Stress?

[Mojo]

In a link which I provided in this topic about stress impact on immunity,can't stress is considered equal to immunity?

 

[Kumar]

Whether all disorders triggering immune response also not cause stress?

 

[Daylightstar]

That is bit different though Instinct, stress & immunity relation is part of that topic. Here I am/shall try o find out:
...)

No Kumar, it's really the same.

 

[Daylightstar]

Whether all disorders triggering immune response also not cause stress?

An immune response can be seen as stress on the body. Your wiki text in your op already should have made that clear to you.

Perhaps you want to assign your own special properties to stress?

 

[Mojo]

Whether all disorders triggering immune response also not cause stress?

Being ill causes stress; this does not meant that stress is "equal to immunity".

As another example: being ill often causes financial problems. This does not mean that financial problems are "considered equal to immunity".

 

[Kumar]

An immune response can be seen as stress on the body. Your wiki text in your op already should have made that clear to you.

Perhaps you want to assign your own special properties to stress?

IIs it always an immune response seen on stress on body?

Can there be no immune response inspite stress on body?

I mean can stress be independent of immune response?

 

[Kumar]

Being ill causes stress; this does not meant that stress is "equal to immunity".

As another example: being ill often causes financial problems. This does not mean that financial problems are "considered equal to immunity".

Financial problem is not physiological. On the other hand financial problems can cause stress--which may trigger immune response.

 

[Kumar]

No Kumar, it's really the same.

Let us see how it lands,

Like chronic stress can compromise immunity, is it also possible that chronic relaxation weaken(compromise?) immunity? We can look anything both sided.

 

[dlorde]

Can't stress impact is explained by "fight or flight" response or with Sympathetic Autonomic Nervous system?

Yes, "fight or flight" is a stress response mediated by the sympathetic nervous system.

...,can't stress is considered equal to immunity?

No, not at all.

 

[dlorde]

Like chronic stress can compromise immunity, is it also possible that chronic relaxation weaken(compromise?) immunity? We can look anything both sided.

Chronic relaxation? you mean like paralysis?

 

[Daylightstar]

IIs it always an immune response seen on stress on body?

Can there be no immune response inspite stress on body?

I mean can stress be independent of immune response?

Does hard physical labour cause an immune response?

 

[Mojo]

On the other hand financial problems can cause stress--which may trigger immune response.

 

[Mojo]

Perhaps you want to assign your own special properties to stress?

He has previously attributed health problems to "modern lifestyle"; more recently he's been complaining about things not being "natural to us" or not having "inharent sense of right & wrong".

 

[Mojo]

Chronic relaxation? you mean like paralysis?

He probably means "modern lifestyle".

 

[Dancing David]

Can't stress impact is explained by "fight or flight" response or with Sympathetic Autonomic Nervous system?

In a link which I provided in this topic about stress impact on immunity,can't stress is considered equal to immunity?

Your question does make sense to me, please try again.

Bodies are integrated parts, none is equal.

 

[Dancing David]

Whether all disorders triggering immune response also not cause stress?

Over broad and begging some unknown point you want to make, in short: no.

 

[Dancing David]

IIs it always an immune response seen on stress on body?

Can there be no immune response inspite stress on body?

I mean can stress be independent of immune response?

Not unless you want to redefine stress, why is it that you are doing that?

Stress is a state of emotional vulnerability caused by an extended state of arousal.

two different things.

 

[Dancing David]

Financial problem is not physiological. On the other hand financial problems can cause stress--which may trigger immune response.

Your burden to demonstrate, where is your data?

 

[Dancing David]

Let us see how it lands,

Like chronic stress can compromise immunity, is it also possible that chronic relaxation weaken(compromise?) immunity? We can look anything both sided.

More of your burden, you find your data, you tell us.

I know of no evidence that says any such thing. Stop making crap up Kumar.

 

[Varanid]

Anecdotal, short of measuring levels of cortisol, but I would wager anyone that has worked in animal husbandry on a professional level would agree that stress (defined colloquially) in captive animals is almost always correlated with subsequent health decline.

You have an animal exposed to daily germs and the rigors of live that is able to remain vigorous. Then you have a serious period of stress (being but on public display, new cage mates, climate problems, whatever), and shortly thereafter you have bacterial upper respiratory infections (associated with ubiquitous bacteria) ravaging the animal.

Whether or not it is verified, as a matter of practice, the axiom "stress kills" is one of the first things I tell interns and new keepers.