Winterfrost
Thinker
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2004
- Messages
- 132
Great article.
After reading up a bit, I'm curious about the story of "Sarah Logan," and I'm wondering if there is some way to confirm that she was even real. If she was, as stated on a page linked from the Brookdale Lodge's website (http://www.hauntedbay.com/features/BrookdaleLodge.shtml), "six year old Sarah Logan, the niece of the lodge owner" (obviously meaning the "original" owner, as J. H. Logan died in 1928 and had sold Brookdale long before that) and Sarah supposedly died sometime in the 1940's, they are one curiously virile family!
Assuming that Sarah died in 1940, she was born in 1934 -- 6 years after J.H. Logan died, though he would have been 93. With multiple marriages and younger wives, it's possible that J.H. may have had a brother at least 20 years his junior, who sired Sarah at a ripe old age, I suppose (J.H. had a child at age 70)... but it doesn't seem very probable to me...
The other possibility is that "niece" refers to a "great niece" or some slightly more distant relation. The fact that the ghost is being tied back to the original owner (who was dead and no longer owned the place) just smells suspiciously like "myth building" to me.
Does anyone out there have access to a genealogy website that might be able to check some of these details about the Logan family? Seeing as J. H. Logan was in public office, I would think his family details might be more accessible, but I can't find anything.
I know it's not really your intention to disprove ghosts on your site, RSL, but surely if the ghost that Sylvia saw could be shown to never have even been a real person, that's worth something...
Anyway, keep up the good work!
After reading up a bit, I'm curious about the story of "Sarah Logan," and I'm wondering if there is some way to confirm that she was even real. If she was, as stated on a page linked from the Brookdale Lodge's website (http://www.hauntedbay.com/features/BrookdaleLodge.shtml), "six year old Sarah Logan, the niece of the lodge owner" (obviously meaning the "original" owner, as J. H. Logan died in 1928 and had sold Brookdale long before that) and Sarah supposedly died sometime in the 1940's, they are one curiously virile family!
Assuming that Sarah died in 1940, she was born in 1934 -- 6 years after J.H. Logan died, though he would have been 93. With multiple marriages and younger wives, it's possible that J.H. may have had a brother at least 20 years his junior, who sired Sarah at a ripe old age, I suppose (J.H. had a child at age 70)... but it doesn't seem very probable to me...
The other possibility is that "niece" refers to a "great niece" or some slightly more distant relation. The fact that the ghost is being tied back to the original owner (who was dead and no longer owned the place) just smells suspiciously like "myth building" to me.
Does anyone out there have access to a genealogy website that might be able to check some of these details about the Logan family? Seeing as J. H. Logan was in public office, I would think his family details might be more accessible, but I can't find anything.
I know it's not really your intention to disprove ghosts on your site, RSL, but surely if the ghost that Sylvia saw could be shown to never have even been a real person, that's worth something...
Anyway, keep up the good work!