StopSylviaBrowne: Ryan Katcher Reading

The 'here is the evidence, you draw your own conclusion' style of the site, much like StopKaz, is extremely effective.
Thanks, Ripley.

...but it wouldn't hurt to restate that her claim is that he had already aspirated before his final resting place (presumably while still at the party.)
I'll give that some thought, thanks.

A pickup truck could be a "metal (sort of) tube"! :p
Yeah, I got yer "tube" right here, pal.

Further to this you can see from the transcript that Browne links the aspiration to the alcohol he was drinking. Which would rule out drowning in the water in my opinion.
Agreed.

"Smug arrogance" is exactly how I would describe SB whenever I've seen her.
I received an email today from a man who that he had never realized how arrogant she was until reading the site. It was nice to read.

Weird!
I usually don't like people but I'm starting to like RSLancastr
;)
Hey, it's mutual, even though your avatar kinda creeps me out... :boxedin:
 
I wouldn't give her even a partial hit for aspirated.

Unfortunately - you're not SB or her fans. They would, and that's exactly what we need to start pointing out, while drawing particular attention to how poor the reading actually was, with video and audio evidence.

(By we, of course, I mean The Great and Mighty RSLancastr... Although I'd very much like to help, if and when I can...)
 
Rob, I would emphasise somehow the nearly 100% miss she did with this one. Literally, you said this by means of a single prefix to another word. Perhaps you could score her "predictions" for each story in a format like this:

Sylvia Browne Predictions: 5, Hits: 0 (that's zero)
 
(By we, of course, I mean The Great and Mighty RSLancastr...
Pay no attention to the webmaster behind the curtain!!

Although I'd very much like to help, if and when I can...)
Thanks!

Rob, I would emphasise somehow the nearly 100% miss she did with this one.
I debated doing something like this, but I didn't come up with a way that (like yours) seems a little too didactic for the site's tone. I just uploaded a modification so that at least the word "incorrect" is bolded. Hope that helps some.
 
I have another suggestion, and JREFers who wish to help you can provide some of the manpower needed.

SB makes a lot of money from book sales. Perhaps you could do a section with critical reviews of her books. If you can find them at the library, or used (cheap) on Amazon, assign a book to a volunteer who would look for claims that could then be checked for accuracy. You could also look for woo statements that appear to contradict other woo statements she has made. She can't possibly keep all those straight. Even better, would be finding statements or claims that conflict with common christian beliefs. That would greatly reduce her book sales demographic.
 
I have another suggestion, and JREFers who wish to help you can provide some of the manpower needed.

SB makes a lot of money from book sales. Perhaps you could do a section with critical reviews of her books. If you can find them at the library, or used (cheap) on Amazon, assign a book to a volunteer who would look for claims that could then be checked for accuracy. You could also look for woo statements that appear to contradict other woo statements she has made. She can't possibly keep all those straight. Even better, would be finding statements or claims that conflict with common christian beliefs. That would greatly reduce her book sales demographic.

Oh dear - I'm beginning to regret offering to help now... :boxedin:
 
Has anyone ever come to this forum to defend or stand up for Sylvia? I've seen posters at least drive by and defend some of the most insane, crackpot ideas and people, but I can't remember anybody coming in with any love for Sylvia. Did I just miss it? Is there anywhere that Sylvia supporters post, where we can go and push Rob's site?
 
SB makes a lot of money from book sales. Perhaps you could do a section with critical reviews of her books.
Yes, that is definitely in the plans. Here's a link to the site's Support page, where I discuss that very thing:

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/support/#donatebooks

Currently, I intend on doing the reading myself, though I would be interested in whatever anyone else wants to say about any book. As you can imagine, this will take some time.

Even better, would be finding statements or claims that conflict with common christian beliefs. That would greatly reduce her book sales demographic.
Yeah, I am considering an article along those lines as well. Her latest book, "The Mystical Life of Jesus" is full of stuff which would upset "mainstream" Christians.
 
Has anyone ever come to this forum to defend or stand up for Sylvia? I've seen posters at least drive by and defend some of the most insane, crackpot ideas and people, but I can't remember anybody coming in with any love for Sylvia. Did I just miss it? Is there anywhere that Sylvia supporters post, where we can go and push Rob's site?
I don't recall any pro-Sylvia posters here. As for any pro-Sylvia forums: I'm sure they are out there, but I didn't find any with cursory searches. Is TVTalk still out there? It probably has a Sylvia or Montel section.
 
Good work Robert! I really, really, really admire you for your efforts to expose this vampiric skum that is Sylvia. You present a balanced, factual, and compassionate analysis of these instances. Keep up the good work! Hopefully, at least a few people's eyes will be opened by your efforts.
 
Has anyone ever come to this forum to defend or stand up for Sylvia? I've seen posters at least drive by and defend some of the most insane, crackpot ideas and people, but I can't remember anybody coming in with any love for Sylvia. Did I just miss it? Is there anywhere that Sylvia supporters post, where we can go and push Rob's site?

The only thread I could find with a quick search was
Sylvia Browne is NOT that bad!
 
The only thread I could find with a quick search was
Sylvia Browne is NOT that bad!

I think KQ was a troll, of sorts, though. He disappeared after starting that thread. The upshot of the commentary was that a couple of people thought that skeptics were too tough on woo's, or not polite enough in our discourse occasionally. Not a criticism one could make about Rob's work, I feel.

I don't think anyone's really come forward to seriously defend SB, in my time here.

ETA: Well, except Amy Wilson... didn't she comment somewhere that Sylvia was a wonderful person.....
 
I have another suggestion, and JREFers who wish to help you can provide some of the manpower needed.

SB makes a lot of money from book sales. Perhaps you could do a section with critical reviews of her books. If you can find them at the library, or used (cheap) on Amazon, assign a book to a volunteer who would look for claims that could then be checked for accuracy. You could also look for woo statements that appear to contradict other woo statements she has made. She can't possibly keep all those straight. Even better, would be finding statements or claims that conflict with common christian beliefs. That would greatly reduce her book sales demographic.

It would probably be fun to do - but I am 99% certain it would have at best a very marginal effect on the buyers of her line of mental crap. They know their Sylvia converses with Dog and that evil people (that would be us) want to mock her and stop her from helping them.:jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom