draw the line at historical inaccuracy. Heavilly.
 
But I can certainly see why race could be an important factor in this situation, and discrimination should be allowed.
Even the dissent does not appear (from Brown's snippet, I admit to not reading the whole thing) to argue the principle of such discrimination, merely that the facts of this particular application were not sufficiently compelling. Something that I think is difficult to pass judgment on from my Internet vantage point.
 
Wait wait wait... Thomas actually had a different opinion than Scalia? :jaw-dropp
It happens. In a case decided just yesterday, New Jersey vs. Delaware, Justice Thomas was the deciding vote, and he did not join with Justice Scalia, who dissented.

The case was an interesting one, because it involved two neighboring states in an ongoing border feud, and the case was brought to the Supreme Court directly (not through appeal). In this particular case, Delaware thought that New Jersey was trying to build a facility in the Delaware River next to its territory, and the facility that might be hazardous. Apparently emotions ran high, and there were concerns about one state invading another. According to the opinion:
Delaware considered authorizing the National Guard to protect its border from encroachment. ... One New Jersey legislator looked into recommissioning the museum-piece battleship U. S. S. New Jersey, in the event that the vessel might be needed to repel an armed invasion by Delaware.
In addition, one state looked into claiming the territory of another:
As a result of the 1934 boundary determination, Delaware urged, “the entire River is on Delaware’s ‘own side,’ and New Jersey consequently ha[d] no ‘side’ of the River on which to exercise any riparian rights or riparian jurisdiction.”
 
Makes sense to me. Do you think the FBI should send a white agent to infiltrate the Black Muslims? Or a black man to 'advise' the KKK?

Even the ADA only outlaws discrimination against the handicapped if the handicap has no affect on job performance. It's perfectly legal to not hire a blind man to drive a bus. Even if he isn't female. ;)
 
But I can certainly see why race could be an important factor in this situation, and discrimination should be allowed.

Likewise, I'd have no sympathy for a white actor who sued a movie producer for not casting him in the lead role of The Martin Luther King Story solely because he's white.
Oh there you go, throwing common sense n stuff into the race thing. Have you lost your mind??
 
Sounds a reasonable judgement to me. And is this not discrimination on apperanace rather than race?
 
Why would the CIA hire a a former weightlifter with no college background, applicable experience, or insider knowledge in the first place?

Or is the issue painted too simply?
 
they said that the weightlifter guy had an equal amount of experience but much less education.
 
Why would the CIA hire a a former weightlifter with no college background, applicable experience, or insider knowledge in the first place?

Why would a country elect a hack bad actor to be President? Why would it elect a hack bodybuilder to be a state governor? Or a former pro wrestler?

America, the streets are paved with gold, I tell ya, leastaways if'n you come from Hollywood or a bodybuilding studio.
 
Likewise, I'd have no sympathy for a white actor who sued a movie producer for not casting him in the lead role of The Martin Luther King Story solely because he's white.
Old Cheech and Chong bit - excited Hispanic used car salesman doing a TV ad, finishes up with, "...only feefty dollars down, and feefty dollars a month for feefty years! Now back to our movie, The Jackson Five Story, starring Chon Wayne!"

ETA: Some years ago, my niece was in a high school production of The Sound of Music (she played a nun). They cast a black kid as Captain von Trapp. The world continued to turn on its axis.
 
Last edited:
For the record, the Supreme Court case about the spies was fake. I expect that at least somebody recognized that Collier was Barney Collier, and W.A. was Willy Armitage, both characters on the CBS show "Mission: Impossible." Barney Collier was portrayed by the late Greg Morris, and Barney was a freakin genius. Willy, portrayed by Peter Lupus, was a muscleman and... that was pretty much about it as far as Willy's skills were concerned.

What I said about the other Supreme Court case, New Jersey vs. Delaware, however, was not fake at all (or if it was, it was the greatest hoax since Bush vs. Gore). Clarence Thomas really did cast the deciding vote, and he did not vote with Justice Scalia. The case really was brought to the Supreme Court directly, and the quotes were real. Apparently both sides had been acting like jerks for several years, with Delaware threatening to mobilize its National Guard and also considering laying claim to the whole river (thereby preventing New Jersey from having a "side" on the river and preventing New Jersey from arguing that it can do whatever it wants on its side), and a New Jersey legislator threatening to bring in a WWII battleship to intimidate Delaware. There were other bizarre episodes in this real-life war between the States.
 
For the record, the Supreme Court case about the spies was fake. I expect that at least somebody recognized that Collier was Barney Collier, and W.A. was Willy Armitage, both characters on the CBS show "Mission: Impossible." Barney Collier was portrayed by the late Greg Morris, and Barney was a freakin genius. Willy, portrayed by Peter Lupus, was a muscleman and... that was pretty much about it as far as Willy's skills were concerned.
Before my time, I'm afraid. Bit below the belt, posting the day before, but well done.
 
Why would a country elect a hack bad actor to be President? Why would it elect a hack bodybuilder to be a state governor? Or a former pro wrestler?

America, the streets are paved with gold, I tell ya, leastaways if'n you come from Hollywood or a bodybuilding studio.

I don't see a correlation between an election process by a democracy and the hiring process of an institution.

I would also remind you that those people to whom you refer actually did meet the minimum qualifications to serve in their offices. This body builder hired by the CIA doesn't meet any qualifications for the position as far as I know.
 
Last edited:
Before my time, I'm afraid. Bit below the belt, posting the day before, but well done.
It's a quibble, but I waited until it was 1 April according to the forum's clock, as I did not want to stay up late posting this nonsense. As I write this, the post is dated "Yesterday." Eventually it should be dated as 1 April.
 
For the record, the Supreme Court case about the spies was fake. I expect that at least somebody recognized that Collier was Barney Collier, and W.A. was Willy Armitage, both characters on the CBS show "Mission: Impossible." Barney Collier was portrayed by the late Greg Morris, and Barney was a freakin genius. Willy, portrayed by Peter Lupus, was a muscleman and... that was pretty much about it as far as Willy's skills were concerned.

That is the subtlest April Fools' story I have read in my entire life. I think it would have been better if you had said that Collier volunteered to where a facial prothesis to make him appear to be an elderly white man.
 
It's a quibble, but I waited until it was 1 April according to the forum's clock, as I did not want to stay up late posting this nonsense. As I write this, the post is dated "Yesterday." Eventually it should be dated as 1 April.
(shakes fist at Brown for posting an April Fool's Day joke on March 31)







:p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom