StopSylviaBrowne: Montel: Lynda McClelland Reading

David Repasky knew one sure fire way to get the heat off didn’t he.
At least for a while anyway!!

Maybe other murderers might take the proactive approach and have $ylvia throw people off the scent.

Just get yourself in the audience on Montel’s show & $ylvia will do the rest.

It was a very gut wrenching clip - she is so rude and obnoxious as well.
Why do they bother, when she treats people with so little sensitivity anyway?
That ought to be enough to turn everyone off.

If she ever claimed that she can fly around on a broom stick, I reckon I’d believe her!

Oh boy...


(bold mine)

Well, that's a nice supportive way to describe someone with a mental illness to their family members. They went goofy. Can I vomit now?

And thanks for the updates, they're awesome :)

I live in NYC and my friend and I were planning to attend the show in January and I was preparing to "pyschic-bait" Sylvia - tell her something untrue in a cold reading so that she'd go from it and tell me, say, all about my mother's future knee surgery when my mom in fact was perfectly allright. Then reveal I had lied to Sylvia and she didn't know the difference on the Internet.

Unfortunatly, Shawn Hornbeck happened in the meantime and that episode was cancelled and I lost my tickets and wasn't invited back, making me miss my one chance to see Sylvia in the flesh, making me very angry cause I had made arrangements to miss work and was on the waiting list since November.
 
Montel's shows are free (I think?). So, had this thought ... Round up a few Sylvia skeptics, maybe to include past victims. They will live w/in the show area or be willing to travel there. Each month several will gleefully volunteer to attend a show as a "plant".

For ex.,

A few will ask q's as grieving family members, some will ask career q's and a few will ask r-ship q's. The "grievers" will have entirely intact families. The career folks will be dressed in ways suggestive of career interests and hobbies that contradict their actual jobs. The "singles" will leave the wedding rings/bands at home and keep their ring hand lowered at all times.

Small vid.s (maybe on cell phones), and audio recorders would be snuck in for taping the show. In advance there'd be documented proof of each "plant's" present career and marriage status. Live family members of course are proof there's a lack of genuine bereavement.

All the results would be publicized, whether on your site, Youtube ... in general media, or in some combination thereof. These planted set-ups would periodically continue; a war of attrition for the critical exposition of Sylvia's shaft jobs.

I live in NYC and my friend and I were planning to attend the show in January and I was preparing to "pyschic-bait" Sylvia - tell her something untrue in a cold reading so that she'd go from it and tell me, say, all about my mother's future knee surgery when my mom in fact was perfectly allright. Then reveal I had lied to Sylvia and she didn't know the difference on the Internet.

Unfortunatly, Shawn Hornbeck happened in the meantime and that episode was cancelled and I lost my tickets and wasn't invited back, making me miss my one chance to see Sylvia in the flesh, making me very angry cause I had made arrangements to miss work and was on the waiting list since November.


As an ex-'psychic', I can tell you now that this tactic will not work.

Psychics and their supporters will argue that they are unable to truthfully read those who are being deliberately deceptive, and all that happens is you end up looking evil, or stupid.
 
That counter-tactic has a short half-life though. If the alleged psychic continues to respond to phony questions over time and it gets officially documented along the way, the following question will become unavoidable:

Why does the alleged psychic continue to grant readings to people who are deliberately deceptive? Why isn't her psychic radar cluing her in and keeping her from responding to these ppl in the first place, wasting her time and breath?

Also, there's another way to go about disenfranchising Sylvia Brown. Those planted in the audience can document and publically complain about her bad readings, while putting up the guise of having been genuine Sylvia fans prior to her crappy advice. These complaints would add to the accounts of genuine ex-followers who are disenchanted and have come out publically against her.

One more idea is to routinely plant a medical professional in the audience. Have him (or her) complain about symptoms that are highly specific to an obscure disease that requires immediate, highly specialized treatment. Let her fall go into her usual "diagnostic" evaluation, telling him he has migraines (after he complains of head pain lol) and to cut back on caffeine or sugar or whatever quasi-medical advice slips off her careless tongue.

The taped segment would be brought to the attention of authorities as a clear demonstration of Sylvia's issuing of unqualified "medical" advice leading to a hypothetical fatality. At the very least the media and medical organizations would be contacted about the incident. I'd also make sure to implicate Montel to put increasing pressure on him to cut Sylvia loose.
 
As an ex-'psychic', I can tell you now that this tactic will not work.

Psychics and their supporters will argue that they are unable to truthfully read those who are being deliberately deceptive, and all that happens is you end up looking evil, or stupid.


But Sylvia doesn't claim to "read" her subjects. She is being told all these secrets by "spirits".

If I tell her my grandmother had one leg and it was a lie, wouldn't my grandmother's spirit tell Sylvia that it wasn't true.

These psychics act like kids in a playground, pulling out new invented "rules" when things don't go their way.
 
One more idea is to routinely plant a medical professional in the audience. Have him (or her) complain about symptoms that are highly specific to an obscure disease that requires immediate, highly specialised treatment. Let her fall go into her usual "diagnostic" evaluation, telling him he has migraines (after he complains of head pain lol) and to cut back on caffeine or sugar or whatever quasi-medical advice slips off her careless tongue.

You do not need a medical professional to do this. You just need someone with a serious disease. Would she know how to recognise even the more common diseases? I can just imagine it, many people being able to see immediately how bad her advice is.
 
But Sylvia doesn't claim to "read" her subjects. She is being told all these secrets by "spirits".

If I tell her my grandmother had one leg and it was a lie, wouldn't my grandmother's spirit tell Sylvia that it wasn't true.

These psychics act like kids in a playground, pulling out new invented "rules" when things don't go their way.

Ah, but if you're lying to Sylvia, then that's inviting mischievous spirits to come talk to her and not your grandmother. If you're evil, the spirits will be evil. If you lie, the spirits will lie. It's karma, and just proof that the cosmic forces are in tume and balanced and she, Sylvia, is the centre of it all.

They have an out for anything. :hb:
 
Guys, let alone that discussing "secret" plans to plant skeptic members in the studio audience on a public forum is not exactly guerilla old school style, I think you are not aware how such a TV program is produced, how very difficult this would be to achieve. And the results incalculable. Sylvia at the Montel show is not the average fortuneteller at your local carnival.
 
Guys, let alone that discussing "secret" plans to plant skeptic members in the studio audience on a public forum is not exactly guerilla old school style, I think you are not aware how such a TV program is produced, how very difficult this would be to achieve. And the results incalculable. Sylvia at the Montel show is not the average fortuneteller at your local carnival.

This week's commentary illustrates the point beautifully.
 
If I tell her my grandmother had one leg and it was a lie, wouldn't my grandmother's spirit tell Sylvia that it wasn't true.
Dunno. It would depend on what a nitpicker your grandmother was. The vast majority of people in the world have one leg.

Besides, don't you know, everybody gets healed in Heaven.
 
Probex, while I obviously sympathise with your intent, I really think this is an ineffective way of acheiving results, for a number of reasons, some already mentioned above.

I believe that lying during the reading has limited effectiveness, but lying to the public is an extremely bad move, and is what you seem to be suggesting here:

Also, there's another way to go about disenfranchising Sylvia Brown. Those planted in the audience can document and publically complain about her bad readings, while putting up the guise of having been genuine Sylvia fans prior to her crappy advice.
 
Guys, let alone that discussing "secret" plans to plant skeptic members in the studio audience on a public forum is not exactly guerilla old school style, I think you are not aware how such a TV program is produced, how very difficult this would be to achieve. And the results incalculable. Sylvia at the Montel show is not the average fortuneteller at your local carnival.

This week's commentary illustrates the point beautifully.

That was a coincidence, I had not read this week's commentary when posting the above. But I read it now, of course.

I've been working for television (producing entertainment shows) for almost 10 years, including the big stuff aired on Saturday evenings. To make a long story short:

I continuously warned all my family members and all friends, should ever someone call from television, should they ever be asked to be a guest or member of the audience, just hang up the phone. Should ever someone on the street shove a camera or microphone in your face, say nothing and turn away. No kidding, I meant it.

Most people have no idea how easy it is for the producers to make smart people look stupid on TV, and to make stupid people look smart (see 95% of all hosts). This even works with live programs, you just need a little more preparation to make things sure. Editing, of course, is the ultimate means of manipulation, but not needed to produce a show the way you (the station) want it.
 
What amazed me was the empathy and concern Sylvia demonstrated in her reading for both the daughters and the victim. Describing her mental illness as being "goofy" and using a common mocking gesture to indicate. If that's the kind of attitude you need to start a church sign up my 11 year old nephew.
 
Also, there's another way to go about disenfranchising Sylvia Brown. Those planted in the audience can document and publically complain about her bad readings, while putting up the guise of having been genuine Sylvia fans prior to her crappy advice. These complaints would add to the accounts of genuine ex-followers who are disenchanted and have come out publically against her.


I think the best way to do it is embedded in the above quote. As RSLancaster is doing, simply collect as many statements as possible from people who really and truly believed in Sylvia and no longer do so. That would be much more convincing, in the long run, than making anything up or using trickery.

The phrase "set a thief to catch a thief" can be useful sometimes, but not in this context I think.
 
Well you all gave me plenty to think about. My snakey, filthy side still tells me fighting phoniness w phoniness could get really good results. Yes it's the low road. And for some reason, on this particular issue, I don't mind moo-hahaha.

But I think I see your point. It's unclean enough that losing credibility w the public would be likely. So, yeah, screw it.

Yeah, I agree that a doctor wouldn't necessarily need to be planted. Truetrue. Also, the issue w editing: Right. That's why sneaking in a tiny cam and/or recorder would be nice. How easy or hard is that to do btw?
... Do you know?

Cause I agree that mounting personal testimony against her is good, but ongoing Youtube vid.s and such would be even more powerful, I'd think.
 
Probex, while I obviously sympathise with your intent, I really think this is an ineffective way of acheiving results, for a number of reasons, some already mentioned above.

I believe that lying during the reading has limited effectiveness, but lying to the public is an extremely bad move, and is what you seem to be suggesting here:


I still think asking Sylvia about my mother's non-existant knee surgery would have worked but, ok, how about if you ask something that's not a lie but that could just mislead a pyschic in a cold reading? Something that could be misconstrued in a cold reading? Like how SB thought that "will my parents be around me?" meant "will their spirits be around me?" and "I'd like to ask about my mother" meant "I'd like to ask about my mother's spirit".

I have this idea that's been knocking around my head for a while.

My plan would be to go as a plant to one of Sylvia's shows with a friend and have my friend say, for example, "I knew this girl Eeney Minnie Moe in high school. She's red haired, brown-eyed, a little on the short side. She overdosed. Is she...allright? Can you see her? Could you tell her something for me?" and trap Sylvia into thinking I'm dead and telling my friend that I'm on the Other Side when the truth is I did once accidentally overdose on prescription medication in high school but not fatally. In fact, I didn't even have to seek medical attention for it.

If Sylvia was psychic she'd certainly say "Yes I can 'see' her-she's sitting right next to you! Looks allright to me and tell her anything you want yourself! I'm psychic, of course I knew you were trying to trick me."

And it goes without saying she'd be ale to tell me all about my codeine episode.
 
Right. That's why sneaking in a tiny cam and/or recorder would be nice. How easy or hard is that to do btw?
... Do you know?
I have one anecdote that is relevant, namely, attending a Van Praagh taping. In order to gain admittance, each audience member had to sign a 4-page form that prohibitted you from even TALKING to the press about what you saw. It explicitly forbade recording equipment.

There were no pat downs but I suspect that if you held up a cameraphone or other device, security would be on you like ugly on a monkey.
 
I have this idea that's been knocking around my head for a while.

My plan would be to go as a plant to one of Sylvia's shows with a friend and have my friend say, for example, "I knew this girl Eeney Minnie Moe in high school. She's red haired, brown-eyed, a little on the short side. She overdosed. Is she...allright? Can you see her? Could you tell her something for me?" and trap Sylvia into thinking I'm dead and telling my friend that I'm on the Other Side when the truth is I did once accidentally overdose on prescription medication in high school but not fatally. In fact, I didn't even have to seek medical attention for it.

If Sylvia was psychic she'd certainly say "Yes I can 'see' her-she's sitting right next to you! Looks allright to me and tell her anything you want yourself! I'm psychic, of course I knew you were trying to trick me."

And it goes without saying she'd be ale to tell me all about my codeine episode.

:clap:

This would be much more effective, and should you get the opportunity, you should definitely try it.

People have tried for years to show up psychics by lying about themselves in readings. It doesn't work. However, honest testimony works, as can be seen by the StopSylvia site, and responses to RSL.

In fact, people like Sylvia are so bad so often, that we shouldn't need to resort to dishonest tactics, really.
 
Psychics and their supporters will argue that they are unable to truthfully read those who are being deliberately deceptive, and all that happens is you end up looking evil, or stupid.

They have an out for anything.

No matter how well thought out your ruse, they have the biggest out of all. Their powers will just not work on skeptics. We are all too close-minded and cynical. That's all the believers need to know. :mad:
 
Just heard about this on another site, Robert. Another coup! Well done.

That's right up there with the Shawn Hornbeck fiasco. The murderer sitting right there in front of her.

Beeeeeeeautiful!

I can just imagine what he was thinking. "Hey, thanks, Sylvia!"

How nice. Not only does SB aid and abet the murderer, she slanders the victim as nutso.

Very nice.

Way to go, Montel!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom