William Rea
Banned
- Joined
- Sep 4, 2006
- Messages
- 983
It's both.
-Gumboot
In which case there is no point continuing until we have established the strawman aspect conclusively.
It's both.
-Gumboot
Are we agreeing it is not a strawman before we continue with considerations of loaded questions?
You're coming awfully close to a false choice fallacy, there.![]()
Oh no, this is death by a thousand logical fallacies!![]()
It's a slow and painful one.![]()
This is not a loaded question, just interest, do you have a Philosophy background?
No. Why do you ask?
You appear to have a good knowledge of logical fallacies etc.
Even more impressive if you are self taught btw (that's not meant to be condescending either - just in case I get called up for that).
Thanks - But I'm just a nerd who likes Google![]()
Back to the topic at hand, William Rea, have you studied communications at a tertiary level?
-Gumboot
I will answer the question when you have given the full context of it.
Finalist 10 has been selected on an incorrect basis and should therefore be voided. The original nomination was on the basis that petgoat proposed that the WTC was wired with explosives by motivated junkies.
Let's keep it factual.
Er what? Why isn't suggesting that the WTC was wired to explode by junkies not worthy of a stundie?
You need to read my post again.
I have several times. You aren't making any sense.
It's not my problem if you can't follow it.
Actually, it is your problem for failing to communicating your meaning clearly.
The communication is clear, the comprehension is not.
If you have studied it, your earlier discussion regarding the interpretation of meaning of posts (which is what my question was asked in relation to) is nothing more than wilful ignorance, and shall be ignored.
If, on the other hand, you have not studied communications at a tertiary level, I would be happy to explain a number of aspects of communication to you, in relation to the understanding of posts etc.
Just to refresh your memory, my question was asked in response to this exchange:
-Gumboot
I understand your question completely which is why I want you to frame it further. Think about it in the context of the discussion that resulted with yourself and Garnos after your subsequently unproven accusation of strawman.
Frame the question and I will answer it.
I have already fully explained the context of the question, my reason for asking it, and how I intend to respond based on your answer.
Your refusal to answer is noted.
-Gumboot
All you have given is assumed outcomes.
1. The first is that I have been wilfully ignorant.
2. The second is implied, in that my communication skills are lacking potentially because I have had no formal training in communication.
Acknowledging your loaded question with any answer means that I accept your assumptions when there is at least a third possibility that the person reading the posts is simply not capable of understanding them.
You have still not framed the question.
-Gumboot
Example conversation taken from Monty Python's Life of Brian
William Rea said:All you have given is assumed outcomes.
1. The first is that I have been wilfully ignorant.
2. The second is implied, in that my communication skills are lacking potentially because I have had no formal training in communication.
Acknowledging your loaded question with any answer means that I accept your assumptions when there is at least a third possibility that the person reading the posts is simply not capable of understanding them.
You have still not framed the question.
You have committed another strawman fallacy. Incredible!
This discussion has nothing to do with your communication skills.
Your last point is the fundamental reason behind answering this question...snip...
How on earth is that a strawman?
Especially as you go on to confirm item 2 of my analysis by offering up some educational instruction.
This discussion has EVERYTHING to do with your perception of my communication skills, you're just not honest enough to say it.
This discussion has EVERYTHING to do with your perception of my communication skills, you're just not honest enough to say it.