StopSylviaBrowne: Shawn Hornbeck Reading

This is great - maybe it will convince my dad, normally a sensible and sceptical sort, that Browne is a fraud. He saw part of a Montel episode and said he thought she seemed really 'tormented' and became convinced she must be the real deal.
 
"I think it's just cruel to jump on this one case in which I was wrong," she added defensively. "I've said thousands of times I'm not God."

"Except for all those times that I've said she's with god or he's with god or I know what god wants or I feel god inside me or ok actually I am god and I wrote four books about me and god so give me more money thanks."

Doesn't this stupid person front her own religion nowadays?

M.
 
There are a lot of people out there (not all of them stupid) who just assume that if someone is on Montel or Larry King that she must have dome something really spectacular and that Montel's people must have checked it out. Or they see "Psychic Detectives" and they just assume that Court TV (or is it A&E?) would not distort and fabricate evidence just to get ratings.

I'm oft reminded of a story told by people who had the misfortune to buy the "Amityville Horror House" after the Lutz's moved out but before the book came out. They recalled yelling at a tourist "It's all fake! They made it up!"

The guy looked incredulous and said "No!" The flabbergasted homeowner yelled "Some guy tells you he saw a flying piggy and you believed it and you won't believe me when I tell you they made it all up?!"

Yep, the mass media repeat and promote outright and silly lies. Deal with it.
 
I had to redo the upload since the one from last night was WAAAYYY out of sync. The new one is here.




Sorry about that. If an mod/admin could remove the youtube from my previous video post in this thread I would be glad.

I haven't been able to use your link in two days.

M.
 
Watched the segment on Tivo this afternoon. Pretty good...especially given how skeptics are usually treated in the MSM. I thought Cooper did admirably well...and I generally am no fan (too much star and ego, to little in-depth reporting). In this case, however, he split it about right. It would have been facinating however had SB not been too scared to participate (wonder why she didn't see this coming? Somebody above said she can't predict for herseld, or the Hornbecks, or Randi, or Cooper...hmmmm.).

Robert: you were good. Keep it up. Always remember you've got about 7 seconds to make your best soundbite. But you are my new hero. And, timing is everything...had this happend two months ago...it would have been missed...but you brought your site on line just in time. Great job.

I loved Randi when he said something to Cooper along the lines of: She accepted the challenge, than claimed she couldn't find me...what kind of psychic is that? Beautiful.

I agree totally with those who say Cooper should be comended. DO SO. It did a good, honest report.

The other part I love -- though and here IMO is where Cooper dropped the ball...He said that Sylvia offered additional help to the Hornbecks for money. Cut to the Hornbecks who agree with the assertion. Cooper than says that SB's representative said that she never charges in missing persons cases and has a great record of success helping the police. Two points: Cooper should have pointed out that the Hornbeck's have no reason to lie about whether SB asked them for money...and, he didn't press on the point about proving assertions as to how many cases she's helped solve. It would have been nice, for instance, to note that NO law enforcement agency (at least that I am aware of) has ever said that a psychic, little less Browne, has helped solve a case or even been of use.

Anyway, great job to Randi and Robert!
 
I saw the Anderson Cooper video on YouTube. I wasn't able to see it on Friday. It was great. Wonderful job, RSL and Mr. Randi. And, Mr. Cooper for that matter. The whole piece was excellently produced, and the three of you combined to so completely thrash her that it's difficult to believe that anyone who sees it will believe her woo ever again.

This is the 4th great thing that happened due to the events on Friday the 12th:

1a. Shawn Hornbeck is found and returned to his family.
1b. Ben Ownby is found and returned to his family.
3. A(n) (alleged) pedofile is removed from the public and jailed.
4. Sylvia Browne is publicly and obviously discredited.

Arguably, 3 and 4 could be interchanged based on how many / much people are hurt by these criminals.
 
"I think it's just cruel to jump on this one case in which I was wrong," she added defensively. "I've said thousands of times I'm not God."


Hmmm - in reference to her 87% accuracy:

Shawn is no longer with us.

Wrong - 0-1

Body was in a wooded area about 20 miles southwest of Richwoods, Missouri.

Wrong - 0-2

She said it would be near two large, jagged boulders that seem out of place in that area

Wrong - 0-3

The bicycle he was riding when he disappeared, is in a dump in another state

Has not been verified, as far as I know - for pity's sake we'll leave it at 0-3

Shawn was taken by a "dark-skinned man, he wasn't black – more like Hispanic."

Wrong - 0-4

The kidnaper had long, black hair worn in dreadlocks and was "really tall."

Wrong - 0-5

He was driving an older model blue sedan, she said, a car with fins like in the late 1950's and early 1960's Chevrolets.

Wrong - 0-6


So, if she can just get her next 40 guesses right, she will be 40 for 46, and get back to her average at 87%.
 
This morning, Howard Stern started his show by talking about Sylvia Browne and Montel Williams. Howard played two clips of Sylvia answering questions. One was a couple's question about their daughter who died suddenly. Sylvia immediately and unequivocally said she was shot. The parents said no, that their daughter's autopsy showed no signs of a gunshot. Sylvia said "she didn't care" what the autopsy showed and reiterated that she was shot. The parents then followed up by saying that their daughter was an athlete and just died in her room. Sylvia, with Montel's help, said "it felt like she was shot" and Montel said that there were two cases where high school baseball players had been hit in the chest with baseballs and died shortly afterwards without being bruised. This was on top of another clip when a woman asked Sylvia what happened to her boyfriend who died and whose body was never recovered. Sylvia said that the reason why the body was not found was because it was under water. The woman said that her boyfriend was a firefighter who died on 9-11 at the World Trade Center. Sylvia insisted that he "said" that he couldn't breathe because he was under water. Montel once again chimed in by agreeing with Sylvia when she pointed out that if they were trying to put out the fires that he would be covered with water. Later in the segment, a caller called in and told everyone about the JREF and the $1M Challenge that Sylvia agreed to in 2001 but has still not taken. Howard then added his admiration for James Randi. All in all, the bit ran about a half hour.

By now, it's clear that Syvlia has a much credibility as Montel has hair.

Michael
 
Hmmm - in reference to her 87% accuracy:

Shawn is no longer with us.

Wrong - 0-1

Body was in a wooded area about 20 miles southwest of Richwoods, Missouri.

Wrong - 0-2

She said it would be near two large, jagged boulders that seem out of place in that area

Wrong - 0-3

The bicycle he was riding when he disappeared, is in a dump in another state

Has not been verified, as far as I know - for pity's sake we'll leave it at 0-3

Shawn was taken by a "dark-skinned man, he wasn't black – more like Hispanic."

Wrong - 0-4

The kidnaper had long, black hair worn in dreadlocks and was "really tall."

Wrong - 0-5

He was driving an older model blue sedan, she said, a car with fins like in the late 1950's and early 1960's Chevrolets.

Wrong - 0-6


So, if she can just get her next 40 guesses right, she will be 40 for 46, and get back to her average at 87%.


The interesting thing is how easy (though it has taken some work to Organize...thank you Robert!) it is to find proof of SB being wrong...kinda funny that there isn't similar proof...clips from Montel, newspaper stories, police officers saysing they couldn't have solved it with out her, etc. showing when she's been right.

If, as she claims, she's 85+ accurate...those examples should be legion. Instead, we are left with a growing body of her errors...if this body constitutes the bad 15%...than the good stuff must be great...and yet crickets.

Additionally, someone above made the point and it is well worth pressing with her supporters and fans. Yes, even if she is possessed of this power, it may not be 100% accurate...so what? She never qualifies her predictions or prognostications. She doesn't say...it seems to me, I might be wrong...she states it as fact. ANd, as such she hurts people...that in iteslf is enoght to give her the cold shoulder...

oh, yeah, than there is all the lack of proof of anything more than guessing... but we're all over that already. :)
 
Has Sylvia Browne Ever Been Right?

Lying in bed today, nursing a mild fever, I thought that I might perhaps start a new thread, or even a thread on some of Sylvia's fan boards.

When I say "ever" I have to exclude certain special cases.

Unverifiable and meaningless information, such as "Your guardian angel is named Fred." How would you ever confirm this? The only way I could think of would be to ask another psychic (perhaps Chris DuFrene?), but if they disagreed then all it would show is "only God is 100% right." Or you could wait a few years and ask a second time, but all it would show is that Sylvia keeps records.

Decent guesses, such as "Brittany and K-Fed will break up." Now I have to admit that I would not have guessed this, but then again I would not have recognized K-Fed if he bumped into me, fell down and vomited on my shoes.

The results of cold, warm, and hot reading. Don't think I need to explain this to anyone on this board, but I'm sure a Sylvia fan board would be confused.

So does anyone know if she has ever been right?
 
Howard Stern spent the first 45 minutes of his show discussing Sylvia Browne and the Hornbeck debacle. Talked about her cruise (one cast member said the name of the ship was probably the SS Bull****), played several Montel clips, etc.

A caller phoned in and mentioned the JREF, Randi and the prize and how she's been ducking it ever since she agreed to be tested in '01. Howard then mentioned what a cool dude Randi was for going after these crooks.

edit to add: I now see Coalesce already summarized the bit before me...sorry 'bout that.
 
Last edited:
According to the Anderson Cooper 360 info, she did say that Shawn Hornbeck's abductor was named Michael. She also said that he:

- was hispanic
- was tall
- had dredlocks
- had black hair
- drove a blue 1960's era sedan
- had killed Shawn
- had hidden his body in the woods
- had dumped his bike in a dumpster in another state

So, since the "Michael" name prediction makes her like, 1 for 9 on the Hornbeck reading, I would chalk it up to a "lucky guess" more than anything else. I'm suprised she didn't get more things "right", actually. I've done a ton better than 11% personally on the NerdTests Psychic Ability Quiz. (About 65% accurate is my highest score, and yes, that's all luck, I think the next round through I scored a 25%)
 
This morning, Howard Stern started his show by talking about Sylvia Browne and Montel Williams. Howard played two clips of Sylvia answering questions. One was a couple's question about their daughter who died suddenly. Sylvia immediately and unequivocally said she was shot. The parents said no, that their daughter's autopsy showed no signs of a gunshot. Sylvia said "she didn't care" what the autopsy showed and reiterated that she was shot. The parents then followed up by saying that their daughter was an athlete and just died in her room. Sylvia, with Montel's help, said "it felt like she was shot" and Montel said that there were two cases where high school baseball players had been hit in the chest with baseballs and died shortly afterwards without being bruised. This was on top of another clip when a woman asked Sylvia what happened to her boyfriend who died and whose body was never recovered. Sylvia said that the reason why the body was not found was because it was under water. The woman said that her boyfriend was a firefighter who died on 9-11 at the World Trade Center. Sylvia insisted that he "said" that he couldn't breathe because he was under water. Montel once again chimed in by agreeing with Sylvia when she pointed out that if they were trying to put out the fires that he would be covered with water. Later in the segment, a caller called in and told everyone about the JREF and the $1M Challenge that Sylvia agreed to in 2001 but has still not taken. Howard then added his admiration for James Randi. All in all, the bit ran about a half hour.

By now, it's clear that Syvlia has a much credibility as Montel has hair.

Michael

Great post. It's clear that Williams is a shill for SB. Couldn't be clearer.

One hand washes the other, and together they suck, big time.

M.
 
40 predictions for the year 2000 made by Sylvia Browne. Excellent test of her 87 - 90 percent accuracy claim.

Interest rates will rise very slowly until Spring and then will level off and begin to go downward.
Stocks stay pretty steady. The NASDAQ fluctuates up and down wildly in March, but the Dow stays pretty solid.
Building everywhere from all corners of the State (CA) is at an all-time high.
There will be a lot of purchasing of property in foreign countries by Americans and for the first time at such an all-time high.
There is going to be a shake-up at American Airlines during January and February. American will also merge with Alaska Airlines.
TWA is hanging on by a thread and will probably not last until the end of the year.
Unemployment will be very low. There will be another acceleration of the minimum hourly wage by mid-year.
New electronic companies are in the making now, but will really burst on the scene by late Fall. This is as a result of not only technical advances but also genetic research.
The beginnings of a surge for a flat tax will be bantered around and come to some conclusion before the next election that will take us into 2001.
Air travel reaches an all-time high, but because of overbookings and poor service, the airlines will need to revamp their scheduling practices.
As in the 1940's and 50's, we are going to see a lot of small businesses flourish like the old Mom and Pop operations.
There is a big upsurge in the population looking for more antiques and handmade articles than things that are mass-produced.
There will be extensive monitoring of the internet that will be imposed to govern and reduce indiscriminate pornography. This will be drastically different from the filtering software available now, along with harsh regulation.
There will be a definite crackdown by the Federal Government regarding frivolous lawsuits. This has been bantered around for a while, but now a definite crackdown is imposed.
Sorry to say there will be three hurricanes that hit in rapid succession in the Fall, again around the Bahamas, then Mexico, Florida, and the Carolinas.
Tornadoes touch down in Ohio in April and a devastating one touches down in Brownesville and San Antonio, Texas in the Spring.
An earthquake hits around the Niagara Falls area, small but significant because of where it is.
There will be small earthquakes that hit around the Northern California area in January and February, nothing of significance.
Los Angeles registers a 5.3 earthquake in and around the valley in late March.
Seattle area, around Olympia, gets a 4.9 earthquake around June. None of these earthquakes above are devastating.
The warming trend continues and climates begin to change drastically even more than we have seen in the last ten years. Temperatures along the East Coast become milder and along the West Coast colder and more damp and also due in part to the polar tilt.
NASA finally cuts back on the space program realizing that every time they send up a space vehicle they are tearing the ozone layer.
The midwestern U.S. has a big uprising because of some kind of polluted waste hazard. This has not been recognized at this point, but begins to surface around Branson.
There is going to be a very definite detection of mines and some bombs that have not been detonated off the coast of Hawaii.
Train wrecks will occur in France and England causing quite a bit of devastation in May.
In June a major airline disaster is averted.
An airline high-jacking is thwarted out of Florida in August.
Democrats will win the election with Bill Bradley, with close competition from the Reform Party.
New York crime continues to be at an all-time low, and crime across the country, including crime in schools seems to reach an all-time low.
The one thing that is very frightening as we go into the millennium, and even though spirituality is at an all-time high, is that we will see more occult groups arising and people professing to be the Messiah.
Organized religion becomes gentler and kinder and more liberal, which goes along with spirituality and in keeping with Christ's words.
We are approaching an age of innate goodness and acceptance and the philosophy of living and let live. People become more conscious of others like it was in the 1940's and 50's; e.g., when someone dies, people come together to help with a more community-like lifestyle. Families begin to band together as they once did.
Elizabeth Taylor ends up back at the Betty Ford Center.
Brad Pitt and Jennifer Anniston get married, but it lasts for only a short time.
Gwyneth Paltrow marries an older man who is in the entertainment business, but not as well known as she.
David Letterman decides to call it quits from his nightly late show after this year.
John Travolta has to be very careful flying his plane in February.
Donald Trump buys another large hotel and goes into partnership with someone very well known in a production company.
Neither Warren Beatty nor Donald Trump has any success in politics.
Courtney Cox will get pregnant this year and have a baby boy.

Anyone care to chip away at it? Might be useful on RSL's site.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom