StopSylviaBrowne - Follow-up to "Novus: An Aramaic Prayer?"

Ms. Browne (no relation, as I have to remind folks from time to time) has a dismal record of making predictions. My record, on the other hand, is quite impressive, if I do say so myself.

In the original thread about the "Aramaic" "prayer," I wrote:
It may be worth mentioning that there is a popular "out" that is often used with nonsense prayers.

This "out" finds favor in many branches of charismatic Christianity. According to the Pentacost story of Acts 2, people began to speak in languages that they had not been taught. According to the account, these languages were legitimate and not mere babble, and could be understood by at least some fluent speakers in attendance.

In 1 Corinthians 14, however, Paul said that not all those who speak in tongues will be understood by those in attendance, implying that NOT being understood is the norm. This is the "out." In the event of some sort of nonsense utterance, the faithful may assert that the utterance is not in a language of men, but rather in a language of the Almighty, or a language of the angels.

1 Corinthians 14 also discusses an odd adjunct of speaking in tongues, namely, interpretation of tongues. Interpretation is basically the assigning of meaning to an unknown utterance. Even though the interpreter does not speak the "language," the interpreter announces what the utterance means. (Observational studies have shown, of course, that two people "interpret" a meaningless utterance quite differently, suggesting that there is no real translation occurring. Would it be otherwise, it could be strong evidence of the existence of the Holy Spirit.)

Thus, part of the "out" is to say that the uttered language is not an earthly language (and thus conveyance of the utterance is a miracle in and of itself), and the other part of the "out" is to say that the interpretation allows the meaning of an utterance in an unknown language to become known (a second miracle). You get two miracles for the price of one!

Would this be SNS's "explanation" for the prayer, that it is in a heavenly language rather than an earthly language? There is no way to say at this time. One can only say that there certainly would be ample precedent for offering such an "explanation."
So we are now asked to consider that "the prayer 'Arem, Shem...' originated from ancients who spoke in Aramaic and who were speaking in tongues when this phrase was first spoken."

Ah, those classic "outs" never seem to go out of style, do they?

We further have the popular double miracle of a message being conveyed in an unknown language, and the interpretation of apparent nonsense being made known as well. And for good measure, we have a liberal dose of double-talk. First we have an assertion that the words are in one language, but upon being shown that this assertion is false, we have an assertion that the words are in another unknown language, which of course cannot be tested.

The faithful, I suspect, are not supposed to notice.
 
I think this is a good example of what happens when Sylvia lies, and then documents the discrepancies by publishing so many books. She's practically a "book of the month club" all by her little self. :)

Keep on chuglin', Robert.
 
I'm no linguist but are you sure it's Atlantean and not Atlantish or Atlantese? Atlanti?

But at least we've come to the bottom of things.. Aramaic? Gibberish? Ah.. Atlantean. Now it makes sense. :boggled: And another very good article, and very nice that you've included a bit to inform readers about speaking in tongues/glossolalia.
 
I'm not quite sure about one thing that Robert said:
[Glossolalia] is a highly controversial practice, frowned upon in most Christian denominations, and those skeptical of it think that it is nothing more than what it sounds like - gibberish.
It is not fair, in my judgment, to say that "most" Christian denominations "frown upon" speaking in tongues. Many denominations do not practice it openly (as, say, charismatic sects do), but neither do they disapprove of it. They keep it "in the closet," as it were, a phenomenon that is still regarded as legitimate but not to be trotted out in front of the masses as a golly-gee-whiz miracle. In this sense, glossolalia is much like the practice of curing illness by casting out demons. The "thinking" is that Jesus said that demons cause illness, so it must be true; but we don't put that kind of magical thinking into practice with the expectation of getting real results. Except in movies like "The Exorcist":
There is one outside chance for a cure. I think of it as shock treatment - as I said, it's a very outside chance... Have you ever heard of exorcism? Well, it's a stylized ritual in which the rabbi or the priest try to drive out the so-called invading spirit. It's been pretty much discarded these days except by the Catholics who keep it in the closet as a sort of an embarrassment, but uh, it has worked. In fact, although not for the reasons they think, of course. It's purely a force of suggestion. (from imdb.com)
Christians of nearly all mainstream sects regard speaking in tongues as an integral part of the Pentacost story of Acts chapter 2, and at least one service every year is devoted to Pentacost. Nearly all sects refer frequently to Paul's essay on "gifts of the spirit," of which speaking in tongues is one such gift. Further, it is my understanding that even though some denominations do not incorporate speaking in tongues into their Sunday services, they can and do practice it in small groups.

So basically, glossolalia is kept in the closet in many mainstream denominations. But skepticism about glossolalia is kept in the closet, too.
 
I've been a Catholic for more than half of my life and prior to last year, I had never even heard of speaking in tongues in my life.

I think it's fair to say most Christians have never practised it, indeed, probably don't even know what it is.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom