StopSylviaBrowne: Shawn Hornbeck Reading

Apparently, someone on the "tvtalkshows.com" forum has seen the light. See http://www.tvtalkshows.com/board/showthread.php?p=1617198#post1617198 (post by Forallgood):

-Bri

This is not to say that I don't believe in psychics altogether. I do believe in the possibility of psychics. I believe in prophets and the spiritual world as much as I am Christian and I believe in God and life after death. We shouldn't shut out all possibilities, but as for Sylvia, it is just too plain that she is FAKE !!

Not so much seen the light as admitted she was ok to be fooled, but only as long as she didn't realise how it's done ...
 
Not so much seen the light as admitted she was ok to be fooled, but only as long as she didn't realise how it's done ...

Not sure what you mean by "ok to be fooled." S/he seemed fairly angry about it, I thought. I doubt that s/he's much of a skeptic judging from his/her poor language skills (we all know that skeptics have excellent language skills), but I think that's what makes it important -- even a (former) believer can see through Sylvia's pathetic act. It's not posts by obvious skeptics that are going to change the minds of those who believe.

That said, a skeptic can believe in the possibility of psychics or even life after death, if that's what you're referring to.

-Bri
 
Not sure what you mean by "ok to be fooled. S/he seemed fairly angry about it, I thought. "

Like too many people who believe in all kinds of irrationnal stuff, she's angry against SB for being unable to hide her fakeness, but she's ready to be fooled again, provided the next peddler of supernatural/mystical/psychic stuff is less blatantly making a fool of her ...

ETA: most people can live with being fooled but not being told they're fools.

I doubt that s/he's much of a skeptic judging from his/her poor language skills (we all know that skeptics have excellent language skills),

I would certainly never judge someone from their language skills, particularly since English is not my mother tongue.

but I think that's what makes it important -- even a (former) believer can see through Sylvia's pathetic act. It's not posts by obvious skeptics that are going to change the minds of those who believe.

Yes, that reflects really badly on that vulture ...


That said, a skeptic can believe in the possibility of psychics or even life after death, if that's what you're referring to.

As long as they don't believe in its probability , why not. SciFi is fun ... ;)
 
Like too many people who believe in all kinds of irrationnal stuff, she's angry against SB for being unable to hide her fakeness, but she's ready to be fooled again, provided the next peddler of supernatural/mystical/psychic stuff is less blatantly making a fool of her ...

ETA: most people can live with being fooled but not being told they're fools.

Oh, I don't know. I'll bet Forallgood has learned something from the experience. SB is quite good at what she does, and there are very few that are better, so I think Forallgood is probably less likely to be similarly duped in the future.

Yes, that reflects really badly on that vulture ...

Most people are more likely to believe someone who has learned from personal experience. A former drug addict telling you not to do drugs often is more persuasive than someone who has never done drugs telling you not to do drugs. Personal first-hand experience is generally more credible.

As long as they don't believe in its probability , why not. SciFi is fun ... ;)

Forallgood wrote "I do believe in the possibility of psychics," rather than "I do believe in the probability of psychics."

-Bri
 
Oh, I don't know. I'll bet Forallgood has learned something from the experience. SB is quite good at what she does, and there are very few that are better, so I think Forallgood is probably less likely to be similarly duped in the future.

That's all I wish for her ...




Most people are more likely to believe someone who has learned from personal experience. A former drug addict telling you not to do drugs often is more persuasive than someone who has never done drugs telling you not to do drugs. Personal first-hand experience is generally more credible.

It all depends on the depth of the belief.


Forallgood wrote "I do believe in the possibility of psychics," rather than "I do believe in the probability of psychics."

I hope she understand the difference ...
 
Last edited:
It all depends on the depth of the belief.

Generally, the stronger the belief, the more likely you are to trust someone who previously held the same belief over someone who you believe doesn't understand your point of view.

I hope she understand the difference ...

So do I. So do I.

-Bri
 
Generally, the stronger the belief, the more likely you are to trust someone who previously held the same belief over someone who you believe doesn't understand your point of view.


Some believers do, but in my experience, most believers (and drug addicts) tend to shun defectors and call them traitors or apostate ...
 
Some believers do, but in my experience, most believers (and drug addicts) tend to shun defectors and call them traitors or apostate ...

While it is true that there are those who "shun defectors," they are unlikely to listen anyone, including a skeptic. Those who aren't beyond help will more readily listen to someone who has been in the same position they are in now.

In my opinion, the skeptic community would do well in embracing help from those who might not be entirely skeptical yet, but are on their way. Furthermore, those people should be commended for what they have learned, rather than condemned for how far they have to go. Learning to incorporate critical thinking into one's daily life is an ongoing process.

-Bri
 
SB is quite good at what she does, and there are very few that are better
-Bri

I don't know if i agree with this - if what she does is cold reading, then from what I've seen and heard she's quite average at it....

(of course, if what she does is talk to the dead then obviously she's rubbish...)
 
I don't know if i agree with this - if what she does is cold reading, then from what I've seen and heard she's quite average at it....

(of course, if what she does is talk to the dead then obviously she's rubbish...)

Sylvia Browne probably has more going for her than just an ability to cold read, although that is certainly a large part of her act. As far as cold reading, I haven't seen enough cold readers to evaluate Sylvia Browne's technical ability in that regard. However, her fame would seem to be evidence that she certainly has an ability to get people to believe her shtick, for whatever reason.

My point was that it sounded to me as though the poster is now a little wiser, and having the ability to see a high-profile psychic like Sylvia Browne for what she is would probably be an indication that the poster would be more skeptical when viewing another psychic as well. Therefore, the poster is probably less likely to be duped in the future. Of course, that's only my impression based on the post.

-Bri
 
This thread have been derailed somewhat, but the truth is that the best psychics cheat, and this includes Sylvia. Even the best cold reader has no chance against a hot reader.
 
Robert, I would be interested in the change in the number of hits on your site since the media coverage.

Would you share them with us?
Sure.

Prior to the NY Daily News article, the site was averaging around 2,500 page loads per day.

Here are the page load stats from the past two weeks or so:

Date Pageloads
09-Jan 1,948
10-Jan 2,721
11-Jan 3,175
12-Jan 2,641 (Shawn Hornbeck story on site)
13-Jan 2,674
14-Jan 3,226
15-Jan 4,502
16-Jan 3,430
17-Jan 4,303
18-Jan 43,234 (NY Daily News, Howard Stern)
19-Jan 34,014 (CNN Anderson Cooper)
20-Jan 23,247
21-Jan 14,718
22-Jan 19,252
23-Jan 26,656
24-Jan 16,963
25-Jan 11,476
 
Wow, Robert. Those are impressive figures. YES!!! I'm so glad to see that people are becoming concerned enough about Syl to actually begin checking on her.
 
Numbers, I love playing with numbers. Before the extra publicity ()9 13 Jan) Robert had an average of 2,632 hits per day. After that he had 14,453 hits per day. This is an extra 173,439 hits (and still counting) because of the extra publicity. That translates to a lot of new people.
 
Thanks Robert.

I expected a jump, but not quite so large.

Great work....You are making a difference.

.
 
Wow, Robert. Those are impressive figures. YES!!! I'm so glad to see that people are becoming concerned enough about Syl to actually begin checking on her.
Yes, I'm pretty happy with the traffic. It is down to around 8,000 page loads per day now, but it is still a nice number.

Numbers, I love playing with numbers. Before the extra publicity ()9 13 Jan) Robert had an average of 2,632 hits per day. After that he had 14,453 hits per day. This is an extra 173,439 hits (and still counting) because of the extra publicity. That translates to a lot of new people.
Yup!

Thanks Robert.

I expected a jump, but not quite so large.

Great work....You are making a difference.
Thanks, H3LL.

Rob,

Your article is the number one google hit for "Browne Hornbeck". Any word on when the video will available?
I hope to get to it this weekend, but am really swamped now. I'll post a notice here when it is up.

Your site is now number 4 when searching in google for "Sylvia Browne", behind two of her pages and Wikipedia.
Yes, someone pointed that out to me recently - very nice!! Andof course, it is largely due to the people here!
 
I just realized Robert doesn't have the transcript up:

THE MONTEL WILLIAMS SHOW
SHOW: The Montel Williams Show (5:00 PM ET) - SYND
February 26, 2003 Wednesday
LENGTH: 7232 words
...
(Excerpt from videotape)

CRAIG (11-year-old Son Vanished on October 6, 2002): Shawn's a typical 11-year-old boy; bright, energetic, very inquisitive. We were pretty much inseparable, my little shadow.

PAM (11-year-old Son Vanished on October 6, 2002): Shawn had a smile that would just knock you completely off your feet. He had the cutest smile that there was. And you could be mad at him or angry or upset with him, and all's he'd have to do was look at you with his big brown eyes and he smiled and it--all that went away.

Unidentified Girl #1: He rode his bike every day, even if there was bad weather, and we didn't want him to.

Unidentified Girl #2: When I got home from school, I'd watch him, and he'd be here like a half an hour before I was. And he'd bug me all the time, so that was cool. I miss that.

PAM: We had gotten up Sunday morning, Craig and I was getting ready down--to sit down and watch a movie. He had asked us if he could ride his bike down to his friend's house.

CRAIG: And we said, 'Sure, no problem. Bye. Be careful. Be home by 5.' And he walked out the door about 1:15.

PAM: Watched him ride the bike down the driveway and down the road, and that's the last time that I've seen Shawn.

CRAIG: We search for Shawn every single day, seven days a week, and we have since the day he was missing. We've purchased our own canines. We have so much ground to cover. We're--this is an extremely rural area. It's all densely wooded. To cover it all by foot--we're--we're four months into this now, and there's still places within 10 miles of here that we haven't--haven't touched yet. Flyers everywhere. I don't think there's anything that could be done that we haven't done. You would think that eventually you would find some evidence or find someone that--that saw something happen or, you know, some little clue to give you some kind of an indication as to what really happened. And right now, we have nothing.

Unidentified Girl #2: At school, I can basically keep myself busy from it. But here at the house, it's not as busy, so then you think more about it.

Unidentified Girl #1: I missed Shawn the most when we all sit down for dinner, when we just do normal things, and it's something missing. I miss Shawn the most when we're not a family.

PAM: This is Shawn's room. I just basically come in here and look at his Christmas presents and look at his baseball stuff and lay on his bed a lot and just--I talk to him. I talk to him every day, every morning. I tell him good morning. Every night, I'd tell him good night, Mommy is thinking about him, and I am still looking for him and I will never give up on him.

Please let me know where my son's at and let me bring him home.

(End of excerpt)

WILLIAMS: Please welcome shawn's parents, Pam and Craig, to the show. You have done everything--almost everything conceivably possible to at least try to find a clue, something, from organizing search parties and the community has gotten involved, and still yet, not even a whim, is there? Is there any whim at all of what happened?

CRAIG: There's absolutely no evidence to support any--any kind of theory.

WILLIAMS: He left the house--I'm sorry, he left the house at what time?

CRAIG: 1:15.

WILLIAMS: And there was some children who said that they saw him at what time? Around 4.

CRAIG: There's been sightings up to 4:30.

WILLIAMS: But he was only traveling to a friend's house, which was 7/10ths of a mile away, so he could have gotten there in five or six minutes. So what do you think--and--and none of his other friends anywhere in--around saw him--Correct?--between that time.

CRAIG: No, most--the friends that he played with normally on a regular basis didn't see him that day. There were just some other kids that he normally didn't play with that have seen him.

PAM: ...(Unintelligible).

Ms. BROWNE: Who does--who did he know, or who do you know of by the name of Keith?

CRAIG: Keith?

PAM: Is it a kid or an adult?

Ms. BROWNE: No, no, it's a young kid. Because there's somebody by the name of Keith, a blond kid, who saw him after this 4:30 period.

CRAIG: Doesn't--doesn't ring any bells. We'll have to look into that.

Ms. BROWNE: Well, I'd ask, ask around. 'Cause he doesn't live that far from where the friend is. Do you see what I mean? He wasn't a best friend, but he sort of goes in and out of the group. Because he was picked up in a--in a blue-colored sedan by a guy by the name of Michael, and the last name sounds like (censored).

WILLIAMS: Is this somebody who lives in the area? Somebody passing through the area?

Ms. BROWNE: Somebody passing through the area.

PAM: So it wasn't su...

WILLIAMS: I'm sorry? What was that question again?

PAM: Was it anybody that Shawn knew?

Ms. BROWNE: No.

WILLIAMS: Was he abducted when you say picked up?

Ms. BROWNE: Abducted, yeah. Yeah.

WILLIAMS: He was grabbed.

Ms. BROWNE: Grabbed. Yeah.

CRAIG: Is there any better description of the vehicle other than just a blue sedan?

Ms. BROWNE: The vehicle is a blue sedan, and I think it's a Chevrolet. It's an older Chevrolet. It reminds me of what I had years ago, you know, sort of with the tail fins on 'em, which was what, around '58, '59?

WILLIAMS: So an old model car.

Ms. BROWNE: Old model car. I think they called them--what were they, Impalas?

WILLIAMS: Could have been Impala.

Ms. BROWNE: Were they Impalas? Yeah, I'm pretty sure it was an Impala.

CRAIG: Is there any kind of a description of the person driving the car?

Ms. BROWNE: Yeah. The--the guy was dark-skinned, although he wasn't black. He was more Hispanic looking, had real long, dark hair. And strange enough, Hispanic, but he had dreadlocks. He was really tall and really--almost like what you think a basketball player's build would be.

CRAIG: Can you tell how far from the area he was taken?

Ms. BROWNE: Maybe about 20 miles.

CRAIG: And he's still within a 20-mile radius even now?

Ms. BROWNE: He's still within a 20-mile radius of--let's say, here's where you are, 20-mile radius, but it's really southwest of where you are.

CRAIG: Southwest.

Ms. BROWNE: So whatever is Southwest, because it looks like this is--here we go again with the wooded, with the--you know, the wooded areas. So southwest of you.

PAM: Is there any landmarks around?

Ms. BROWNE: Yeah. Strange enough, there are two jagged boulders, which look really misplaced. Because everything is trees, and then all of a sudden, you've got these stupid boulders sitting there.

WILLIAMS: And he could be found near there?

Ms. BROWNE: He's near the boulders.

PAM: Is he still with us?

Ms. BROWNE: No.


CRAIG: Do you see the bicycle anywhere?

Ms. BROWNE: I think the--see, here's what's strange. I think the--the--the bicycle is in another state in a dump.

WILLIAMS: Let me take a little break. We'll be back right after this.
...

Related matter:

I hope to get to it this weekend, but am really swamped now. I'll post a notice here when it is up.

Any word on the video yet?
 
Last edited:
Any word on the video yet?
Well, now that I don't have to type in the entire transcript, it won't be as long as it woud have otherwise! Thanks!

But still, I am swamped of late. I hope to get to it this weekend, but there is a lot on my plate at the moment, both home-related, work-related and SSB-related.

Keep rattling my cage, but don't hold your breath, okay?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom