StopSylviaBrowne: Shawn Hornbeck Reading

I'm reading through the myspace thread and I can't help but think that the people on there are resisting you because they know that that you will attempt to explain away their religion. They are distrustful and would never help you for fear of getting burned. No matter how nice you are they may have become skeptical of skeptics because of their past experiences with people mocking their beliefs.

I wouldn't advocate being deceptive, but do you think they might be more helpful to someone claiming to put up a website to defend against SB skeptics? You could still require the same rigorous detail but they may try to help you because they'd be thinking that they were helping Sylvia. Or maybe it would be the same because there really aren't any solid cases to cite.

Again, I wouldn't advocate this because it would only serve as an example of skeptics being deceptive and mean-sprited.
 
I'm reading through the myspace thread and I can't help but think that the people on there are resisting you because they know that that you will attempt to explain away their religion. They are distrustful and would never help you for fear of getting burned. No matter how nice you are they may have become skeptical of skeptics because of their past experiences with people mocking their beliefs.

I wouldn't advocate being deceptive, but do you think they might be more helpful to someone claiming to put up a website to defend against SB skeptics? You could still require the same rigorous detail but they may try to help you because they'd be thinking that they were helping Sylvia. Or maybe it would be the same because there really aren't any solid cases to cite.

Again, I wouldn't advocate this because it would only serve as an example of skeptics being deceptive and mean-sprited.


What on Earth are you suggesting? Skeptics are deceptive only when they need to be, and they are never mean-spirited.

M.
 
I'm not suggesting anything, just merely an observation about how the people on the myspace thread responded to Robert. A few were receptive, but many were turned off just by his name.

Oh and happy birthday, Moochie.
 
OK, Shawn Hornbeck's parents are going to be on Larry King tonight. I e-mailed the following question to Mr. King for him to ask the Hornbecks.

"I heard that Sylvia Browne and other psychics told you your son was dead. Can you explain how these people may have helped or hurt the investigation into what happened to Shawn? Would you recommend that other parents in a similar situation use the services of a psychic?"
 
I just finished reading the thread at SB's MySpace. Robert, I know you're at TAM, but I must say... you are a gentleman and a scholar! Your polite tone (despite juvenile comments and bating) was something all of us could learn from.

Note to self: Yet another reason to attend TAM VI - to meet Robert S. Lancaster in person.
 
Didn't read the whole thread, but in case it hasn't been pointed out already:

The 13 year old that was found along with Hornbeck had the last name "Ownby", not "Owenby"

reference


It's picky, I know, but you asked.
 
Just saw an ad for Anderson Cooper's show on CNN highlighting Psychics getting it wrong in the Hornbeck case. very cool.
 
Good evening.
I just posted this in another thread here and feel it should be said again.
Good evening everyone.
In the words of the great Harvey Keitel in Pulp Fiction,
Let's not start s@#&ing each others D*@#s just yet.
I agree that this seems like a cool thing, but when all is said and done it comes down to editing. From what I read the parents were already willing to trust a psychic. I don't know if that's true but that is what I read.
I would love to believe that this could be a turning point in the pro-pyschic media, but I realy doubt that will happen. I suspect at best a very soft comment on her. I also doubt that Montel will be mentioned.
I hope I am wrong.
JPK
 
Good evening.
I just posted this in another thread here and feel it should be said again.
Good evening everyone.
In the words of the great Harvey Keitel in Pulp Fiction,
Let's not start s@#&ing each others D*@#s just yet.
I agree that this seems like a cool thing, but when all is said and done it comes down to editing. From what I read the parents were already willing to trust a psychic. I don't know if that's true but that is what I read.
I would love to believe that this could be a turning point in the pro-pyschic media, but I realy doubt that will happen. I suspect at best a very soft comment on her. I also doubt that Montel will be mentioned.
I hope I am wrong.
JPK

I wouldn't expect this to be a turning point such that SB suddenly loses all credibility (would it were so) but I think the effect is cumulative. Publicizing more like incidents will build the negative response.

Thanks to Mr Lancaster and StopSilviaBrowne.com this "mistake" seems to have had a much higher visibility in the press than the alive/dead miners did and that was at least as big a f. u. as this.
 
Good evning Gord_in_Toronto
I wouldn't expect this to be a turning point such that SB suddenly loses all credibility (would it were so) but I think the effect is cumulative. Publicizing more like incidents will build the negative response.

Thanks to Mr Lancaster and StopSilviaBrowne.com this "mistake" seems to have had a much higher visibility in the press than the alive/dead miners did and that was at least as big a f. u. as this.
I just wrote a rather long response to this but somehow it got lost.
Here is the reader digest version.
Mr. Lancaster is suppling a place for the cumulative effect to take place.
I have no doubt that believers will continue to belive. A journey needs to start with a first step. I hope that StopSilviaBrowne.com is that step.
Perhaps a few will follow. Maybe not.
My real concern is how Mr. Lancaster comes across in the press. He has a message. It will be interesting to see how that message might be presented.

JPK
 
Sweet , sweet sweet sweet sweet sweet!!!!

RSL on, Sylvia so very wrong...Oh, this is beautiful!!!

700 dollars /hour to help find their dead son... of course syl denies...
 
One segment over--it could not have gone better.

RSL, you are my new hero!!!
 
BEST TV EVER!!

I made everyone I know turn it on!!

My dearest friend WAS a Sylvia follower. Between RSL's page and tonight's show SB now has lost a follower! YAHOO!!

Thank you RSL and Randi!

(Now I will go make my family watch it again on TIVO, just incase they don't fully grasp what kind of danger these people really are.)

HerNibs
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom