StopSylviaBrowne - Scorecard: Missing/Homicide Readings & Open Letter to Browne

There used to be an old adage, crude but with a bit of a valid point. The adage was:

"Put up or shut up."

The principle of this adage has often appeared in various forms, such as "Talk is cheap," "Money talks, [other stuff] walks," and the like. If you're not going to actually back up your rhetoric with action or evidence or finance, then spare the rest of us the empty bluster, will you please? Talk is cheap. Take a walk.

The challenges offered to psychics by Houdini and the Amazing Randi and others invoked this principle. Can you show everyone that you really can do what you say you can do? If you can, then you ought to be able to do it under conditions that reduce the risk of trickery, and you ought to be able collect my substantial prize. And if not, why don't you shut your damn pie hole?

Psychics don't put up, but what's worse, they don't shut up, either. Even more rude is their penchant for actually increasing their windy doubletalk after having their bluffs called.

RSLancaster's courteous letter to Browne does not invoke the "put up or shut up principle," which would be seen rightly as antagonistic. Omitting the "shut up" option, Robert has asked Browne if she is willing to put up.

As many have guessed, Sylvia will probably not put up. This is not necessarily due to any moral turpitude on her part, but is more likely due to the fact that she can't put up, even if she wanted to.

My guess is that not only will she not put up, she won't shut up, either. The refusal to refrain from swaggering inane verbosity is, unlike the failure to put up, a strong indicator of moral turpitude. It indicates a lack of personal integrity. It further indicates a guilty knowledge that it is known for a fact that the claims at issue were bluffs, having about as much solid substance as the odors rising from fertilizer.
 
Last edited:
Excellent articles. I couldn't help but chuckle at reading your letters and come to "StopSylviaBrowne.com" here and there. And the scorecard is great. Gee, not one "right" article? How can that be? :boggled:

:p
 
Well done! But for the "open letter to Sylvia Browne", I don't think much will come of it. First, I don't think Linda Rossi or Michael McClellan will pass the information along. And on the off chance they do, I doubt Sylvia will even look at it. She'll probably just think, "Oh that crank. I have nothing to prove to him." (Though I'm sure deep-down she's just afraid. Knowing she has nothing to combat the truth with.)

But I hope to be proven wrong.
 
Well done! But for the "open letter to Sylvia Browne", I don't think much will come of it. First, I don't think Linda Rossi or Michael McClellan will pass the information along. And on the off chance they do, I doubt Sylvia will even look at it. She'll probably just think, "Oh that crank. I have nothing to prove to him." (Though I'm sure deep-down she's just afraid. Knowing she has nothing to combat the truth with.)

But I hope to be proven wrong.

Her days of being able to ignore Robert and Randi are numbered.

Speaking of Randi, how about an article recounting SB's acceptance of the MDC and then backing out? The fact that this happened on Larry King's show makes it even more interesting, I think.
 
Ouch!

I doubt you're expecting a reply from SB to your open letter.
I am, but she may surprise me.

Either way, the invitation had to be made, if for no other reason than to be able to say "Yes, I HAVE asked her."

Robert: maybe you should consider sending a new open letter to Montel...formally pointing out this record of achievement and asking him whether there is something missing in his opinion and if not, why he continues to support this liar and fraud.
I am considering doing just that, 'Scratcher.

Minor typo in the Scorecard page - "If you are aware of any missing person of murder case ...".
Fixed, thanks!

I wonder if there is a way you could extend the same invitation to Montel or his managers?
Not a bad idea, thanks.

I think the letter to the ministers is a brilliant idea. If only this makes one of them think about where the evidence is, it's been worthwhile.
Thanks, Mr. Stick. That letter to the ministers also made certain that they were aware of the site. I have been told that there is a very high turnover among the ministers, ministers-in-training and study group coordinators. The list from which I gleaned these email addresses was from 2005, and so there is a good chance that many on the list are no longer associated with Novus, and so may not be aware of the site. The letter took care of that.

Two more excellent articles - the "score card" in particular is absolutely devastating.
Thanks, Alice.

It doesn't matter how often I read Browne's sickening Opal Jo Jennings fantasy, it still makes my blood boil. :mad:
Me too. :mad: :mad:

The format, succinctness, and implication of the last two lines is the best thing I've read on SSB all year.
Thanks, alfa.

I'd be shocked if Sylvia responded, especially since all of their previous responses have been dismal.
You're probably right, but you never know...

Should they respond, it will be to the effect that she has to keep everthing confidential since she is dealing with sensitive information that is given only to her clients.
Well, since I specifically asked for examples from the Montel show, it would be difficult for them to support a claim of confidentiality, I'd think. The readings were on national television.

Or they will send unverifiable cases.
Maybe so.

One must smile when they realize that not even Sylvia Browne or her staff will be able to produce cases that she got right :)
Well, just by statistics, she eventually has to get at least one (mostly) right.

Those who claim to be psychic ought to be able to do something comparable.
You'd think so, wouldn't you?

Great articles, Robert! Will be interesting to see what happens, although I have a feeling this can only go the way of the master's degree in English that wasn't.
So then, you think that Browne will send to me, through the webmaster of GSB, something totally unrelated to the question at hand? :)

Just repeating what everyone else has already said. Great article. Keep up the good work.
Thanks, Drew!

Maybe all those posters on GSB who said that all the cases are she's solved that are too numerous to list will actually step up and produce one. Or two.

Or not. :D
Hope springs eternal...

Great letter! I'll bet her circle are cringing as we post.
Thanks, Minarvia.

Outstanding work! You do a fabulous job of maintaining a climate of fairness, objectivity and civility on SSB.
Thanks, Tan!

It must be tough, considering that Sylvia is, well, Sylvia.
Sometimes tougher than others...

If I have one complaint, it's that after all my hard work and countless hours, you didn't use my list of homicide/ missing persons case that have never been solved. :(
As I say in the article, it will be updated.

Also, I think it would be fair to list Terrence Farrell as a missing person.
The article is specifically about her readings on the Montel Williams show.

And update the Weyman Robbins article with what Mrs. Robbins told us.
I am still waiting to hear from Mrs. Robbins.

Edit: Thank you for giving QG and me and the others credit. I really appreciate it.
You deserve it.

Will you be organizing your articles on the "articles page" according to subject rather than date? The "articles page" is really long and reorganizing it might make it easier to read.
Yes, this has been on my to-do list for some time. When will I get to it? I can't say.

Also you might consider putting the two Hornbeck articles together on your "scorecard". You listed the two articles separately, thereby counting one case twice.
I did not count it twice, but yes, I will be rearranging the readings on that page, probably in alphabetical order by missing/murdered person's name.

Great article!
Thanks, bjb!

Perhaps you could print a copies of your open letters and send them by registered mail. Either you get a receipt signed by Sylvia Browne, or a 'refused' receipt from her office. Either way, you'll get an interesting item for your files.
Yes, I am considering doing that.

If anyone has access to the Mercury News archive, I did a key word search and came up with the following abstract:

I don't know if/or how this might be linked to Sylvia Browne, just something I found.
Thanks, Enlighten! I don't know offhand if this is one on EMM's list or not.

The "scorecard" is great...and the "Open Letter" absolutely brilliant.
Thanks, Locknar!

sweet. the page w/the summaries is NICE.
Thanks, nails!

Excellent articles.
Thanks, kt!

Well done!
Thanks, ORM!

But for the "open letter to Sylvia Browne", I don't think much will come of it.
Whether anything does or doesn't, I have made the effort.

Speaking of Randi, how about an article recounting SB's acceptance of the MDC and then backing out? The fact that this happened on Larry King's show makes it even more interesting, I think.
Yes, a "JR & SB" article has been on my to-do list since day one. I have put it off due to it already being covered in spades elsewhere (both here and Skeptic Report, among other places). But an article on it definitely belongs on SSB. Particularly because I get the occasional email asking about the "heart prediction."

When will I get to it? Perhaps Sylvia could say... :)
 
Well, the letter is great for the purposes of the site but we all know that it's for naught.

My job the past year has been putting together Sylvia's full missing persons/ homicide scorecard.

I already have researched just about every missing person's/ homicide reading SB has done on Montel since 2001 (and then some) and the only cases I ever found are a) cases that have never been solved and b) cases where SB was wrong.

The closest thing to a correct reading I have ever come across was when SB apparently correctly predicted John Baglier was dead and near water and even there, one, I don't have a record of the reading she gave and, two, that's very, very weak.
 
Last edited:
Well, just by statistics, she eventually has to get at least one (mostly) right.
I doubt it. Not if the standard is that her reading helps to solve the case. The odds would be pretty high that she get enough points of information right to be of any use. (Again, I propose the standard used for giving out a reward: she has to provide information that leads to an arrest and conviction, or at least the return of a missing person.)

I predict there will never be one reading where she was mostly right unless she used information that was already known. (Remember how confidently she said she knew the miners would all be found alive?)
 
If anyone has access to the Mercury News archive, I did a key word search and came up with the following abstract:
The next day on July 7th:
Search: http://www.mercurynews.com/archivesearch
I don't know if/or how this might be linked to Sylvia Browne, just something I found.

Thanks for finding this, Enlighten!

Unfortunatly, Lexis Nexis's archives from this paper only go back to 1994 and the Montel transcripts only go back to 2001.

No other article I have access to so much as mentions the case.
 
I doubt it. Not if the standard is that her reading helps to solve the case. The odds would be pretty high that she get enough points of information right to be of any use. (Again, I propose the standard used for giving out a reward: she has to provide information that leads to an arrest and conviction, or at least the return of a missing person.)
There is a reason why it will be difficult for Browne to meet a standard of providing information that will lead to an arrest and conviction. Any evidence obtained by use of supposedly psychic means could well be inadmissible, and any arrests based upon anything said by a psychic would very likely be a violation of constitutional rights.

Search warrants in the USA cannot be issued unless there is a showing of probable cause, and investigations of possible criminal activities of individuals can only be based upon reasonable grounds to suspect that the individual has committed a crime or is up to no good. Psychic "information" (in addition to generally being worthless in leading to corroborrative evidence) is not based upon reason. It cannot be the sole or principal basis for a stop or a search or an arrest or a warrant. It is therefore not an effective source of information that can contribute to bringing anyone to justice.
 
There is a reason why it will be difficult for Browne to meet a standard of providing information that will lead to an arrest and conviction. Any evidence obtained by use of supposedly psychic means could well be inadmissible, and any arrests based upon anything said by a psychic would very likely be a violation of constitutional rights.

Search warrants in the USA cannot be issued unless there is a showing of probable cause, and investigations of possible criminal activities of individuals can only be based upon reasonable grounds to suspect that the individual has committed a crime or is up to no good. Psychic "information" (in addition to generally being worthless in leading to corroborrative evidence) is not based upon reason. It cannot be the sole or principal basis for a stop or a search or an arrest or a warrant. It is therefore not an effective source of information that can contribute to bringing anyone to justice.

Right but if someone did indeed have psychic powers, their version of events would match up to what the police found. Sylvia's stories on Montel would match with what turned out to be true when the case was solved.

And as I and QG and others have proven, they haven't. Not ever.

Edit: I should send Sylvia my own letter. "For the past year, I have been going through every criminal case showcased on Montel since 2001 and any others I could have found through other sources. If you have solved any successful missing persons/homicide case as seen on Montel, please bring it to my attention as it would certainly be news to me. "
 
Last edited:
There is a reason why it will be difficult for Browne to meet a standard of providing information that will lead to an arrest and conviction. Any evidence obtained by use of supposedly psychic means could well be inadmissible, and any arrests based upon anything said by a psychic would very likely be a violation of constitutional rights.
I’d have to disagree. If SB (using a “Clue” analogy) was on Montel and said “Col Mustard did it, in the study, with the candlestick” (ie. provided specific information) the information she provides would be corroborated via the police investigation. In SBs case, her “facts” typically to vague to be of any value.

Search warrants in the USA cannot be issued unless there is a showing of probable cause, and investigations of possible criminal activities of individuals can only be based upon reasonable grounds to suspect that the individual has committed a crime or is up to no good. Psychic "information" (in addition to generally being worthless in leading to corroborrative evidence) is not based upon reason. It cannot be the sole or principal basis for a stop or a search or an arrest or a warrant. It is therefore not an effective source of information that can contribute to bringing anyone to justice.
While I'd agree that psychic "information" can not be the sole reason for a search, or arrest...same as I mentioned above; if specific enough it would be corrobrated/supported by other evidence.

Obviously in SBs case, it is a PR game. Her “evidence” is simply to vague to be of any value other then to look good on TV, or when more specific (such as “the miners will be found alive” or “Shaw Hornbeck is dead”) is just spectacularly wrong.
 
Last edited:
I'm going to use my brilliant predictive powers here and state for the record that Sylvia will not respond, nor her ministers. Assuming that happens:

Robert, please update the open letter portion of the website to let readers know the status. I'm picturing something like:

2/1/08 After 60 days neither Sylvia Browne nor her representatives have responded.

2/15/08 A copy of the open letter sent certified mail to Browne's address was returned unclaimed.

5/1/08 After six months and a follow-up email we have received no response from Sylvia.

etc.

I'm sure her silence will speak volumes.
 
I’d have to disagree. If SB (using a “Clue” analogy) was on Montel and said “Col Mustard did it, in the study, with the candlestick” (ie. provided specific information) the information she provides would be corroborated via the police investigation. In SBs case, her “facts” typically to vague to be of any value.
Actually, I think we are in quite a bit of agreement. Psychic "evidence" can only be of use if there is corroboration, and as I mentioned, psychics are generally worthless in leading investigators to corroborative evidence.

Suppose the cops were looking for a particular suspect, and did not know where to find him. And suppose Browne said something like, "The suspect is in Missoula, Montana," even though there was no reason to think so. If a law enforcement officer in Missoula, hearing Browne's remark, happened to see a person on the streets who matched the description of the suspect, the officer could still pursue that lead. In this case, the known description of the suspect, and the appearance of the person matching that description, are probably sufficient corroboration to support further reasonable inquiry.

Similarly, of the police search a public area for evidence based upon a psychic tip, where no search warrant is required, and they find evidence, that would probably be allowable. If the evidence was discovered in an area with no expectation of privacy, and if the authenticity of the evidence can be verified, then this would be sufficient corroboration.

Psychic tips are about on par with hunches and guesses. Hunches and guesses play a role in legitimate investigations. It is not hyperbole to say that some hunches and guesses are more valuable tools than psychic tips, because hunches and guesses of law enforcement personnel tend to be modestly informed and realistic, whereas psychic tips tend to be the "pulled out of the psychic's butt" variety. And as you say, psychic tips are also often too vague to be of any real investigative use.

When it comes to pointing out a suspect or providing evidence to support a search warrant or arrest warrant, or having a basis for a stop, psychic tips are poison. If all the officer has is the psychic's say-so, or if the basis for inquiry into a particular suspect was due to having him pointed out by a seer, then there is a lack of a reasonable basis for the investigation, and any evidence obtained in that investigation may be ruled inadmissible.

Furthermore, a psychic certainly cannot testify in court to facts bearing upon guilt or innocence that were allegedly observed or otherwise sensed by paranormal means.

An arrest or a search or a stop or a focused inquiry cannot be based upon a hunch or a guess, and it cannot be based upon a psychic tip, either.
 
<snip>Robert, please update the open letter portion of the website to let readers know the status. I'm picturing something like:

2/1/08 After 60 days neither Sylvia Browne nor her representatives have responded.

2/15/08 A copy of the open letter sent certified mail to Browne's address was returned unclaimed.

5/1/08 After six months and a follow-up email we have received no response from Sylvia.

etc.

I'm sure her silence will speak volumes.

I like this idea.

I think Robert will get replies. Nothing specific in them. Maybe some abuse. But if Robert does get a reply from somebody then how can he put that fact up on the site? He has agreed on confidentiality.

For Sylvia's benefit here is what I would say to her followers if I was Sylvia.

Please ignore Robert. He is a dark spirit. He will only lead you down the wrong path. I have lost too many of my loyal supports because of him. I do not want to lose any more. We can all stick to our delusion that Sylvia is a great person, who has helped many people and solved many crimes.
 
I like this idea.

I think Robert will get replies. Nothing specific in them. Maybe some abuse. But if Robert does get a reply from somebody then how can he put that fact up on the site? He has agreed on confidentiality.

For Sylvia's benefit here is what I would say to her followers if I was Sylvia.

Please ignore Robert. He is a dark spirit. He will only lead you down the wrong path. I have lost too many of my loyal supports because of him. I do not want to lose any more. We can all stick to our delusion that Sylvia is a great person, who has helped many people and solved many crimes.

rjh01 you are good; that's what Sylvia already does say, although I haven't heard that specifically about Robert yet, since I left before he was a threat. But she pretends to have Francine say it on her behalf, so it sounds more convincing. She has done that for years, trying to rally the ministers and keep the remaining people from leaving. I'm certain sure she wouldn't hesitate to say that about Robert. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black, as the saying goes. Except in this case, the kettle isn't black. So, if there are any spiritual fence-sitters out there, reading these posts, trying to make up their minds about Sylvia, please take it from an ex-minister of Novus Spiritus who knew Sylvia personally for many years: If either of the two were to fit Sylvia's description of a dark entity, it wouldn't be Robert. As a matter of fact, the dark entity description (lack of conscience, willing to do anything to advance their own purposes) fits Sylvia herself alarmingly well.
 
Perhaps Sylvia really is psychic, but she's just too stupid to realize Francine has been pulling her leg all these years. And having a laugh.
 
Last edited:
Yes, a "JR & SB" article has been on my to-do list since day one. I have put it off due to it already being covered in spades elsewhere (both here and Skeptic Report, among other places). But an article on it definitely belongs on SSB. Particularly because I get the occasional email asking about the "heart prediction."

When will I get to it? Perhaps Sylvia could say... :)
What about maybe a brief paragraph and a link to Randi's SB page?
http://www.randi.org/joom/content/view/112/81/

Or, maybe Randi would give you permission to reprint the page on your site?

I agree that the topic should be covered on your site. It highlights her own lack of confidence in her abilities and shows what her word is worth.
 
Awesome work Robert.

I have a tiny gripe about one of your older articles.

quote: "On November 14 2000, ten workers were painting the Ambassador Bridge (connecting Detroit, Michigan, and Windsor, Canada) when the scaffolding they were on collapsed."

Should probably be "Windsor, Ontario". "Windsor, Canada" would be like you saying "Detroit, USA".

Not really a big deal but I live in Windsor, so it probably affects me more then 99% of your readers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom