Subliminal Compliance (a.k.a. Psychological Manipulation)

Thanks for the information.
I will use it in the future.:)

But for the record the test/demonstration/experiment was started before this thread.

In fact DaSkeptic made note of it and has offered commentary that has been ignored because
it is the truth many here will not acknowledge.

The reason being, it is psychologically uncomfortable to do so.

However I will explain the value of the Twain quote tactic and when I first started using it.

Best Wishes,

Jim
I totally made you say that.
 
I totally made you say that.

LMAO :D

What is this manipulation Jim is so adept at(should I put this in the other thread?)? Getting people to reply to his posts? Wow it haooens all the time on forums,that's what they are there for! If it's to believe he has paranormal powers,I don't think anyone on here believes that.Because he makes deliberate(he claims)spelling mistakes,that people correct him on? Again wow! You would expect some degree of literacy when posting on a forum.
IF all that is true so what? Surely it makes Jim a sad individual.
Also I think Randi has manipulated Jim! WHo is that continually attacks,and attempts to riducule and slander him? Why Jim of course.Randi makes one comment about him on his page some time ago and lights the fuse then sits back in amusement as he Jim conforms to type.
Well done Jim have a gin.:D
 
I'll start the discussion with a simple question: Once a person has been discovered to be manipulating, can anything they have said or will say ever be trusted? .... What do others think?

Going back to the original question, I think the line is drawn when the lights are dark, the camera is off, and the stage is empty.

When a performer is on stage or on camera, performing, anything goes. Lie your fool head off. Derren does this, Penn & Teller do this, Criss Angel does this, any magician, mentalist, hypnotist, etc, does this on stage. We have to. It's our job to decieve you while we are up there. That's what you pay us to do. You choose to give us the power to manipulate you.

However, once the "curtain drops", the show is over, it is that performer's responsiblity to be honest. I don't mean give away the secret of the tricks, I mean fess up to reality and say that all they did was fool the audience. There's no magic, no special powers, no long lasting infallible psychological manipulation.

That's the line.

For example, there was an episode from Criss Angel's show where he did a seance and ghost appeared, etc, etc. It made it look like he had this power to call the dead. But at the end of the show, at the end of the credits, he came on screen and said "Do you believe in ghosts? I don't" with a wink. Right there, he was telling everyone it was just a trick.

Penn & Teller do this too. They will tell you right out that they are lieng, do the trick, and it's still amazing.

That's being an "honest liar". That's the line. If a person who likes a magician is willing to look beyond the stage, and sees that that performer is just a person, no powers, no supernatural abilities, etc, and that performer is willing to admit that, then that performer is to be trusted.

In my twenty-some-odd years of studying magic, there has never ever been a trick in which a secret says "Now use your magic abilities to communicate to the dead to get the answer" or some such nonsense. Any magician or mentalist at all will vouch for that.

Once a performer, when the show is done, continues to claim that they can use psychological manipulations all the time and sell books, not to teach how to do a magic performance, but to teach this as a way to control others, has stepped over the line.
 
Last edited:
Deleted so as to not lead this thread further away from its origins.

Alex.
 
Last edited:
Sorry man it sounds a bit like a fitting for a ball team.
I do not think I have to go any further.

Jim
 
Looks like Banacheck has garnered a lot of respect and won many awards for hos talents:

Banachek is often sought out by various top entertainers and magic TV shows around the world as a consultant. The entertainers include Penn & Teller, David Blaine, Lance Burton, James Randi and Criss Angel.[citation needed] He has been responsible for putting more magic and mentalism on American television than any other magic consultant in the world.[citation needed]

Banachek has received the APCA (Association for the Promotion of Campus Activities) Entertainer of the Year award two years in a row and the College Campus novelty act. He also has been the recipient of the Psychic Entertainers Association's coveted awards for creativity in mentalism, the Dan Blackwood award for outstanding contributions to mentalism and the Dunninger Award, awarded for "Distinguished Professionalism in the Performance of Mentalism."

Banachek is renowned for fooling scientists at Washington University into believing that his supposed psychic abilities were genuine during the Project Alpha hoax in the early 1980s. He also took part in an investigation with Randi exploring Peter Popoff, which ultimately exposed Popoff's false claims.[2]

In 2007 his book Psychological Subtleties 2 won the first place in The Magic Woods Awards, for best book.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banachek

I would submit that Banachek would be an excellent commentator on psychological manipulation.
 
Last edited:
Have you seen them do the Cup and Balls with clear plastic cups? Wow. You see everything, and yet you still see nothing!

I love Penn & Teller. They do something amazing, tell you how they did it, and as you are sitting there, still reeling as to how it's done and still figureing it out, they do something even MORE amazing and the reaction is "woah! They said that this is trick...but how....?"

That's talent. That's what magicians are supposed to do. :)

I would submit that Banachek would be an excellent commentator on psychological manipulation.

I would agree. Banachek is one of those "Honest lairs". I have a bought and used a couple of his tricks. He's really good at this and another excellent book writer as well.
 
Looking up the last few posts and the typos,I tihnk we have all fallen under Jim's subliinal trap :D
 
I love Penn & Teller. They do something amazing, tell you how they did it, and as you are sitting there, still reeling as to how it's done and still figureing it out, they do something even MORE amazing and the reaction is "woah! They said that this is trick...but how....?"

That's talent. That's what magicians are supposed to do. :)



I would agree. Banachek is one of those "Honest lairs". I have a bought and used a couple of his tricks. He's really good at this and another excellent book writer as well.


Banacheck and I got on pretty well for the several weeks we were around each other.
Why don't you contact him and ask him what he thinks about my performances.

He is a member here is he not?

Also the entire idea of honest liars is total BS in my opinion.
It a definition used by magic boys who want to pass judgment on others
for doing what they have not the skills to create and or perform.

Truth is the artists decides when the performance is over not another performer.
(You for instance).
The artist decides the rules and sets the boundaries of the performance.
I have and do.

What I do is not unlike what the writer of a novel does.
I create reality.
But my reality is dependant on yours for it is were the basic building materials are acquired.

As to the idea of subliminal control it is possible and it is based upon time and
exposure.
It is not a short term instant cause and effect situation.


Best Wishes,

Jim
 
Banacheck and I got on pretty well for the several weeks we were around each other.
Why don't you contact him and ask him what he thinks about my performances.

He is a member here is he not?

Also the entire idea of honest liars is total BS in my opinion.
It a definition used by magic boys who want to pass judgment on others
for doing what they have not the skills to create and or perform.

Truth is the artists decides when the performance is over not another performer.
(You for instance).
The artist decides the rules and sets the boundaries of the performance.
I have and do.

*snip*

We decided your performance was over roundabout Halloween.:D
 
Also the entire idea of honest liars is total BS in my opinion.
It a definition used by magic boys who want to pass judgment on others
for doing what they have not the skills to create and or perform.

Funny, since Banachek is such a better performer than you and has the awards to prove it.

Truth is the artists decides when the performance is over not another performer.(You for instance).

Every time someone watches a youtube clip of you flailing about and doesn't bother to finish, they are deciding when the performance is over.



The artist decides the rules and sets the boundaries of the performance.
I have and do.

The only performance you're doing here is being an ass. Myself and others are on control of that performance.

What I do is not unlike what the writer of a novel does.
I create reality.
But my reality is dependant on yours for it is were the basic building materials are acquired.

What you do is not like a writer. A writer can tell you what she or he is going to write before they do it. The reality here is that you are a silly man.

As to the idea of subliminal control it is possible and it is based upon time and exposure. It is not a short term instant cause and effect situation.

You don't know anything about subliminal control. It has been proven. Banachek knows far more than you.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom