StopSylviaBrowne: Janet McDonald's Reading and Does Browne Smoke?

Nice articles, Rob. I've always wondered about her smoking, too. Her voice and her hacking cough doesn't sound merely like a "natural whiskey voice" to me.
And I was sad to hear about Janet. She will definately be missed.
Her article was one reason I found about about the JREF Forum in the first place. Her article was informative, funny, and sad all at the same time. I particularly liked how she began with Sylvia as an eager believer then things went quickly downhill from then on.
 
I don't.

But I think this is her take on it...

A "ghost" is someone who has died and doesn't realize it, and has yet to "cross over" to "the other side."

A "spirit" is someone who has died and has successfully crossed over. They are between incarnations.

A "spirit guide" is a spirit who has chosen to be a living person's guide. Once they are no longer that person's spirit guide (for whatever reason), they can choose to be reincarnated.


I see a problem there: given the fact that she ascribes a spirit guide to every single living person on Earth (or so it appears), and all those ghosts and in-between-incarnations-spirits, there must not be enough left to reincarnate ...
 
The smoking thing really surprises me, I remember reading transcripts of taped readings and her clients indicating that she was smoking on the phone, recently.
 
I see a problem there: given the fact that she ascribes a spirit guide to every single living person on Earth (or so it appears), and all those ghosts and in-between-incarnations-spirits, there must not be enough left to reincarnate ...
How do you figure?

The smoking thing really surprises me, I remember reading transcripts of taped readings and her clients indicating that she was smoking on the phone, recently.
Yes, since the article went up, I have heard from someone ho used to get phone readings from Browne during the 90s, who says that you could hear her smoking over the phone.
 
How do you figure?


Well, I'm not that good at maths, but if reincarnation has started early in human history and there's, say, 1 spirit guide, plus 1 ghost for every person alive there must be a dearth of spirits ready to reincarnate in the next generation - or a factory of new spirits somewhere ... of course, there's the theory of souls evolving from animals, but given the fact that she pretends that we'll find our pets (all aged 30 ?) on the other side ...
 
I always thought the problem with reincarnation was the exact opposite one: there are so many more people on Earth now than there ever were so where did all 6 billion souls come from?

Even more complicated if you add spirit guides, plus ghosts, plus everything else SB believes in.
 
CSICOP review of Edwards'book on reincarnation

Another stumbling block raised by Edwards is the steadily climbing world population. If the souls of every one of today's earthlings necessarily inhabited a body in a previous generation, and -- also according to doctrine -- no new souls are being created, and there were fewer bodies on the planet then than now, we would seem to be faced with a serious soul deficit. A few reincarnationists have attempted to sidestep this impediment with mind-numbing ad hoc gyrations (upgrading of animal souls, recruiting souls from other planets or dimensions, soul sharing, etc.), but the extremes to which these apologists have gone only underscores, as Edwards notes, how fanciful the whole reincarnationist enterprise really is.

and speaking of ad hoc gyrations with a grain of salt ...

There have been times even in the historical past when the birth rate of new babies worldwide did not match the death rate. So according to the theory of reincarnation, did some souls get put on hold for awhile in a spiritual wait zone until there were enough babies to go around? Or did they hang out in the turnips? Conversely, our current population explosion clearly demonstrates way more births than deaths. So does that mean that some babies are born with half-souls or no souls? There can't be that many souls waiting in turnips to fill the current demands!
Buddhists may help us out here. Buddhists seek to skip the Hindu wheel of birth, death and reincarnation altogether through discipline and meditation. They believe that they can reach a point at which independent identity is no longer relevant. The "soul" loses itself by merging with a universal mass of spiritual energy called Nirvana, something analogous to the universal mass of living energy that scientists call biomass. For the sake of discussion, let's call this "spiritmass."
That solves the mathematical problem, because math in the spirit world may not add up the same as it does here in the mundane world. If there is spiritmass, then some babies could inherit old souls directly and some may get new ones from the reservoir of spiritmass. Whatever the case, nature and nurture inevitably work to individualize the baby's identity, just like they individualize his or her body into a unique new person. Old souls are either absorbed into spiritmass or changed in their new incarnation and new souls are sprung from spiritmass. In either case, the old identity is lost. Tulip becomes turnip, and essence of Uncle Frank becomes Little Carol.
 
RSL - What you really need is that caught "red-handed" photo showing SB smoking, or at least with a cigarette in hand. Wonder if the ex-husband you interviewed for one of your stories has such a photo?
 
RSL - What you really need is that caught "red-handed" photo showing SB smoking, or at least with a cigarette in hand. Wonder if the ex-husband you interviewed for one of your stories has such a photo?

It would need to be demonstrably recent, or she could claim that it was during the brief period when she smoked many years ago. (Yeah right!)

I'm thinking we need to get hotel records that show she always reserves a smoking room. (Either that, or she stinks up a non-smoking room.) I don't suppose those records are public.
 
FWIW: I'm 100% certain she quit smoking for good on the very same day that she received her M.A. in English.
 
It would need to be demonstrably recent, or she could claim that it was during the brief period when she smoked many years ago. (Yeah right!)

I'm thinking we need to get hotel records that show she always reserves a smoking room. (Either that, or she stinks up a non-smoking room.) I don't suppose those records are public.


Not necessarily…. While she has never denied smoking, she has consistently stated “I don’t smoke” and implied strongly implied she has never smoked.

Even if an old picture, that would at least clarify the question “did she ever smoke”…or does she, and her whole family, just have a naturally husky voice?
 
On the Montel front, I still haven't come across any mention of her allegedly never having smoked on the show.

I can't account for why it's not there when Robert so clearly remembers it. Unless I'm missing something. :confused:
 
Well, I'm not that good at maths, but if reincarnation has started early in human history and there's, say, 1 spirit guide, plus 1 ghost for every person alive there must be a dearth of spirits ready to reincarnate in the next generation - or a factory of new spirits somewhere ... of course, there's the theory of souls evolving from animals, but given the fact that she pretends that we'll find our pets (all aged 30 ?) on the other side ...
Well, I'm not great at math myself, but I fail to see the problem (mathematically, anyway).

There are about six billion people on the planet today. Each of them has at least one spirit guide.

So, with six billion spirits in current incarnations, and another six billion serving as their spirit guides, that makes twelve billion spirits currently accounted for.

There are a few complications:

1. I think that Browne says that "dark entities" (such as her ex-husband and her mother) don't have spirit guides, and that as much as 60% of the population is "dark."

2. Some peole have more than one spirit guide (Browne has two: Francine and Raheim).

3. Can a spirit be the "spirit guide" for more than one person at a time? I don't know what Browne says about that.

Ignoring those complications for the moment, we have accounted for twleve billion spirits, half in current incarnations, half spirit guides on The Other Side.

Depending on who you ask, the estimate is that there have been anywhere from 69 billion to 110 billion people who have ever lived on the planet.

Given that, what do you see as the (mathematical) problem?

Also, you might be assuming that souls/spirits don't get created until there is a body for it to occupy. I don't think that this is the case in Browne's theology.

On the Montel front, I still haven't come across any mention of her allegedly never having smoked on the show.

I can't account for why it's not there when Robert so clearly remembers it. Unless I'm missing something. :confused:
It is possible that it is from a show which is too old to be in the lexisnexis database. If so, then it would have to be one of the older shows which I have taped. There are only a handful of those, so I will look through them to see if that is where I saw it.

Thanks for looking though!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom