StopSylviaBrowne: New: "Asks Montel" & "Parents Around"

Regarding that second article, I wish more people would just pause - give her some space. I wonder what story about their deaths Sylvia would have gone on to tell, if the woman had not explained they were alive in another country.
 
He related how when Albert Einstein died and his brain was cut open, he was discovered to have had a more developed parietal lobe than the average human and that when Sylvia Browne dies and her brain is studied, she'll be found to have a very advanced brain lobe for intuition, far more than what the average human has.

A testable claim! I will submit my application for the million dollar prize soon. My claim is that Sylvia Browne has very advanced brain lobes for intuition. I suggest a protocol whereby we remove Sylvia's brain from her skull and dissect it to determine if these lobes are indeed more advanced than normal. As a control, we will perform the same investigation on the brain of Uri Gellar, who has been shown to have little or no intuition. I suggest we begin the preliminary test immediately.
 
I like the separate threads - it's the best way to draw attention to new content, because the casual browser can see from the thread title that there is new content and can decide to read the thread on that basis.

But if you just add new stuff to an existing thread, how does the casual browser know if it's a post about new articles, or a post about colour scheme, a reply to a comment, etc. He doesn't.

Also, every time you start a new thread, as long as it's not too frequently, it draws fresh attention to the site. Each thread title describes the articles, so a forum user may visit a thread (and the articles as a result) based on an interest in that particular topic, for example Montel.

There are many other reasons why separate threads are better in this case but I think those two alone are sufficient to justify it.
 
Geez, twice in one lifetime I agree with Tkingdoll. :eek:

RSL, when you had StopKaz going, you had a new thread for each new item you added to the site, and it was great to have those "alerts" to let us all know.

What we are experiencing now is the startup phase of the SSB site, and that will mean a lot of new stuff being added in fairly rapid order. I'm sure later on down the line things will be more spaced apart, and then we will definitely need these alerts about new material.

Perhaps in the beginning, a topic for every new "bunch" of material. This topic has two new items, which is good.
 
Yeah, I like the separate threads too. The site is coming along nicely, and it's nice to have the new info.
 
From the article Young woman "Asks Montel" (emphasis mine):

Perhaps he assumed the woman did not believe in psychic powers (it is not clear from her question, or even her entire email, whether that is the case, or whether she just doesn't think that Browne is psychic)...

I took the following comment to indicate that she doesn't believe in psychics at all (emphasis mine):

In conclusion, Montel told me "and you'll notice that in the 16 years I've been on air, I have never had anyone else in her profession ever appear on the show, not once. She's the only mentalist, psychic, anyone like that who's ever been let on, even though many have come to me and wanted to be on the show." Excellent, Montel, you only believe in one more non-psychic than I do, I thought.

If the comment in bold is taken literally, it makes no sense in context (it would mean that she believes Sylvia to be a psychic, which obviously isn't the case based on the rest of the email). Therefore, I think she meant "psychic" here, but said "non-psychic" because Montel indicated that he didn't believe her to actually be a psychic. Therefore, I took her comment to mean that Montel only believes in one psychic -- one more than she does.

-Bri
 
Suggestion: new thread for new article batch, then after a fixed amount of time, ask a mod to merge them into one big SSB thread?
 
Maybe she deserves a subforum. She does seem to be number one right now, and if RSLancaster can really bring her down, it would be great to have all the threads in one place where newcomers can see them.
 
Suggestion: new thread for new article batch, then after a fixed amount of time, ask a mod to merge them into one big SSB thread?

I think merging the threads would make it harder for someone to use the forum's search function effectively.

Besides if its easier to deal with a shorter thread the first week or so after its created -- it's still easier to deal with a shorter thread 6 months (or whatever fixed amt of time you had in mind) after it's created.

I've researched various topic using the search function here, and I'm always happier when what I'm looking for is in a shorter vs. a longer thread.

I also like the separate threads for all the reasons already mentioned, so I won't repeat them. ;)
 
Merging threads won't work well, because the posts are merged together by time. The new merged thread won't make any sense at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom