StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Susan and the MRI

For the rest of her Farewell Tour, those living in states that she is slated to "lecture" in should notify their State Attoreny General that she dispenses medical advice without a medical license.

That is what I am doing, as well as lodging a complaint with the Mayor and Prosecutor of the city here that she is coming to.

Wouldn't that make a great story for SSB; SB being lead out of a convention center in handcuffs for practicing medicine without a license!!!!!!
 
Very nice, and scary too. Not sure what it's worth, but I liked the "tells" just for the picture of her licking her lips. Granted, that may not be an objective, rational reason, but I'm sticking to it.
 
That advice was shocking and I would think that at least a few people in the audience would be aware of the possible danger Susan could face if she indeed followed thru with the MRI. Perhaps someone spoke to her afterwards and warned her.

I wouldn't count on it. :(

I LOL'ed at that pic. It was both hilarious and disgusting.

Wow, your sense of humor must be very different from mine! I think I threw up a little in mouth at that screenshot. :confused:

Very nice, and scary too. Not sure what it's worth, but I liked the "tells" just for the picture of her licking her lips. Granted, that may not be an objective, rational reason, but I'm sticking to it.

That's really funny- I thought it belonged in Pink Flamingos. :covereyes

Edit: I'd actually like to thank Claus myself because it was actually his mentioning it to Robert that lead me to look it up unasked.

It occured to me one day as I was sitting at my desk at work to try Lex-Nex for it and I actually thought I wouldn't find anything- it sounded like an urban legend similar to the bridge in Ohio and other outlandish claims of "One time on Montel, I saw-" that Robert has gotten.

Lo and behold, it was real! I sent it under "Do I have something for you"; I had to resist the urge to title it "Late Birthday Present".
 
Last edited:
MR is not only potentially dangerous, as you point out,
I agree that an X-ray would be the best instrument for the job, but aren't surgical instruments made from stainless steel? If so, they would be unaffected by a magnet, yes?

Of course, all I really know about it is that magnets won't stick to a stainless steel refrigerator...
 
Last edited:
Well, having had an MRI, they do allow me to take the key to the locker holding my stuff into the room. It looks like metal, but I don't know what it is exactly. That's never been a problem. But my jewlery and my regular keys and everything else has to stay in that locker. My jeans are ok, but they do give me a quick look over just to be sure.
 
I'm amused by not telling the doctor anything. Surely the doc won't have pulled her medical records before her scheduled visit, or look at them afterwards. Not divulging your history in such a way will make the doc very weary about your motives and will probably lead them to think she's got an axe to grind with the medical establishment or has a need for attention from medical professionals.
 
I agree that an X-ray would be the best instrument for the job, but aren't surgical instruments made from stainless steel? If so, they would be unaffected by a magnet, yes?

Of course, all I really know about it is that magnets won't stick to a stainless steel refrigerator...
There are MRI scanners specifically designed to be used ... well, in surgery isn't quite the right term given the size. In any event, it's called interventional MRI. All the equipment has to be specifically chosen to be used in this scenario. Normal surgical equipment is not cleared for this.

Conversely, things like stents and clips are a contra-indication for MRIs unless they're known to be safe (if I recall correctly, there has been at least one incident of a fatality due to a stent or clip).

So, it might not be affected ... but it's risky, and any competent medical professional would not allow an MRI. And, as mentioned, a simple Xray would suffice to identify any solid object left behind. Whether that would identify a sponge or similar soft object I'm not sure, but it wouldn't be that well identified by the MRI in that case either - and for that case an ultrasound might be appropriate.

Fundamentally, though, Ms. Browne is appallingly ignorant of the medical issues here, to the extent that her advice is actually potentially harmful.
 
Can I just say that I almost pee'd myself when I saw this picture:

montel_susanandthemri_3.jpg


Nice :D
 
And if you watch the video, note how after he makes sure she understands about the type of surgery it was, Browne nods sagely, as though to say "of course I knew that. I'm psychic." :rolleyes:

Fortunately, one doesn't have to be psychic to know that skin goes on the outside of the body, the stomach isn't the abdomen, and if you have a surgical instrument inside your body, one thing you don't want to do is get yourself next to a machine with a honking strong magnetic field.

Some of these people, I just want to whack them upside the head to wake them up.

Good article, by the way. That snake tongue is going to give me nightmares, though.
 
Last edited:
Cool pictures and movie of things stuck in the MRI coil. These guys were very brave, because pulling on the chair is also pulling on the magnet solenoid which is thousands of feet of hair thin wire on a ceramic form. Breaking it can result in a rapid quenching of the magnet and a possible explosion. At best, a large release of helium which can suffocate if not quickly vented.
 
I am a little conflicted about pointing out the hints in Sylvia's body language that she might be lying. It seems reasonable information to put out there, yet it would seem to be far from conclusive, and your caveat on that appears much later in the article. I think that's the first instance I have seen where someone might be able to argue you weren't being entirely fair to her.

I have to agree. Presenting weak evidence like the body language angle could be read as desperate or biased -- it would be better to just leave it out. I just think it dilutes the strength of the real evidence that's on the site.

The rest of the article presents some strong evidence of Sylvia's habit of dispensing (sometimes harmful) medical advice even though she's not a doctor. The point is about just how harmful this practice could be, yet it is obscured by some tangential conjecture about body language.

At the very least Robert should write a statement up front explaining why he includes the body language stuff in the article. But I think he should just remove it and replace the images with better ones from the video. The article is extremely convincing without the body language comments, but could have the opposite effect with them.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
After the woman tells Sylvia that she has been to 34 doctors and has had 5 other surgeries, Sylvia says:

I'm telling you, nobody wants to take...the credit, I mean nobody wants to take the fall for leaving something inside. She's got something left inside.

Sylvia Browne is blaming a conspiracy of doctors for this woman's ailment.

Browne runs a multi-million dollar show that could well be called "It Is Never Your Fault, Dear."
Source

Damn, I hate being right all the time... ;)

sbrowneeyes.jpg
 
lol, "Searching for the truth with Sylvia Browne".
You'll be searching for a while
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom